Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: soon after the experimental discovery  @xcite of carbon nanotubes , it was suggested  @xcite that there might also exist carbon _ nanotori _  , carbon nanotubes in which the ends of the tube are identified and sewn together . within a few years , experimental evidence for such structures emerged  @xcite , and since then they have attracted a great deal of experimental  @xcite and theoretical  @xcite attention . there are a variety of reasons for this intense interest . for example , certain species of carbon nanotori exhibit unusual magnetic properties  @xcite , including persistent magnetic moments at nearly zero flux  @xcite and colossal paramagnetic moments  @xcite . these objects can also display a diverse variety of electric properties : some nanotori are inherently metallic , while others are semiconducting and still others are insulators . as we shall discuss , the most general nanotorus can be parametrized by four integers @xmath0 . together and in various combinations , these describe the radius of the underlying nanotube , the chirality of the underlying nanotube , the length of the underlying nanotube , and the relative twist  @xcite that might occur upon sewing opposite ends of the tube together to form the torus . the important point , however , is that nanotori with different @xmath0 are fundamentally physically distinct : they have different sizes , different shapes , and different twisted `` honeycomb '' patterns of carbon atoms laid out on their surfaces . of course , there are certain symmetries of the underlying graphene sheet which lead to trivial equivalences amongst these nanotori . for example , @xmath1 rotations of the underlying graphene sheet will produce identical nanotori . such nanotori are therefore not physically distinct .    in this paper , however , we shall demonstrate that there are additional symmetries that relate _ physically distinct _ nanotori to each other , forcing such nanotori to exhibit identical energy spectra and electrical properties . these so - called `` modular '' symmetries therefore transcend the traditional hexagonal lattice symmetries of the graphene sheet , and arise solely in the process of compactifying the graphene sheet in order to form the nanotorus . in some sense , the appearance of these modular symmetries is entirely expected , for they result directly from the geometry of the compactification . however , to the best of our knowledge , the significance and consequences of these symmetries have not been fully appreciated thus far in the nanotorus literature . as we shall demonstrate , these symmetries have a number of profound effects . first , we shall see that use of these symmetries allows us to partition the set of carbon nanotori into distinct equivalence classes as far as their spectral properties are concerned , and leads to a dramatic reduction in the numbers of _ spectrally distinct _ carbon nanotori as compared with the numbers of _ physically distinct _ nanotori . moreover , as we shall show , many of the standard rules of thumb advanced in the literature in order to describe the conductivity properties of these nanotori actually fail to respect these symmetries . such rules of thumb are therefore incomplete as descriptions of the physics of these nanotori , and must be replaced by statements which respect the full symmetry structure of the compactified graphene sheet . finally , we demonstrate that these symmetries even extend to situations in which the carbon nanotori enclose different types of magnetic flux . they thus should have applicability for many of the fascinating magnetic properties of carbon nanotori , including the possibility of persistent currents . in order to explain the origins of these spectral symmetries , we begin with a brief review which will also serve to highlight our notation and conventions .      3.0 truein    for the uncompactified graphene sheet , all electron wavevectors @xmath9 are allowed . however , this situation changes when we `` roll up '' one dimension of the graphene sheet to produce a single - walled carbon nanotube , or equivalently when we identify any two carbon atoms on the graphene sheet whose positions differ by an arbitrary lattice vector @xmath14 with @xmath15 . imposing the bloch condition on the electron wavefunctions @xmath16 in addition to the new periodicity condition @xmath17 then restricts @xmath18 to the set of wavevectors satisfying the condition @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 . these allowed values of @xmath22 therefore form parallel lines in the @xmath23 plane , and the locations at which these lines intersect the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] determine whether the corresponding @xmath24 nanotube is metallic , semiconducting , or insulating . nanotubes for which @xmath25 ( , @xmath26 ) or @xmath27 ( , @xmath28 ) are dubbed `` zigzag '' or `` armchair '' respectively ; nanotubes with other values of @xmath24 are generally referred to as `` chiral '' . in general , the vector @xmath29 perpendicular to @xmath30 is the tube axis .    2.15 truein    we now consider imposing _ two _ non - parallel identifications on the graphene sheet , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] . in general , we consider two arbitrary lattice identification vectors @xmath31 and @xmath32 ; without loss of generality we shall assume that @xmath33 . we shall also assume without loss of generality that the quantity @xmath34 is positive , or equivalently that the relative angle @xmath35 from @xmath30 to @xmath36 lies in the range @xmath37 , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] . such identifications together result in a so - called @xmath0 nanotorus which may be viewed as a @xmath24 nanotube in which opposite ends are joined to each other , potentially with a relative twist angle @xmath35 . this description is especially appropriate if @xmath38 . note that @xmath39 describes the number of hexagonal cells which tile the surface of the resulting donut , and is equal to precisely half the number of carbon atoms in the nanotorus . imposing the double periodicity condition @xmath40 on the electron wavefunction @xmath16 in conjunction with the bloch condition then leads to the constraint in eq . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) as well as the additional constraint @xmath41 where @xmath42 . solving eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : tubek2 ] ) simultaneously then yields @xmath43 \nonumber\\    k_y & = & \frac{2\pi}{l_1l_2\sin\theta }      \left[-\ell_1 l_2\cos\delta + \ell_2 l_1\cos\beta\right ]   \label{eq : torik}\end{aligned}\ ] ] or equivalently @xmath44\nonumber\\    k_y & = &   { 2\pi \over \sqrt{3 } n_{\rm hex } } \left [ -\ell_1 ( 2p + q ) + \ell_2 ( 2m+n ) \right]~. \label{eq : torik2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we see that the allowed electron wavevectors now form a two - dimensional grid of points in the @xmath23 plane . note that there are always exactly @xmath39 allowed wavevectors lying inside the fundamental region bounded by the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , where points lying on a single bragg plane itself are counted as half and where points lying at the intersections of two bragg planes are counted as a third .    whether such nanotori are metallic , semiconducting , or insulating depends on whether these points hit or come particularly close to the intersections of the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] . it is found that nanotori in which both @xmath45 and @xmath46 are multiples of three are metallic , with solutions to eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) that lie precisely on the fermi surface . for practical applications , it proves useful to focus on only those nanotori with @xmath47 , as this condition allows one to bend the nanotube into a nanotorus without excessive strain or deformation of the underlying graphene sheet ( the effects of which would otherwise distort the dispersion relation in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , and hence the band structure of the torus ) . within this limit , it is then conventional to regard nanotori with @xmath48  ( mod  3 ) but @xmath49  ( mod  3 ) as semiconducting , since the allowed wavevectors come `` close '' to the fermi surface in this limit . all other nanotori are then considered insulating . all of the above results are completely standard , and are well known in the carbon - nanotorus literature . in particular , tori with different values of @xmath0 are physically distinct : they have entirely different arrangements of hexagons tiling their surfaces , with different values of the physical radii @xmath50 , chiral angle @xmath51 , and twist angle @xmath35 . we shall take this to be our definition of `` physically distinct '' . there are , of course , certain trivial identifications which relate different nanotori to each other : for example , the @xmath0 torus and the @xmath52 torus are actually identical , since they correspond to @xmath53 pairs which are related to each other by a uniform @xmath1 rotation . such trivial identifications reflect the underlying hexagonal lattice symmetries of the graphene sheet from which these nanotori are constructed , and result in identical carbon nanotori with identical patterns of carbon atoms on their surfaces . such nanotori are therefore not physically distinct .    by contrast , an important question is whether there exist physically _ distinct _ nanotori ( , tori which are _ not _ related by symmetries of the hexagonal lattice ) which nevertheless yield identical grids of allowed wavevectors @xmath23 . if so , we will have found cases of physically distinct tori with different values of @xmath54 which are nevertheless spectrally identical . in other words , such tori will have identical energy spectra and electrical conducting properties .    at first sight , it might appear that no such spectral equivalences exist for carbon nanotori . after all , the results in eq . ( [ eq : torik ] ) for carbon nanotori may initially appear to be nothing more than a two - dimensional generalization of the results in eq . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) for carbon nanotubes , and no such spectral equivalences exist for carbon nanotubes . however , it is important to realize that this is not true for carbon nanotori . in particular , it turns out that the set of allowed values of @xmath23 in eq . ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) is actually invariant under two additional symmetry transformations which we shall denote @xmath55 and @xmath56 : @xmath57 under these transformations , it is straightforward to demonstrate that @xmath34 is invariant , while the physical parameters @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath35 , and @xmath51 transform in the following manner : @xmath60 it is important to stress that the individual equations in eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) are not invariant under @xmath55 or @xmath56 ; rather , what is invariant is the _ set _ of values of @xmath23 to which these equations lead . moreover , since these sets of solutions for @xmath23 are invariant under @xmath55 and @xmath56 individually , they are also invariant under any sequence of @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations . for example , under the @xmath61 transformation we find @xmath62 , and this too is a symmetry of the solutions to eq . ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) . it then follows from these observations that any two tori whose defining vectors @xmath30 and @xmath36 differ through @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations share the same electronic spectra but are intrinsically different from each other  , that they are isospectral but physically distinct . that they are isospectral follows from the fact that the same set of @xmath23 solutions are selected in each case . by contrast , that they are physically distinct follows from the fact that the fundamental identifications between carbon atoms on the graphene sheet are altered by @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations in a manner that transcends trivial hexagonal lattice symmetries . this is perhaps easiest to see in the case of the @xmath56 transformation , which corresponds to the action @xmath63 . this changes not only @xmath59 but @xmath35 , and thus produces a new torus which has a greater `` twist '' when the ends of the nanotube are joined .    