Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: over the past few years , the increasingly stronger exclusion limits set by the large hadron collider ( lhc ) on colored top partners have put significant pressure on the classic solutions to the hierarchy problem . the absence of beyond - the - standard model ( bsm ) signals has , at the same time , sparked a renewed interest in models of neutral naturalness , where the top partners do not carry standard model ( sm ) color charge . the prime example in this class is the twin higgs ( th ) model @xcite , where the top and gauge partners are complete singlets under the sm , and the sensitivity to ultraviolet ( uv ) scales is softened thanks to a discrete @xmath2 symmetry .    by construction , the collider phenomenology of the lowest - lying states in th is very challenging , and rare decays of the higgs into long - lived twin particles typically constitute the most promising signatures @xcite . however , these signals display a strong sensitivity to the unknown parameters of the model that limits to some extent their robustness . for example , in the fraternal th model @xcite , where only the third generation of twin particles is introduced to avoid the cosmological problems associated with light degrees of freedom , the lightest twin glueball can be long - lived . it decays into sm particles through mixing with the higgs , with a width proportional to @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the confinement scale of twin qcd . as a consequence , the twin glueball displaced decays are observable at the lhc only in a relatively narrow range of twin confinement scales , while naturalness considerations allow a wider uncertainty on @xmath7 . on the other hand , a robust deviation from the sm is provided by higgs couplings modifications proportional to @xmath8 that arise due to the pseudo - goldstone nature of the higgs , where @xmath9 is the scale of spontaneous @xmath2 breaking and @xmath10 is the electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) higgs vacuum expectation value ( vev ) . still , the future lhc precision on higgs couplings measurements will be limited to @xmath11-@xmath12 @xcite . altogether , these considerations suggest that it is not inconceivable that the lhc may remain blind to a th model with @xmath13 tev . the low - energy theory of th , however , requires uv completion at a relatively low scale @xmath14 tev . the extended theory necessarily contains new particles , some of which can give visible signals at colliders . while more model - dependent , these signatures may turn out to be key to the discovery of the model . for example , non - supersymmetric uv completions generically predict the existence of new exotic fermions , charged under both the sm and twin gauge symmetries . these vector - like fermions were already introduced in the original th paper @xcite , to cut off the residual logarithmic divergences in the higgs potential . furthermore , they appear in composite th completions @xcite , where they are resonances of the strong sector , and in uv completions with extra dimensions @xcite , where they are kaluza - klein ( kk ) excitations of bulk fields whose zero modes are removed through boundary conditions or orbifold projections . some of these fermions carry sm color ( as well as twin electroweak ) charge and can therefore be produced with large rates at the lhc or at a future @xmath15 tev collider , depending on their masses . the phenomenology of these ` exotic quarks ' was presented in ref . @xcite , where it was shown that future searches for their signals can test large regions of the parameter space of the fraternal th .    in this paper we explore the phenomenology of other states that can be expected to accompany the exotic quarks ( which were labeled by @xmath16 in ref . @xcite ) , in a non - supersymmetric uv completion of th . we focus primarily on the mirror partners of the exotic quarks , which are vector - like ` exotic fermions ' that carry twin color and sm electroweak charges ( labeled by @xmath17 in ref . in addition we consider exotic vector particles , including both bifundamentals under @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 denote the sm and twin weak groups , respectively , and bifundamentals under the color symmetries @xmath21 . the electroweak bifundamentals , which we label @xmath22 , are necessary to restore at high energy the @xmath23 ( or @xmath24 ) symmetry that protects the pseudo - goldstone higgs . on the other hand , the @xmath25 bifundamentals , dubbed @xmath26 , appear in models where the sm and twin color groups are embedded into an @xmath27 symmetry . this is not strictly required for a consistent uv completion , so the presence of @xmath26 is somewhat more model - dependent .    