Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: the dynamical response of black holes to any external disturbance is dominated , at intermediate times , by a discrete set of damped oscillations called quasinormal modes ( qnms ) . this result has been verified not only at linearized level , but also in fully numerical simulations for stellar gravitational collapse @xcite and collision of two black holes @xcite . the possibility of observation in the forthcoming years of the radiation due to the qnms opens a new perspective for the gravitational wave astronomy . from these observations it will be possible to obtain direct evidence of black holes existence , as well as to estimate their parameters ( mass , electric charge , and angular momentum ) @xcite . in addition to the astrophysical applications , an interpretation appeared some years ago of the qnms in terms of the ads / cft conjecture @xcite . according to this conjecture , there is a correspondence relation ( or duality ) between string theory in an anti - de sitter ( ads ) spacetime and a conformal field theory ( cft ) on the boundary of this space @xcite . it implies that a large black hole in the ads spacetime corresponds to an approximately thermal state in the cft . perturbing the black hole is equivalent to perturbing the thermal state , and the perturbation damping time gives the time scale for the return to the thermal equilibrium . therefore , by computing quasinormal ( qn ) frequencies in an ads space it is possible to obtain the thermalization time scale in the strongly coupled cft . the early works studying perturbations of ads black holes considered the evolution of a conformally invariant scalar field in such background spacetimes @xcite . after the advent of the ads / cft conjecture , qnms of spacetimes with a negative cosmological constant , such as kottler ( also called schwarzschild - ads ) @xcite , reissner - nordstrm - ads @xcite and kerr - ads @xcite , were computed for different fields , dimensions , and boundary conditions . within this program , other kinds of black hole solutions were also analyzed . for instance , in the baados - teitelboim - zanelli solution @xcite , analytical expressions for the qn frequencies presented exact agreement with the poles of the retarded correlation function in the dual cft @xcite . this result provided an important quantitative test of the ads / cft correspondence . as a complement to the aforementioned studies , analyses of the time evolution of some fields in asymptotically ads backgrounds have been performed @xcite . more recently , the conjecture relating the highly damped qnms to black hole area quantization has motivated a search for qn frequencies with large imaginary parts also in asymptotically ads spacetimes @xcite . the studies of perturbations in ads spacetimes were also extended to black holes with nonspherical topology . in ref . @xcite the evolution of a conformal scalar field in the family of topological backgrounds was investigated , which includes the plane - symmetric black hole as one of its members , while in ref . @xcite the case of a nonminimally coupled scalar field in the same kind of spacetimes was considered . lately , the lowest qn frequencies associated with the scalar , electromagnetic , and gravitational perturbations of the plane - symmetric black hole background were computed @xcite . the study of the scalar and electromagnetic fields was relatively complete . however , important questions were left without answers in connection with the gravitational perturbations . for instance , what are the wave equations governing general metric perturbations ? what is the physical interpretation of the modes with different wave numbers ? what are the qn frequencies in the intermediate and small black hole regimes ? what is the relation between these frequencies and the wave number ? why is the pure imaginary frequency not proportional to the horizon radius in the large black hole limit as it happens for ordinary modes ? is there some relation between the latter and the algebraically special frequency ? and what is the behavior of the qnm spectrum in the regime of highly damped overtones ? the objective of the present work is answering most of the previous questions as well as other ones that appeared during this work . some of the conclusions drawn here are extended to the schwarzschild - ads black hole . the plan of this paper is the following . in sec . [ solucao ] , we write the equations defining the background spacetime in a newman - penrose ( np ) null tetrad frame @xcite . in sec . [ perturb - np ] , we obtain schrdingerlike equations governing the axial and polar perturbations . in sec . [ qnm ] , we define the qnm boundary conditions to be used and prove the black holes stability against perturbations with a non - negative potential . a brief description of the horowitz - hubeny method ( sec . [ metodo ] ) follows , as well as subsequent exposition of the qn frequency values for different horizon radii and wave numbers ( sec . [ resultados ] ) . then , we study the large black hole limit of the axial qnms ( sec . [ limite ] ) and the non - qn character of the algebraically special frequency ( sec . [ algebrico ] ) . finally , we conclude by summarizing and commenting the main results ( sec . [ conclusao ] ) .    throughout this work , we use the geometric system of units in which the speed of light and the newton s gravitational constant are set to unity . the background spacetime , moreover , has a natural lengthscale given by the ads radius @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the negative cosmological constant . here we choose the length unit so that @xmath7 and measure everything in terms of the ads radius . in relation to notation , the asterisk ( @xmath8 ) denotes complex conjugation and the definition of the np quantities follows ref . with the aim of investigating the evolution of linear gravitational perturbations in the background of a plane - symmetric ads black hole @xcite , we summarize here the basic properties of such a spacetime . the metric may be written in the form @xmath9 where @xmath10 there is an event horizon at @xmath11 , and an essential singularity at @xmath12 . depending on the ranges of coordinates @xmath13 and @xmath14 , the metric may represent a cylindrical ( @xmath15 , @xmath16 ) , toroidal ( @xmath17 ) or planar ( @xmath18 ) black hole spacetime . for the torus , @xmath19 is related to the adm system mass @xcite ; for the cylinder , to the mass per length unit of @xmath14 line @xcite ; and for the plane , to the mass per area unit of the @xmath20 plane @xcite .    according to the petrov classification , the above metric is algebraically type d. it is then convenient to define the np quantities in terms of a kinnersley - like null frame @xcite . in this case , the two real vectors of such a frame , @xmath21 and @xmath22 , are chosen to lie , respectively , on the ingoing and outgoing radial null geodesics and are defined by @xmath23 which are the double principal null directions of the weyl tensor . in order to complete the frame basis we have the vector @xmath24 and its complex conjugate @xmath25 . both of these vectors , @xmath26 and @xmath27 , are orthogonal to @xmath28 and @xmath29 , and satisfy the normalization condition @xmath30 . with the chosen tetrad basis , the only nonvanishing spin coefficients are @xmath31 and the only nonvanishing weyl and ricci scalars are @xmath32 here the equations for the linear gravitational perturbations are obtained by using the np formalism , which allows us to investigate general properties of such perturbations without any further simplifying assumption . in this approach , changes in the metric coefficients are directly related to changes in the tetrad null vectors . furthermore , perturbations in the vectors @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath33 lead to first order alterations in weyl and ricci scalars , and also in the spin coefficients . the full system of linearized perturbation equations is obtained by expanding the complete np equations on the plane - symmetric black hole background , and retaining only the first order terms in the perturbation functions . generally , the linearized np equations form a large system of coupled equations whose solutions are difficult to be found . however , for petrov type d vacuum spacetimes , the problem reduces to solving a pair of decoupled equations for the gauge and tetrad invariants @xmath34 and @xmath35 @xcite . in the present case , these equations assume the simple forms @xmath36\psi_{0}=0 , \label{fund1}\\ [ ( \delta+3\gamma-\gamma^{\ast}+4\mu+\mu^{\ast})(d-\rho)- \delta^{\ast}\delta-3\psi_{2}]\psi_{4}=0 . \label{fund2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] the foregoing equations are already linearized since the weyl scalars @xmath34 and @xmath35 vanish in the equilibrium state , and then they are to be considered first order perturbations . the other quantities take their unperturbed values given in eqs . - . the background symmetries , together with the perturbation equations and , indicate that each one of the perturbation functions @xmath34 and @xmath35 can be written as a product of four different functions depending upon only one of the coordinates @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 . moreover , due to the wavelike character of the equations , the dependence of these functions on the coordinates @xmath37 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 is of the form @xmath39 $ ] , where @xmath40 is the frequency , and @xmath41 and @xmath42 are wave numbers which may assume discrete or continuous values , depending on whether @xmath13 and @xmath14 are compact or noncompact coordinates , respectively . the radial functions , in turn , are conveniently written as @xmath43 where the subscripts @xmath44 are related to the spin weight and to the conformal weight of the weyl scalars @xmath34 and @xmath35 . the resulting equations for @xmath45 take the following standard form : @xmath46 where we introduced the differential operators @xmath47 here @xmath48 is the tortoise coordinate , defined in such a way that @xmath49 , and @xmath50 with @xmath51 .    