Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: one of the fascinating solutions of the gravity theories is the black hole space time . pioneering works of bekenstain @xcite , hawking @xcite and later on bardeen et al @xcite illuminated the fact that all the laws of black hole mechanics are identical to those of the ordinary thermodynamics with properly identification of the respective quantities , like temperature , entropy , energy etc . and hence they do act as the ordinary thermal system . people then started thinking that black holes may play a crucial role to give idea on the quantum nature of the gravity . but till now there is no such complete theory of quantum gravity . several recent results strongly indicate the possibility that the field equations of gravity have the same status as the equations of fluid mechanics or elasticity . for a recent review , see @xcite . one specific implementation of this idea considers the field equations of the theory to be ` emergent ' in a well - defined sense , rather than use that term in a more speculative vein like e.g. , considering the space and time themselves to be emergent etc . the evidence for such a specific interpretation comes from different facts like the possibility of interpreting the field equation in a wide class of theories as thermodynamic relations @xcite , the nature of action functional in gravitational theories and their thermodynamic interpretation @xcite , the possibility of obtaining the field equations from a thermodynamic extremum principle @xcite , application of equipartition ideas to obtain the density of microscopic degrees of freedom @xcite , the equivalence of einstein s field equations to the navier - stokes equations near a null surface @xcite etc . the important fact in the emergent paradigm is that one does not need to know about the details of the microscopic description of the theory . these lead to the idea that one can study the different aspects of thermodynamics , in the case of gravity , without any detail of the underlying microscopic structure . here we will adopt the same logic and study the phase transition of the black hole solution in hoava - lifshitz theory following the prescription in ordinary thermodynamics . studying the thermodynamics @xcite-@xcite as well as the critical behavior @xcite-@xcite of various black hole solutions in the framework of usual einstein gravity has been a fascinating topic of research for the past few decades . apart from these , there also exist topological black hole solutions whose thermodynamics has been studied in einstein gravity @xcite , einstein - gauss - bonnet gravity and dilaton gravity @xcite as well as lovelock gravity @xcite . on the other hand , inspired by the dynamical critical phenomena in usual condensed matter systems , very recently p. hoava proposed a uv complete theory of gravity @xcite that reduces to the usual einstein gravity at large scales . since then a number of attempts have been made in order to understand various aspects of this theory @xcite-@xcite including different cosmological aspects @xcite . various black hole solutions were also found in @xcite . the thermodynamics of these black holes have been studied in @xcite . although these attempts are self contained and rigorous , still there remains some major questions which have not yet been attempted . studying the critical behavior of black holes is one of the important aspects , which we aim to explore for hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity .    in ordinary thermodynamics , critical exponents plays a crucial role in order to understand the singular behavior of various thermodynamic entities near the critical point . in usual thermodynamic systems , it is customary to express the singular behavior of various thermodynamic systems in terms of power laws characterized by a set of _ static critical exponents _ which determines the qualitative nature of the phase transition near the critical point . all these exponents are not independent and are found to satisfy certain _ thermodynamic scaling laws _ near the critical point @xcite-@xcite . it is generally observed that for @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the spatial dimension of the system , the critical exponents do not depend on the spatial dimension of the system , which reflects the mean field characteristics of a theory . on the other hand if the interaction between the constituent elements are short range then the critical exponents are found to be depe ndent on @xmath6 .    in this paper , based on a canonical framework ( i.e ; keeping the charge ( @xmath7 ) of the black hole fixed @xcite ) , we investigate the critical behavior of topological charged black holes in hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity at the lifshitz point @xmath1 . the black hole solution is given in @xcite . although all the thermodynamic quantities were evaluated earlier @xcite , a detailed study of the nature of phase transition is still lacking . particularly the issue regarding the _ scaling behavior _ of ( charged ) black holes has never been investigated so far in the frame work of hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity . we investigate the phase transition phenomena for all the three cases taking @xmath8 . we observe the following interesting features : @xmath9 there is no hawking page transition @xcite for black hole with @xmath10 . @xmath9 for @xmath4 , there is a upper bound in the value of the event horizon , above which the temperature becomes negative . this indicates that above this critical value of horizon , the black hole solution does not exist . we will call this valid range as the _ physical region_. @xmath9 within the physical region , interesting phase structure could be observed for the hyperbolic charged black holes ( @xmath11 ) . in this particular case we observe the second order transition . this is _ different _ from the usual one . in einstein gravity , hawking page transition occurs for @xmath3 while there is no such transition for @xmath12 . the critical point of second order phase transition is marked by the divergence in the heat capacity at constant charge ( @xmath13 ) . finally , we explicitly calculate all the _ static critical exponents _ associated with the second order transition , and check the validity of _ thermodynamic scaling laws _ near the critical point . interestingly enough it is found that the hyperbolic charged black holes ( @xmath14 ) in the hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity fall under the same universality class to that with the black holes having spherically symmetric topology ( @xmath15 ) in the usual einstein gravity . the values of these critical exponents indeed suggest a universal _ mean field _ behavior in black holes which valid in both the einstein as well as hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity @xcite-@xcite . the plan of the paper is as follows : we begin in section 2 by giving a brief introduction of the black hole solution in hoava - lifshitz gravity and use it in section 3 to study the different thermodynamic quantities as well as the phase transition . in section 4 , the critical exponents near the critical point are being evaluated and a brief discussion on the validity of the ordinary scaling laws is presented . finally , we conclude in section 5 . in this section a brief discussion on the black hole solution in hoava - lifshitz gravity will be presented . for details , one can follow @xcite where the meaning of all the parameters are given explicitly . we will mainly concentrate on the solutions at the lifshitz point @xmath1 , particularly , the static spherically symmetric topological charged black holes solution @xmath16 where , @xmath17 is the line element for a two dimensional einstein space with constant scalar curvature @xmath0 . without loss of generality , one can take @xmath18 respectively . the form of the metric coefficient , for the detailed balance condition , is given by @xcite @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 corresponds to the negative cosmological constant . the physical mass and the charge ( @xmath7 ) corresponding to the black hole solution are respectively given by , @xmath22 where , @xmath23 , @xmath24 are the integration constants , @xmath25 is the volume of the two dimensional einstein space and @xmath26 , @xmath27 are the constant parameters of the theory . the event horizon is the solution of the equation @xmath28 . in ordinary thermodynamics the phase transition is studied by the divergence of relevant thermodynamic quantities . here , the same technique will be adopted . we shall first calculate the hawking temperature , entropy and specific heat of the black hole using a canonical ensemble frame work , which means that we shall carry out our analysis keeping the total charge ( @xmath7 ) of the black hole fixed @xcite . finally , a graphical analysis will be given to study the phase transition . before we proceed further , let us mention that in the following analysis we re - scale our variables as @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , where we have set @xmath32 with @xmath33 . the hawking temperature is calculated as @xmath34 and after the above mentioned re - scaling the entropy is found to be @xmath35 in the above , @xmath36 is the integration constant which must be fixed by the physical consideration . to be precise , entropy is always determined upto some additive constant . but in all physical considerations the difference is important . therefore in the present analysis we will consider only the difference . however , the integration constant @xmath36 could be determined using the usual thermodynamic prescription ; i.e. determination of entropy in the @xmath37 limit , which might be the entropy of an extremal black hole .    ) plot of topological black holes for @xmath10 with respect to @xmath38 for @xmath39 and @xmath40._,width=453 ]    ) and entropy ( @xmath41 ) plot of topological black holes for @xmath11 with respect to @xmath38 for @xmath39 and @xmath40._,width=453 ]    before we proceed further , let us first try to analyze the behavior of hawking temperature ( @xmath42 ) for different choices of @xmath43 . first of all , for the case @xmath44 , we note that the hawking temperature ( @xmath42 ) is a monotonically increasing function of horizon radius ( @xmath45 ) ( see fig . 