it may be less obvious that the @xmath55 transformation also connects physically distinct tori . indeed , this transformation corresponds to the action @xmath64 , and at first glance it might appear that this is merely a trivial relabeling of the two independent periodicities , along with a reflection ( sign flip ) . however , we must remember that the @xmath55 transformation also changes the associated @xmath35 and @xmath51 angles in non - trivial ways . alternatively , we can also appreciate the non - trivial nature of @xmath55 by considering the combination t   s t^-1 s^-1  =   t s t [ tprimedef ] which corresponds to the action @xmath65 . [ the second equality in eq . ( [ tprimedef ] ) follows as a result of the identity @xmath66 , or equivalently @xmath67 . ] note that @xmath68 is in some sense `` dual '' to @xmath56 : each performs a full twist around a different cycle of the torus . in other words , as illustrated in fig . [ tori ] , while @xmath56 corresponds to cutting through one side of the torus and re - attaching the two edges along with a twist , @xmath68 corresponds to cutting the torus along the other cycle and then twisting along the cut in an analogous manner before attaching the newly adjacent bonds . thus , @xmath68 results in a physically distinct torus , just as @xmath56 does , and furthermore these resulting tori are not related to each other through hexagonal lattice symmetries . it then follows from eq . ( [ tprimedef ] ) that @xmath55 also can not correspond to a lattice symmetry  , @xmath55 must connect physically distinct tori as well . indeed , @xmath55 and @xmath68 are interchangeable in the sense that the two generators of the modular group can be considered to be either @xmath69 or @xmath70 .    3.5 truein    note that if we define the complex quantity @xmath71 , then the @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations correspond to @xmath72 and @xmath73 respectively . together , these transformations generate the so - called `` modular group '' , which is one of the primordial symmetries associated with toroidal compactifications . in general , any transformation which takes the form @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 is a modular transformation . what we have shown , then , is that any two carbon nanotori whose defining parameters are related by a modular transformation are spectrally identical even though they are physically distinct . in other words , any transformation which can be generated through repeated actions of the @xmath55 and @xmath56 generators leads to a spectral equivalence between physically distinct tori .    it is important to emphasize that the appearance of these modular symmetries is not a total surprise . modular symmetries often arise in the presence of toroidal compactifications , and are a direct consequence of the underlying geometry of the carbon nanotorus . indeed , the zone - folding of a macroscopic lattice necessarily introduces periodic equivalences of the sort discussed here , and in the case of two dimensions with non - parallel identifications , such periodicities generically lead to modular symmetries . in other words , the underlying toroidal graph is not altered by modular symmetries , and thus the adjacencies of the graph ( and the isospectrality which results ) are preserved intact . however , when applied to the case of carbon nanotori , these symmetries are _ physical _ , in the sense that the nanotori they relate are isospectral but physically distinct . as we shall see , this is particularly significant , allowing these symmetries to have profound effects on the physics of these nanotorus systems and in particular on the range of behaviors they may exhibit .    in a sense , these modular symmetries can be viewed as a generalization of a similar set of symmetries that emerge for mbius graphs . to see this , let us imagine taking a long strip of hexagons and gluing opposite ends of this strip together with an arbitrary number of half - twists . at first glance , one might suspect that the resulting spectrum should depend on the actual number of half - twists . however , it turns out that the resulting spectrum depends only on whether this number is even or odd  @xcite . this mbius case is , of course , a relatively trivial example of this phenomenon , since it deals with only a single possible kind of twist corresponding to the single periodicity that defines the mbius strip . indeed , for the case of carbon nanotori , our point is that there exists a whole _ group _ of transformations  the modular group  which is built upon the actions of _ two _ non - commuting underlying generators ( @xmath55 and @xmath56 ) which can be combined and performed in a variety of inequivalent ways . this leads to `` sewing '' and `` gluing '' configurations on the torus which are much more complex than on the mbius strip , and which require greater mathematical machinery to study  and this in turn leads to distinctions between the notions of `` physically distinct '' and `` spectrally distinct '' which are even more pronounced than in the mbius case . however , even the relatively simple mbius case illustrates one of our basic themes : there can be lots of physically distinct twisted hexagon strips , yet very few of them are spectrally distinct . it is the preservation of the underlying graph in each case which makes this possible .    as a result of these modular symmetries , we can henceforth establish an unambiguous convention for uniquely describing the spectral properties of a given carbon nanotorus : we calculate its complex parameter @xmath77 as defined above , and then use a sequence of @xmath55 and @xmath56 modular transformations as needed in order to bring @xmath77 into a special region of the complex @xmath77-plane known as the `` fundamental domain '' @xmath78 defined by  :  -0  ,   ||1where @xmath79 and @xmath80 . note that the condition @xmath81 already ensures that @xmath82 . we can then use the underlying symmetries of the hexagonal graphene lattice in order to bring the resulting angle @xmath51 into the range @xmath83 . note that this convention is tantamount to describing the spectrum of a given carbon nanotorus in terms of that spectrally equivalent nanotorus which is as close to being rectangular as possible . following this procedure therefore provides an unambiguous test of whether any two physically distinct carbon nanotori in fact have the same spectral properties . the existence of these modular symmetries and the spectral equivalences they induce has profound implications for the physics of carbon nanotori . indeed , as we shall see , the use of these modular symmetries will sharpen our ability to classify nanotori on the basis of those physical properties ( such as their metallicities , _ etc . _ ) which ultimately stem from their band structures . furthermore , use of these modular symmetries can even provide _ statistical _ insights into the properties of randomly produced carbon nanotori  insights which may ultimately have practical consequences for the manufacture of such objects in environments in which their resulting properties often can not be controlled or engineered in advance .    as discussed above , the first and most direct implication of these modular symmetries is that there exist physically distinct nanotori  often with markedly different radii and chiral angles  which nevertheless possess identical energy spectra and conductivity properties . as an example of this phenomenon , let us consider the @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 carbon nanotori . clearly , we see that these nanotori are physically distinct and are characterized by different sets of cycle lengths @xmath50 , different chiral angles @xmath51 , and different twist angles @xmath35 . as a result , these three tori have entirely different patterns of carbon atoms tiling their surfaces . yet , the latter two nanotori are in fact related to each another by @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations , and consequently they each yield the same spectrum of allowed @xmath22 vectors shown in fig .  [ fig : energyspecthreetori ] . similarly the first nanotorus is related to the second two through not only @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations , but also trivial 60@xmath87 rotations of the underlying graphene sheet . thus , these tori all share identical spectra , and according to the convention specified above , we can describe this spectrum uniquely as having @xmath88 , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 .    3.0 truein    second , as a corollary to this observation , we also learn that the usual notions of `` zigzag '' and `` armchair ''  notions which are critical for describing the chirality and metallicity of carbon nanotubes  no longer hold as special indicators of the spectral properties of corresponding carbon nanotori . in other words , nanotori built from zigzag or armchair nanotubes might have spectral properties which are identical to those of nanotori built from non - zigzag or non - armchair nanotubes ; moreover , these spectral properties might or might not correspond to the special zigzag or armchair angles @xmath91 . as an example , the @xmath92 nanotorus is built from a zigzag nanotube while the @xmath93 nanotorus is built from an armchair nanotube and the @xmath94 and @xmath95 nanotori are built from chiral nanotubes with different chiralities . yet all four nanotori have identical spectral properties which are the same as those of a chiral nanotorus with @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and @xmath98 ( or @xmath99 ) . indeed , using the mathematical results of ref . @xcite , we can show that any carbon nanotorus is spectrally equivalent to one built from a zigzag carbon nanotube . conversely , a carbon nanotorus can have a spectrum which exhibits a zigzag or armchair property that is lacking in the original nanotube from which it is constructed . as an example , the @xmath100 nanotorus is built from a zigzag nanotube and the @xmath101 nanotorus is built from a chiral nanotube . yet both nanotori have the spectral properties of an armchair nanotorus , with @xmath96 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 . likewise , the @xmath104 nanotorus is built from an armchair nanotube and the @xmath105 nanotorus is built from a chiral nanotube . yet both nanotori have the spectral properties of a zigzag nanotorus , with @xmath96 , @xmath106 , and @xmath107 . third , it turns out that not every possible spectral signature @xmath108 can be realized , even in principle . instead , these three quantities experience internal constraints and correlations which ultimately reflect the fixed hexagonal lattice structure of the underlying graphene sheet and which require that any allowed spectral signature @xmath108 originate from four real integers @xmath0 . these correlations amongst @xmath108 can take a variety of different forms . for example , for odd values of @xmath39 , it turns out that there exist no self - consistent spectral signatures with purely imaginary values of @xmath77 . similarly , for @xmath109 , there are solutions with @xmath110 , but no other inverse integers ; likewise , all of these except for @xmath111 have @xmath26 . in fact , these internal constraints amongst the four real parameters embodied in @xmath112 are sufficiently strong that they effectively eliminate one real degree of freedom from within this parametrization . in other words , although four real degrees of freedom are required in order to parametrize a given physically distinct nanotorus , only three real degrees of freedom are required in order to uniquely describe its spectral properties  @xcite . it is easy to understand why such constraints arise . ordinarily , as a question of topology , tori can exist with all shapes and volumes , for there are literally an infinite number of ways in which we can construct a torus by rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper . however , in the case of carbon nanotori , our original `` sheet of paper '' is not unmarked : it is actually a graphene sheet of carbon atoms which has its own hexagonal lattice structure . the existence of such a lattice structure has a number of critical consequences : it forces our toroidal defining vectors @xmath30 to @xmath36 to be _ lattice vectors _ ; it restricts the resulting possible combinations of @xmath39 and @xmath77 to those values consistent with the periodicity of the lattice ; and it breaks the rotational symmetry of our original uncompactified two - dimensional sheet and necessitates the introduction of a new measurable parameter , the angle @xmath51 defined in fig .  [ fig : torusparam ] , which describes the orientation of the torus relative to the underlying lattice . conversely , the presence of the hexagonal lattice gives a clear meaning to the twist angle @xmath35 . this quantity would have had no meaning when rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper . fourth , it is clear that the existence of spectral equivalences between different nanotori implies that the number of _ spectrally _ distinct nanotori in any set will necessarily be smaller than the number of _ physically _ distinct nanotori in that set . however , it turns out that the magnitude of this truncation can easily become quite staggering . as an example , let us consider the set of physically distinct @xmath0 nanotori with fixed @xmath113 which can be formed from integers in the range @xmath114 for some cutoff @xmath115 . for concreteness , we shall take @xmath116 . in order to count only physically distinct nanotori , we shall require that @xmath24 be chosen such that @xmath117 . we shall also require , as a rough measure of their physical consistency in three - dimensional space , that each such nanotorus have an outer circumference @xmath59 which is at least triple its inner cross - sectional circumference @xmath58 ; note that other similar mathematical conditions may alternatively be imposed , but the qualitative results to follow are essentially unchanged . given these constraints , we then find through direct enumeration that there are exactly @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori which have @xmath88 . yet , as a result of these spectral equivalences , it turns out that these @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori give rise to only @xmath119 distinct energy spectra ! these distinct energy spectra are listed in table  [ nhex18table ] , along with a representative carbon nanotorus in each class . .for @xmath88 and @xmath116 , there are @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori @xmath0 with @xmath120 . however , these exhibit only 14 spectrally distinct energy spectra and band structures , and only four of these correspond to metals . these 14 spectrally distinct values of @xmath121 and @xmath51 are listed above , along with a sample @xmath0 nanotorus in each class . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]     this is clearly a major truncation . even with the relatively small value @xmath88 and relatively small cutoff @xmath116 , each spectral signature listed in table  [ nhex18table ] is shared by literally hundreds or thousands of physically distinct carbon nanotori . fifth , it is also worth noting that this truncation does not treat metallic and non - metallic nanotori equally . in general , a given @xmath0 carbon nanotorus will be metallic if at least one of its allowed wavevectors @xmath9 lies on the fermi surface , or in this case on one of the six points at which two bragg planes intersect . as is well known , this occurs only when the differences @xmath45 and @xmath46 are each a multiple of three . this implies that in any large set of physically distinct carbon nanotori , approximately one - ninth of the nanotori should be metallic . however , we see from table  [ nhex18table ] that four out of the fourteen possible distinct spectral signatures are metallic . this is almost triple what would have been expected , implying that the fraction of spectrally distinct nanotori which are metallic is nearly triple the fraction of physically distinct nanotori which are metallic . in other words , the truncation from the four - parameter space of physically distinct nanotori to the three - parameter space of spectrally distinct nanotori is remarkably sensitive to the metallicity of the nanotori in question . one might argue that both of these effects  the huge truncation in the number of distinct spectral signatures and the relative abundance of those which are metallic  merely reflect the fact that we restricted our integers @xmath0 to lie within a fixed range bounded by @xmath122 , or that we took a relatively small value of @xmath39 . however , it is easy to demonstrate that the second of these effects is relatively insensitive to the choice of @xmath115 , and that the first of these effects only becomes even more dramatic as @xmath115 is increased . for example , if we restrict our attention to carbon nanotori with @xmath96 , we find that the number of physically distinct nanotori and the number of spectrally distinct nanotori both rise as a function of @xmath115 . however , we see from fig .  [ panels ] ( left panel ) that the number of physically distinct nanotori with fixed @xmath39 grows as @xmath123 , as expected , while the number of spectrally distinct nanotori quickly hits a plateau ( right panel ) which remains flat for an increasingly long interval in @xmath115 before a new , hitherto - unrealizable spectral signature becomes possible and a new plateau develops . [ this growth in the number of physically distinct nanotori as a function of @xmath115 can easily be deduced from the observation that the number of quadruplets of integers @xmath0 grows as @xmath124 , while the corresponding number of attainable values of @xmath125 grows as @xmath123 . ] as a result , the number of physically distinct nanotori quickly outpaces the number of spectrally distinct nanotori . moreover , we see from fig . [ panels ] that the number of distinct metallic spectral signatures remains roughly one third ( and not one ninth ) the total number of distinct spectral signatures . we may also consider how these results vary with the choice of @xmath39 . this is shown in fig . [ nhexplot ] where , as functions of @xmath39 and for @xmath116 , we have plotted the number of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori as well as the number of those spectrally distinct carbon nanotori which are metallic . it is clear from these results that the numbers of spectrally distinct nanotori remain relatively small , even though they rise with @xmath39 , as expected . 3.4 truein 0.2truein 3.4 truein    -0.1 truein    3.25 truein    it is also easy to understand the jagged , oscillating nature of the results in fig .  [ nhexplot ] . nanotori must have @xmath126 in order to be metallic , while they must have @xmath127 if they are rectangular , with @xmath128 . thus , one difference between tori with @xmath129 and those with @xmath130 is the existence of additional non - rectangular carbon nanotori with @xmath131 . however , it must also be borne in mind that a random selection of four integers @xmath0 is @xmath132 times more likely to result in an even value for @xmath133 than an odd one . as we see from fig . [ nhexplot ] , the combined effect from these two features is fairly significant .    finally , another important implication of these spectral equivalences between physically distinct carbon nanotori concerns the traditional rules of thumb which allow us to determine whether a given carbon nanotorus is metallic , semiconducting , or insulating . throughout the existing literature on this topic , one finds what we shall call the `` rule of three '' : a given @xmath0 carbon nanotorus with @xmath134 will be metallic if both @xmath45 and @xmath46 are multiples of three , semiconducting if @xmath45 is multiple of three while @xmath46 is not , and insulating in all other cases . it is , of course , easy to verify that this characterization of a metallic nanotorus is modular invariant . specifically , if a given nanotorus has @xmath0 parameters which are metallic according to the rule of three , then all other nanotori to which it is spectrally equivalent will also have parameters which are metallic according to the rule of three . in other words , if @xmath45 and @xmath46 are both multiples of three , modular transformations of these parameters will not disturb this property . by contrast , the rule - of - three definition of semiconductors is _ not _ modular invariant  even when we preserve the condition that @xmath135 . as a graphic illustration of this point , consider the @xmath136 torus . note that indeed @xmath135 for this torus . according to the standard rule of three , such a torus can be identified as a semi - conductor because @xmath45 is a multiple of three . by contrast , let us now consider the @xmath137 nanotorus . this torus also clearly has @xmath135 . however , because @xmath45 is not a multiple of three , we would expect this nanotorus to be an insulator . indeed , the rule of three tells us to expect this even though our first impression might be that the second nanotorus has larger radii in both directions , and therefore might have energy levels which are more closely spaced . however , even though these tori have very different physical parameters , it turns out that they are related through modular transformations and therefore have identical energy spectra . they therefore also have identical metallicity properties . this provides a graphic illustration that as a mathematical statement , the standard `` rule of three '' fails to characterize the conductivity properties of such nanotori because it is inconsistent with the modular transformations which reflect the additional symmetries of the compactified graphene sheet . in other words , the standard definition for a semiconducting carbon nanotorus fails to be modular invariant , and thus can not be complete as a description of the underlying conductivity properties of the nanotorus . this is yet another consequence of the fact that modular invariance in this context is an actual physical symmetry relating the spectra of physically distinct nanostructures . we close this section with an important comment . throughout this section , our goal has been to illustrate various mathematical ramifications of the modular symmetries which govern the spectra of different carbon nanotori . the specific examples we have provided throughout this section were therefore chosen for their mathematical simplicity as opposed to their phenomenological practicality . for example , we restricted our attention in this section to nanotori with relatively small values of @xmath39 , while realistic carbon nantoroi can be expected to have @xmath138 . likewise , realistic carbon nanotori will generally be quite long and thin , with quantities such as @xmath139 exceeding @xmath58 by an order of magnitude or more . however , all of the conclusions we have drawn in this section continue to hold even when more realistic tori are considered . as an example , let us restrict our attention to carbon nanotori with @xmath140 for which @xmath141 . the latter condition guarantees that our nanotorus remains relatively long and thin even if there are multiple windings of the hexagonal carbon lattice around the tube axis of the torus . taking @xmath142 , we find there are @xmath143 physically distinct nanotori which satisfy these conditions , but only @xmath144 of these are spectrally distinct . furthermore , of these @xmath144 spectral equivalence classes , @xmath119 correspond to metals . we see , then , that even for realistic nanotori , our modular symmetries continue to lead to large classes of spectrally equivalent nanotori and a relative overabundance of classes which are metallic . indeed , in the limit @xmath145 , it is straightforward to show that the number of physically distinct carbon nanotori in each spectral equivalence class also grows to infinity . with an eye towards potential implications of modular symmetries for the magnetic phenomena associated with twisted carbon nanotori  @xcite , we now consider the introduction of magnetic fluxes . for full generality , we consider the possibility of _ two _ distinct fluxes : one which travels all the way around ( and through ) the length of the nanotube which forms the torus ; and another , namely the usual aharonov - bohm flux , which pierces the plane of the nanotorus , coming up through the donut hole . we shall denote these fluxes @xmath146 and @xmath147 respectively , as their associated vector potentials @xmath148 and @xmath149 lie parallel to the vectors @xmath30 and @xmath29 in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] , respectively . as is typical for such systems , we then find that we can incorporate the effects of these fluxes by keeping our previous band - structure energy function @xmath150 in eq . ( [ eq : bandstightbinding ] ) unchanged , and simply modifying our constraint equations for @xmath23 in eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : torik ] ) so that the integers @xmath151 are shifted according to _ i   _ i + _ i_0   where @xmath152 is the flux quantum and where _ 2   _ t + _ 1 _ 1  . note that it is the possible existence of a non - trivial twist angle @xmath35 which is responsible for the distinction between @xmath153 and @xmath147 . we then find that the resulting system continues to exhibit a spectral equivalence under the modular transformations in eqs . ( [ eq : stonindices ] ) and ( [ eq : stonvars ] ) as long as we allow @xmath154 to remain invariant under the @xmath56 transformation and to mix with each other under the @xmath55 transformation : s :   . thus , a carbon nanotorus parametrized by @xmath155 will have the same spectral properties as one parametrized by @xmath156 , where these two sets of parameters are related through the modular transformations discussed above . in this paper , we have highlighted and investigated the implications of a geometric symmetry  modular invariance  which emerges upon the compactification of a graphene sheet to form a carbon nanotorus . although not traditionally considered in the carbon - nanotorus literature , modular invariance plays a critical role in describing the spectral properties of these nanotori and leads to spectral equivalences between physically distinct nanotori . as we have shown , this has profound implications for the classification of carbon nanotori , indicating that large numbers of seemingly unrelated nanotori are in fact completely identical in terms of their spectral properties . along the way , we also showed that the traditional `` rule of three '' classification rubric is incomplete , as it is based on quantities which are do not respect these spectral equivalences . we also found that the fraction of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori which are metals is approximately three times greater than would naively be expected on the basis of standard results in the literature . finally , we also showed that these spectral equivalences can easily be extended to cases in which non - trivial magnetic fluxes are present . the existence of these spectral symmetries also provides a deeper theoretical underpinning to certain results which already exist in the literature . for example , it is well known that many carbon nanotori exhibit persistent currents in the presence of a non - zero magnetic flux @xmath157 . as functions of @xmath158 , these currents typically follow complicated `` sawtooth '' patterns which have a natural periodicity under shifts @xmath159 . it has also separately been observed ( see , , ref . @xcite ) that any such sawtooth pattern is preserved but shifted horizontally upon the introduction of a nanotorus twist in which @xmath160 , where @xmath161 is chosen such that @xmath162 is also a lattice vector . indeed , when @xmath163 , the magnitude of this horizontal shift exactly matches the periodicity of the sawtooth pattern and the net result is unchanged .    