the chandrasekhar transformation theory @xcite can now be used to transform eqs . into one - dimensional schrdingerlike equations of the form @xmath52 this is done by means of the substitutions @xmath53 whose inverse transformation gets the form @xmath54 where @xmath55 in the foregoing equations , the potential functions @xmath56 are given by @xmath57 , \label{pot - polar}\ ] ] @xmath58 while the auxiliary functions @xmath59 are , respectively , @xmath60    the meaning of the signs @xmath61 comes from the metric approach to the perturbation problem , as it was performed in ref . they are related to the parity property of the perturbed metric functions under the exchange @xmath62 ( or @xmath63 ) . the variable @xmath64 represents the polar ( even ) perturbations , while @xmath65 represents the axial ( odd ) ones .    in a certain sense , the wave equations can be thought of as a generalization to those found by cardoso and lemos @xcite . here the perturbations depend on both coordinates @xmath13 and @xmath14 , while in the aforementioned work the analysis was restricted to @xmath14-independent metric variations . this is equivalent to the vanishing of the wave number @xmath42 , resulting in @xmath66 . however , the plane symmetry of the background spacetime renders possible to find new coordinates ( @xmath67 , @xmath68 ) in such a way that one of the wave numbers , @xmath69 or @xmath70 , is zero . that is to say , it is always possible to find a coordinate system in which the perturbations depend only on two space coordinates ( @xmath38 and @xmath13 , or @xmath38 and @xmath14 ) . another result derived from the above analysis is related to the starobinsky constant @xcite , @xmath71 , where @xmath72 are given by eq . . the solutions of @xmath73 correspond to algebraically special frequencies in the sense of chandrasekhar @xcite . as we shall see in sec . [ resultados ] , one of such solutions , given by @xmath74 appears in the numerical results in connection to the purely damped qnms . the properties of the axial perturbations related to these algebraically special modes are analyzed in some detail in sec . [ algebrico ] . to solve the wave equations we must impose boundary conditions on the possible solutions . first , however , consider the case of the asymptotically flat schwarzschild spacetime . gravitational perturbations lead to schrdingerlike equations whose potentials vanish at infinity and at the event horizon . hence , close to these extremities , the solutions are plane waves , @xmath75 , where the @xmath48 coordinate ranges from @xmath76 to @xmath77 . qnms are then defined as solutions which are purely ingoing waves at the horizon , @xmath78 , and purely outgoing waves at infinity , @xmath79 . these requirements are satisfied only for a discrete set of complex @xmath40 called the quasinormal frequencies .    in asymptotically ads spacetimes , we keep the requirement of purely ingoing waves at the horizon . in the meantime , since now the tortoise coordinate @xmath48 takes a finite value at spatial infinity , the boundary condition at infinity must be changed . this can be dirichlet , neumann , or robin boundary condition , depending on whether the field , its derivative , or a combination of both vanishes , respectively . here , as in most of the literature , we adopt dirichlet boundary conditions , since these lead to energy conservation in the field theory on ads space @xcite ( for alternative boundary conditions see ref . @xcite ) . having defined the qnms , we show below that the imaginary part of the qn frequencies is positive for non - negative potentials . the demonstration follows the one carried out in the schwarzschild - ads case by cardoso and lemos @xcite . initially , we exchange the variable @xmath80 by @xmath81 , so that eq . becomes @xmath82 where @xmath80 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 stand for both perturbation types , the polar @xmath85 and the axial ones @xmath86 . near the horizon and at infinity , the solutions @xmath83 satisfying the qnm boundary conditions are given , respectively , by @xmath87 } , \label{assint1}\ ] ] @xmath88 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 are arbitrary constants , and @xmath91 and @xmath92 are definite constants whose values depend on the perturbation type . now we multiply eq . by @xmath93 and integrate by parts using the asymptotic solutions and . after some algebra we obtain @xmath94dr= \frac{|\omega|^{2}|\phi(r_{+})|^{2}}{\mbox{im}(\omega)}. \label{int - final}\ ] ] since @xmath95 assumes only positive values outside of the black hole , the sign of the quantity on the left hand side of eq . depends crucially on the sign of the potential @xmath96 . for non - negative @xmath84 , it follows that the imaginary part of the qn frequencies is positive , @xmath97 . moreover , it is seen from eq . that @xmath98 is positive in the region @xmath99 for any @xmath1 and @xmath0 , and then we conclude that the plane - symmetric ads black holes are stable against polar perturbations . the same is true for axial perturbations as far as the wave numbers are restricted by @xmath100 . on the other hand , for @xmath101 , the potential @xmath102 takes negative values and the theorem can not be applied . another interesting property of frequencies associated to perturbations of a plane - symmetric black hole comes from the particular symmetry of such a background . this symmetry allows us to rescale @xmath40 , @xmath1 and @xmath0 by a pure scale transformation of coordinates @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , and @xmath106 , where @xmath107 is a constant @xcite . it implies that the frequency is a first degree homogeneous function of its parameters : @xmath108 . in particular , we can take @xmath109 so that @xmath110 then , after computing the qn frequencies for a given @xmath1 , e. g. , for @xmath111 , and for different values of @xmath0 , we can obtain @xmath112 by using the previous equation , and the values of @xmath40 for a fixed wave number @xmath1 are naturally divided into three different regimes : large ( @xmath113 ) , intermediate ( @xmath114 ) and small ( @xmath115 ) black holes . in the large ( small ) black hole limit , @xmath1 ( @xmath0 ) is negligibly small and it is expected that @xmath116 ( @xmath117 ) . we are now in a position to solve the perturbation equations and to find the values of the qn frequencies . this task , however , is more easily done through numerical procedures . therefore , it is appropriate summarizing here the method used for such a purpose . in the last decades a series of methods has been developed to numerically calculate the qnms of black holes . here we briefly describe one of these methods , used in ref . @xcite , which is of particular interest for the present work since it is suited for asymptotically ads spacetimes . in order to apply such a method we rewrite here the perturbation equations in the appropriate form .    by introducing the independent variable @xmath118 , eq . becomes @xmath119 where @xmath120 and @xmath121 , with @xmath84 and @xmath122 now being considered as functions of @xmath123 . the foregoing equation has a regular singular point ( @xmath124 ) in the region of interest , @xmath125 . then , by fuchs theorem , any solution of can be written as a frbenius series @xcite . the behavior of the solutions near the horizon may be explored by writing @xmath126 , where @xmath127 is a constant to be determined . by substituting this expression into eq . and keeping terms only to the leading order , it follows that @xmath128 , which has the roots @xmath129 and @xmath130 . these roots correspond exactly to the ingoing and outgoing waves at the horizon , respectively @xcite . since we want only ingoing modes , we take @xmath129 and look for solutions of the form @xmath131 substituting eq . into , we find expressions for the @xmath132 s in terms of the frequency @xmath40 ( and of the parameters @xmath1 and @xmath133 ) . then , imposing the boundary condition at infinity , @xmath134 , we obtain @xmath135 thus , the problem of finding qn frequencies has been reduced to that of obtaining the roots of the infinite - order polynomial equation . of course , we can not carry out numerically the full sum in expression . in effect we truncate the series after a large number of terms and look for the zeros of this partial sum . the precision of the results is then verified by computing the relative variation between the zeros as we perform higher partial sums . we stop our search once we have a @xmath136 decimal digit precision . for each pair of @xmath1 and @xmath0 , we find a set of qn frequencies ( out of the infinity of possible frequencies ) . these frequencies are labeled as usual with the principal quantum number @xmath137 and ordered in a set beginning with the roots with the lowest imaginary parts . we use the horowitz - hubeny procedure described above to compute the gravitational qnms of plane - symmetric ads black holes . as it happens to other ads black holes , there are _ purely damped modes _ , whose frequencies are pure imaginary numbers , in addition to the _ ordinary modes _ , the frequencies of which also have nonzero real parts which are responsible for the oscillatory behavior of the perturbations . as mentioned earlier , the numerical analysis is divided into three different regimes according to the ratio @xmath138 values . that is to say , we have ( i ) large black holes when the ratio @xmath138 is large compared to unity ; ( ii ) intermediate black holes if @xmath138 is of the order of unity ; and ( iii ) small black holes when @xmath138 is small compared to unity . it is also worth mentioning here that some numerical analysis of the gravitational qnms was done in ref . however , such a study was restricted mainly to the large black hole regime for a specific value of @xmath1 , without generalizations for a generic wave number . in what follows , we perform a more detailed analysis , including small and intermediate black holes , and extend implicitly the numerical results to all values of @xmath1 . we also search the qn frequency values in the limit of highly damped overtones .      