1 ) which indicates that the corresponding heat capacities ( @xmath13 ) are always positive definite . therefore these black holes are globally stable and there is no phase transition . next consider the other case , @xmath11 . for this , the hawking temperature ( [ t ] ) reduces to the following form : @xmath46 it it interesting to note that the hawking temperature ( @xmath42 ) is always positive in the range @xmath47 . furthermore , if we plot the entropy ( @xmath48 ) as a function of @xmath49 , using ( [ s ] ) , it shows that @xmath48 is also positive in this range ( see fig . interestingly enough this condition is found to be valid for any value of the physical charge ( @xmath7 ) of the black hole . on the other hand , we note that @xmath50 as @xmath51 . this is due to the fact that as @xmath51 the second term on the r.h.s of ( [ tk ] ) dominates over the first one which ultimately produces a large negative temperature . this is a nonphysical situation and the corresponding black hole solution does not exist for @xmath52 . considering this fact , in the present paper we carry out our analysis in the _ physical range _ @xmath47 where the temperature ( @xmath42 ) of the black hole is _ finite _ as well as _ positive _ definite .    in the above specified range ( @xmath47 ) we observe a change in slope at @xmath53 of the corresponding ( @xmath54 ) plot ( see fig . 2 ) . this change in slope signals a discontinuity at @xmath53 in the corresponding heat capacity @xmath13 . it gives a indication of second order phase transition at @xmath53 , which we shall refer as the critical point of phase transition . in order to make the discussion more transparent we next compute the corresponding heat capacity ( @xmath13 ) .    using ( [ t ] ) and ( [ s ] ) the heat capacity is determined as @xmath55    ) plot of topological black holes for @xmath11 with respect to @xmath38 for @xmath39 and @xmath40._,width=302 ]    from the above figure ( fig . 3 ) , we see that specific heat ( @xmath13 ) indeed suffers a discontinuity at @xmath56 . this shows that there is a genuine second order phase transition at @xmath56 . for the phase 1 the heat capacity ( @xmath13 ) is always found to be positive ( see fig . 3 ) which means that this phase is thermodynamically _ stable_. on the other hand , @xmath57 for the phase 2 and therefore it is an _ unstable phase_.    this scenario is completely different in the einstein gravity , where we have no hawking page transition for @xmath58 . whereas , @xmath3 case exhibits hawking page transition @xcite-@xcite . for the above phase structure one can further investigate the critical behavior of the black hole in hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity near the critical point @xmath59 , which we aim to discuss in the next section . in this section , based on a thermodynamic approach , we explicitly calculate various critical exponents ( that is associated with the second order phase transition at @xmath59 ) for the hyperbolic charged black holes ( with @xmath11 ) in the fixed charge ( @xmath7 ) ensemble .    in the theory of phase transitions , critical exponents play an important role in order to understand the singular behavior of various thermodynamic entities near the critical point(s ) . in order to have a complete understanding of the physics of phase transition phenomena , one generally introduces a set of static critical exponents @xmath60 which play a central role in the theory of critical phenomena , and studies the so called thermodynamic scaling laws @xcite near the critical point .    in order to find the critical exponents , we write near the critical point @xmath61 where @xmath62 . defining @xmath63 , the taylor expansion of the temperature ( @xmath42 ) about @xmath53 yields @xmath64_{x_+=x_2}(x_+-x_2)+\frac{1}{2}\big[\left(\frac{\partial^{2}t}{\partial x_+^{2 } } \right)_{q}\big]_{x_+=x_2}(x_+-x_2)^{2}+ { \textrm { higher order terms}}~. \label{eq2}\ ] ] it has been shown earlier that at the critical point @xmath59 , @xmath65 diverges ( see figure 3 ) . therefore ( [ cq ] ) implies that the second term on the right hand side of ( [ eq2 ] ) vanishes . hence neglecting the higher order terms and then using ( [ eq1 ] ) in ( [ eq2 ] ) we obtain , @xmath66 where , @xmath67 _ { x_+=x_2}=\frac{6x_2^{2}+3q^{2}x_2^{2}-6x_2^{4}-6q^{2}x_2^{4}-2-q^{2}}{x_2^{3}(x_{2}^{2}-1)^{3}}.\ ] ]    now to find the critical exponent @xmath68 which is defined by the standard relation @xmath69 we use the relation ( [ eq1 ] ) in ( [ cq ] ) and then keep the terms only linear in @xmath70 to obtain @xmath71 with @xmath72 finally , using ( [ eq3 ] ) in the above we find the behavior of @xmath13 near the critical point @xmath53 : @xmath73 where , @xmath74 a comparison of ( [ eq4 ] ) with the standard relation ( [ alpha ] ) yields @xmath75 . next the determination of the critical exponent @xmath76 which is defined through the relation ( for a fixed value of charge @xmath7 ) as , @xmath77 will be done . here the potential @xmath78 is given by @xmath79 to proceed , let us first taylor expand @xmath80 about @xmath81 : @xmath82_{x_+=x_2 } ( x_+-x_2)+{\textrm{higher order terms } } \nonumber \\ & = &   \phi(x_2 )   - \frac{q}{x_2 ^ 2 } ( x_+-x_2)+{\textrm{higher order terms}}~. \label{phi1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as before , neglecting the higher order terms and then using ( [ eq1 ] ) we obtain , @xmath83 where in the final step ( [ eq3 ] ) also has been used . this immediately determines @xmath84 .    to find out the exponent @xmath85 , associated with the divergence of the inverse of the isothermal compressibility @xmath86 $ ] @xcite , we first find the explicit expression of @xmath87 . the thermodynamic identity @xmath88 yields @xmath89 in order to evaluate the right hand side of ( [ kt1 ] ) first note that , @xmath90 also , from the functional relation , @xmath91 we find , @xmath92 right hand side of both ( [ neweq1 ] ) and ( [ neweq2 ] ) can be easily calculated using the relations ( [ t ] ) and ( [ potential ] ) which finally yields , @xmath93 then to obtain the near critical point expression , use ( [ eq1 ] ) and next ( [ eq3 ] ) in the above . this yields , @xmath94 comparing with the standard relation @xmath95 , defined for the fixed value of charge ( @xmath7 ) , we get @xmath96 .    the critical exponent @xmath97 is defined through the relation , @xmath98 at constant temperature @xmath42 . to find it , we first expand @xmath99 in a sufficiently small neighborhood of @xmath100 which yields , @xmath101_{x_+=x_2 } ( x_+-x_2)+\frac{1}{2 } \left [ \left ( \frac{\partial^{2 } q}{\partial x^{2}_+}\right)_{t}\right]_{x_+=x_2 } ( x_+-x_2)^{2 } \nonumber \\ & + & { \textrm{higher order terms}}~. \label{q}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath102 ( see eq . ( [ t ] ) ) , one finds for the fixed @xmath103 @xmath104 now at the critical point @xmath81 , @xmath65 diverges and so , as earlier , @xmath105_{x_+=x_2}=0 $ ] . therefore , after neglecting the higher order terms , ( [ q ] ) reduces to @xmath106 where , @xmath107_{x_+=x_2}=\frac{18x_2^{8}+32x_2^{4}-44x_2^{6}-3q^{2}x_2^{4}-4x_2^{2}-2-q^{2}}{2q^{2}x_2^{2}(x_2^{2}-1)^{2}}.\ ] ] next since @xmath108 , we have the functional relation @xmath109 and so @xmath110 therefore using ( [ eq7 ] ) we find , @xmath111_{x_+=x_2 } = \left [ \left ( \frac{\partial \phi}{\partial x_+}\right)_{q } \right]_{x_+=x_2}=-\frac{q}{x_2^{2}}.\label{eq9}\ ] ] finally , expanding @xmath112 close to the critical point @xmath113 at constant @xmath103 and then using ( [ eq8 ] ) and ( [ eq9 ] ) we obtain , @xmath114^{1/2}~. \label{eq10}\ ] ] hence , the critical exponent is read off as @xmath115 . now re - expressing ( [ eq4 ] ) by using ( [ eq3 ] ) in the following form : @xmath116 and then substituting the value of @xmath117 from ( [ eq8 ] ) we obtain . ] @xmath118 comparing this with the standard definition @xmath119 we find @xmath120 .    in the following the calculation , the critical exponent @xmath121 , defined by @xmath122 will be found out . expansion of the entropy for fixed charge @xmath123 about the critical point @xmath59 yields @xmath124_{x_+ = x_2 } ( x_+ - x_2)+{\textrm{higher order terms}}~. \label{new1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then following the identical steps as earlier and using ( [ eq8 ] ) we find @xmath125 which yields @xmath126 .    in the following table , we give the values of the critical exponents for the present example :    .various critical exponents and their values [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]     [ e1 ]    it may be interesting to mention that the critical exponents for the second order phase transition in the case of hyperbolic black hole in hoava - lifshitz gravity are exactly equal to those obtained earlier in @xcite for the einstein - born - infeld gravity with @xmath3 .    in the last part of the section , we discuss about the validity of the usual thermodynamic scaling laws for our present situation . it should be mentioned that in the realistic thermodynamic systems various critical exponents are found to satisfy certain ( scaling ) relations among themselves , known as _ thermodynamic scaling laws _ @xcite-@xcite , which may be expressed as , @xmath127 since the critical exponents , we find here , are exactly equal to those obtained in the usual einstein - born - infeld gravity for @xmath128 @xcite , all the above relations ( [ scaling laws ] ) are indeed satisfied for the present case , in spite of difference in the nature of the black hole solution and the phase structure . this can be checked easily by substituting the values from the table in ( [ scaling laws ] ) . in this sense , it may be possible that the black holes in both type of theories fall under the same class such that their critical exponents are identical . finally we are in a position to check the additional scaling laws for the exponents @xmath129 and @xmath130 which are associated with the diverging nature of correlation length and correlation function near the critical point . since the spatial dimension ( @xmath6 ) of our theory is @xmath131 , therefore it will be natural to assume that the additional scaling relations , @xmath132 will hold in general . this immediately determines the other exponents . taking @xmath133 and using the exponent values from table 1 , we finally obtain , @xmath134 in practical situation , the assumption that the scaling laws ( [ add ] ) are valid , may not be true . hence it must be checked that these are indeed valid or not . alternatively , one should find the above exponents by some alternative method . it is now evident that gravity and thermodynamics are closely connected to each other @xcite . the repeated failure to quantize gravity led to a parallel development where gravity is believed to be an emergent phenomenon just like thermodynamics and hydrodynamics instead treating it as a fundamental force @xcite . the fundamental role of gravity is replaced by thermodynamic interpretations leading to similar or equivalent results without knowing the underlying microscopic details .    