as discussed in ref . @xcite , stop searches based on @xmath28 plus missing transverse energy ( met ) constitute a robust probe of the exotic quarks . given the absence of any signals in the first @xmath29 fb@xmath30 of data collected by each of atlas and cms at @xmath31 tev , we estimate that the current lower bound on the vector - like mass of the @xmath16 is approximately @xmath32 tev . if the masses of the exotic fermions respect the @xmath2 symmetry , as we assume in the first part of this paper , the same lower bound applies to @xmath33 , the mass of the @xmath17 . as a consequence the uncolored exotic fermions have a very suppressed electroweak pair - production , even at a @xmath15 tev collider . on the other hand , if the colored exotic vector @xmath26 is heavier than the exotic fermions , its decays can provide a sizable production rate for the @xmath17 . we sketch the corresponding phenomenology , finding that it is qualitatively similar to that of the exotic quarks : the most promising signature is @xmath34 , accompanied either by large missing transverse energy ( met ) or by the displaced decay of a twin particle @xcite . we find that the best strategy to pin down the presence of the @xmath26 and @xmath17 would be to require an additional @xmath5 boson in the final state , since this is generated very rarely in the decays of the exotic quarks . we also outline the phenomenology of the electroweak bifundamental vectors , showing that some of them can mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and therefore be singly produced in the drell - yan process . on the other hand , we find that the @xmath35 parameter of electroweak precision tests ( ewpt ) requires their masses to be at least @xmath36 tev , implying that they are likely out of the lhc reach , but may be discovered at a @xmath15 tev collider . notice that from a phenomenological perspective , @xmath37 is independent from @xmath33 . furthermore , @xmath38 breaks the @xmath2 only softly , thus preserving the cancellation of @xmath39-loop quadratic divergences in the higgs mass . since @xmath40 only couples to the sm through the electroweak interactions , the experimental constraints still allow it to be relatively light . it is therefore logical to analyze the region of parameter space where @xmath41 , to which the second part of this paper is devoted . we find that for @xmath33 in the few hundred gev range , one of the exotic fermions , @xmath42 , naturally has a very suppressed decay width . this implies that once produced through the electroweak interactions , @xmath43 pairs form bound states held together by the twin strong force , which eventually annihilate back to the sm . we study in detail the associated resonance signals , which provide a novel phenomenological aspect of th models . in addition , we consider the significant effects that a relatively light color bifundamental vector may have on the bound state decays . a light @xmath26 is expected to be accompanied by a light excited gluon ( for which we will use the name ` kk gluon ' in analogy to an extra - dimensional model ) in realistic models , so for completeness , we also summarize the main constraints on the kk gluon . finally , we inspect closely the consequences on naturalness of the @xmath2-breaking exotic fermion masses . while the @xmath39-loop effects are mild , we identify a @xmath44-loop quadratically divergent contribution to the higgs mass that can be important for light @xmath26 . the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ exoparticles ] we introduce the exotic states that are the subject of this paper . for concreteness we do this in the context of a two - site model , which provides a convenient minimal description , but many of our results are general , and also apply to more elaborate constructions . section  [ z2preserve_pheno ] presents the phenomenology of the scenario where the exotic fermion masses respect the @xmath2 symmetry . in [ subs pheno:1 ] we compute the pair - production cross section of the color bifundamental vector , and estimate the main signals arising from cascade decays that involve the @xmath17 . the salient properties of the weak bifundamental vectors are discussed in [ subs pheno:2 ] . section  [ z2break ] contains the discussion of the @xmath2-breaking scenario , which gives the main novel results of our paper . the phenomenology of @xmath45 bound states is studied in  [ subs z2break:1 ] , whereas [ subs z2break:2 ] focuses on the bound states containing the @xmath46 partner of @xmath42 , whose signals are more model - dependent . in [ subs z2break:3 ] we discuss the effects of a light @xmath26 on the bound state physics , and in [ subs z2break:4 ] we summarize the main properties of the kk gluon , which is expected to have a mass comparable to that of @xmath26 . to conclude the section , the consequences on naturalness of the @xmath2 breaking in the exotic fermion masses are presented in [ subs