to begin with , we discuss the case of regular ( ordinary ) qnms for which the frequencies have nonvanishing real and imaginary parts , @xmath139 . we list some numerical results of the lowest quasinormal frequencies for @xmath140 and some selected values of @xmath0 . the computed quantities include both the axial and polar perturbations , and the three regimes defined above . the data for large , intermediate , and small black holes are shown , respectively , in tables [ tlarge ] , [ tmedium ] , and [ tsmall ] . .the lowest ordinary qn frequencies for @xmath140 and several values of @xmath0 in the large black hole regime . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] although numerical procedures need to be used to compute the qn frequencies , it is possible to study analytically the special case of axial perturbations of very large black holes . here we show in some detail the process of finding an asymptotic expression for the frequency of the purely damped modes . the analysis is performed in such a way that it holds for both the plane - symmetric and the schwarzschild - ads spacetimes . our starting point is the horowitz - hubeny approach described in sec . [ metodo ] . there , the qn frequencies of axial perturbations are associated to solutions of the equation @xmath141 hence , we need to obtain an analytical expression for the sum of this series in order to find exact frequency values . such a task is very difficult to be carried out for a general @xmath133 , but it becomes feasible for the large black hole limit of purely damped modes . the coefficients @xmath142 appearing in eq . are the frbenius coefficients of the power series solution to either eq . written for the axial functions , or the corresponding equation in the schwarzschild - ads case ( see ref . they are given in terms of the frequency , and of the other physical parameters of the problem , by the following recurrence formulas : @xmath143 . \label{rec2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] the last equation is valid for all @xmath144 and we have shortened the equations by introducing the quantities @xmath145x_{+}^{2 } , \label{def1}\\ b_{m}=(m^{2}-2m-3)\left[1+\kappa x_{+}^{2}\right ] , \label{def2}\\ f_{m}=\left[m(3+\kappa x_{+}^{2})+2i\omega x_{+}\right]^{-1 } , \label{def3}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath146 and @xmath147 depending on whether it is considered a plane or spherical hole , respectively , and now the foregoing expressions hold for any @xmath148 .    in the large black hole regime , the wave number ( or the angular momentum ) of the perturbation is negligible and the frequency scales as @xmath149 . in terms of the variable @xmath133 , it implies that @xmath40 has a first order pole at @xmath150 . therefore , @xmath151 has a laurent series about @xmath150 , which is valid over the range @xmath152 , for some @xmath153 @xcite . such an expansion can be conveniently written as @xmath154 where @xmath155 are constants to be determined . however , not all of the elements @xmath155 are independent , since part of them can be eliminated on the basis of the parity property of the function @xmath151 . independently of what results from the sum on the left - hand side of eq . , the form of the quantities @xmath156 , @xmath157 , and @xmath158 ensures that the product @xmath159 is a function of @xmath160 . this means that @xmath40 changes its sign under the transformation @xmath161 , being an odd function of @xmath162 . accordingly , the series representing @xmath163 should be an even function of @xmath133 , which means that only the even powers of @xmath162 should survive , and then one should have @xmath164 for all @xmath165 . this result allows us to write @xmath166 where @xmath167 and @xmath168 are constants to be determined . the series representation of @xmath169 opens the possibility of taylor expanding the terms @xmath170 about @xmath171 . before doing this , we notice that the value of @xmath172 is arbitrary , since all the terms in the series of eq . are proportional to this element and the full sum is equal to zero . for simplicity , we choose here @xmath173 . then we substitute eq . into eq . and expand @xmath158 ( which depends on @xmath162 and also on @xmath40 ) about @xmath171 . when this expansion is substituted back into eqs . and , we obtain a set of taylor series for the elements @xmath170 ( one of such series for each @xmath174 ) , which may be represented by @xmath175 where the elements @xmath176 are functions of @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 , @xmath180 , ... , @xmath181 . substituting the previous expansions into eq . and collecting terms of the same power in @xmath14 , we find @xmath182 + \left[\eta_{1}^{1}(c_{0},c_{1})+\eta_{2}^{1}(c_{0},c_{1 } ) + ... \right]z+ ... =0 . \label{colecao}\ ] ]    yet the left - hand side of eq . is a power series in the variable @xmath14 . it implies that , in order for the equation being satisfied , all bracketed terms should vanish . therefore , the zeroth order coefficient provides an equation for @xmath179 , the first order coefficient , together with the earlier calculated value of @xmath179 , provides an equation for @xmath180 , and so on . here we begin with the computations that lead to @xmath179 . the first two relevant terms for this task are @xmath183 and @xmath184}$ ] . moreover , it can be seen from eq . that @xmath185 is identically zero , and as a consequence the term @xmath186 differs from @xmath187 only by a multiplicative factor . this implies , in particular , that the element @xmath188 is related to @xmath189 by @xmath190 such a relation , together with the formulas and , implies that all the subsequent elements are also proportional to @xmath189 . more specifically , the @xmath174th coefficient ( for @xmath191 ) can be written as @xmath192 , where @xmath193 is given by the recurrence formula @xmath194,\ ] ] with @xmath195 and @xmath196 . taking into account the last results , the @xmath14-independent term of eq . gives rise to the following equation for @xmath179 : @xmath197=0 . \label{puredampedzeros}\ ] ]    clearly the above equation has the special solution @xmath198 , in addition to the roots that arise as zeros of the square - bracketed term . the existence of this special solution explains why the purely damped modes do not scale with the horizon size , as it happens to ordinary modes in the large black hole limit . in fact , the numerical computations show that purely damped modes are the only qnms which in first approximation are not proportional to @xmath0 . this fact suggests they should be associated to the root @xmath198 , and then it follows from eq . that for large horizon radii the corresponding frequencies go as @xmath199 . on the other hand , the numerical results also indicate that the ordinary axial qnms are proportional to @xmath0 ( in first approximation ) . from this one concludes that the remaining roots that are obtained from the zeros of the term among brackets in eq . correspond to the asymptotic values of the function @xmath200 for these ordinary qnms . it is seen from the above analysis that , in order to calculate the leading term of the large horizon limit for the purely damped mode frequency , we must take @xmath198 and calculate the next parameter @xmath180 . in such a case , the coefficients @xmath201 and @xmath202 reduce to @xmath203/3 $ ] and @xmath204 , while the other elements @xmath205 ( for @xmath206 ) assume the form @xmath207 . substituting these results into the first order coefficient of we obtain an equation that can be solved for @xmath180 , yielding @xmath208}{\left(4+\gamma \right)},\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath209    the problem now is summing the series that leads to @xmath210 . fortunately , we succeeded in summing up this series ( see appendix b ) and the exact result is @xmath211 . with this , the coefficient @xmath180 becomes @xmath212 where @xmath213 and @xmath214 are given by @xmath215    once we have obtained an expression for @xmath180 , the asymptotic formula of the pure imaginary qn frequency follows directly from eq . . in fact , considering a plane - symmetric ads black hole , for which @xmath216 and @xmath217 , we have @xmath218 , and the interesting result follows : @xmath219 alternatively , for a schwarzschild - ads black hole one has @xmath220 and @xmath221 , which implies in @xmath222 and @xmath223 , leading to @xmath224 both of the last two formulas for the purely damped frequencies are exact results at the asymptotic limit of large black holes , in perfect agreement with the approximate fits found through the numerical calculations . the numerical results of the qn frequencies revealed a close relation between the algebraically special modes and the purely damped qnms . for a fixed wave number , the imaginary frequency @xmath225 approaches the values of the special frequency @xmath226 as the horizon radius goes to zero ( see the comments at the end of section [ perturb - np ] ) . there also seems to exist a meeting point @xmath227 between the two frequencies for a special combination of parameters such that @xmath228 , as it can be seen from the numerical results shown in fig . [ fpuro ] . furthermore , the relation between the purely damped modes and the algebraically special frequency in the small horizon limit is not restricted to the plane - symmetric black hole case , but it also appears in axial perturbations in the schwarzschild - ads spacetime . all these facts render it convenient to analyze here the qn character of the algebraically special perturbation modes . the frequency function of these modes for the plane - symmetric black hole is given by eq . , while the corresponding expression in the spherical case is found in ref . @xcite . in a general form , the frequency @xmath226 can be written as @xmath229 } { 6(1+\kappa x_{+}^{2})}x_{+}^{3},\ ] ] where again @xmath146 and @xmath147 , as it is considered a plane or spherical black hole , respectively .    