remarkably , this coincidence is now easy to understand from the point of view of modular transformations : when @xmath163 , the mapping from @xmath164 is nothing but the @xmath56 modular transformation , and as we have shown , modular transformations preserve the electrical properties of the torus , including its persistent currents . we thus see that the periodicity of the sawtooth pattern for persistent currents under shifts @xmath159  a periodicity which can be understood on elementary grounds having nothing to do with modular transformations  can now also be interpreted as a spectral equivalence under the @xmath56 modular transformation . moreover , we now see that this is merely the tip of the iceberg , and that these sorts of spectral equivalences actually have a richer structure and context that not only corresponds to the entire modular group but also transcends the specific example of persistent currents . as we have discussed above , the traditional `` rule of three '' is not formulated in a modular - invariant way and is therefore incomplete as a description of the electronic properties of carbon nanotori . however , the full implications of these modular symmetries are significantly broader than just the rule of three : no theoretical result concerning the electronic properties of carbon nanotori can be correct unless it respects these modular symmetries . in other words , no calculation of any electronic property of a given carbon nanotorus in terms of its fundamental defining parameters @xmath0 can be correct unless it yields a result which is invariant under the modular transformations in eq . ( [ eq : stonindices ] ) . in this respect , modular invariance functions for carbon nanotori in much the same way as gauge invariance functions for electromagnetic systems : no theoretical result can be correct unless it can be phrased in terms of quantities which are invariant under the symmetry in question . of course , at a mathematical level , both modular invariance and gauge invariance rest on relatively simple algebraic identities . however , they both provide powerful organizing principles , and have significant physical manifestations and implications for the symmetry structures of the systems in which they appear . needless to say , several additional comments are in order . first , it should be noted that in this paper we have focused on what might called the `` ideal '' nanotorus . in particular , we have not accounted for the fact that the actual physical construction of such a torus in three - dimensional space requires that we introduce both an intrinsic and extrinsic curvature onto our otherwise flat graphene sheet . in this sense , the construction of a carbon nanotorus is different from that of a carbon nanotube ( in which only the extrinsic curvature is non - vanishing ) . the introduction of intrinsic curvature requires that we subject our underlying graphene sheet to considerable strain , deforming not only the positions of carbon atoms but also their relative spacings . these effects have been addressed by a number of authors , using a variety of different techniques  @xcite . that said , these spectral equivalences should continue to hold , even in the presence of such deformations . there are several reasons for this . first , in the limit @xmath165 , all effects due to these deformations will be suppressed . however , this is precisely the limit in which nanotori can be constructed from purely hexagonal graphene sheets without the introduction of curvature - inducing pentagonal or heptagonal carbon rings . second , it can be shown that even when such strain is present , maximum toroidal stability occurs when this strain is uniformly distributed along the nanotorus  @xcite , and this is precisely the situation in which the techniques of ref . @xcite can be used in order to mathematically rewrite the effects of such strain as arising due to a fictitious magnetic flux . as we have seen , the spectral equivalences we have found continue to exist even when such fluxes are introduced . but most importantly , while _ any _ deformations of the underlying graphene sheet can be expected to have effects on the corresponding band - structure energy function @xmath8 shown in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , such deformations will not disturb the symmetries inherent in the constraint equations for @xmath166 derived in eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : tubek2 ] ) . indeed , these equations reflect nothing more than the effects of toroidal compactification , and their structure leads directly to the modular symmetries inherent in eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) . thus , since these spectral equivalences ultimately stem from these symmetry properties , we are assured that any two tori related by modular transformations will sample the same set of wavevectors @xmath9 . such tori will therefore continue to be spectrally identical regardless of the function @xmath8 , provided the deformations to @xmath8 for the two tori are themselves identical . moreover , as we have argued above , even in cases where these deformations are not identical , they can at most differ by terms which are suppressed by factors of the presumably large nanotori radii . such differences can therefore be safely neglected . a similar conclusion also holds for thermal effects . it might seem , at first glance , that thermal effects could also destroy the spectral equivalences , since they too can have a dramatic effect on the band structure of the underlying graphene sheet  @xcite . however , as noted above , these spectral equivalences are a consequence of the geometric symmetries that arise upon _ compactifying _ this sheet ; they are largely independent of the symmetries of the sheet itself . indeed , these modular symmetries exist for _ any _ choices of identification vectors @xmath30 and @xmath36 , even if those vectors are altered by other effects . therefore , as long as the temperature is sufficiently low that the electron coherence length exceeds both the inner and outer toroidal circumferences , the spectral equivalences we have been discussing should remain intact up to terms suppressed by the large nanotori radii .    these comments notwithstanding , it still remains true that not all such nanotori are equally likely to appear in nature . in particular , those nanotori whose constructions implicitly involve large numbers of twists are likely to be rather difficult to construct or stablize , as the carbon atoms that constitute the underlying graphene sheet are likely to experience significant strain , leading to major deformations of the underlying carbon bond lengths and angles away from their ideal values . this is especially relevant , given that our statistical discussions in sect . iv implicitly assume that each of the relevant @xmath0 nanotori can appear with equal probability .    at a mathematical level , it is difficult to draw a firm boundary between those carbon nanotori which are realizable in nature as _ bona - fide _ molecules and those which are not . however , in this paper we have restricted ourselves to statistical examinations of only those nanotori which already obey certain critical constraints . for example , we have limited ourselves to nanotori in which @xmath58 and @xmath59 are both significantly bigger than the carbon - carbon bond length @xmath7 . thus each twist experienced for the whole nanotorus has only a minor effect on the bond lengths and angles corresponding to each individual carbon atom . in addition , we have further limited ourselves to nanotori which also satisfy @xmath167 . this ensures that each such nanotorus can be realized in three - dimensional space , without the unphysical self - overlapping that would arise if this condition were not met . together , these conditions help to ensure that the strains induced by these modular transformations are not too severe . needless to say , there are many implications of these spectral equivalences which we have not yet explored . it would be interesting , for example , to consider the implications of these symmetries for the existence or absence of persistent currents as well as the existence or absence of colossal magnetic moments . this work is currently in progress . it would also be interesting to understand these modular transformations in terms of fictitious fluxes , using analogues of the techniques presented in ref . @xcite . first , as we have seen , modular invariance is the symmetry which underlies most of the results we have presented in this paper . at a mathematical level , modular invariance is normally just a relabelling symmetry in the sense that two sets of torus parameters related by a modular transformation normally correspond to the same physical torus . this is certainly the case in string theory , and in most other situations in theoretical high - energy physics in which modular transformations have played a significant role ( see , , ref . @xcite ) . however , the case of carbon nanotori is quite different . here , modular transformations relate parameters corresponding to carbon nanotori which are physically distinct . as we have discussed , this is because we are not merely rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper when we subject it to two non - parallel identifications ; we are rolling up a graphene sheet which already has a hexagonal carbon lattice imprinted on it . viewed from this perspective , it is therefore somewhat remarkable that modular transformations continue to play a role , indicating when two distinct nanotori will have the same spectral properties . indeed , in the case of carbon nanotori , we see that modular invariance is thus promoted from a mere relabeling symmetry to something far deeper : _ modular invariance becomes an outright physical symmetry between physically distinct entities_. we know of no other physical situation in which modular invariance plays such a role . second , it is also exciting at a practical level that physically distinct carbon nanotori can have identical energy spectra and electrical properties . since these nanotori are physically distinct , some are likely to be far more complicated to construct in the laboratory than others . nevertheless , these spectral equivalences suggest that it may not be necessary to fabricate a very complex nanotorus ( or generate sizable magnetic fluxes ) in order to obtain a desired spectral property ; there are likely to be far simpler nanotori and/or fluxes which can perform the same function . this could have significant implications for the production and use of such nano - materials . this work was supported in part by the department of energy under grant  de - fg02 - 04er-41298 . we are happy to thank p.  mceuen , d.  ralph , c.  stafford , and h.  tye for discussions , and we wish to acknowledge the hospitality of the kavli institute for theoretical physics ( kitp ) in santa barbara , california , where this paper was completed . the opinions and conclusions expressed here are those of the authors , and do not represent either the department of energy or the national science foundation . m.  terrones , w.  k.  hsu , j.  p.  hare , h.  w.  kroto , h.  terrones , and d.  r.  m.  walton , phil . a * 354 * , 2025 ( 1996 ) ; h.  r.  she , r.  martel , and p.  avouris , phys . * 84 * , 4441 ( 2000 ) ; m.  sano , a.  kamino , j.  okamura , and s.  shinkai , science  * 293 * , 1299 ( 2001 ) ; h.  watanabe , c.  manabe , t.  shigematsu , and m.  shimizu , appl .  phys .  lett .  * 78 * , 2928 ( 2001 ) . m.  f.  lin , r.  b.  chen , and f.  l.  shyu , solid state commun . 107 , 227 ( 1998 ) ; a.  a.  odintsov , w.  smit , and h.  yoshioka , europhys . lett . * 45 * ( 5 ) , 598 ( 1999 ) ; k.  sasaki , phys . b * 65 * , 155429 ( 2002 ) ; s.  latil , s.  roche , and a.  rubio , phys .  rev . b * 67 * , 165420 ( 2003 ) ; z.  zhang , z.  yang , x.  wang , j.  yuan , h.  zhang , m.  qiu , and j.  peng , j.  phys .  condens . matter * 17 * , 4111 ( 2005 ) ; c. feng and k.  m.  liew , carbon * 47 * , 1664 ( 2009 ) .