in this paper , we adopted the standard thermodynamic approach to explore the phase structure of the topological charged black holes in hoava - lifshitz gravity for the lifshitz point @xmath1 . these black holes were introduced earlier in @xcite . in @xcite the authors have computed the general expression for the hawking temperature for these black holes . in spite of this attempt , till date the issue regarding the nature of phase transition , particularly the issue of critical phenomena , remains completely unexplored . in the present paper , we attempted to provide an answer to all these questions . a number of interesting features have been observed in this regard which have never been explored so far to the best of our knowledge . these are as follows : @xmath9 we showed that there exits a _ physical range _ @xmath135 , where the black hole solution exists . @xmath9 within this range , the second order phase transition occurs . @xmath9 the situation is not exactly identical to einstein theory . in einstein theory , there is no hawking page phase transition for @xmath12 while @xmath3 case exhibits such phase transition . here , only @xmath4 solution has phase transition . @xmath9 finally , the critical exponents near the critical point of the phase transition were derived . this was done again using the ordinary thermodynamic analogy . it may be noted that the critical point has been marked by the discontinuity of the heat capacity ( @xmath136 ) which suggests that it is a second order phase transition . moreover , as a point of conformation , we also found that the critical exponent , associated with the divergence in @xmath65 , is @xmath137 which simultaneously indicates a mean field feature as well as a second order nature of the phase transition . interestingly , these are exactly equal to those of einstein - born - infeld theory @xcite-@xcite and also they satisfy the ordinary thermodynamic scaling laws . this in fact suggests two remarkable facts : ( 1 ) black holes in both the einstein as well as hoava - lifshitz theory of gravity fall under the same universality class , ( 2 ) there exists a universal _ mean field _ behavior in both of these gravi ty theories . it may be pointed out that the issues , dealt with the present paper , are notoriously difficult to study . so far what we have done is completely based on the ordinary thermodynamic analogy . but a simple analogy with the thermodynamics may not be enough to draw safe conclusions . also the understanding of the thermodynamic interpretation of gravity is far from complete since the arguments are more heuristic than concrete and depend upon specific ansatz or assumptions . therefore the results are suggestive rather than definitive . hence it is necessary to compute the critical exponents by other alternative / direct procedures ; e.g. correlation function technique of the scalar modes , the ads / cft correspondence , re - normalization group scheme , etc . which is beyond the scope of the present paper . in spite of this , we still believe that the analysis , presented here , could illuminate the underlying microscopic structure of the gravity . 99 j.  d.  bekenstein , phys . d * 7 * , 2333 ( 1973 ) . s.  w.  hawking , nature * 248 * , 30 ( 1974 ) . j.  m.  bardeen , b.  carter and s.  w.  hawking , commun . * 31 * , 161 ( 1973 ) . t.  padmanabhan ( 2010 ) , _ rept . _ , * 73 * , 046901 [ arxiv:0911.5004 ] . + t. padmanabhan , _ conf.ser._ , * 306 * , 012001 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.4476 ] . t. padmanabhan , _ class.quan.grav._ , * 19 * , 5387 ( 2002 ) [ gr - qc/0204019 ] ; + dawood kothawala and t. padmanabhan , _ phys . _ , * d 79 * , 104020 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.0215 ] ; + t. padmanabhan , _ a physical interpretation of gravitational field equationsaip conference proceedings _ , * 1241 * , 93 - 108 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.1403 ] . t. padmanabhan , _ brazilian jour.phys . ( special issue ) _ * 35 * , 362 ( 2005 ) [ gr - qc/0412068 ] ; + a. mukhopadhyay and t. padmanabhan , _ phys . _ , * d 74 * , 124023 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0608120 ] ; + sanved kolekar and t. padmanabhan , _ phys _ , * d82 * , 024036 , 2010 [ arxiv:1005.0619 ] . t. padmanabhan and aseem paranjape , _ phys.rev . _ * d75 * 064004 , ( 2007 ) [ gr - qc/0701003 ] ; + t. padmanabhan , _ gen.rel.grav_. , * 40 * , 529 - 564 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0705.2533 ] . t. padmanabhan , _ mod.phys.letts._ , * a 25 * , 1129 - 1136 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0912.3165 ] ; + t. padmanabhan , _ phys.rev._ , * d 81 * , 124040 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1003.5665 ] . t. padmanabhan , phys.rev . , * d 83 * , 044048 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.0119 ] ; + sanved kolekar , t. padmanabhan , _ action principle for the fluid - gravity correspondence and emergent gravity , _ [ arxiv:1109.5353 ] s.w . hawking , d.n . page , comm . 87 , 577 ( 1983 ) . y. s. myung , phys . b 624 ( 2005 ) 297303 . s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov , phys . b 521 ( 2001 ) 8795 . a. chamblin , r. emparan , c. v. johnson , r. c. myers , phys . d , 60 , 064018 , ( 1999 ) . s. fernando , phys . rev . d 74 , 104032 ( 2006 ) . r. a. konoplya , a. zhidenko , phys . rev . d 78 , 104017 ( 2008 ) . y. s. myung , y.w . kim , y.j . park , phys . d 78 , 084002 ( 2008 ) . yun soo myung , phys . b 638 ( 2006 ) 515518 . y. s. myung , mod.phys.lett.a 23,667 - 676,2008 . b. m. n. carter , i. p. neupane , phys . d 72 , 043534 ( 2005 ) . r. g. cai , phys . d 65 , 084014 ( 2002 ) . r. g. cai , d. w. pang , a. wang , phys . rev . d 70 , 124034 ( 2004 ) . r.  banerjee , s.  k.  modak , s.  samanta , eur . j.   c 70 , 317 ( 2010 ) . r.  banerjee , s.  ghosh , d.  roychowdhury , phys.lett.b 696 , 156 ( 2011 ) . r. banerjee , s. k. modak and s. samanta , phys.rev.d 84 , 064024 ( 2011 ) . r. banerjee , s. k. modak and d. roychowdhury , arxiv:1106.3877 [ gr - qc ] . r. banerjee , d. roychowdhury , jhep 11 , 004 ( 2011 ) . a. lala , d. roychowdhury , arxiv:1111.5991 [ gr - qc ] . lousto , nucl . b 410 , 155 - 172 ( 1993 ) , gr - qc/9306014 . c.o . lousto , gen . 27 , 121 ( 1995 ) . r. g. cai , y.s . myung , nucl . b 495 , 339 - 362 ( 1997 ) . c.o . lousto , int.j.mod.phys . d 6 , 575 - 590 ( 1997 ) . c.o . lousto , phys . d 51 , 1733 ( 1995 ) , gr - qc/9405048 . k. maeda , m. natsuume , t. okamura , phys . d 78 , 106007 ( 2008 ) . s. jain , s. mukherji , s. mukhopadhyay , jhep 0911:051 ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0906.5134 [ hep - th ] . a. sahay , t. sarkar , g. sengupta , jhep 1007:082,(2010 ) , arxiv:1004.1625 [ hep - th ] . a. sahay , t. sarkar , g. sengupta , jhep 1011:125 , ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1009.2236 [ hep - th ] . y. liu , q. pan , b. wang , r. g. cai , phys . b 693 , 343350 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1007.2536 [ hep - th ] . s. carlip , s. vaidya , class . quantum grav . 20 , 3827 - 3837 ( 2003 ) , gr - qc/0306054 . x. n. wu , phys . d 62 , 124023 ( 2000 ) . r. banerjee , d. roychowdhury , phys . d 85 , 044040 ( 2012 ) . r. banerjee , d. roychowdhury , phys . d 85 , 104043 ( 2012 ) arxiv:1203.0118 [ gr - qc ] . d. birmingham , class . quantum grav . 16(1999 ) 1197 - 1205 . r. g. cai , a. wang , phys . rev . d 70 , 064013 , 2004 . r. g. cai , s. p. kim , b. wang , phys . d 76 , 024011 ( 2007 ) . r. g. cai , phys . b 582 , 237 ( 2004 ) . p. horava , phys . rev . d 79 , 084008 ( 2009 ) . p. horava , jhep 03 ( 2009 ) 020 . horava , phys . 102 , 161301 ( 2009 ) . m. visser , phys . rev.d 80 , 025011 ( 2009 ) . g.  calcagni , jhep * 0909 * , 112 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.0829 [ hep - th ] ] . + e.  kiritsis and g.  kofinas , nucl . b * 821 * , 467 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.1334 [ hep - th ] ] . + a.  wang and y.  wu , jcap * 0907 * , 012 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0905.4117 [ hep - th ] ] . h.  lu , j.  mei and c.  n.  pope , phys . lett .   * 103 * , 091301 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.1595 [ hep - th ] ] . r. g. cai , l. m. cao , n. ohta , phys . d 80 , 024003 , ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0904.3670 [ hep - th ] . j.  -z . tang and b.  chen , phys . d * 81 * , 043515 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0909.4127 [ hep - th ] ] . + e.  o colgain and h.  yavartanoo , jhep * 0908 * , 021 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.4357 [ hep - th ] ] . y. s. myung , phys . b 678 ( 2009 ) 127130 , arxiv:0905.0957 [ hep - th ] . + y.  s.  myung and y.  -w . kim , eur . j.  c * 68 * , 265 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0905.0179 [ hep - th ] ] . rong - gen cai , li - ming cao , nobuyoshi ohta , phys . b 679 ( 2009 ) 504509 , arxiv:0905.0751 [ hep - th ] . + b.  r.  majhi , phys .  lett . b * 686 * , 49 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.3239 [ hep - th ] ] . a. hankey , h. e. stanley , phys . b 6 , 3515 ( 1972 ) . h. e. stanley , introduction to phase transitions and critical phenomena , oxford university press , new york ( 1987 ) .