to verify if the algebraically special modes satisfy the qnm boundary conditions we need to obtain the solution @xmath230 associated with the algebraically special frequency @xmath226 . since this function is a particular case of the general power series solution , we may use eqs . and to determine the coefficients @xmath132 for @xmath231 . once again we may take @xmath173 , so that the coefficients @xmath232 and @xmath233 are given , respectively , by @xmath234 @xmath235 + 6i\omega ( 1+\kappa x_{+}^{2})}{4x_{+}(3+\kappa x_{+}^{2}+i\omega x_{+ } ) ( 3+\kappa x_{+}^{2}+2i\omega x_{+})}.\ ] ] it is seen from the last equation that @xmath233 vanishes for the frequency @xmath231 . moreover , since all the other elements @xmath132 ( for @xmath206 ) differ from @xmath233 only by a multiplicative factor , we have @xmath236 . the solution for @xmath230 then reduces to @xmath237x_{+}^{2}}\left(1-\frac{x}{x_{+}}\right ) . \label{afunc}\ ] ]    we know from the horowitz - hubeny method that the function represents an ingoing wave at the event horizon . here the problem is verifying if @xmath230 satisfies the dirichlet boundary condition at the spatial infinity . imposing the condition @xmath238 , we find an equation that is satisfied only if @xmath239 or @xmath240 , where @xmath214 and @xmath213 are given by eq . . for a plane - symmetric ads black hole , this means we need a vanishing wave number in order to have a qn frequency equal to @xmath226 . in this case , however , the resulting perturbation functions would be independent of time , which could not represent gravitational waves . similarly , for a schwarzschild - ads spacetime we need to have @xmath241 or @xmath242 . the first root is a physically forbidden value , while the second one leads to a static perturbation , which only adds a small rotation to the black hole @xcite . on the basis of these results , we conclude that @xmath226 can not be a qn frequency , because the associated wave function @xmath230 does not satisfy the dirichlet boundary condition at infinity . although the numerical calculations show that in the small horizon limit @xmath225 is very close to @xmath226 , the above result proves that the frequency function associated with purely damped modes is not exactly equal to the algebraically special frequency . the solid line in fig . [ fpuro ] does not coincide with the dots , which represent qnms , not even in the small black hole regime . there is , however , a special point @xmath227 where @xmath226 seems to coincide with @xmath243 . the answer to the question whether @xmath226 corresponds to a qn frequency at that point or not is given in the following .    in spite of the generality of the analysis performed above , it fails to test the qn character of @xmath226 in the case where @xmath244 . this situation happens for a special family of parameters satisfying the condition @xmath245 in this case the roots of the frbenius index equation , which are @xmath129 and @xmath246 ( @xmath247 ) , differ by an integer number and the horowitz - hubeny method is not valid . we can circumvent this problem by writing explicitly the axial version of eq . for @xmath231 and parameters satisfying eq . . by doing this in such a way that the analysis holds for both the plane and the spherical ads black holes , it is found that @xmath248 \frac{d^{\,2}\phi_{a}^ { ( -)}}{dx^{2}}+ \left[3(1+\kappa x_{+}^{2})x + ( 3+\kappa x_{+}^{2})x_{+}\right ] \frac{d\phi_{a}^ { ( -)}}{dx}-3(1+\kappa x_{+}^{2 } ) \phi_{a}^ { ( -)}=0 . \label{fund - new}\ ] ] here @xmath249 is a regular point of the above differential equation , and the solution for @xmath250 can be expressed as a taylor series , @xmath251 substituting this expression into eq . , we find as usual that all coefficients @xmath252 ( for @xmath253 ) can be expressed in terms of the first two , @xmath254 and @xmath255 . the general solution of eq . then assumes the form @xmath256\\ & + d_{1}\left[(x - x_{+})+ \frac{(3 + 2\kappa x_{+}^{2})}{(3+\kappa x_{+}^{2 } ) } \sum_{m=2}^{\infty}\frac{\beta_{m}}{(-x_{+})^{m-1 } } ( x - x_{+})^{m}\right ] , \label{sol - geral } \end{split}\ ] ] where the parameters @xmath257 ( for all @xmath258 ) are given by the recurrence formula @xmath259 with @xmath260 and @xmath261 .    the first term among brackets in eq . represents a perturbation function which is constant at the event horizon and corresponds to an ingoing wave , while the second term represents an outgoing wave , since it goes as @xmath262 in the limit @xmath263 . to satisfy the qnm boundary condition at the horizon , we must take @xmath264 and keep only the first term of the general solution . in addition , without loss of generality we may choose @xmath265 . finally , we must verify if the function @xmath230 satisfies the dirichlet boundary condition at the spatial infinity @xmath266 . by substituting @xmath267 , @xmath268 , and @xmath266 into eq . it follows that @xmath269    for plane - symmetric ads black holes , our numerical calculations show that @xmath270 , independently of the horizon radius . on the other hand , we obtain different values for @xmath271 as we change the schwarzschild black hole size . another way to see this variation is in terms of the angular momentum , since @xmath133 and @xmath4 are coupled through eq . . [ falgeb ] , we plot the numerical values of @xmath272 ( dashed line ) and of @xmath271 for @xmath273 ( dots ) . as the angular momentum goes to infinity , which means @xmath274 , the results found for the spherical case tend to the value of the plane black hole . since @xmath275 is always different from zero , we conclude that the algebraically special modes are not qnms , not even for the special parameters that lead to @xmath228 . for the plane - symmetric black hole and for @xmath140 , this corresponds to the point @xmath227 in fig . [ fpuro ] , where the lines representing the purely damped qn and the algebraically special frequencies tend to intercept each other . among other things , this result implies that the qnm spectrum of some black holes does not present a particular pure imaginary frequency , for those specific modes whose wave numbers ( or angular momentum ) satisfy eq . . for instance , an axial quadrupole ( @xmath276 ) perturbation is not able to excite a purely damped qnm in a schwarzschild - ads black hole with @xmath277 . whether this conclusion has some physical implication to the ads / cft conjecture or not is still an open question . we have studied the gravitational quasinormal modes of plane - symmetric anti - de sitter black holes . these modes are responsible for the late time behavior of small gravitational disturbances . the wave equations governing the axial and polar perturbations were derived by a procedure based on the newman - penrose formalism and on the chandrasekhar transformation theory . this approach allowed us to treat equally the two spacelike coordinates @xmath13 and @xmath14 , as well as provided the algebraically special frequencies associated to the gravitational waves radiated by the black hole .    using the horowitz - hubeny method , we have computed the quasinormal frequencies for @xmath140 and several values of @xmath0 in the large , intermediate , and small black hole regimes . the wave - number dependence of the modes was obtained on the basis of the homogeneity property of the function @xmath112 . for large black holes , the ordinary frequencies scale linearly with @xmath0 , and the pure imaginary frequency goes as @xmath199 . for small black holes , the fundamental modes present @xmath278 and @xmath279 , while @xmath225 approaches the algebraically special frequency @xmath280 . in the limit of highly damped overtones , we found the qn frequencies are evenly spaced , with the spacing per unit of horizon radius being a constant which is independent of the wave - number value , perturbation parity , and black hole size .    in relation to stability , we have shown analytically that for a non - negative potential the imaginary part of the frequency is positive definite for every mode . from the numerical results it also follows that all qn frequencies have a positive imaginary part , including the cases where the potential takes negative values . these results conjointly imply that plane - symmetric ads black holes are stable against gravitational perturbations .    to study the large black hole limit we have developed an analytical method based on the expansion of the frequency in powers of @xmath199 . application of this method to axial perturbations showed that there is a special frequency for which the ratio @xmath281 goes to zero as @xmath282 . the first nonvanishing term is @xmath283 for the plane hole and @xmath284 for the schwarzschild hole . it is important to observe that these purely damped modes are particularly long living for large black holes , which is exactly the relevant regime for the ads / cft correspondence . if the above asymptotic formulas could be derived on the cft side , it could provide an important quantitative test to the maldacena s conjecture .    as a last remark , it should be noted that the discussion of the physical interpretation of the modes with different wave - number values remains . preliminary results show that the zero wave - number axial perturbations yield only small rotations on the system , while the polar ones lead to an increase in the mass and the production of gravitational waves @xcite . this issue , however , must be investigated in more detail and shall be considered in our future work . we are indebted to v. cardoso for suggestions and for a critical reading of the manuscript . we also thank j. p. s. lemos for stimulating conversations . one of us ( a. s. m. ) thanks the conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico - cnpq , brazil , for a grant . in this appendix we discuss briefly how to find the modes of gravitational perturbations in pure plane - symmetric ads spacetimes . this is to be compared to the small black hole limit qnms , as calculated numerically in sec . [ resultados ] .    