Abstract:

Answer: recently there has been considerable interest in the properties of carbon nanotori . such nanotori can be parametrized according to their radii , their chiralities , and the twists that occur upon joining opposite ends of the nanotubes from which they are derived . in this paper , however , we demonstrate that many physically distinct nanotori with wildly different parameters nevertheless share identical band structures , energy spectra , and electrical conductivities . this occurs as a result of certain geometric symmetries known as modular symmetries which are direct consequences of the properties of the compactified graphene sheet . using these symmetries , we show that there is a dramatic reduction in the number of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori compared with the number of physically distinct carbon nanotori . the existence of these modular symmetries also allows us to demonstrate that many statements in the literature concerning the electronic properties of nanotori are incomplete because they fail to respect the spectral equivalences that follow from these symmetries . we also find that as a result of these modular symmetries , the fraction of spectrally distinct nanotori which are metallic is approximately three times greater than would naively be expected on the basis of standard results in the literature . finally , we demonstrate that these modular symmetries also extend to cases in which our carbon nanotori enclose non - zero magnetic fluxes .    .7ex .7ex = cmss10 = cmss10 at 7pt epsf


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: it is well known that primordial black holes ( pbhs ) could have formed in the early universe @xcite . a comparison of the cosmological density at any time after the big bang with the density associated with a black hole shows that pbhs would have of order the particle horizon mass at their formation epoch : m(t ) 10 ^ 15(t10 ^ - 23  s ) g. pbhs could thus span an enormous mass range : those formed at the planck time ( @xmath1s ) would have the planck mass ( @xmath2 g ) , whereas those formed at 1  s would be as large as @xmath3 , comparable to the mass of the holes thought to reside in galactic nuclei . pbhs would could arise in various ways @xcite . since the early universe is unlikely to have been exactly friedmann , they would form most naturally from initial inhomogeneities but they might also form through other mechanisms at a cosmological phase transition .    the realization that small pbhs might exist prompted hawking to study their quantum properties . this led to his famous discovery @xcite that black holes radiate thermally with a temperature t = c^38gmk 10 ^ 26 ( mg)^-1  k 10 ^ -7 ( m)^-1  k. this means that they evaporate on a timescale ( m ) 10 ^ 64 ( m)^3  . only black holes smaller than @xmath4 g would have evaporated by the present epoch , so eqn ( 1 ) implies that this effect could be important only for black holes which formed before @xmath5s . despite the conceptual importance of this result , it is bad news for pbh enthusiasts . for since pbhs with a mass of @xmath4 g , which evaporate at the present epoch , would have a temperature of order 100  mev , the observational limit on the @xmath6-ray background intensity at 100  mev immediately implies that their density could not exceed @xmath7 times the critical density @xcite . not only does this render pbhs unlikely dark matter candidates , it also implies that there is little chance of detecting black hole explosions at the present epoch @xcite .    despite this conclusion , pbh evaporations could still have interesting cosmological consequences . in particular , they might generate the microwave background @xcite or modify the standard cosmological nucleosynthesis scenario @xcite or contribute to the cosmic baryon asymmetry @xcite . pbh evaporations might also account for the annihilation - line radiation coming from the galactic centre @xcite or the unexpectedly high fraction of antiprotons in cosmic rays @xcite . pbh explosions occurring in an interstellar magnetic field might also lead to radio bursts @xcite . even if pbhs had none of these consequences , studying such effects leads to strong upper limits on how many of them could ever have formed and thereby constrains models of the early universe . indeed pbhs serve as a probe of times much earlier than that associated with most other  relicts " of the big bang . while photons decoupled at @xmath8y , neutrinos at @xmath9  s and wimps at @xmath10s , pbhs go all the way back to the planck time . therefore even if pbhs never formed , their non - existence gives interesting information . we review the formation mechanisms and evaporation constraints on pbhs in section 2 . much of this material is also contained in my contribution to the 1996 chalonge school @xcite . however , there have been several interesting developments since then and these are covered in section 3 . the remaining sections will examine how the pbh constraints are modified if the value of the gravitational  constant " @xmath0 was different at early times . as reviewed in section 4 , this idea has a long history and should no longer be regarded as exotic . it arises in various scalar - tensor theories of gravity and these are a natural setting for many currently popular models of the early universe . black hole formation and evaporation could be greatly modified in variable-@xmath0 cosmologies , since many of their properties ( eg . their hawking temperature ) depend explicitly on @xmath0 . however , as emphasized by barrow @xcite and discussed in section 5 , the nature of the modification depends upon whether the pbh preserves the value of @xmath0 at its formation epoch ( corresponding to what is termed `` gravitational memory '' ) or always maintains the changing background value . there would be interesting modifications to the cosmological consequences of pbh evaporations in both cases but they would be more dramatic in the first . barrow & carr @xcite considered the implications of these two scenarios in detail and this work has been taken further with goymer @xcite . we will review the conclusions of these papers in section 6 and highlight a particularly interesting development in section 7 . one of the most important reasons for studying pbhs is that it enables one to place limits on the spectrum of density fluctuations in the early universe . this is because , if the pbhs form directly from density perturbations , the fraction of regions undergoing collapse at any epoch is determined by the root - mean - square amplitude @xmath11 of the fluctuations entering the horizon at that epoch and the equation of state @xmath12 . one usually expects a radiation equation of state ( @xmath13 ) in the early universe . in order to collapse against the pressure , an overdense region must be larger than the jeans length at maximum expansion and this is just @xmath14 times the horizon size . on the other hand , it can not be larger than the horizon size , else it would form a separate closed universe and not be part of our universe @xcite . this has two important implications . firstly , pbhs forming at time @xmath15 should have of order the horizon mass given by eqn ( 1 ) . secondly , for a region destined to collapse to a pbh , one requires the fractional overdensity at the horizon epoch , @xmath16 , to exceed @xmath6 . providing the density fluctuations have a gaussian distribution and are spherically symmetric , one can infer that the fraction of regions of mass @xmath17 which collapse is @xcite ( m ) ~(m ) where @xmath18 is the value of @xmath11 when the horizon mass is @xmath17 . the pbhs can have an extended mass spectrum only if the fluctuations are scale - invariant ( i.e. with @xmath11 independent of @xmath17 ) but this is expected in many scenarios .    the fluctuations required to make the pbhs may either be primordial or they may arise spontaneously at some epoch . one natural source of fluctuations would be inflation @xcite and , in this context , @xmath19 depends implicitly on the inflationary potential . pbhs formed before inflation would be drastically diluted but new ones could form from the fluctuations generated after inflation . many people have studied pbh formation in this context @xcite as an important way of constraining the inflationary potential . this was the focus of my 1996 erice lecture , so it will not be covered again here . note that the gaussian assumption has been questioned in the inflationary context @xcite , so eqn ( 4 ) may not apply , but one still finds that @xmath20 depends very sensitively on @xmath11 . in some situations eqn ( 4 ) would fail qualitatively . for example , pbhs would form more easily if the equation of state of the universe were ever soft ( @xmath211 ) . this might apply if there was a phase transition which channelled the mass of the universe into non - relativistic particles or which temporally reduced the pressure . in this case , only those regions which are sufficiently spherically symmetric at maximum expansion can undergo collapse ; the dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath11 would then have the form @xcite = 0.02 ^ 13/2 , which is much weaker than indicated by eqn ( 4 ) , but there would still be a unique relationship between the two parameters . some formation mechanisms for pbhs do not depend on having primordial fluctuations at all . for example , at any spontaneously broken symmetry epoch , pbhs might form through the collisions of bubbles of broken symmetry @xcite . pbhs might also form spontaneously through the collapse of cosmic strings @xcite or domain walls @xcite . in these cases @xmath22 depends , not on @xmath19 , but on other cosmological parameters , such the bubble formation rate or the string mass - per - length . these mechanisms were discussed in more detail in my 1996 erice contribution @xcite . in all these scenarios , the current density parameter @xmath23 associated with pbhs which form at a redshift @xmath24 or time @xmath15 is related to @xmath20 by @xcite _ r(1+z ) 10 ^ 6 ( ts)^-1/2 10 ^ 18(m10 ^ 15g)^-1/2 where @xmath25 is the density parameter of the microwave background and we have used eqn ( 1 ) . the @xmath26 factor arises because the radiation density scales as @xmath27 , whereas the pbh density scales as @xmath28 . any limit on @xmath23 therefore places a constraint on @xmath22 and the constraints are summarized in fig . 1 . the constraint for non - evaporating mass ranges above @xmath4 g comes from requiring @xmath29 . stronger constraints are associated with pbhs smaller than this since they would have evaporated by now @xcite . the strongest one is the @xmath6-ray limit associated with the @xmath4 g pbhs evaporating at the present epoch @xcite . other ones are associated with the generation of entropy and modifications to the cosmological production of light elements . the constraints below @xmath30 g are based on the ( not necessarily secure ) assumption that evaporating pbhs leave stable planck mass relics , in which case these relics are required to have less than the critical density @xcite . the constraints on @xmath22 can be converted into constraints on @xmath19 using eqn ( 4 ) and these are shown in fig . 