Abstract:

Answer: gravity can be thought as an emergent phenomenon and it has a nice `` thermodynamic '' structure . in this context , it is then possible to study the thermodynamics without knowing the details of the underlying microscopic degrees of freedom . here , based on the ordinary thermodynamics , we investigate the phase transition of the static , spherically symmetric charged black hole solution with arbitrary scalar curvature @xmath0 in hoava - lifshitz gravity at the lifshitz point @xmath1 . the analysis is done using the _ canonical ensemble _ frame work ; i.e. the charge is kept fixed . we find ( a ) for both @xmath2 and @xmath3 , there is no phase transition , ( b ) while @xmath4 case exhibits the second order phase transition within the _ physical region _ of the black hole . the critical point of second order phase transition is obtained by the divergence of the heat capacity at constant charge . near the critical point , we find the various critical exponents . it is also observed that they sati sfy the usual thermodynamic scaling laws .


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: essentially all low - redshift , powerful ( @xmath14 w  hz@xmath15  sr@xmath15 ) radio galaxies are housed in normal giant elliptical galaxies . thus radio selection has long been regarded as providing an efficient method of identifying high - redshift ellipticals . however , very radio - powerful high - redshift sources have proved virtually useless as probes of galaxy evolution due to the contaminating effects of the active galactic nucleus ( agn ) at ultraviolet  infrared wavelengths ( mccarthy et  al . 1987 ; tadhunter et  al . 1992 ; best , longair & rttgering 1996 , 1997 ) . given the success of the lyman - break technique for selecting high - redshift galaxies on the basis of their optical colours ( steidel et  al . 1996 , 1999 ) , it might be presumed that radio galaxies are no longer of any importance for probing galaxy evolution . in fact , nothing could be further from the truth , since the identification of high - redshift galaxies at optical wavelengths is by necessity biased towards the bluest , most ultraviolet - active systems  such methods can not detect old or dust - reddened sources . what is required is an _ optically unbiased _ selection method , such as radio selection at low flux densities . unlike their high - power counterparts , faint radio sources have only weak emission lines ( kron , koo & windhorst 1985 ) and show little evidence of an alignment effect ( dunlop & peacock 1993 ) .    there are a number of radio surveys with millijansky flux density limits at 1.4  ghz ( @xmath16  mjy ) . this limit is sufficiently _ faint _ that a large fraction of the sources potentially lie at high redshifts , and yet sufficiently _ bright _ that objects selected at this flux density are still predominantly radio galaxies rather than low - redshift starbursts ( hopkins et  al.2000 ) . some of the more recent surveys are the first survey ( becker , white & helfand 1995 ; white et  al . 1997 ) , the nvss ( condon et  al .  1998 ) , the vla survey of the elais regions ( ciliegi et  al . 1999 ) , and the atca survey of the marano field ( gruppioni et  al . 1997 ) . in order to study the evolution of the hosts of these radio sources , it is essential to identify optical / infrared counterparts to a majority of the radio sources . this has not yet been achieved for any of these recent surveys . this paper presents essentially complete optical identifications for a subsample of the leiden  berkeley deep survey ( lbds ; windhorst , van heerde & katgert 1984a ) , together with infrared @xmath5-band observations of 85% of the optically identified sources . a companion paper ( waddington et  al.2000a ; hereafter paper ii ) will present the results of the spectroscopic observations and photometric redshift estimates of these sources . the layout of the paper is as follows . in section 2 the radio observations and previous work using the lbds are reviewed , and the resolution corrections for the sources are recalculated . in section  3 the optical identifications and photometry of sources in the hercules sample are presented . the infrared observations are presented in section  4 . finally , section  5 is a discussion of the properties of the sample as a whole and of a number of the individual sources , and compares the @xmath5-band magnitude distribution to that of brighter radio surveys . unless otherwise stated , a cosmology with @xmath17  km s@xmath15 mpc@xmath15 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 is assumed . the lbds began with a collection of multi - colour prime focus plates that had been acquired with the 4-m mayall telescope at kitt peak for the purpose of faint galaxy and quasar photometry @xcite . several high latitude fields were chosen in the selected areas sa28 ( referred to as lynx ) , sa57 , sa68 and an area in hercules . the fields were selected on purely optical criteria , such as high galactic latitude ( @xmath20 ) and minimum h column density , resulting in a random area of sky from the radio perspective . nine of these fields were then surveyed with the 3-km westerbork synthesis radio telescope ( wsrt ) at 21  cm ( 1.412  ghz ) with a 125 beam @xcite . these observations yielded noise limited maps with @xmath210.28 mjy in 12  hours , with absolute uncertainties in position of order 04 and in flux of order 35% . a total of 471 sources were found , out of which a complete sample of 306 sources was selected . this complete sample is defined by : ( 1 ) a peak signal - to - noise @xmath22 , corresponding to @xmath231.0 mjy ; and ( 2 ) a limiting primary beam attenuation of @xmath24  db , which corresponds to a radius of 0464 , or an attenuation factor @xmath25 . with this attenuation radius , the wsrt field then covers the same area as the mayall 4-m plates . images were also made at the resolution of the 1.5-km wsrt ( @xmath26 mjy ; windhorst et  al . 1984a ) and at 50  cm ( 0.609  ghz ) with the 3-km wsrt ( @xmath27 mjy ; windhorst 1984 ) . the radio data for the two hercules fields are summarised in table  [ radiotable ] .    [ cols="<,>,>,>,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]     for five sources ( 53w010 , 53w019 , 53w020 , 53w022 , 53w027 ) , only @xmath3-band observations from the 1984 run were available so no colour correction could be applied to them . in addition , only two standard star observations were available for each of the two nights , which was inadequate to determine both the extinction and zero - points . thus , the mean extinction coefficient from table  [ kccoeffs ] was adopted , and the zero - point calculated from the observed magnitudes of the standards . for five other sources ( 53w080 , 53w081 , 53w085 , 53w086 , 53w090 ) , no photometric calibrations were available for the @xmath2 and @xmath3 images . the zero - points adopted for these mosaics were taken as the mean of the zero - points for all the other observations in the sample . this is reflected in the slightly larger errors for these sources in table  [ photmaster ] . the sky background subtraction for each source was done using a method based upon the image reduction package cassandra by d.  p.  schneider , adapted to run as an iraf task using the apphot package for the numerical work . a rectangular box ( typically 1020  on a side ) surrounding the source , and excluding any other objects , was cut out of the mosaic image . a plane was fitted to this box , excluding from the fit a circle centered on the source , and the sky was subtracted from the image . photometry was performed using a circular aperture of 40 , 75 or 100 diameter ( depending on the extent of the source ) , with the sky statistics determined over the remainder of the box . this enabled a large asymmetric sky aperture to be used , which is not possible with the basic apphot , in addition to providing a better measure of the sky background than is possible with an annulus around the object .    during testing of this method an error was found in the way that apphot calculates magnitude errors for faint objects . apphot makes the approximation @xmath28 which for faint sources overestimates the error by as much as 0.10.2 magnitudes . this was corrected by including the second , and for good measure the third , order terms in the expansion : @xmath29 . the apparent magnitude was then calculated from equation  [ mageqn1 ] using the coefficients in table  [ kccoeffs ] and the appropriate zero - points . the results are presented in table  [ photmaster ] . the errors quoted are the quadratic sum of the instrumental magnitude errors from apphot ( shot - noise in the object aperture , sky - noise ) , and the errors in the determination of @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 .    in order to compare those radio sources with photographic magnitudes , @xmath33 , to those sources with 4-shooter  gunn magnitudes , @xmath34 , it was necessary to convert one photometric system to another @xcite . windhorst et  al . ( 1991)derived transformations from the gunn system to the photographic system , and inverting these gives the required equations : @xmath35 for those sources without 4-shooter  observations , the optical magnitudes in table  [ photmaster ] are photographic magnitudes from kron et  al.(1985 ) transformed to the gunn system using these equations . an error of 0.3 magnitudes is assigned to each of these values , corresponding to the quadratic sum of the error in the transformations ( 0.1  mag ) and the error in the photographic magnitudes ( 0.20.3  mag ) . for the eighteen sources with both photographic and 4-shooter  gunn photometry , the transformed photographic magnitudes are compared with the 4-shooter  data in fig . [ gritranscomp ] . it can be seen that the transformations are in good agreement with the data for @xmath3623  mag ; fainter than this , the @xmath33 magnitudes are close to the detection limits of the photographic plates and are less reliable . infrared data are crucial to understanding high - redshift galaxies . beyond @xmath37 , optical observations sample the restframe ultraviolet emission of galaxies and the restframe optical emission has shifted into the near - infrared . thus in order to properly compare sources at high-@xmath38 with those at low-@xmath38 , the analysis must move to longer wavelengths . the @xmath5-band has long been recognized as a valuable window through which to investigate radio galaxies , and so we sought to obtain @xmath5 magnitudes for the complete hercules sample . approximately half the sample has been observed during three major observing runs at the 3.8-m uk infrared telescope , mauna kea , hawaii ( table  [ hercukirt ] ) . the first two runs ( 1992 & 1993 ) used the infrared camera ircam , a 62@xmath3958-pixel insb array with a scale of 0.62 arcsec pixel@xmath15 . all these observations were done in the @xmath5-band . the 1997 run used the upgraded camera ircam3 , which had 256@xmath39256 