the relevant wave equations for axial and polar perturbations may be obtained from eq . by assuming @xmath286 wherever it appears . for instance , the potentials @xmath287 reduce to the same constant value @xmath288 the resulting equations are then @xmath289 whose solutions in terms of the coordinate @xmath290 are of the form @xmath291 where @xmath292 , @xmath293 , @xmath294 , and @xmath295 are integration constants . the solution functions for @xmath296 are analytic in the whole range of the radial coordinate which is of interest for comparison to the small black hole qnms , @xmath297 . hence , the only condition @xmath40 must satisfy is @xmath298 in order to avoid the wave growing exponentially in the limit @xmath299 . however , additional restrictions to these modes arise by imposing the usual boundary conditions for qnms in ads spacetimes : no wave can come out from the black hole horizon , which is located at @xmath300 ; and no wave can propagate to spatial infinity , @xmath301 . by substituting these conditions into eqs . it follows that @xmath302 and @xmath303 , which means waves whose frequencies satisfy the relation @xmath296 do vanish everywhere . we are then left with the solutions for which @xmath304 only . in this case there is in fact no wave in the radial direction , so that the solutions @xmath305 , for @xmath306 , represent waves traveling along the spatial directions orthogonal to the @xmath38 direction . in other words , there are no waves coming out from the horizon nor propagating to spacelike infinity . considering these as the plane - symmetric pure ads modes , their frequencies , given by @xmath307 agree with the result found numerically for small black holes . here we show how the series presented in eq . can be summed up exactly . since it is an alternating series , it is important not only to prove its convergence , but also to test it for absolute convergence . by mathematical induction , we find that the series can be written as a combination of seven terms @xmath308 where the elements @xmath309 ( @xmath310 , @xmath311 , ... , @xmath136 ) are given by @xmath312 then we are left with a sum of six series , and by proving the absolute convergence of each one of them , the absolute convergence of the whole series @xmath313 is also proved . in order to do that , we calculate the limit @xmath314 and verify that it is smaller than unity for any @xmath315 , and then by applying the dalembert ratio test we conclude that every individual series is absolutely convergent . this result implies that the final sum for @xmath210 is independent of the element ordering in the alternating series . in particular , we can add the terms @xmath316 over all @xmath315 , for @xmath310 , @xmath311 , ... , @xmath136 , before performing the sum over @xmath174 . by doing that , we find the simple result @xmath317 for any value of @xmath174 , and hence the sum over @xmath174 gives zero . therefore , the sum of the series ( [ comb1 ] ) is @xmath211 .
Abstract:

Answer: we study in detail the quasinormal modes of linear gravitational perturbations of plane - symmetric anti - de sitter black holes . the wave equations are obtained by means of the newman - penrose formalism and the chandrasekhar transformation theory . we show that oscillatory modes decay exponentially with time such that these black holes are stable against gravitational perturbations . our numerical results show that in the large ( small ) black hole regime the frequencies of the ordinary quasinormal modes are proportional to the horizon radius @xmath0 ( wave number @xmath1 ) . the frequency of the purely damped mode is very close to the algebraically special frequency in the small horizon limit , and goes as @xmath2 in the opposite limit . this result is confirmed by an analytical method based on the power series expansion of the frequency in terms of the horizon radius . the same procedure applied to the schwarzschild anti - de sitter spacetime proves that the purely damped frequency goes as @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the quantum number characterizing the angular distribution . finally , we study the limit of high overtones and find that the frequencies become evenly spaced in this regime . the spacing of the frequency per unit horizon radius seems to be a universal quantity , in the sense that it is independent of the wave number , perturbation parity and black hole size .


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: thermodynamics is an integral cornerstone of our understanding of the physical world , where the core principles are based on the existence of a thermal equilibrium . for systems driven out - of - equilibrium , the governing principles are much less understood ; see _ e.g. _  @xcite . it is extremely difficult to address such questions in a strongly coupled quantum system . first , given a microscopic description , conventional perturbative techniques are inadequate at strong coupling . second , conceptual insights that may lead to an effective description are also lacking .    in recent years , the ads / cft correspondence@xcite , more generally the gauge - gravity duality@xcite , has emerged to be an extremely powerful tool to address aspects of strongly coupled physics . string theory provides a large class of concrete examples where this correspondence is precise . many of these examples correspond to a strongly coupled conformal or a scale - invariant field theory and is naturally equipped in describing quantum criticality . however , criticality is not necessary . the duality works for generic large-@xmath0 gauge theories with a running coupling constant@xcite , or a confining gauge theory@xcite .    in this article , we will use the gauge - gravity duality to explore an emerging principle for a system driven out - of - equilibrium . we will consider a non - equilibrium steady - state ( ness ) situation within a probe sector which is kept in contact with a large background at some given temperature @xmath1 . the ness in the probe sector is induced by introducing a constant external electric field @xmath2 that drives a constant current . we will argue that _ all modes _ in this probe sector experience an effective temperature , denoted by @xmath3 , with respect to which it has a purely thermal behaviour . we will also argue that for conformal systems this effective temperature is always larger than the background temperature : @xmath4 . by virtue of the probe limit , the heat flow between the probe sector and the background is suppressed . for critical systems , @xmath3 depends only on three ingredients : ( i ) dimensionality @xmath5 , ( ii ) the global symmetry group @xmath6 and ( iii ) how ness is induced , _ i.e. _ ,  @xmath2 . for gapped systems , or systems with a running coupling constant , there may be additional dependences on the beta function of the gauge coupling or other dimensionful parameters in the system . the existence of the unique effective temperature @xmath3 is , nonetheless , ubiquitous . in generic situations one can verify that @xmath7 . however , there may be special cases when this is not true , see _ e.g. _ the consequences of this are rather profound : it allows us to define thermodynamics with an effective entropy , obtain a fluctuation - dissipation relation and recover an _ otherwise thermal _ physics for the ness . in this article , we will discuss the main results for a broader perspective and a technically detailed account will appear elsewhere@xcite . in the most familiar example of the ads / cft correspondence @xmath8 for a boundary theory in @xmath5 spacetime dimensions@xcite . in all known examples , the gravity description emerges from the closed string sector . this is typically described by a @xmath9-dimensional geometry of the freund - rubin type : _ e.g. _ ads@xmath10 , where ads@xmath11 denotes the anti - de sitter space in @xmath12-dimensions and @xmath13 denotes a compact manifold . the symbol @xmath14 denotes a warped product geometry . this geometry and the various matter fields are sourced by a collection of a large number of branes , which equivalently gives rise to the adjoint sector of the dual large-@xmath0 , @xmath15 gauge theory . a finite non - zero temperature is realized as the presence of an event horizon in the geometry . the corresponding hawking temperature can be obtained by demanding regularity of the euclidean metric with a compact time direction . we introduce probe degrees of freedom in the background of a thermal adjoint sector , which transform under the fundamental representation of the @xmath15 gauge group . in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry , this can be achieved by introducing probe branes of appropriate dimensions , which amounts to introducing open string degrees of freedom in the closed - string background . the details of the probe embedding depend primarily on three factors : ( i ) dimensionality , ( ii ) stability of the embedding and ( iii ) the physics we want to realize . this was pioneered in @xcite . clearly , the full details of the @xmath9-dimensional background play a crucial role in such embeddings and each case needs to be studied individually . for simplicity , however , we will abstract away from this detailed constructions and focus on a _ reduced _ description for the probes@xcite . let us begin with a background @xmath12-dimensional metric , in the string frame , of the general form @xmath16 where we assume that the metric functions depend on only one co - ordinate @xmath17 , which is the radial direction . in our convention , @xmath18 is the boundary of the bulk spacetime . the dual field theory lives in the @xmath19-plane . furthermore , we collectively represent the compact manifold by @xmath20 . in this background we introduce @xmath21 number of probe d@xmath22-branes which wrap @xmath23 and @xmath24 of the remaining space - directions ( along with @xmath25 of the compact directions ) . the dynamics of these probes is determined by the dirac - born - infeld ( dbi ) action@xcite @xmath26 +   f \right]\right)^{1/2 } , \label{dbi } \\                      & = & - n_f t_p \int d^{p+1 } \xi \ , l_{\rm dbi } \ , \\ { \rm with } \quad 1 & = & \left(2 \pi \alpha'\right ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 denotes the tension of the d@xmath22-brane , @xmath28 denotes the collective coordinates on the brane worldvolume ( including the compact