z2break:5 ] . finally , our conclusions are drawn in sec . [ conclusions ] . for the sake of completeness , the detailed construction of a two - site model for the electroweak sector is given in app . [ su4exo ] . appendix  [ so8exo ] contains some details about the additional states that appear if the global symmetry of the th is extended from @xmath23 to @xmath24 , which ensures custodial protection of the @xmath47 parameter . the phenomenologies of the new exotic states are qualitatively similar to the ones already considered . the simplest way to introduce the exotic fermions is to follow the approach of the original th paper @xcite , where the symmetries of the top yukawa were extended to @xmath48 . adopting the notation of ref . @xcite , where in particular the sm @xmath46 is embedded in the lower right corner of @xmath23 , we have @xmath49 where @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 . the color and twin color gauge groups are embedded in the diagonal of @xmath27 . the ` exotic ' fermion doublets @xmath53 and @xmath54 are given vector - like masses , @xmath55 if the masses in eq . respect the @xmath2 symmetry , then @xmath56 cuts off the logarithmic divergences in the higgs potential arising from eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) ,  ( [ eq : mass ] ) , leaving a finite and calculable result . in this paper we also consider the @xmath2-breaking scenario @xmath38 , in which case the residual logarithmic divergences need to be cut off by additional states with larger , @xmath2-symmetric masses . the phenomenology of the states belonging to @xmath57 , which carry sm color and twin electroweak charges , was extensively discussed in ref . @xcite . inserting in eq . the expression of the higgs field in the unitary gauge , @xmath58 leads to the mass mixing of the up - type component @xmath59 with the top quark , and the corresponding heavy mass eigenstate was labeled @xmath60 . the down - type component does not mix , and was labeled @xmath61 . these exotic quarks are pair - produced through qcd and decay into sm tops plus twin gauge bosons @xmath62 ( henceforth we denote the twin partners of the sm particles with a hat ) , followed by the decay of the twin gauge bosons into twin fermions . thus the ` irreducible ' signal of the exotic quarks is @xmath28+met , where the twin particles escape detection . in addition , depending on the parameters in the twin sector , some of the twin particles produced in the cascade can decay back to the sm with long lifetimes , giving rise to @xmath28+displaced vertex signatures . for example , the decay @xmath63 is followed by twin hadronization , and some of the resulting twin bottomonia or twin glueballs can have macroscopic lifetimes . the twin leptons that arise from the decay of @xmath64 can also give displaced signals , through mixing with the sm neutrinos . the reach of the searches for these exotic signatures extends above @xmath44 tev at the lhc and above @xmath1 tev at a future @xmath15 tev collider , often surpassing that of the searches for stop - like signals based on large met @xcite . notice that the mass mixing between @xmath59 and the top quark implies the theoretical lower bound @xcite @xmath65 in addition , we estimate that stop searches currently set an experimental lower bound @xmath66 in this paper we focus instead on the fermions contained in @xmath17 , which carry twin color and sm electroweak charges and whose phenomenology was so far unexplored .    in a uv completion , it is also plausible that new vector particles exist , that allow for the restoration of the full @xmath67 $ ] symmetry at high energies . for @xmath27 , the new states include ` exotic vectors ' which transform as the bifundamental representation of @xmath21 , denoted by @xmath68 in this work , as well as the excited state of the gluon ( labeled @xmath69 ) and that of the twin gluon . for @xmath23 , among the new vectors we expect exotics which transform as the bifundamental of @xmath70 , denoted by @xmath71 , in addition to excitations of the sm and twin gauge bosons . all these particles can be described , for example , in a two - site model . on one site , there is a full @xmath72 gauge symmetry . all the fields in eq . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) live on this site , so the yukawa interaction respects the symmetry . on the second site , only @xmath73 is gauged . all the light sm and twin fermions , as well as the right - handed exotic fermions @xmath74 , live on this second site . the gauge symmetries on the two sites are broken down to the diagonal subgroup by the vevs of link fields , which also generate the mass terms for the exotic fermions in eq .  . for a strongly coupled uv completion , the first site can be viewed as the hidden local symmetry from the strong dynamics  @xcite . its gauge coupling , which we denote @xmath75 for @xmath27 and @xmath76 for @xmath23 , is expected to be very large and the particles living on that site are composite degrees of freedom of the strong dynamics . the second site represents the elementary gauge fields and fermions . the two - site model can also be viewed as a deconstruction  @xcite of an extra dimensional model  @xcite . the details of the two - site model for @xmath23 are given in app . [ su4exo ] . .quantum numbers of the exotic fields under the sm and twin gauge symmetries . ( @xmath77 is the twin hypercharge . ) the fields in the upper part of the table are dirac fermions , while those in the lower part are complex vectors . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in this section we outline the phenomenology of the exotic off - diagonal states , with the exception of the exotic quarks @xmath78 , which were thoroughly studied in ref . the quantum numbers of the particles are collected in table  [ tab : charges ] . in this section we assume that the masses of the exotic fermions respect the @xmath2 symmetry . in addition to the mixing of @xmath59 with the sm top quark , the lagrangian in eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) ,  ( [ eq : mass ] ) yields a mixing of the top - component exotic fermion @xmath79 with the twin top , @xmath80 where @xmath81 . the mixing is diagonalized by the rotations @xmath82 where @xmath83 and @xmath84 are mass eigenstates . for the remainder of this section we assume @xmath85 , so @xmath86 . the mixing angles are given by @xmath87 while the masses read , at first order in @xmath88 , @xmath89 on the other hand , @xmath90 does not mix with any other state . the decays of the @xmath91 can be understood using the goldstone equivalence theorem . plugging the expression of @xmath92 expanded to @xmath93 @xcite into the top yukawa , we find , for @xmath94 , @xmath95 + \mathrm{h.c.},\ ] ] where @xmath96 and @xmath97 are the would - be goldstone bosons eaten by the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , @xmath98 is the physical higgs boson , and @xmath99 corresponds to the longitudinal component of the twin @xmath100 . .   shows that the largest decay widths of @xmath84 are those into @xmath101 , with a small component of @xmath102 parametrically suppressed by @xmath8 . the couplings mediating the additional decays @xmath103 and @xmath104 , which are @xmath105 , can not be neglected . notice , however , that since @xmath106 , the latter is actually a @xmath107-body decay . ] the @xmath42 , on the other hand , decays to @xmath108 with unity branching ratio .    the theoretical and experimental constraints in eqs .  ,   require @xmath32 tev ( we take @xmath109 tev as benchmark in this paper ) . for a @xmath2-symmetric spectrum this constraint also applies to @xmath33 , implying that the pair production of the @xmath110 via the electroweak interactions is suppressed even at a future @xmath15 tev collider . however , if @xmath111 the decays of the exotic vector @xmath26 can provide a much larger production rate for the uncolored exotic fermions . the @xmath26 is a bifundamental of @xmath21 , therefore it can be pair - produced in the process @xmath112 . the couplings of @xmath26 to the gluons arise from the kinetic lagrangian @xmath113 where the covariant derivative is defined as @xmath114 . here @xmath115 , @xmath116 are the generators in the fundamental of @xmath117 , and twin color indices and interactions are understood but suppressed . notice that the coefficient of the last term in eq .   would be arbitrary , if we were only imposing the low - energy @xmath117 gauge symmetry . we have set this coefficient to the value that corresponds to @xmath26 gauging part of the ( spontaneously broken ) extended @xmath27 gauge symmetry in the uv , as in the two - site model . using the couplings derived from eq . , the cross section for pair production of @xmath26 can be readily computed @xmath118 , \label{gg to xx}\ ] ] where @xmath119 and an extra factor of @xmath120 was included , due to the twin color sum . by convoluting with the @xmath121 parton luminosity , we obtain the hadronic cross section shown in fig . [ fig : rrxsec ] . colliders for the exotic vector @xmath26 and kk gluon @xmath122 . in addition , for comparison we show the cross section for a dirac fermion @xmath47 in the fundamental representation of color . all cross sections were computed at lo with factorization and renormalization scales set to @xmath123 , using mstw08lo parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) . the ratio @xmath124 varies between 3.0 and 3.7 for the masses and energies considered . notice that @xmath125 contains the factor @xmath120 resulting from the sum over twin color . the different scaling of @xmath126 with the mass is due to the @xmath127-initiated component.,width=302 ]    the @xmath128 also couples , with strength @xmath75 , to the fermions transforming in the fundamental of @xmath27 , namely @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 . for example , @xmath132 notice that the exotic vector carries sm electric charge @xmath133 , and twin electric charge @xmath134 . the right - handed bottom quarks @xmath135 and exotic fermions @xmath74 , as well as the fermions of the first two generations , live instead on the @xmath136 site and therefore do not couple directly to the exotic vector . .   