pixels with a scale of 0.286 arcsec pixel@xmath15 . deep @xmath5 images were obtained for sources which had not previously been detected , together with @xmath7-band observations of several galaxies for which @xmath7 was considered important for constraining the redshift . additional observations of some sources were made during associated projects and via the ukirt service observing programme . a standard jittering procedure was used to obtain a median - filtered sky flat - field simultaneously with the data . nine 3-minute exposures were made , each offset by 8  ( 1992 & 1993 ) or 15  ( 1997 ) from the first position , resulting in a central area around the radio source with a maximal exposure time of 27 minutes , surrounded by a border of low signal - to - noise data . this was repeated two or three times for the faintest sources . observations of faint standard stars were taken to calibrate the data . for all three ukirt runs , the image processing stage in the reduction was performed at the telescope by the observers . this consisted of the following steps : ( i ) a dark frame observed prior to the nine - exposure sequence was subtracted from each image ; ( ii ) a normalised flat - field was constructed by taking the median of the nine exposures ; ( iii ) each exposure was then divided by the flat - field ; ( iv ) an extinction correction was applied ; ( v ) the images were registered and finally combined into a mosaic after rejection of known bad pixels . the standard star observations were reduced in the same manner , and the instrumental magnitude ( corrected for extinction ) calculated . comparison with the known apparent magnitude then yielded a zero - point . standards were observed regularly and the zero - points were found to vary by @xmath40  mag throughout each photometric night . colour coefficients are small in the infrared and were not determined . photometry was performed on each of the mosaics using the same method as for the optical data (  3.5 ) , with the exception of the 1992 observations for which the sky background was determined from the mean of @xmath41 circular apertures placed randomly around the source . the results are presented in table  [ photmaster ] and fig . [ images ] . in addition to the 36 new observations described here , table  [ photmaster ] contains infrared data published by thuan et  al . ( 1984 ) for sixteen sources , unpublished data from g. neugebauer , p. katgert et  al . ( private communications ) for a further twenty sources , and data on five other galaxies referenced in the notes to the table . the results of the optical and infrared photometry are discussed in this section , and compared with both earlier results from the lbds and with results from other radio surveys . discussion of redshift - dependent properties will be presented in paper  ii , following analysis of the new spectroscopic data .      before investigating the photometric properties of the sample as a whole , the optical , infrared & radio observations of some individual sources are worth noting . 53w002  this @xmath42 radio galaxy has been the subject of much study ( see  2.1 ) . comparing the optical and infrared colours recorded in windhorst et  al . ( 1991 ) with those here , shows that they are fully consistent within the errors , although there is some discrepancy between the optical magnitudes . this may be explained by noting that windhorst  et  al . use `` total '' magnitudes which are brighter than the 4  aperture magnitudes in table  [ photmaster ]  indeed , application of the same method to these data produces consistent results . it is important to note that the _ colours _ of faint sources are not significantly affected by aperture size so long as the aperture is larger than the seeing disk , which it is in all cases here . 53w011 & 53w013  there was originally some concern that these two sources may have been confused with the grating rings in the wsrt observations , however both have optical counterparts and so are retained in the sample . 53w014  optical counterpart is at 3.1-@xmath43 from the radio position . a second object , 5  to the north - east , at 3.7-@xmath43 , may also be a possible identification . 53w022  new identification compared with windhorst et  al.(1984b ) . this object looks as if it could be physically associated with the brighter old identification in the @xmath3-band . at @xmath5 , the two objects are distinct and very similar in appearance . 53w032  a @xmath44 galaxy at the centroid of a double radio source . the 4-shooter  images reveal extended emission to the north - east , reminiscent of a tidal tail . note also that component a is coincident with an @xmath45  mag source , although component b does not have an optical counterpart . 53w035 & 53w089  these sources each appeared on two independent mosaics , enabling the repeatability of the photometry to be confirmed . 53w054a & 53w054b  originally classified as the lobes of a classical double radio source @xcite , they are now considered to be two distinct sources . both have solid identifications in the optical , and 53w054a is also identified in the infrared .    53w057  @xmath5 is a marginal ( 2-@xmath43 ) detection at the north - east end of the elongated source in @xmath2 . the brighter source at 6  to the west is also a possible identification , at 2-@xmath43 from the radio position . 53w058  the radio source is in the arm of a bright spiral galaxy at @xmath46 . the coordinates given in table  [ photmaster ] are for the centre of the galaxy ; the position of the radio emission is marked in fig . [ images ] . 53w067  the optical counterpart is 48 ( 8-@xmath43 ) from the radio position but has [ oii ] and ca h & k lines identified in the spectrum , at a redshift of 0.759 ( paper ii ) . the fainter source to the south - east , originally proposed as the identification ( at a separation of 1.2-@xmath43 ) , was identified as an m - type star from spectroscopy with the keck telescope ( spinrad , dey & stern , 1997 , private communication ) . 53w069 & 53w091  these two red sources at @xmath47 have been extensively studied with both the keck telescope and the _ hubble space telescope_. their rest - frame ultraviolet spectra are consistent with an evolved stellar population of ages 34  gyr @xcite , and their rest - frame optical morphologies are dominated by @xmath48 elliptical profiles @xcite . the apparent magnitude distribution is of cosmological interest because it is closely related to the radio source redshift distribution . broadly speaking , the fainter a source is ( in optical / infrared wavebands ) , the more distant it is expected to be . although complicated by evolutionary effects , in the absence of spectroscopic data the magnitude distribution has been an important tool in studying radio galaxies . the optical data are shown in fig . [ grinumbers ] and the infrared data in fig . [ irnumbers ] . in addition to the full hercules distributions , the 2-mjy sample is shown as hatched histograms . the first issue that is apparent from these figures is the greater depth of the new observations . the limiting magnitudes of the kron et  al.(1985 ) photographic data correspond to @xmath49  mag , @xmath50  mag and @xmath51  mag . the 4-shooter  data extend some 34 magnitudes fainter in all passbands . the infrared @xmath5-band data are similarly about four magnitudes deeper than the thuan et  al . ( 1984 ) results . the @xmath52 data are essential complete , approximately half the sources have @xmath7-band measurements and only one - third of the sample has been observed in @xmath6 . it is clear from figs . [ grinumbers ] &  [ irnumbers ] that the number of galaxies per magnitude interval does not continue to increase down to the magnitude limit , but rather turns over at @xmath53  mag . this immediately points to evolution of some form in the radio source population  if the radio sources formed an homogeneous class of object present throughout the history of the universe , the numbers would continue to increase towards the magnitude limit . this turnover was hinted at in the @xmath54 magnitude distribution of the whole lbds @xcite and is clearly confirmed for the hercules subsample here . excluding the 1  mjy  @xmath55  mjy sources does not significantly change the shape of the magnitude distributions , but it does _ increase _ the median magnitude  i.e.  the faintest radio sources are not in general the faintest sources at optical / infrared wavelengths . this would suggest that the faintest radio sources are lower ( radio ) luminosity objects at lower redshift , rather than radio - powerful objects at high redshift . some caution must be applied to this conclusion however , given that these sources are few in number ( 9 ) but have large weights ( @xmath562.5 ) .    in fig . [ multikband ] , the lbds @xmath5-band magnitude distribution is compared with the results of three other radio samples with near complete infrared data . the parkes selected regions ( psr ) data are principally taken from dunlop et  al . only sources in their four - region subsample , for which the @xmath5-band data are essentially complete , are used ( the 12@xmath57 and 13@xmath57 regions are poorly covered in the infrared ) . the 1-jansky sample of allington - smith ( 1982 ) is a complete sample of 59 radio sources with 1  jy  @xmath58  jy at 408  mhz . lilly , longair & allington - smith ( 1985 ) presented infrared observations of 53 of these sources , which are plotted in the third panel of fig . [ multikband ] . finally , a complete sample of 90 radio galaxies was selected from the 173-source 3cr catalogue of laing , riley & longair ( 1983 ) . nearly complete @xmath5-band data was obtained for this 3cr sub - sample @xcite , which excludes all quasars , and is shown in the last panel of the figure . for the first three samples , both galaxies and quasars are shown . the lbds panel also includes the 2-mjy sample for comparison .    as first pointed out by dunlop et  al . ( 1989 ) , the 1-jansky radio galaxies are biased towards larger @xmath5 magnitudes than the ( radio ) brighter 3cr galaxies . however , a similar shift is not seen between the 1-jansky and psr sources , a further factor of two fainter in flux . dropping another factor of @xmath59200 in flux , the lbds galaxies are seen here to have much the same distribution as the 1-jansky and psr galaxies . the median @xmath5 magnitudes for the four samples are 15.3 ( 3cr ) , 16.5 ( 1-jy ) , 16.5 ( psr ) and 16.8 ( lbds ) . to the extent that the @xmath5 magnitude of a powerful radio galaxy is a good estimator of its redshift , this result implies that although the 1-jansky galaxies are consistent with being high - redshift counterparts of the 3cr galaxies , these same sources are not seen at even higher redshifts in the fainter samples . ( note that a median spectral index of @xmath60 was used to bring the flux limits of the samples to a common frequency for this comparison . ) although the number of sources is small , the same effect is not seen in the quasar distributions . the median @xmath5 magnitude of quasars in the fainter three samples increases with decreasing flux limit : 16.1 ( 1-jy ) , 16.3 ( psr ) and 16.8 ( lbds ) . this may suggest that the quasar population is not changing as rapidly as the radio galaxy population . it must be noted , however , that the decrease in restframe optical / infrared flux between the 1-jansky and lbds quasars ( a factor of @xmath61 ) is certainly not comparable to the drop in radio flux ( a factor of @xmath62 )  i.e.  if the @xmath5 magnitude is a fair redshift estimator , the lbds quasars must be less luminous in the radio than the 1-jansky quasars . [ lbdscolmag ] presents colour  magnitude diagrams for the hercules sample . to compare these results with those of kron et  al.