directions ) , @xmath29 is the dilaton field , @xmath30 $ ] denotes the pull - back of the background metric : @xmath31_{ab } = \frac{\partial x^\mu}{\partial \xi^a } \frac{\partial x^\nu}{\partial \xi^b } \ , g_{\mu\nu } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath32 represents a gauge field on the probe worldvolume . for simplicity , we will assume that @xmath30 $ ] is trivial , _ @xmath33 = g \right |_{\rm worldvolume}$ ] , which means that we assume @xmath34 minimizes the probe worldvolume . here , the subscript @xmath35 denotes the classical profile . note that we have implicitly assumed that the background has vanishing ns - ns two - form . this is chosen for convenience , and a non - vanishing ns - ns two - form will not modify the qualitative physics which we will discuss in this article . the steady - state physics can be induced by having a gauge field on the worldvolume @xmath36 where @xmath2 denotes the electric field along @xmath37-direction and @xmath38 is a function that needs to be determined from the equation of motion . since the dbi lagrangian depends only on @xmath32 , it is a functional of @xmath39 only . thus we immediately get an integral of motion , which we call @xmath40 @xmath41 the above definition of @xmath40 yields the equation of motion for @xmath42 , which can be solved to obtain @xmath43 evidently , the solution for @xmath42 has a sign ambiguity . this can be fixed by demanding an  ingoing " boundary condition at the horizon@xcite , which means that the energy - momentum flows into the horizon . using this , the on - shell dbi lagrangian is obtained to be @xmath44^{1/2 } .\label{lagon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in general , because of the square - root expressions , the on - shell dbi lagrangian may not be real - valued for all values of @xmath17 . the reality condition demands that the numerator and the denominator change sign at the same radial location @xmath45 . these conditions in turn determine the constant @xmath40 as a function of @xmath45 : @xmath46 here @xmath45 is obtained by solving ( [ ustar ] ) and , as observed by the bulk geometry , is a completely unremarkable position . we will see that this @xmath45 will play the key role for the open string degrees of freedom . following @xcite it can be shown that the constant @xmath40 is proportional to the boundary current driven by @xmath2 and consequently we can define a conductivity , @xmath47@xcite . so far we have discussed the classical profile of the probe brane . let us now discuss the physics of the fluctuation modes on the probe . from the perspective of the dual field theory , these fluctuations are of three kinds : ( i ) scalar , ( ii ) vector and ( iii ) spinor . the scalar fluctuations are the transverse fluctuations of the probe brane embedding : @xmath48 where @xmath49 denotes the classical profile of the probe and @xmath50 represents the collective transverse fluctuations . the vector fluctuations correspond to the fluctuations of the classical gauge field on the probe @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the classical gauge field on the probe in equation ( [ classgauge ] ) . finally , the spinors come from a supersymmetric counter - part of the dbi action in ( [ dbi ] ) , which schematically consists of a standard volkov - akulov type term @xmath53\right)^{1/2 } , \label{dbi2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath54 + f$ ] and the @xmath55 matrices satisfy anti - commutation relation with respect to @xmath30 $ ] : @xmath56_{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] more precisely , the quadratic fluctuation term on a given d@xmath22-probe brane can be read of from @xcite . the computation of fluctuation modes around a particular classical brane configuration will involve inverting the matrix @xmath57 , which can then be decomposed into a symmetric and an anti - symmetric part : @xmath58 + f^{(0 ) } \right)^{-1 } \right)^{ab}= \s^{ab } + \a^{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be showed that@xcite @xmath59 + f^{(0 ) } } \cdot p[g ] \cdot \frac{1}{p[g]-f^{(0)}}\right)^{ab } \ , \label{osmmet } \\ \s_{ab } & = & p[g]_{ab } - \left ( f^{(0 ) } \cdot p[g]^{-1 } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \right)_{ab } \ , \\ \a^{ab } & = & - \left(\frac{1}{p[g]+ f^{(0 ) } } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \cdot \frac{1}{p[g]-f^{(0)}}\right)^{ab } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the indices are now raised and lowered with respect to the effective metric denoted by @xmath60 , which also determines the kinetic terms for the corresponding fluctuation modes . thus , the fluctuations are governed by lagrangians which take the following schematic form : @xmath61 in @xmath62 we have redefined the gamma matrices by : @xmath63 also in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) , @xmath64 denotes an overall constant , the details of which is not relevant for us . the fields @xmath50 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 represent the various fluctuation modes and the indices @xmath67 represent the worldvolume coordinates on the probe . we have shown only the kinetic parts of the fluctuation lagrangian ; since other potential terms will not affect our conclusions . the key observation is that all these modes perceive an effective metric , denoted by @xmath60 , which is different from both the background metric @xmath68 and the induced metric @xmath30 $ ] . this is the so called _ open string metric_@xcite , which governs the dynamics of open string degrees of freedom propagating in a background geometry with an anti - symmetric @xmath69-form . the open string data , in terms of the closed string data , is given by@xcite @xmath70_{ab } - \left(f^{(0 ) } \cdot p[g]^{-1 } \cdot f^{(0 ) } \right)_{ab } , \label{osm } \\ & & \g_s = g_s \left[\frac{- { \rm det } \left(p[g ] + f^{(0)}\right)}{- { \rm det } p[g ] } \right]^{1/2 } \label{osg } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath60 and @xmath71 denote the open string metric and the open string coupling ; @xmath68 and @xmath72 denote the closed string metric and the closed string coupling . the structure of the fluctuations suggests an _ open string equivalence principle_@xcite .    for the background in ( [ metgen ] ) , the embedding in ( [ embed ] ) and the gauge field in ( [ gaugeelectric ] ) , the open string metric is given by @xmath73 where we are suppressing the compact part on purpose . the various components can be given in terms of the background metric and the gauge field as @xmath74 clearly , the open string metric is non - diagonal in the @xmath75-plane . we can diagonalize this block by introducing a new coordinate system @xmath76 , which is defined as @xmath77 with this , the open string metric takes the following form @xmath78 the zeroes of @xmath79 will now determine the location of an event - horizon of the open string metric . from the definition of @xmath79 in ( [ stt ] ) , we observe that the electric field results in an event horizon of the open string metric at the location @xmath80 , which is obtained by solving ( [ ustar ] ) . subsequently , the open string equivalence principle implies an universal effective temperature in the probe sector . we can read off this temperature by requiring regularity of the euclidean open string metric and compactifying the @xmath81-direction . note that , we can not make euclidean @xmath68 and euclidean @xmath60 regular simultaneously since their respective horizons do not coincide , which implies that the background and the probe sector are not in a thermal equilibrium . carrying out the usual procedure of euclideanization of the osm , periodically identifying the imaginary time - direction and then demanding regularity yields the following formula for the effective temperature @xmath82 \right|_{u = u _ * } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath83 . assuming an @xmath84 symmetry along the @xmath85 directions in the boundary theory , we can choose @xmath86 . in that case , this effective temperature , given in terms of the background data @xmath87 , can be recast in the following general form @xmath88^{1/2 } \right|_{u = u _ * }   \label{teff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath89 represents the beta function corresponding to the running dilaton . assuming @xmath90 , from ( [ teff ] ) it is clear that the sufficient condition to violate @xmath91 is to have @xmath92 , which will violate weak energy condition for the matter field on the classical probe profile . this is expected intuitively , since maintaining the steady - state continually pumps energy into the system and the resulting @xmath3 should be greater than @xmath1 . in the presence of a non - trivial @xmath93 , this inequality @xmath7 is not always true@xcite . the propagation of fluctuations in a dbi - background can be analyzed using the method of boillat ( see _ e.g. _ @xcite and @xcite for a more recent discussion ) . subsequently , it can be shown that the open string causal structure is determined by the boillat metric , which belongs to the same conformal class as the open string metric . typically , the boillat light - cone lies inside the einstein light - cone as long as an weak energy condition is satisfied by the matter field on the probe@xcite . this light cone structure is another manifestation of the @xmath91 inequality . this effective temperature is accompanied by an effective entropy as well . in @xcite the helmholtz free energy for such an ness probe system was conjectured for a particular system . before we generalize the proposal in @xcite , let us offer some comments regarding the validity of our analysis . the basic statement of gauge - gravity duality can be succinctly phrased as below : @xmath94 where @xmath95 corresponds to the _ bulk gravity path integral _ and @xmath96 is the field theory path integral . the quantity @xmath95 is defined as @xmath97 here @xmath98 is the @xmath9 or @xmath99-dimensional supergravity action which gives rise to the metric solution in ( [ metgen ] ) . generically , form fields of various ranks will also be present in the