dictates the decay of the @xmath26 : the main channels are @xmath137 , shown in the top panel of fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2sym ] . in addition , fermion mixings generate a small width for @xmath138 .    if @xmath139 , the qcd pair production of @xmath26 followed by the decays @xmath140 provides the largest production mechanism for the @xmath110 . a sketch of the corresponding spectrum is given in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2sym ] . on the other hand , if @xmath141 the only kinematically allowed decay of the exotic vector is @xmath142 . under the minimal assumption that the @xmath64 and twin bottom escape undetected , most decay patterns of @xmath143 lead to the @xmath34+met final state , resulting in a ` stop - like ' signal . therefore it would be difficult to distinguish the @xmath26 signal from those of the exotic quarks @xmath60 and @xmath61 , which mostly produce @xmath28+met final states . in addition , it would be challenging to tell the very existence of the exotic fermions @xmath110 . for this purpose the most promising channel seems to be @xmath144 followed by @xmath145 . these decays yield an extra @xmath5 or @xmath98 , resulting in signals with extra jets ( @xmath146-tagged or not ) and/or leptons . among these the @xmath147+jets+met signature is particularly interesting , because it can arise from the exotic quarks only through the suppressed @xmath148 decay @xcite . exotic vector @xmath26 . the superscripts indicate the ( sm ,  twin ) electric charges . _ bottom panel : _ sketch of the colored spectrum in the @xmath2-preserving case @xmath149 , under the assumption that @xmath150 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath155.,width=453 ]     exotic vector @xmath26 . the superscripts indicate the ( sm ,  twin ) electric charges . _ bottom panel : _ sketch of the colored spectrum in the @xmath2-preserving case @xmath149 , under the assumption that @xmath150 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath155.,width=377 ]      the off - diagonal vectors contained in @xmath23 form a bidoublet of @xmath18 , which under the sm electroweak symmetry decomposes into two @xmath156 , @xmath157 and @xmath158 . these particles can be described in a two - site model , where the gauge symmetry on the ` strong ' site is @xmath159 , and on the ` elementary ' site it is @xmath160 ^ 2 $ ] . the symmetries are broken to the diagonal subgroup by the vev of a bifundamental link field @xmath161 , @xmath162 , whereas the higgs @xmath92 in eq . transforms in the fundamental representation of the strong gauge symmetry . this leads to the following masses for the @xmath23 exotic vectors ( see app . [ su4exo ] for details ) @xmath163 where @xmath76 is the gauge coupling on the strong site , and the small corrections due to ewsb were neglected . an experimental lower bound on the masses of the @xmath22 comes from the @xmath35 parameter of ewpt , for which the two - site structure leads to the result @xmath164 requiring @xmath165 implies , choosing for example our benchmark @xmath109 tev and @xmath166 , a lower bound @xmath167 gev , or @xmath168 tev and @xmath169 tev . these can be taken as rough reference for the phenomenology . notice that @xmath23 does not contain the custodial symmetry that protects the @xmath47 parameter , which therefore would receive large corrections at tree level . these in turn would push the scale of the vector resonances much higher : for example , in the limit @xmath170 we find @xmath171 , so requiring that @xmath172 leads to @xmath173 tev . however , this issue can be solved by extending the uv symmetry to @xmath174 @xcite , which guarantees that @xmath175 at tree level . in this case additional states are present both in the gauge and in the fermion sector , to fill multiplets of the larger symmetry . while the new states include some exotic ones , their phenomenology is not expected to be qualitatively different from that discussed here , as explained in app . [ so8exo ] . the real component of @xmath176 , which we dub @xmath177 , and @xmath178 have the right quantum numbers to mix with the sm @xmath5 and @xmath4 , respectively , and therefore can be singly produced at hadron colliders in @xmath179 annihilation . their decays are mediated by the couplings of the @xmath22 to fermions , which arise from the kinetic term of @xmath180 under the @xmath48 symmetry on the strong site . then @xmath181 \quad \to \quad \frac{g_\rho}{\sqrt{2}}(\bar{q}_{3l}^a \slashed{\mathcal{w}}^\dagger \tilde{q}_{3l}^a + \bar{q}_{3l}^b \slashed{\mathcal{w } } \tilde{q}_{3l}^b ) + \mathrm{h.c.