(1985 ) , note that the colours are related by @xmath63 and @xmath64 ( from equations  [ gritrans][gritrans1 ] ) . it can be seen that the colours of the new identifications are comparable to those of the photographic identifications at @xmath65  mag . there is some bias towards bluer @xmath66 ( and to a lesser extent , @xmath67 ) colours at the fainter magnitudes . in particular , there is a deficit of faint ( @xmath68  mag ) , red ( @xmath69 , @xmath70 ) radio sources compared with field galaxy surveys of comparable depth @xcite . this is consistent with a continuation of the faint blue radio galaxy population that kron et  al . ( 1985 ) found at brighter magnitudes . the sources classified as quasars ( q & q ? ) tend to have bluer optical colours on average than the galaxies , as one would expect from the dominance of the agn at ultraviolet / optical wavelengths in such sources . ( recall that the classification was based on morphology , not colour . ) the `` galaxy '' class includes objects of unknown identity ( ? ) , which dominate at the faintest magnitudes . figs . [ lbdscolmag](a ) , ( b ) & ( f ) suggest that the bluest of these objects may in fact be quasars . fig .  6 of dunlop et  al.(1989 ) shows that essentially all psr sources with @xmath71 and @xmath72 are quasars . comparing that figure with fig . [ lbdscolmag](f ) here , shows that the same can not be said for the lbds  only one of these faint blue objects is of uncertain classification ( 53w068 ) and one is a probable quasar ( 53w036 ) , while the other three are g ( 53w034 , 53w067 ) and g ? ( 53w027 ) . the lbds quasars have a much broader range of colours than those in the psr , perhaps a consequence of their weaker agn . [ lbdscolmag](c ) , ( d ) & ( e ) show the distribution of near - infrared colours with apparent magnitude . in considering these figures , it must be remembered how incomplete these data are ( only one - third of the sample has @xmath6-band data , only one - half has been observed in the @xmath7-band ) . there appears to be a linear correlation between @xmath73 colour and @xmath4 magnitude in fig . [ lbdscolmag](c ) , however this may simply be due to the absence of faint @xmath6-band photometry  at any given @xmath4 magnitude it is the reddest sources in the sample that would have been preferentially detected at @xmath6 . the dispersion of the @xmath74 colours ( 0.2  mag ) , defined as the standard deviation about the mean colour , is 23 times smaller than the dispersion in the optical colours . this is probably due to the incomplete infrared data , but may also be a genuine property of the sample . the smaller scatter may indicate that the infrared emission is dominated by stellar light from the host galaxies , rather than emission from the agn which tends to dominate at bluer wavelengths and can vary significantly from one source to another .    to summarize , the optical identification of the 72-source lbds hercules sample is essentially complete ( only three sources remain unidentified ) . approximately 85% of the sources have also been identified in the near - infrared @xmath5-band and a programme to obtain complete @xmath6- and @xmath7-band data is ongoing . paper  ii will present the results of work to measure redshifts for this sample from both direct spectroscopy and by using photometric estimation techniques . this is now the most comprehensive sample of radio - selected sources available at millijansky flux density levels , and is ideally suited to study the evolution of the 1.4  ghz radio luminosity function ( for agn ) out to very high redshifts  a topic to be addressed in forthcoming papers . we thank m. oort and s. anderson for contributing to the palomar observations ; t. keck for assisting with the processing of the 4-shooterdata ; and p. katgert , g. neugebauer , h. spinrad and d. stern for allowing us to include some unpublished data . the hale telescope at palomar observatory is owned and operated by the california institute of technology . the united kingdom infrared telescope is operated by the joint astronomy centre on behalf of the pparc . this work was supported by a pparc research studentship ( to iw ) ; and by nsf grants ast8821016 & ast9802963 and nasa grants go-2405.01 - 87a , go-5308.01 - 93a & go-5985.01 - 94a from stsci under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 ( to raw ) . waddington i. , 1998 , in dodorico s. , fontana a. , giallongo e. , eds , asp conference series 146 , the young universe : galaxy formation and evolution at intermediate and high redshift . astronomical society of the pacific , san francisco , p.  520
Abstract:

Answer: the results are presented of an extensive programme of optical and infrared imaging of radio sources in a complete subsample of the leiden  berkeley deep survey . the lbds hercules sample consists of 72 sources observed at 1.4  ghz , with flux densities @xmath0  mjy , in a 1.2 deg@xmath1 region of hercules . this sample is almost completely identified in the @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 bands , with some additional data available at @xmath6 and @xmath7 . the magnitude distributions peak at @xmath8  mag , @xmath9  mag and extend down to @xmath10  mag , @xmath11  mag . the @xmath5-band magnitude distributions for the radio galaxies and quasars are compared with those of other radio surveys . at @xmath12 jy , the @xmath5-band distribution does not change significantly with radio flux density . the sources span a broad range of colours , with several being extremely red ( @xmath13 ) . although small , this is the most optically complete sample of millijansky radio sources available at 1.4  ghz , and is ideally suited to study the evolution of the radio luminosity function out to high redshifts . # 1    * [ note : # 1 ] *    # 1    = = = = = = = =    # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = " 33e = = = = = = = =    # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = =    [ firstpage ]    galaxies : active  galaxies : photometry  quasars : general  radio continuum : galaxies


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: one possible classification of evolutionary games @xcite is to those that are governed by pairwise interactions and to those that are governed by group interactions . the prisoner s dilemma and the snowdrift game @xcite , as well as the stag - hunt game @xcite , are classical examples of evolutionary games that are governed by pairwise interactions . the public goods game , on the other hand , is a typical example of an evolutionary game that is governed by group interactions . similarly as by the transition from two - body to many - body interactions in many branches of physics , in evolutionary games too the transition from pairwise to group interactions leads to a substantial increase in complexity . for example , reciprocity @xcite , _ i.e. _ the act of returning favor for a favor , is straightforward in games governed by pairwise interactions . as there are only two players involved at each instance of the game , it is relatively easy to decide what to do based on what the opponent has done in the past @xcite . in games governed by group interactions , however , it is much more difficult to keep track of actions of all the other players , and hence it is difficult to reciprocate . the same argument is valid for punishment @xcite , where unlike returning positive actions , the goal is to identify those that inflict harm or act antisocial and sanction them accordingly . regardless of the distinction between pairwise and group interactions , the central theme of evolutionary game theory is the successful evolution of cooperation . according to darwin , natural selection favors the fittest and the most successful individuals , which implies an innate selfishness that greatly challenges the concept of cooperation @xcite . to cooperate namely means to sacrifice some fraction of personal benefits for the sake of social welfare . the opposite strategy is defection , implying that players who defect will always try to maximize their fitness regardless of the consequences this might have for the society . since the focus here is on games governed by group interactions , we may use the definition of the public goods game to illustrate the key difference between cooperation and defection as follows . in a group consisting of @xmath0 players , those that cooperate will contribute @xmath1 to the public good , while those that defect will contribute nothing . note that on a larger scale , the contribution of cooperators can be considered as a contribution to society , which will typically contain a large number of such groups . all the contributions will then be multiplied by a factor @xmath2 , which is typically larger than @xmath1 to take into account synergetic effects of collaborative efforts , and subsequently the resulting amount will be shared amongst all the group members irrespective of their initial contribution . from this definition it follows that defectors acquire an evolutionary advantage over cooperators by withholding the initial contribution to the public good , and from the viewpoint of each individual defection is thus clearly the rational strategy to choose . from the viewpoint of the group and the society as a whole , however , cooperation is the optimal strategy as then the multiplication factor @xmath2 will have the biggest impact and accordingly the welfare of the society will be maximized . the fact that defection maximizes individual payoffs while cooperation maximizes social prosperity , and thus that what is best for an individual is opposite to what is the best for society , is traditionally refereed to as a social dilemma . failure to maintain cooperation in such a case leads to the so - called `` tragedy of the commons '' @xcite , where nobody contributes to the public good ( everybody defects ) and the society is therefore destined to go bankrupt . rather surprisingly , and in fact contradictive to the darwinian concept of acting so as to maximize personal fitness , economic experiments on public goods games indicate that humans cooperate much more in such situations than expected @xcite , and in so doing these experiments call for the identification of mechanisms that can explain the successful evolution of cooperation .    