background . however , as we have mentioned before , these form fields will not affect our conclusions . on the other hand , @xmath100 represents the action of the probe in ( [ dbi ] ) . in terms of the gravitational description , @xmath101 since it originates from the closed string sector , whereas @xmath102 , which originates from the open string sector . clearly , the total path integral factorizes into the gravitational part and the probe part . following @xcite , or more recently @xcite , it can be argued that stringy physics can be decoupled from a purely ( super)gravity one in which one can use the gauge - gravity duality safely , as long as the curvature scale is sufficiently small compared to the string scale and the local string coupling is small enough . it is also argued in @xcite , that in the limit the local string coupling grows , one may be able to use an s - dual description or an m - theory uplift and subsequently use the corresponding gravitational description to explore the strongly coupled regime of the dual field theory . at any rate , there exists a range of energy , for which a classical gravity dual description is valid . now , as long as we have a classical gravitational description , we can certainly probe the geometry provided @xmath103 . however this condition may be too naive . in reality , in order for a brane to be a legitimate probe of a background , one needs to compute the stress - energy tensor coming from the probe , denoted by @xmath104 , to the einstein tensor of the background , denoted by @xmath105 and impose : @xmath106 the non - trivial ingredient that enters the relation in ( [ probecond ] ) is the radial - scale of the background geometry , which can override the @xmath103 limit . now , it can also be checked , _ e.g. _  if we place @xmath21 number of d@xmath107-brane probe in the near horizon geometry of a stack of d@xmath22-branes@xcite , the condition in ( [ probecond ] ) is satisfied , at least in a non - vanishing range of the energy scale ( a detailed account will appear in @xcite ) . this essentially means that we can use the purely classical gravitational description and the probe sector _ path integral _ is completely determined by the classical dirac - born - infeld contribution ( there may be wess - zumino term , but it would not change our conclusions ) . by now , this has become a common practice in gauge - gravity duality , see _ e.g. _  @xcite . now , let us comment on @xmath96 . gauge - gravity duality states that the gravitational part is dual to the adjoint sector of the large @xmath108-gauge theory and the probe sector corresponds to the fundamental flavour that has been introduced in the probe limit . likewise , we have @xmath109 here , typically @xmath110 and corresponds to the adjoint sector , while @xmath111 corresponds to the fundamental sector . at this point , one can expect that the fundamental sector is a legitimate probe in the limit @xmath103 , however , the legitimacy of the probe limit can depend on the energy - scale of the theory . recall , that the t hooft coupling is generally dimensionful , so it can set the energy - scale where back - reaction by the flavour sector becomes important . this is precisely the dual realization of the more stringent condition in ( [ probecond ] ) . and , as we have argued just below equation ( [ probecond ] ) , for a large class of examples , there exists at least a non - vanishing energy - range for which the probe limit is perfectly legitimate . for such cases , the qft path integral also factorizes between the adjoint sector and the fundamental sector . now we can introduce the standard trick of thermal field theory : first euclideanize the time direction and then compactify on it . finally the path integral is identified with the partition function and the period of the resulting @xmath112 is identified with the inverse temperature of the system . note , here we can impose two different periodicities for the adjoint and the fundamental sector , respectively . these two periodicities correspond to regularity condition of the euclidean closed - string metric in ( [ metgen ] ) and the regularity of the open string metric in ( [ osmmet ] ) . since the modes in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) on the probe perceive the open string metric , we will focus on the latter . now we are ready to discuss the resulting _ thermodynamic _ description for the probe . we can generalize the proposal of @xcite for the current situation . let us work with the euclidean action , which we denote by @xmath113 : @xmath114 which can be obtained from ( [ dbi ] ) after substituting the ansatz for the gauge field in ( [ classgauge ] ) and then euclideanizing the resulting action . note that , all other constants and volume factors have been absorbed in the constant @xmath115 . evidently , variation of this action yields @xmath116 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where  horizon " and  boundary " respectively stand for the osm horizon and the conformal boundary . generically , we can impose @xmath117 , and subsequently we need to subtract off the boundary contribution coming from @xmath118 . the boundary - terms - subtracted on - shell euclidean action is then given by @xmath119 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the definition of @xmath40 from ( [ defj ] ) . thus the general proposal for the corresponding helmholtz free energy is given by @xmath120 where @xmath121 is given in ( [ lagon ] ) . we have evidently written down the expression in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry . it can be noted that the conjectured free energy is essentially a legendre transformation of the on - shell euclidean probe action . the associated effective entropy is now given by @xmath122 note that , the boundary term in ( [ thermosteady ] ) contributes non - trivially in the entropy of the system .    before leaving this section , let us ponder over an interesting observation . assuming that @xmath123 has a simple zero , where the closed string event horizon is located , it can be verified that @xmath124 where @xmath125 denotes the closed string event horizon , @xmath81 is a typical time - scale and @xmath126 . this time - scale  which has a logarithmic divergence  can be identified with the time light rays take to travel from the conformal boundary to the background event horizon . intriguingly , this time - scale appears in an ohmic dissipation term when the boundary term in ( [ thermosteady ] ) is evaluated at the closed string horizon . by evaluating this boundary term at the osm horizon , we are ir - safe in ( [ thermosteady ] ) . on the other hand , there is a natural candidate for a bekenstein - hawking type area formula involving the open string data @xmath127 . recall that a probe action scales as @xmath128 , where @xmath72 is the closed string coupling . thus , the natural area - law candidate is given by @xmath129 where @xmath130 is an undetermined constant and @xmath131 denotes the area of the open string metric event horizon . also note that both @xmath71 and @xmath131 are functions of the radial coordinate @xmath17 . for a conformal theory beyond @xmath132 , the bekenstein - hawking area formula indeed is proportional to the thermodynamic entropy obtained from ( [ thermosteady ] ) . this , however , is a simple consequence of conformal invariance . in general , ( [ ose ] ) does not yield the thermodynamic entropy obtained from ( [ thermosteady ] ) . in fact it has a different scaling behaviour with respect to the temperature . it will be very interesting to explore and understand the physical significance of ( [ ose ] ) in these general situations . let us now discuss some special cases . ( i ) for a system with @xmath133 , where ( [ seff ] ) and ( [ ose ] ) are proportional to each other , the effective entropy is observed to obey a simple relation with the conductivity @xmath134 the above relation holds for @xmath135 . \(ii ) if we assume that the dual field theory is lorentz invariant , _ @xmath136 then in the limit of strong electric field ( _ i.e. _  @xmath137 , where @xmath1 is the background closed - string metric temperature ) , we will get @xmath138 and subsequently the effective temperature takes a very generic form @xmath139^{1/2 } \ . \label{gen2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in obtaining the above relation in ( [ gen2 ] ) , we have used the conductivity obtained from ( [ ustar ] ) and ( [ current ] ) . for a given physical system obeying such relations perhaps bears the possibility of a holographic dual description . let us now briefly discuss some more specific class of backgrounds . an ads@xmath11-schwarzschild background is given by @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the radius of the ads - space . the dilaton vanishes for this background . the closed - string - background temperature is obtained to be : @xmath142 in the large and small electric field limits , which can be obtained by setting @xmath143 and @xmath144 , we get : @xmath145 interestingly , both expressions above are independent of @xmath5 . the effective temperature in the intermediate regime is given by an interpolating function which can be analytically determined from ( [ teff ] ) . the limiting scaling behaviours are simple consequences of the underlying conformal symmetry of the system . note that , the effective temperature obtained from ( [ teff ] ) by setting @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath133 , we recover the results discussed in @xcite . lifshitz geometry is another special class of geometries that corresponds to a dual field theory with non - relativistic scale invariance under @xmath148 , @xmath149 . here @xmath150 is known as the dynamical exponent of the system . such geometries can be viewed as infrared fixed points that describe low energy quantum criticality , which may be relevant for condensed matter systems . as @xmath151 , the metric components take the form @xmath152 where , for convenience , the radius of the background is set to unity . for such a geometry , in the limit @xmath153 , the location of the osm event horizon obeys @xmath154 and the analogue of the relation in ( [ gen2 ] ) takes the following form @xmath155^{1/2 } . \label{gen2lif }   \end{aligned}\ ] ] for an exact lifshitz geometry , where the entire bulk is defined by ( [ lifback ] ) , the effective temperature is given by @xmath156 a generalization of the lifshitz background is the so called hyper - scaling violation geometry , for which similar relations can be obtained as well . one of the profound consequences of the open string equivalence principle is the existence of a fluctuation - dissipation relation involving the effective temperature . in a system at thermal equilibrium , fluctuation - dissipation relations connect the linear relaxation response of the system to a small perturbation around the equilibrium configuration . in @xcite such a relation was obtained for the current noise in a @xmath157-dimensional theory in a steady - state . because of the open string equivalence principle , here we argue that _ all open string degrees of freedom _ in a holographic theory obey such a relation with respect to @xmath3 . this claim can be explicitly verified by calculating the boundary schwinger - keldysh two - time correlator using the holographic description , as outlined in @xcite .    