2 . also shown here are the ( non - pbh ) constraints associated with the spectral distortions in the cosmic microwave background induced by the dissipation of intermediate scale density perturbations and the cobe quadrupole measurement , as well as lines corresponding to various slopes in the @xmath18 relationship . this shows that one needs the fluctuation amplitude to decrease with increasing scale in order to produce pbhs . [ f1 ]    [ f2 ] recent hydrodynamical calculations for the @xmath31 case have refined the criterion @xmath32 for pbh formation and this modifies the estimate for @xmath22 given by eqn ( 4 ) . niemeyer & jedamzik @xcite find that one needs @xmath33 rather than @xmath34 to ensure pbh formation , and shibata & sasaki @xcite reach similar conclusions . they also find that there is little accretion after pbh formation , as expected theoretically @xcite . another interesting development has been the application of  critical phenomena " to pbh formation . studies of the collapse of various types of spherically symmetric matter fields have shown that there is always a critical solution which separates those configurations which form a black hole from those which disperse to an asymptotically flat state . the configurations are described by some index @xmath35 and , as the critical index @xmath36 is approached , the black hole mass is found to scale as @xmath37 for some exponent @xmath38 . this effect was first discovered for scalar fields @xcite but subsequently demonstrated for radiation @xcite and then more general fluids with equation of state @xmath39 @xcite .    in all these studies the spacetime was assumed to be asymptotically flat . however , niemeyer & jedamzik @xcite have recently applied the same idea to study black hole formation in asymptotically friedmann models and have found similar results . for a variety of initial density perturbation profiles , they find that the relationship between the pbh mass and the the horizon - scale density perturbation has the form m = k m_h(- _ c)^ where @xmath40 is the horizon mass and the constants are in the range @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 for the various configurations . since @xmath44 as @xmath45 , this suggests that pbhs may be much smaller than the particle horizon at formation ( although it is clear that a fluid description must break down if they are too small ) and it also modifies the mass spectrum @xcite . there has been particular interest recently in whether pbhs could have formed at the quark - hadron phase transition at @xmath2s . this is because the horizon mass is of order @xmath46 then , so such pbhs would naturally have the sort of mass required to explain the macho microlensing results @xcite . this is discussed in more detail in my other lecture at this meeting . one might expect pbhs to form more easily at that epoch because of a temporary softening of the equation of state . if the qcd phase transition is assumed to be of 1st order , then hydrodynamical calculations show that the value of @xmath16 required for pbh formation is indeed reduced below the value which pertains in the radiation case @xcite . this means that pbh formation will be strongly enhanced at the qcd epoch , with the mass distribution being peaked around the horizon mass . one of the interesting implications of the pbh macho scenario is the possible existence of a halo population of _ binary _ black holes @xcite . with a full halo of such objects , there could then be @xmath47 binaries inside 50 kpc and some of these could be coalescing due to gravitational radiation losses at the present epoch @xcite . current interferometers ( such as ligo ) could detect such coalescences within 50 mpc , corresponding to a few events per year . future space - borne interferometers ( such as lisa ) might detect 100 coalescences per year . if the associated gravitational waves were detected , it would provide a unique probe of the halo distribution ( eg . its density profile and core radius @xcite . kohri & yokoyama @xcite have recently improved the constraints on @xmath48 which come from cosmological nucleosynthesis considerations . constraints from neutrino background have also been presented by bugaev & konischev @xcite . the recent detection of a galactic @xmath6-ray background @xcite , measurements of the antiproton flux @xcite , and the discovery of very short period @xmath6-ray burts @xcite may even provide positive evidence for such pbhs . this is discussed in detail elsewhere @xcite . some people have emphasized the possibility of detecting very high energy cosmic rays from pbhs using air shower techniques @xcite . however , recently these efforts have been set back by the claim of heckler @xcite that qed interactions could produce an optically thick photosphere once the black hole temperature exceeds @xmath49 gev . in this case , the mean photon energy is reduced to @xmath50 , which is well below @xmath51 , so the number of high energy photons is much reduced . he has proposed that a similar effect may operate at even lower temperatures due to qcd effects @xcite . this is discussed further in the contribution of kapusta at this meeting @xcite . however , these arguments should not be regarded as definitive : macgibbon @xcite claim that heckler has not included lorentz factors correctly in going from the black hole frame to the centre - of - mass frame of the interacting particles ; in their calculation qed interactions are never important . most variable - g scenarios associate the gravitational `` constant '' with some form of scalar field @xmath52 . this notion has its roots in kaluza - klein theory , in which a scalar field appears in the metric component @xmath53 associated with the 5th dimension . einstein - maxwell theory then requires that this field be related to @xmath0 @xcite . although this was assumed constant in the original kaluza - klein theory , dirac @xcite noted the the ratio of the electric to gravitational force between to protons ( @xmath54 ) and the ratio of the age of the universe to the atomic timescale ( @xmath55 ) and the square - root of the number of particles in the universe ( @xmath56 ) are all comparable and of order @xmath57 . this unlikely coincidence led him to propose that these relationships must _ always _ apply , which requires g t^-1 , gm / r ~1 , where @xmath58 is the horizon scale . the first condition led jordan @xcite to propose a theory in which the scalar field in kaluza - klein theory is a function of _ both _ space and time , and this then implies that @xmath59 has the same property . the second condition implies the mach - type relationship @xmath60 , which suggests @xcite that @xmath52 is a solution of the wave equation @xmath61 . this motivated brans - dicke ( bd ) theory @xcite , in which the einstein - hilbert lagrangian is replaced by l = r - _ , _ , g^ + l_m , where @xmath62 is the matter langrangian and the constant @xmath63 is the bd parameter . the potential @xmath52 then satisfies = ( ) t , where @xmath64 is the trace of the matter stress - energy tensor , and this has the required machian form . since @xmath52 must have a contribution from _ local _ sources of the form @xmath65 , this entails a violation of the strong equivalence principle . in order to test this , the ppn formalism was introduced . applications of this test in a variety of astrophysical situations ( involving the solar system , the binary pulsar and white dwarf cooling ) currently require @xmath66 , which implies that the deviations from general relativity can only ever be small in bd theory @xcite . the introduction of generalized scalar - tensor theories @xcite , in which @xmath63 is itself a function of @xmath52 , led to a considerably broader range of variable-@xmath0 theories . in particular , it permitted the possibility that @xmath63 may have been small at early times ( allowing noticeable variations of @xmath0 then ) even if it is large today . in the last decade interest in such theories has been revitalized as a result of early universe studies . inflation theory @xcite has made the introduction of scalar fields almost mandatory and extended inflation specifically requires a model in which @xmath0 varies @xcite . in higher dimensional kaluza - klein - type cosmologies , the variation in the sizes of the extra dimensions also naturally leads to a variation in @xmath0 @xcite . the currently popular low energy string cosmologies necessarily involve a scalar ( dilaton ) field @xcite and bosonic superstring theory , in particular , leads @xcite to a lagrangian of the form ( 9 ) with @xmath67 .    the intimate connection between dilatons , inflatons and scalar - tensor theory arises because one can always transform from the ( physical ) jordan frame to the einstein frame , in which the lagrangian has the standard einstein - hilbert form @xcite l = |r - 2_,_,|g^ + l_m . here the new scalar field @xmath68 is defined by d= ( ) ^1/2 and the barred ( einstein ) metric and gravitational constant are related to the original ( jordan ) ones by g _ = a()^2 |g_,g = [ 1+^2 ( ) ] a()^2 |g , a/a , where the function @xmath69 specifies a conformal transformation and a prime denotes @xmath70 . thus scalar - tensor theory can be related to general relativity plus a scalar field , although the theories are not identical because particles do not follow geodesics in the einstein frame . the behaviour of homogeneous cosmological models in bd theory is well understood @xcite . their crucial feature is that they are vacuum - dominated at early times but always tend towards the general relativistic solution during the radiation - dominated era . this is a consequence of the fact that the radiation energy - momentum tensor is trace - free [ i.e. @xmath71 in eqn ( 10 ) ] . this means that the full radiation solution can be approximated by joining a bd vacuum solution to a general relativistic radiation solution at some time @xmath72 , which may be regarded as a free parameter of the theory . however , when the matter density becomes greater than the radiation density at @xmath73s , the equation of state becomes that of dust @xmath74 and @xmath0 begins to vary again . for a @xmath75 model , one can show that in the three eras @xcite g = g_0 ( t_0/t_e)^n , a t^(2-n)/3 ( t > t_e ) g = g_e g_0 ( t_0/t_e)^n , a t^1/2 ( t_1<t < t_e ) g = g_e ( t / t_1)^-(n + ) /2 , a t^(2 - n - ) /6 ( t < t_1 ) where @xmath76 is the value of @xmath0 at the current time @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 . since the bd coupling constant is constrained by @xmath66 , which implies @xmath80 , eqns ( 14 ) to ( 16 ) imply that the deviations from general relativity are never large if the value of @xmath81 is always the same . however , as we now explain , it is also interesting to consider bd models in which @xmath81 and @xmath63 can vary and thus violate the current constraints . the behaviour of cosmological models in more general scalar - tensor theories depends on the form of @xmath82 but they still retain the feature that the general relativistic solution is a late - time attractor during the radiation era . since one requires @xmath83 to @xmath84 at the epoch of primordial nucleosynthesis @xcite , one needs the vacuum - dominated phase to end at some time @xmath85 1 s. the theory approaches general relativity in the weak field limit only if @xmath86 and @xmath87 but @xmath82 is otherwise unconstrained . barrow & carr consider a toy model in which 2 + 3 = 2(1-/_c)^- where @xmath88 and @xmath20 are constants . this leads to 2 + 3 t^-/(2- ) , /^3 t^(1 - 2)/(1- ) ( t < t_v ) , so one requires @xmath89 in order to have @xmath86 and @xmath90 as @xmath91 . in the @xmath92 case , one finds g t^-2/(3- ) , a t^(1-)/(3- ) , ( t < t_v ) . during the vacuum - dominated era , such models can therefore be regarded as bd solutions in which @xmath63 is determined by the parameter @xmath20 and unconstrained by any limits on @xmath63 at the present epoch . after @xmath93 , @xmath0 is constant and one has the standard radiation - dominated or dust - dominated behaviour . the consequences of the cosmological variation of @xmath0 for pbh evaporation depend upon how the value of @xmath0 near the black hole evolves . barrow @xcite introduces two possibilities : in scenario a , @xmath0 everywhere maintains the background cosmological value ( so @xmath52 is homogeneous ) ; in scenario b , it preserves the value it had at the formation epoch near the black hole even though it evolves at large distances ( so @xmath52 becomes inhomogeneous ) . on the assumption that a pbh of mass @xmath17 has a temperature and mass - loss rate t = ( 8gm)^-1 , - ( gm)^-2 , with @xmath94 in scenario a and @xmath95 in scenario b , barrow & carr calculate the evaporation time @xmath96 for various values of the parameters @xmath81 and @xmath72 in bd theory @xcite . the results are shown in fig . 