introducing additional strategies besides cooperation and defection has proven to be very effective . for example , if players are given the chance to abstain from the public goods game by not contributing but also by not taking part in the distribution of accumulated payoffs , cooperation may be promoted by means of the spontaneous emergence of cyclic dominance between the three competing strategies @xcite . the introduction of peer - punishers , _ i.e. _ those that are willing to bare additional costs in order to sanction defectors , has also proven to be effective for the promotion of cooperation @xcite , as was the introduction of pool - punishers that contribute to the establishment of sanctioning institutions @xcite . rewarding cooperative players instead of punishing defectors has also been considered as an additional strategy that may promote cooperation @xcite , and the emerging `` stick versus carrot '' dilemma ( whether to sanction defectors or reward cooperators ) has recently received ample attention @xcite . interestingly , random explorations of these additional strategies , termed conveniently as  exploration dynamics " @xcite , may also substantially elevate the level of cooperation in a society .    driven by the application of methods from statistical physics ( see @xcite for a comprehensive review ) , as well as by the fascinating complexity arising from the evolutionary competition between the strategies , physicists have also made important contributions to the understanding of the successful evolution of cooperation . foremost , research published in recent years has made it clear that heterogeneities amongst players play a crucial role by the evolution of cooperation . scale - free networks , for example , have been recognized as very potent promoters of cooperative behavior @xcite . in fact , evolutionary games on complex and coevolving networks @xcite in general tend to promote cooperation past the boundaries imposed by regular lattices @xcite . similarly , heterogeneities in strategy adoption probabilities can also enhance cooperation @xcite , especially if the strategy adoption is favored from the more influential players @xcite . heterogeneities can also be introduced directly to payoffs in terms of noise @xcite or quenched diversity @xcite , whereby cooperators are promoted as well provided the uncertainties are adequately adjusted and distributed .    while the majority of previous works aimed at disentangling the impact of heterogeneity on the evolution of cooperation focused on games governed by pairwise interactions , recent results indicate @xcite that cooperation within the public goods game is also susceptible to the same mechanism of promotion . however , if payoffs are evaluated from public goods games in multiple groups , the indirect linkage of players due to their membership in the same groups may result in qualitatively different behavior @xcite as reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . this motivates us to examine to what extent strongly heterogeneous states do in fact promote the evolution of cooperation in games governed by group interactions . for this purpose , we study the evolution of cooperation in the public goods game on three types of regular graphs , namely on the square lattice , the triangular lattice , and the random regular graph ( rrg ) . these are characteristic for interaction graphs with ( square and triangular lattice ) and without ( rrg ) spatial structure , as well as for interaction graphs with zero ( square lattice and rrg ) and a high ( triangular lattice ) clustering coefficient , thus covering a broad plethora of properties that are known to vitally affect the evolution of cooperation @xcite . heterogeneity is then introduced by means of either a uniform or an exponential distribution of payoffs amongst the players , thereby violating the traditional assumption of equally distributed public goods amongst all group members . according to the statistical properties of the two considered distributions , exponentially distributed public goods give rise to strongly heterogeneous states , while uniformly distributed public goods correspond to moderate heterogeneities affecting the evolution of cooperation . unexpectedly , we find that moderate heterogeneities promote cooperation better than strongly heterogeneous states , which is not in agreement with results obtained previously for evolutionary games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite .    the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in the next section we describe the employed evolutionary public goods game and the interaction graphs , while in section 3 we present the results . lastly , we summarize our findings and compare them with those reported earlier for evolutionary games governed by pairwise interactions . assuming structured interactions defined by either the square lattice , the triangular lattice , or the random regular graph , as schematically depicted in figure  [ graphs ] , @xmath3 players are arranged into overlapping groups of size @xmath0 such that every player is surrounded by its @xmath4 neighbors . accordingly , each individual belongs to @xmath5 different groups . initially each player on site @xmath6 is designated either as a cooperator ( @xmath7 ) or defector ( @xmath8 ) with equal probability . cooperators contribute a fixed amount ( here considered being equal to @xmath1 without loss of generality ) to the public good while defectors contribute nothing . the sum of all contributions in each group is multiplied by the factor @xmath2 and the resulting public goods are distributed amongst all the group members . if @xmath7 the payoff of player @xmath6 from every group @xmath9 is @xmath10 and if @xmath8 the payoff is @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the number of cooperators in group @xmath9 while @xmath13 is the scaling factor by means of which the heterogeneity in the distribution of public goods is introduced . the scaling factors are drawn randomly from either the uniform distribution @xmath14 or the exponential distribution @xmath15 . here @xmath16 are uniformly distributed random numbers from the unit interval , and @xmath17 in all cases , so that the average @xmath18 over all the players is zero . moreover , @xmath19 scales the magnitude of heterogeneity and will , together with @xmath2 , be considered as the key parameter affecting the evolution of cooperation . naturally , @xmath20 returns the traditional version of the game , while large @xmath19 lead to segregation of players , which may be additionally amplified by considering exponential rather than uniformly distributed @xmath13 . it should be noted that heterogeneity is here not quantified explicitly ( _ e.g. _ by means of standard deviation of @xmath13 ) , but rather it refers to the diversity of players in the sense of to what extend they can differ from one another . since the exponential distribution segregates the players much more than the uniform distribution , the former is referred to as being substantially more heterogeneous ( see also @xcite for explicit shapes of the two distributions and alternative ways of interpretation ) . related to this setup , it is important to note that quenched heterogeneities introduced via @xmath13 may evoke the existence of the griffiths phase @xcite , which has recently attracted considerable attention @xcite , also in studies concerning the evolution of cooperation @xcite . the essence of the problem of quenched heterogeneities for the extinction processes has been well described in @xcite , where it was shown that such systems are frequently characterized by patches of different sizes , providing better conditions for one of the strategies ( or species ) to survive . due to the localization , the subordinate strategy can die out very slowly on the separated ( or weakly interacting ) patches , with an average lifetime increasing with the patch size . noest @xcite demonstrated that for suitable conditions ( determined by the distribution of patch sizes ) the extinction of the subordinate strategy follows a power law , whereby the exponent depends on the parameters . the latter fact can cause serious technical difficulties in the classification of the final stationary state , especially related to the @xmath21 transition in game theoretical models , as demonstrated for example in figure  3 of @xcite , where it can be inferred that even very long simulation times might not be enough to reach the final stationary state , although the trend ( power law behavior ) clearly indicates the disappearance of the subordinate strategy in the limit when the time goes to infinity . we note that often the introduction of an additional time - dependence in the background can make the analysis more convenient . for example , if the quenched heterogeneities are varied on an extremely slow time scale ( much slower than is characteristic for the main evolutionary process ) , the final conclusions remain the same , yet the occasional variations can accelerate the extinction significantly . this approach seems viable for alleviating difficulties that are frequently associated with models entailing quenched heterogeneities . monte carlo simulations are carried out comprising the following elementary steps . first , a randomly selected player @xmath6 plays the public goods game with its @xmath0 partners as a member of all the @xmath22 groups . the payoff it thereby acquires is thus @xmath23 . next , player @xmath6 chooses one of its nearest neighbors at random , and the chosen co - player @xmath24 also acquires its payoff @xmath25 in the same way as player @xmath6 . finally , player @xmath6 enforces its strategy @xmath26 onto player @xmath24 with the probability @xmath27\}$ ] , where @xmath28 quantifies the uncertainty by strategy adoptions and @xmath0 normalizes the effect for different interaction graphs ( see @xcite for details concerning the selection of the @xmath29 value and the applied normalization ) . these three elementary steps [ 1  random selection of player @xmath6 and the determination of @xmath30 , 2  random selection of neighbor @xmath24 and the determination of @xmath25 , 3  attempted strategy transfer with probability @xmath31 are repeated consecutively , whereby each full monte carlo step ( mcs ) gives a chance for every player to enforce its strategy onto one of the neighbors once on average and is comprised of @xmath3 three elementary steps described above . the average fractions of cooperators ( @xmath32 ) and defectors ( @xmath33 ) in the population were determined in the stationary state after sufficiently long relaxation times . depending on the actual conditions ( proximity to extinction points and the typical size of emerging spatial patterns ) the linear system size was varied from @xmath34 to @xmath35 and the relaxation