in a quantum field theory , the schwinger - keldysh propagator corresponds to the contour - ordered correlation function . following the notations in @xcite , we get @xmath158 here @xmath159 denotes time - ordering and @xmath160 denotes reverse time - ordering . the subscripts @xmath161 correspond to the minkowski part of the contour . on the other hand , the advanced and the retarded green s functions are also related to the schwinger - keldysh correlators _ via _ \rangle \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] from the above definitions it follows that @xmath163 where @xmath1 is the corresponding temperature . taking @xmath164 limit we obtain the fluctuation dissipation relation , which gives @xmath165 where the lhs represents the fluctuation and the bracket - ed term in the rhs represents the dissipation . in ads / cft the relation in ( [ flucdissholo ] ) emerges from the schwinger - keldysh formalism , as demonstrated in @xcite . the schwinger - keldysh computations consist of analyzing analyticity properties of various modes on the kruskal patch of the corresponding bulk spacetime . for a typical black hole geometry , fluctuation - dissipation relations physically arise from the underlying black hole thermodynamics . for the modes in ( [ fscalar])-([fspinor ] ) , this underlying thermodynamics is governed by the open string metric event horizon and thus a corresponding fluctuation - dissipation result is imminent , where the temperature in ( [ flucdissholo ] ) is replaced by the effective temperature @xmath3 . in this article , we have argued that for the holographic probe systems at ness the physics remains thermal with an effective temperature . the corresponding particle distribution functions @xmath166 at an energy @xmath167 are expected to be given by a bose - einstein or a fermi - dirac statistics involving this effective temperature . the governing principles are the existence of an open string metric event horizon and an open string equivalence principle . the origin of this effective temperature is rooted in the combined effect of thermal fluctuation from the background and a schwinger pair production which sets off the ness . we further note that the thermal nature of a similar system was noticed earlier in @xcite in describing phase transitions , and in @xcite , where it was argued that the charge transport properties on the probe can be obtained from a membrane - paradigm - type description on the open string metric event horizon , further adding to the claim of the theme of this article .    in @xcite similar conclusions were arrived at using probe branes rotating along the compact directions , which inherits an event horizon on the worldvolume . it is known that for probe brane systems , t - duality symmetry of string theory transforms a spatial boost of the brane to a gauge field on the worldvolume . thus , our ness is qualitatively a t - dual description of @xcite . it is interesting to note that an underlying thermodynamic principle relates two seemingly unrelated systems by translating the induced metric horizon to an open string metric horizon . this perhaps also insinuates the deep connection between geometry and thermodynamics@xcite that may go beyond einstein gravity . for a recent article involving both an electric field and a rotation on the worldvolume , see @xcite .    on the other hand , our analysis suggests that for systems out - of - equilibrium and at least in a steady - state , an effective thermal description emerges rather universally . this is evidently true for a probe sector in a large-@xmath0 gauge theory with a holographic dual , irrespective of any further details of the system . interestingly , a thermal nature for an inherently nonequilibrium process has also been observed elsewhere : earlier in @xcite-@xcite , in quantum critical systems , _ @xcite , or in aging glass system@xcite . these observations perhaps suggest a more ubiquitous presence of an effective thermodynamic description for systems out - of - equilibrium , even outside the lore of gauge - gravity duality .    by construction , our holographic analysis is applicable for a fundamental probe sector in a large-@xmath0 @xmath15 gauge theory . more recent progress on holography has made it possible to understand gravitational dual descriptions for @xmath168-type gauge theories , which was originally proposed in @xcite . it is an intriguing question whether such an effective thermodynamics persists for an analogous ness situation there . our discussions have also been limited to the probe limit . beyond this limit , the probe ( fundamental ) sector and the background ( adjoint ) undergoes heat exchange since @xmath7 . eventually , after the electric field is turned off , they will reach a thermal equilibrium . this should be realized as the open string equivalence principle merging with the closed string equivalence principle and having the same event horizon in the end . it will be very interesting to explicitly construct such a time - dependent geometric example where this physics is manifest , perhaps along the lines of @xcite . we are grateful to sumit das , jacques distler , willy fischler , vadim kaplunovsky , hong liu , gautam mandal , bala sathiapalan and julian sonner for useful discussions and encouragements about this work . this material is based upon work supported by the national science foundation under grant number phy-0969020 and by texas cosmology center , which is supported by the college of natural sciences and the department of astronomy at the university of texas at austin and the mcdonald observatory . ak is also supported by a simons postdoctoral fellowship awarded by the simons foundation . j.  m.  maldacena , adv . * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) l.  susskind , j.  math . phys .   * 36 * , 6377 ( 1995 ) n.  itzhaki , j.  m.  maldacena , j.  sonnenschein and s.  yankielowicz , phys . d * 58 * , 046004 ( 1998 ) i.  r.  klebanov and m.  j.  strassler , jhep * 0008 * , 052 ( 2000 )        in recent years , interests have grown in examples where @xmath6 is the lie group with lifshitz symmetry@xcite , schrodinger symmetry@xcite or hyper - scaling violation@xcite symmetry . in all these cases , the duality also comes equipped with a bulk - to - boundary correspondence which is essential to translate the computation from one description to another .        by _ reduced description _ we mean implicitly _ integrating out _ the compact directions . the underlying assumption is that such _ reduced _ or _ effective _ descriptions can be embedded in the full @xmath9-dimensional geometry . more details on this issue will be provided in @xcite . m.  s.  alam , v.  s.  kaplunovsky and a.  kundu , jhep * 1204 * , 111 ( 2012 ) a.  karch and a.  obannon , jhep * 0709 * , 024 ( 2007 ) note that this definition is up to a constant which we are not elaborating on . for our purposes , this constant is not relevant . e.  antonyan , j.  a.  harvey , s.  jensen and d.  kutasov , hep - th/0604017 . m.  kruczenski , d.  mateos , r.  c.  myers and d.  j.  winters , jhep * 0405 * , 041 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0311270 ] . d.  mateos , r.  c.  myers and r.  m.  thomson , jhep * 0705 * , 067 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0701132 ] . j.  sonner and a.  g.  green , phys . lett .   * 109 * , 091601 ( 2012 ) c.  p.  herzog and d.  t.  son , jhep * 0303 * , 046 ( 2003 ) t.  albash , v.  g.  filev , c.  v.  johnson and a.  kundu , jhep * 0808 * , 092 ( 2008 ) j.  erdmenger , r.  meyer and j.  p.  shock , jhep * 0712 * , 091 ( 2007 ) k.  -y . kim , j.  p.  shock and j.  tarrio , jhep * 1106 * , 017 ( 2011 ) s.  r.  das , t.  nishioka and t.  takayanagi , jhep * 1007 * , 071 ( 2010 ) t.  jacobson , phys . rev .  lett .   * 75 * , 1260 ( 1995 ) m.  ali - akbari , h.  ebrahim and z.  rezaei , arxiv:1307.5629 [ hep - th ] . a.  g. green and s.  l. sondhi , phys . lett . * 95 * , 267001 ( 2005 ) .
Abstract:

Answer: using the gauge - gravity duality , we argue that for a certain class of out - of - equilibrium steady - state systems in contact with a thermal background at a given temperature , the macroscopic physics can be captured by an effective thermodynamic description . the steady - state is obtained by applying a constant electric field that results in a stationary current flow . within holography , we consider generic probe systems where an open string equivalence principle and an open string metric govern the effective thermodynamics . this description comes equipped with an effective temperature , which is larger than the background temperature , and a corresponding effective entropy . for conformal or scale - invariant theories , certain scaling behaviours follow immediately . in general , in the large electric field limit , this effective temperature is also observed to obey generic relations with various physical parameters in the system .