3(a ) for scenario a and fig . 3(b ) for scenario b. here @xmath97 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at the present epoch , @xmath98 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at time @xmath99 and @xmath100 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at the present epoch in the standard ( constant @xmath0 ) scenario . in scenario a with @xmath101 , there is a maximum mass of a pbh which can ever evaporate and this is denoted by @xmath102 . the results for the scalar - tensor with @xmath82 given by eqn ( 17 ) with @xmath103 are shown in fig . 3(c ) for scenario b with various values of the parameters @xmath104 and @xmath93 . the corresponding modifications to the constraints on @xmath22 in all three cases are shown in fig . 3(d ) , which should be compared to fig . 1 . barrow & carr considered both scenarios a and b but did not attempt decide which was more plausible . in this section we address this question more carefully . the main argument for scenario a comes from an important result of hawking @xcite . he showed that in bd theory , providing the weak energy condition holds , the gradient of @xmath52 must be zero everywhere for stationary , asymptotically flat black holes . this means that such black holes are identical to those in general relativity . this result can be generalized to all scalar - tensor theories and suggests that such theories are in agreement with the `` no - hair '' theorem . numerical calculations support this theorem @xcite . collapse is accompanied by outgoing scalar gravitational radiation , which radiates away the scalar mass until the black hole settles down to the schwarzschild form with a constant scalar field . in particular , harada et al . @xcite have investigated oppenheimer - snyder collapse in which a ball of dust described by a @xmath105 friedmann interior and a schwarzschild exterior collapses to a black hole . in these calculations the scalar field is taken to be constant before the collapse and its back - reaction on the metric is assumed to be always negligible . it is found that , as the collapse proceeds , a scalar gravitational wave propagates outwards before the scalar field settles down to being constant again .    it should be stressed that the scalar no hair theorem has only been proved for asymptotically flat spacetimes , so it is not clear that it also applies in the asymptotically friedmann case . while the no hair theorem suggests that @xmath52 should tend to a _ locally _ constant value ( close to the black hole ) , it is not obvious that this needs to be the asymptotic cosmological value . indeed , since the homogeneizing of @xmath52 is only ensured by scalar wave emission , one might infer that this can only be achieved on scales less than the particle horizon . one way to determine what happens is to seek a precise mathematical model for a black hole in a cosmological background . for example , one can try to match a black hole and cosmological solution over some boundary @xmath106 . such a matching is provided in general relativity by the einstein - straus or  swiss cheese " model @xcite . here a friedmann exterior is matched with a general spherically symmetric interior . if there is no scalar field , it turns out that the latter has to be the static schwarzschild solution but the situation may be more complicated in the present context due to the presence of scalar gravitational radiation . in general one can show that the following continuity conditions must apply at @xmath106 : = 0 , = [ g _ u^ n^ ] = 0 , = 0 , = 0 where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are 4-vectors normal and tangent to @xmath106 , respectively @xcite . unfortunately , it turns out that an einstein - straus type solution does not exist in bd theory . this is because the only way to satisfy the junction conditions ( 21 ) is if @xmath52 is spatially and temporally constant , which is just the general relativistic case . jacobsen @xcite has addressed the problem analytically by looking for a spherically symmetric solution which represents a perturbation of the schwarzschild solution near the origin but is asymptotically friedmann at large distances , with @xmath52 satisfying the appropriate cosmological conditions . he presupposes that the black hole event horizon is much smaller than the particle horizon , so that the cosmological timescale is much longer than the black hole timescale . in this case , he finds that there is little lag between the value of @xmath52 at the event horizon and particle horizon , which suggests that memory can only be weak . however , it must be emphasized that this conclusion need not follow if the black hole has a size _ comparable _ to the particle horizon at formation and , as indicated in section 2 , this is expected for a pbh .    another way to investigate the problem is to study the collapse of dust in a tolman - bondi background using the same approximation employed by harada et al . @xcite , i.e. neglecting the back reaction of the scalar field , but requiring that @xmath52 have the required cosmological time - dependence at large distances . one puts in an initial density perturbation for the dust but assumes that @xmath52 is initially homogeneous . our preliminary numerical calculations @xcite use the characteristic method to determine the evolution of the scalar field perturbation along null and constant - time hypersurfaces . we find that @xmath52 does initially build up near the centre but it then gets smoothed out , tending eventually to homogeneity . although this suggests that there is no gravitational memory , it should be stressed that this conclusion only applies for dust and if one neglects the back reaction . since we lack definite knowledge about the evolution of the scalar field when a black hole forms in a cosmological background , it is useful to consider a range of scenarios which go beyond the two possibilities envisaged by barrow . in general , the background scalar field will have a present value @xmath109 and a value @xmath110 when the black hole first formed . however , it is likely to develop inhomogeneties for at least some intervening period . in the following discussion , we will characterize the degree of gravitational memory by comparing the value of the scalar field at the black hole event horizon ( @xmath111 ) and the cosmological particle horizon ( @xmath112 ) . we first consider the two extreme situations described by barrow @xcite :    scenarioa : _ eh(t ) = _ ph(t ) for  all  t a schwarzschild black hole forms at time @xmath113 with its event horizon radius being @xmath114 . if @xmath115 evolves with time , then the black hole adjusts quasi - statically through a sequence of schwarzschild states approximated by @xmath116 , see fig . 4(a ) . in this scenario there is no gravitational memory . scenario b : _ eh(t ) = _ eh(t_f ) for  all  t a schwarzschild black hole of size @xmath117 forms at time @xmath113 and , while @xmath115 equals the evolving background value beyond some scale - length @xmath118 , it remains constant within @xmath119 , see fig . 4(b ) . in this case the black hole size is determined by @xmath120 even at the present epoch and this means that the region @xmath121 has a memory of the gravitational `` constant '' at the time of its formation . .2 in    neither of these scenarios can be completely realistic since they both assume that @xmath52 is homogeneous almost everywhere . however , even if @xmath52 were homogeneous initially , one would expect it to become inhomogeneous as collapse proceeds . indeed , in the dust case , this is confirmed by the numerical calculations described above @xcite . therefore , if the background value is increasing ( as usually applies ) , one would expect @xmath52 in the collapsing region to become first _ larger _ than the background value on a local dynamical timescale and then _ smaller _ than it on a cosmological timescale . such behaviour would necessarily entail a variation of @xmath52 in space as well as time . we must also allow for the possibility that @xmath52 may vary interior to @xmath119 but on a slower or faster timescale than the background . we therefore propose two further scenarios : .2 in    scenarioc : |_eh(t)| |_ph(t)| for  all  t where the dot represents a time derivative . this implies that the scalar field evolves faster at the event horizon than at the particle horizon until it eventually becomes homogeneous , see fig . we describe this as _ short - term _ gravitational memory and it reduces to scenario a as the timescale to become homogeneous tends to zero . this would apply , for example , if @xmath52 were to change on the dynamical timescales of the black hole since this is usually less than the cosmological timescale . scenario d : [ beta ] |_eh(t)| < |_ph(t)| for  all  t this implies that @xmath52 evolves faster at the particle horizon than the event horizon , see fig . we describe this is as _ weak _ gravitational memory and it reduces to scenario b when the left - hand - side of eqn ( [ beta ] ) is zero . in this case , the evolution of @xmath52 is again dominated by the black hole inside some length - scale @xmath119 . note that , in either this scenario or the last one , the length - scale @xmath119 need not be fixed , since it could either grow or shrink as scalar gravitational radiation propagates . a particular example of this , to which we return shortly , would be _ self - similar _ gravitational memory , in which the ratio of @xmath111 to @xmath112 always remains the same . .2 in    [ f4 ] in general relativity there is an