time was varied from @xmath36 to @xmath37 mcs to ensure proper accuracy . we start by presenting results obtained on the square lattice with @xmath38 ( depicted schematically in figure  [ graphs ] left ) in figure  [ sqr ] . the left panel features the full @xmath39 phase diagram for uniformly distributed public goods . focusing on the @xmath40 transition line ( depicted red ) , marking the survivability threshold of cooperators , we find that increasing values of @xmath19 continuously decrease the minimally required multiplication factor @xmath2 . from @xmath41 at @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( note that such weekly expressed heterogeneity actually returns the traditional version of the game where the public goods are distritbuted equally @xcite ) , the minimally required multiplication factor decreases to @xmath44 at @xmath45 , and further to @xmath46 at @xmath47 . importantly , note that such contradictory critical values of @xmath2 that are smaller than @xmath1 are possible only when individual @xmath13 can exceed @xmath0 , _ i.e. _ when some individuals can effectively collect shares of the public good also from players that are not within the same group . for the uniformly distributed public goods it is straightforward to determine that this happens when @xmath48 , which is also approximately where the critical multiplication factor @xmath2 dips below @xmath1 . for such high @xmath19 , however , the public goods game is essentially overridden and the stationary state is always @xmath49 , irrespective of @xmath2 ( within the mixed @xmath50 phase ) . the pure @xmath51 phase , _ i.e. _ @xmath52 , on the other hand , emerges only for intermediate values of @xmath19 , as depicted by the green line marking the @xmath21 transition .    by comparing the results depicted in the left panel of figure  [ sqr ] with those depicted in the right panel , we can observe that exponentially distributed public goods ( right ) on the square lattice fail to promote cooperation to the same extent as uniformly distributed public goods ( left ) . while the position of the @xmath40 transition line remains largely unaffected , the mixed @xmath50 phase is characterized by substantially lower values of @xmath53 ( brighter shades of blue prevail ) . moreover , the pure @xmath51 region is substantially smaller , and the override of the public goods game , where @xmath49 irrespective of @xmath2 ( within the mixed @xmath50 phase ) sets in already for @xmath54 ( see left panel of figure  [ sqr ] ) . these observations indicate that strongly heterogeneous states ( constituted by exponentially distributed public goods ) may be less effective in warranting high levels of cooperation at low multiplication factors than moderately heterogeneous states ( constituted by uniformly distributed public goods ) . irrespective of the type of heterogeneity , however , the survivability of cooperators can be greatly enhanced , _ i.e. _ the minimally required @xmath2 for @xmath32 to be larger than zero greatly reduced . figure  [ tri ] features the results of the same analysis as depicted in figure  [ sqr ] , only that instead of the square lattice the triangular lattice was used as the interaction graph . the use of the triangular lattice is motivated by its high clustering coefficient ( note that the square lattice has the clustering coefficient equal to zero ) , which is a property that has been found crucial for the evolution of cooperation , especially by games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . in particular , while interaction graphs with zero or negligible clustering coefficients are characterized by an optimal level of uncertainty at which cooperators can survive , as was reported in @xcite , interaction graphs with overlapping triangles ( which are inherent to the triangular lattice , as can be observed from figure  [ graphs ] ) preclude such an observation , _ i.e. _ the @xmath40 phase boundary is monotonically descending towards lower @xmath2 in the @xmath55 limit . remarkably , recent results for games governed by group interactions indicate that there the interaction graph may play a less crucial role , since in fact joint memberships in the same groups effectively link players that are otherwise not directly connected @xcite . by comparing the results presented in figures  [ sqr ] and [ tri ] for the same type of heterogeneity in @xmath13 , this is indeed fully confirmed as all the main features are identical . altogether , these results solidify the impression that strongly heterogeneous states in the public goods game can be less effective in warranting high levels of cooperation than moderately heterogeneous states .    as the last type of interaction graph we consider the random regular graph ( rrg ) , which unlike the square lattice and the triangular lattice , lacks spatial structure . note that locally the random regular graph is similar to the bethe tree ( see figure  [ graphs ] right ) . since the seminal paper by nowak and may @xcite clearly established spatial structure as an important agonist for the successful evolution of cooperation , it is certainly appropriate to test our results also against this variation moreover , due to the lack of spatial structure , there is an expected difference in the directed percolation universality class @xcite if compared to the square lattice . results presented in figure  [ rrg ] depict full @xmath39 phase diagrams for uniformly ( left ) and exponentially ( right ) distributed public goods . compared to results obtained for the square lattice ( see figure  [ sqr ] ) , on the rrg too the position of the @xmath40 transition line remains largely unaffected by the type of distribution of @xmath13 . moreover , the mixed @xmath50 phase for exponentially distributed public goods ( right panel of figure  [ rrg ] ) is characterized by substantially lower values of @xmath53 ( brighter shades of blue prevail ) and the pure @xmath51 region is altogether missing . it is thus from results obtained for the rrg that in fact the failure of strongly heterogeneous states to reach the same levels of cooperation promotion as moderately heterogeneous states is most obvious . at the same time , as already noted above for the square as well as the triangular lattice , the position of the @xmath40 transition line does not shift due to the difference in the distribution of @xmath13 , which highlights that in games governed by group interactions the details of the interaction graph play a less prominent role than this is the case for games governed by pairwise interactions . with ample support from these final observations , we conclude that the strongly heterogeneous distribution is a less potent promoter of cooperative behavior in the public goods game . we have studied the evolution of cooperation on three different types of regular graphs in the public goods game with uniformly and exponentially distributed payoffs , with the aim of determining to what extent do strongly heterogeneous states promote cooperative behavior . the presented results have important implications for the evolution of cooperation in games governed by group interactions . while past research has undoubtedly shown that strongly heterogeneous states facilitate the evolution of cooperation in games governed by pairwise interactions ( for reviews see @xcite ) , results presented in this paper question this in relation to moderate heterogeneities for games governed by group interactions . in fact , here we find that uniformly distributed public goods are more successful in maintaining high levels of cooperation than exponentially distributed public goods , which is different to what was reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite . this conclusion prevails irrespective of the type of the interaction graph , and is in agrement with previous observations @xcite in that qualitative differences between the outcomes of games governed by pairwise interactions and games governed by group interaction should be expected due to the indirect linkage of players that are members of the same groups . a direct consequence of this indirect linkage is also the fact that differences in the clustering coefficient play a minor role by the promotion of cooperation , which is different from what was reported previously for games governed by pairwise interactions @xcite , where a high clustering coefficient was found to be tightly linked to flourishing cooperative states . accordingly , in our case one could expect the triangular lattice to promote cooperation much better than the square lattice or the random regular graph , yet the difference is quite marginal . moreover , it is also important to note that the random regular graph is fundamentally different from the square and the triangular lattice in that it has no local structure . the indirect linkage of players due to group interactions , however , renders these differences in structural properties of the interaction networks virtually irrelevant . altogether , results presented in this paper point clearly towards the fact that the transition from pairwise to group interactions has important implications for the successful evolution of cooperation . we hope that this work will inspire future studies aimed at clarifying the role of heterogeneity for other types of games and further promote quantitative research in social systems with methods from physics @xcite . we thank eberhard bodenschatz for valuable comments towards the presentation of our work , as well as attila szolnoki and gyrgy szab for illuminating discussions and helpful advice . this research was supported by the slovenian research agency ( grants z1 - 2032 and j1 - 4055 ) . 10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 sigmund k 1993 _ games of life : exploration in ecology , evolution and behavior _ ( oxford , uk : oxford university press )
Abstract:

Answer: previous research has highlighted the importance of strong heterogeneity for the successful evolution of cooperation in games governed by pairwise interactions . here we determine to what extent this is true for games governed by group interactions . we therefore study the evolution of cooperation in the public goods game on the square lattice , the triangular lattice and the random regular graph , whereby the payoffs are distributed either uniformly or exponentially amongst the players by assigning to them individual scaling factors that determine the share of the public good they will receive . we find that uniformly distributed public goods are more successful in maintaining high levels of cooperation than exponentially distributed public goods . this is not in agreement with previous results on games governed by pairwise interactions , indicating that group interactions may be less susceptible to the promotion of cooperation by means of strong heterogeneity as originally assumed , and that the role of strongly heterogeneous states should be reexamined for other types of games .