equivalence between a scalar field and a stiff fluid and this can be exploited in studying gravitational memory . in the einstein frame , the energy momentum tensor for a perfect fluid is |t _ = ( + p)u _ u _ + |g _ p where @xmath122 is the velocity of the fluid . if we define a velocity field by [ fvel ] u _ = , this gives |t _ = - + p |g_. by comparing this to the energy - momentum tensor for a scalar field , we find that p = = - |g^ | _ | _ , so we have a stiff fluid . this equivalence applies provided that the derivative of the scalar field is timelike . otherwise the velocity field defined in ( [ fvel ] ) would be imaginary . this is relevant to the gravitational memory problem because we can now interpret the various scenarios discussed in section 6 in terms of the _ accretion _ of a stiff fluid . if the black hole does not accrete at all or accretes very little , this will correspond to strong or weak gravitational memory ( scenarios b and d , respectively ) . however , if enough accretion occurs to homogenize @xmath52 , this will correspond to short - term gravitational memory ( scenario c ) . the faster the accretion , the shorter the memory , so scenario a corresponds to the idealization in which homogenization is instantaneous . a simple newtonian treatment @xcite for a general fluid suggests that the accretion rate in the einstein frame should be = 4r^2_a v_s , where @xmath123 is the accretion radius and @xmath124 is the sound - speed in the accreted fluid . for a stiff fluid , @xmath125 and @xmath126 , while @xmath127 in a friedmann universe at early times , so we have . this can be integrated to give [ mass ] m where @xmath128 is the black hole mass at the time @xmath113 when it formed . if we define a parameter @xmath129 , then eqn ( [ mass ] ) implies mm_f(1 - ) ^-1 as t. if @xmath130 , the black hole could not grow very much . however , if @xmath38 is close to 1 , which must be the case if @xmath131 , then the black hole could grow significantly . in particular , in the limit @xmath132 , eqn ( [ mass ] ) implies @xmath133 , so the black hole grows at the same rate as the universe . this simple calculation suggests that a black hole surrounded by a stiff fluid can accrete enough to grow at the same rate as the universe .    since the above calculation neglects the effects of the cosmological expansion , one needs a relativistic calculation to check this . the newtonian result suggests that one should look for a spherically symmetric _ self - similar _ solution , in which every dimensionless variable is a function of @xmath134 , so that it is unchanged by the transformation @xmath135 for any constant @xmath136 . this problem has an interesting but rather convolved history . by looking for a black hole solution attached to an exact friedmann solution via a sonic point , carr & hawking first showed that there is no such solution for a radiation fluid @xcite and the argument can be extended to a general @xmath39 fluid with @xmath137 . lin et al . @xcite subsequently claimed that there is such a solution in the special case @xmath138 . however , bicknell & henriksen @xcite then showed that this solution is unphysical , in that the density gradient diverges at the event horizon . this suggests that the black hole must soon become much smaller than the particle horizon , after which eqn ( 32 ) implies there will be very little further accretion . therefore the stiff fluid analysis suggests that there should be at least _ weak _ gravitational memory . we have seen that studying the formation and evaporation of pbhs can place interesting constraints on models of the early universe even if they never existed . on the other hand , if they did exist , pbhs can provide unique information about times much earlier than those probed by any other relics of the big bang . in particular , they may provide information about the variation of @xmath0 at early times . the precise signature of such a variation depends upon the degree to which a black hole can  remember " the value of @xmath0 at its formation epoch . this is still unclear but various methods are being pursued to resolve this issue . zeldovich and i.d . novikov , sov . 10 ( 1967 ) , 602 . s.w . hawking , mnras 152 ( 1971 ) , 75 . carr , in _ observational and theoretical aspects of relativistic astrophysics and cosmology _ , ed . j.l.sanz & l.j.goicoechea ( world scientific , 1985 ) p 1 . s.w . hawking , nature 248 ( 1974 ) , 30 . d.n.page and s.w . hawking , ap.j . 206 ( 1976 ) , 1 . n.a . porter and t.c . weekes , nature 277 ( 1979 ) 199 . zeldovich and a.a . starobinsky , jetp lett . 24 ( 1976 ) 571 . novikov , a.g . polnarev , a.a . starobinsky and ya.b . zeldovich , astron.astrophys . 80 ( 1979 ) 104 . barrow , mnras 192 ( 1980 ) 427 . okeke and m.j . rees , astron.astrophys . 81 ( 1980 ) 263 . p. kiraly et al . , nature 293 ( 1981 ) 120 . rees , nature 266 ( 1977 ) 333 . carr , in _ current topics in astrofundamental physics _ n.sanchez & a. zichichi ( world scientific , 1997 ) , p 306 . j. d. barrow , phys . d. 46 ( 1992 ) , r3227 . j. d. barrow and b. j. carr , phys . d. 54 ( 1996 ) , 3920 . c. goymer and b. j. carr , preprint ( 1999 ) . b. j. carr and s. w. hawking , mnras 168 ( 1974 ) , 399 . carr , ap.j . 201 ( 1975 ) , 1 . khlopov , b.e . malomed and ya.b . zeldovich , mnras 215 ( 1985 ) , 575 . naselsky and a.g . polnarev , sov.astron . 29 ( 1985 ) , 487 . b.j . carr and j.e . lidsey , phys.rev.d . 48 ( 1993 ) , 543 . carr , j.h.gilbert and j.e . lidsey , phys.rev.d . 50 ( 1994 ) , 4853 . p. ivanov , p. naselsky and i. novikov , phys.rev.d . 50 ( 1994 ) , 7173 . j. garcia - bellido , a. linde and d. wands , phys.rev.d . 54 ( 1997 ) , 6040 . a.m. green & a.r . liddle , phys.rev.d . 56 ( 1997 ) 6166 ; 60 ( 1999 ) , 0635616 . l. randall , m. soljacic and a.h . guth , nuc . b. 472 ( 1996 ) , 377 . j. yokoyama , astron . 318 ( 1997 ) , 673 . bassett and s. tsujikawa , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0008328 . a.m. green and k.a . malik , preprint ( 2000 ) ; hep - ph/0008113 . bullock and j.r . primack , phys.rev.d . 55 ( 1997 ) , 7423 . p. ivanov , phys . d. 57 ( 1998 ) , 7145 . m.yu . khlopov and a.g . polnarev , phys.lett.b . 97 ( 1980 ) , 383 . m. crawford and d.n . schramm , nature 298 ( 1982 ) , 538 . s.w . hawking , i. moss and j. stewart , phys.rev.d . , 26 ( 1982 ) , 2681 . d. la and p.j.steinhardt , phys.lett.b . 220 ( 1989 ) , 375 . polnarev and r. zemboricz , phys.rev.d . 43 ( 1988 ) , 1106 . s.w . hawking , b. 231 ( 1989 ) , 237 . j. garriga and m. sakellariadou , phys.rev.d . 48 ( 1993 ) , 2502 . r. caldwell and p. casper , phys . 53 ( 1996 ) , 3002 . macgibbon , r.h . brandenberger and u.f . wichoski , phys . d. 57 ( 1998 ) , 2158 . rubin , m.yu . khlopov and a.s . sakharov , grav . supp . 6 ( 2000 ) , 1 . carr , ap.j . 206 ( 1976 ) , 8 . macgibbon and b.j . carr , ap.j . 371 ( 1991 ) , 447 . macgibbon , phys . rev.d . 44 ( 1991 ) , 376 . macgibbon and b.r . webber , phys.rev.d . 41 ( 1990 ) , 3052 . macgibbon , nature 329 ( 1987 ) , 308 . barrow , e.j . copeland and a.r . liddle , phys.rev.d . 46 ( 1992 ) , 645 . dolgov , p.d . naselsky and i.d . novikov , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0009407 . j. niemeyer and k. jedamzik , phys.rev.d . 59 ( 1999 ) , 124013 . m. shibata and m. sasaki , phys.rev.d . ( 1999 ) ( in press ) ; gr - qc/9905064 . choptuik , phys . 70 ( 1993 ) , 9 . c. r. evans and j. s. coleman , phys . 72 ( 1994 ) , 1782 . d. maison , phys . lett b 366 ( 1996 ) , 82 . t. koike , t. hara and s. adachi , phys . d 59 ( 1999 ) , 104008 . j. niemeyer and k. jedamzik , phys.rev.lett . 80 ( 1998 ) , 5481 . h. kim , preprint ( 1999 ) . a.m. green and a.r . liddle , phys . d. 60 ( 1999 ) , 063509 . k. jedamzik , phys.rev.d . 55 ( 1997 ) , r5871 ; phys . 307 ( 1998 ) , 155 . k. jedamzik and j. niemeyer , phys.rev.d . 59 ( 1999 ) , 124014 . t. nakamura , m. sasaki , t. tanaka and k. thorn , astrophys.j . 487 ( 1997 ) , l139 . k. ioka , t. tanaka and t. nakamura et al . d. 60 ( 1999 ) , 083512 . k. ioka , astrophys.j . ( 1999 ) ( in press ) . k. kohri and j. yokoyama , preprint ( 1999 ) . bugaev and k.v . konischev , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0005295 . wright , ap.j . 459 ( 1996 ) , 487 . k. maki , t. mitsui and s. orito , phys.rev.lett . 76 ( 1996 ) , 3474 . d.b.cline , d.a . sanders and w. hong , ap.j . 486 ( 1997 ) , 169 . carr , phys . 307 ( 1998 ) 141 . coyne , c. sinnis & r. somerville , in _ proceedings of the houston advanced research center conference on black holes _ ( 1992 ) . f. halzen , e. zas , j. macgibbon , & t.c.weekes , nature 298 ( 1991 ) 538 . a. heckler , phys . 55 ( 1997 ) 840 . a. heckler , phys . b. 231 ( 1997 ) 3430 . j. kapusta , this volume ( 2001 ) . macgibbon , b.j . carr and d.n . page ( 2000 ) . t. kaluza , sitz.d.preuss.akad.d.wiss.physik-mat.klasse ( 1921 ) , 966 . p.a.m.dirac , proc . a165 ( 1938 ) , 199 . p. jordan , _ schwerkraft und weltall _ , vieweg ( braunschweig , 1955 ) . d. sciama , mnras 113 ( 1957 ) , 34 . c. brans and r. h. dicke , phys . 124 ( 1961 ) , 925 . will , _ theory and experiment in gravitational physics _ ( cambridge , 1993 ) . bergmann , int.j.theor.phys . 1 ( 1968 ) r.v.wagoner , phys.rev.d.1 ( 1970 ) , 3209 . k. nordtvedt , astrophys . j. 161 ( 1970 ) , 1059 , a. guth , phys . rev . d. 23 ( 1981 ) , 347 . p.g.o.freund , nuc . b. 209 ( 1982 ) , 146 . k. maeda , class . grav . 3 ( 1986 ) , 233 . kolb , m.j.perry and t.p.walker , phys.rev.d . 33 ( 1986 ) , 869 . callan et al . , nuc . b. 262 ( 1985 ) 597 . t. damour and a.m. polyakov , nuc.phys.b 423 ( 1994 ) 532 . p.j . steinhardt and f.s . accetta , phys . 64 ( 1990 ) 2740 . barrow and p. parsons , phys . d , 55 , 1906 ( 1997 ) . s. w. hawking , commun . phys . 25 ( 1972 ) , 167 . m. a. scheel , s. l. shapiro and s. a. teukolsky , phys . rev . d. 51 ( 1995 ) , 4208 . m. a. scheel , s. l. shapiro and s. a. teukolsky , phys . d. 51 ( 1995 ) , 4236 . j. kerimo and d. kalligas , phys . d. 58 ( 1998 ) 104002 . t. harada , t , chiba , k. nakao and t. nakamura , phys . d. 55 ( 1997 ) , 2024 . a. einstein and e. g. straus , rev . 17 ( 1945 ) , 120 . c. b. g. mcintosh , phys . 43a(1973 ) , 33 . t. jacobsen , phys . 83 ( 1999 ) , 2699 . t. harada , b.j . carr and c.a . goymer , preprint ( 2000 ) . d. n. c. lin , b. j. carr and s. m. fall , mnras 177 ( 1976 ) , 51 . g. v. bicknell and r. n. henriksen , ap . j. 219 ( 1978 ) , 1043 .
Abstract:

Answer: we discuss recent developments in the study of primordial black holes , focussing particularly on their formation and quantum evaporation . such studies can place important constraints on models of the early universe . an especially interesting development has been the realization that such constraints may be severely modified if the value of the gravitational  constant " @xmath0 varies with cosmological epoch , a possibility which arises in many scenarios for the early universe . the nature of the modification depends upon whether the value of @xmath0 near a black hole maintains the value it had at its formation epoch ( corresponding to gravitational memory ) or whether it tracks the background cosmological value . this is still uncertain but we discuss various approaches which might help to resolve the issue .