}.\ ] ] expanding in components , retaining only couplings of @xmath176 and @xmath178 and rotating to the basis of mass eigenstate fermions , we arrive at @xmath182 + \mathrm{h.c.},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the sine and cosine , respectively , of the mixing angle between the top and the exotic quark @xmath60 @xcite . depending on the relative hierarchy between the masses of the exotic particles , we can envisage two situations :    * for @xmath185 , the dominant decays are @xmath186 and @xmath187 . it follows that single production of @xmath176 leads to the @xmath188+met and @xmath189+met final states , whereas single production of @xmath178 leads to @xmath190+met and @xmath191+met ; * for @xmath192 only the direct decays into light states are open , @xmath193 and @xmath194 . the main decays are summarized in fig . [ fig : su4decay ] .    . the superscripts indicate the ( sm ,  twin ) electric charges . ] the lower bound @xmath195 tev from the @xmath35 parameter suggests that these exotic vectors are likely out of the lhc reach , but may be discovered at a future @xmath15 tev collider . on the other hand , the states contained in @xmath196 carry a non - vanishing twin electric charge , therefore their mixing with the sm gauge bosons is proportional to the breaking of the twin @xmath197 , which is more model - dependent . if this breaking is negligible or absent , @xmath196 can only be pair - produced through the electroweak interactions , with very suppressed cross section . notice that in ref . @xcite the limit @xmath198 was considered , corresponds to @xmath9 in the notation of sec . 2.1 of ref . @xcite . ] in which case @xmath199 decouples and only @xmath200 remains in the low - energy spectrum .    before concluding this section , we wish to comment on the assumption we have made so far , that the twin particles produced in the cascade decays of the exotic vectors do not give any signals in the lhc detectors , effectively contributing to the missing energy . in the fraternal th scenario , in each event a @xmath201 pair is produced , held together by a string of the twin strong force this bound state hadronizes either via string fragmentation , leading to production of twin bottomonia , or via twin gluon emission , leading to production of twin glueballs . depending on the values of @xmath202 and @xmath7 , the resulting twin hadrons can travel a macroscopic distance before decaying within the detector , giving rise to displaced signatures . the twin leptons can also be produced through the decays of @xmath64 , and have long - lived decays trough mixing with the sm neutrinos . in these cases , the searches for long - lived particles in association with sm objects provide a sensitivity complementary to ( and possibly stronger than ) that of searches based on large missing energy , as thoroughly studied for the exotic quarks in ref . @xcite .      in this section we consider a region of parameters where the vector - like masses of the exotic fermions softly break the @xmath2 symmetry , @xmath41 . for small @xmath33 the mass matrix in eq . is diagonalized by @xmath203 here @xmath84 and @xmath83 are mass eigenstates with @xmath204 , where we have assumed @xmath205 . for example , for @xmath206 gev we find @xmath207 gev , @xmath208 gev and @xmath209 gev , with mixing angles @xmath210 and @xmath211 . a sketch of the spectrum is given in fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2break ] .    since @xmath212 , the dominant decay of @xmath42 is into the three - body final state @xmath213 . the partial width can be obtained by adapting the results for the decay of a chargino into a neutralino and a pair of sm fermions in a supersymmetric standard model  @xcite . summing over all @xmath214 pairs , we find    -breaking case @xmath215 . for definiteness we took @xmath216 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath217 . , width=377 ]    @xmath218    where we neglected the small corrections due to the mixing angles , setting @xmath219 . we find that for the parameter region @xmath220 gev which we are interested in , @xmath221 is always satisfied . as a consequence , when a @xmath43 pair is produced at the lhc via the electroweak interactions , it forms a bound state held together by the twin color force . furthermore , as will be discussed in detail momentarily , the annihilation of the @xmath222 bound states is much faster than the decay of the individual @xmath42 s , leading to resonance signals . on the other hand , @xmath84 decays into @xmath223 , where the twin @xmath64 can be on - shell or off - shell . the corresponding width , being suppressed by @xmath224 , satisfies @xmath225 across all parameter space , implying the formation of additional bound states containing @xmath84 . however , if the @xmath223 final state is on - shell , which occurs in a significant portion of parameter space , tev we have @xmath226 gev . ] the decay of the individual @xmath84 s is faster than the annihilation of @xmath227 and @xmath228 bound states . thus we will first concentrate on the signals from @xmath45 bound states , which appear to be more generic , and comment later about the observability of the @xmath229 and @xmath228 bound states , which requires the @xmath84 to have a @xmath107-body decay , _ i.e. _ @xmath230 . the @xmath231-wave @xmath45 bound states are a pseudoscalar and a vector , which we label @xmath232 and @xmath233 , respectively , following the sm bottomonium conventions . at hadron colliders , the @xmath233 is produced in @xmath127 annihilation via @xmath231-channel @xmath234 , see the first diagram of fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] . the cross section is proportional to the width for the decay @xmath235 , to the photon and @xmath5 are defined as @xmath236 and @xmath237 , respectively . ] @xmath238,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath239 is the wavefunction at the origin . we will return momentarily to the evaluation of this quantity . the cross section for drell - yan ( dy ) production is then @xmath240 where @xmath241 $ ] is the @xmath127 parton luminosity . the parton luminosities are computed using the mstw08nlo @xcite pdfs evaluated at @xmath242 .    . in the middle diagram the @xmath4 s are longitudinally polarized , and the amplitude is dominated by exchange of a virtual twin top.,width=491 ]    since @xmath243-@xmath244 gev , to evaluate @xmath239 we apply the standard coulomb approximation , where the effects of confinement are neglected . then for the ground state ( see for example ref . @xcite for a general discussion ) @xmath245 where @xmath246 is the quadratic casimir of the fundamental representation of @xmath25 , and @xmath247 is the running twin qcd coupling evaluated at @xmath248 , the inverse of the average distance between the two constituents , related to the bohr radius @xmath249 $ ] by @xmath250 . using eq . we compute the @xmath233 production cross section at the lhc : for example , for @xmath206 gev , @xmath251 at @xmath31 tev varies between @xmath252 and @xmath253 fb for @xmath254 $ ] gev . what are the main decays of @xmath233 ? as a consequence of twin color conservation , in the perturbative approximation the leading contribution to the twin hadronic width comes from @xmath255 . thus , as for the sm @xmath256 and @xmath257 , the strong decays are suppressed , leading to large branching fractions for the decays into fermion - antifermion pairs , mediated by the weak interactions : the @xmath233 decays into sm quarks about @xmath258 of the time , see fig . [ fig : upsilonbr ] . , whose width scales as @xmath259 , where @xmath260 , leading to a very suppressed branching ratio @xmath261 , not shown in fig . [ fig : upsilonbr ] . ]     as a function of @xmath262 . the twin confinement scale is set to @xmath263 gev . solid ( dashed ) curves denote decays into final states containing at least one detectable sm particle ( only twin particles or sm neutrinos).,width=302 ]    experimentally , the most promising decay is into sm dileptons , which provides a very clean final state and benefits from a sizable branching ratio @xmath264 , with mild dependence on @xmath33 . the signal cross section is shown in solid blue in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] , as a function of @xmath265 , for three representative choices of the twin confinement scale : @xmath263 gev is the approximately @xmath2-symmetric value , while for @xmath266 gev the lightest twin glueball decays far out of the detector , and finally for @xmath267 gev the lightest twin glueball decays promptly @xcite . in the last two cases the displaced decay signatures @xcite of the twin glueballs are washed out . then the exotic fermion signals , such as @xmath268 , play an even more important role in probing the th model at colliders . we compare the signal cross section to the current atlas exclusion @xcite , based on @xmath269 fb@xmath30 at @xmath31 tev , reported as a solid orange curve . interestingly , a non - trivial constraint , @xmath270 gev , can already be extracted for larger @xmath267 gev . in the same figure we also show the projected constraint after @xmath271 and @xmath272 fb@xmath30 , obtained by rescaling the current cross section bound @xmath273 , with @xmath274 the integrated luminosity . the amplitude for the decay of @xmath233 into two transverse gauge bosons is velocity - suppressed , and therefore negligible . thus the only sizable decay width of the spin-@xmath39 bound state into two gauge bosons is @xmath275 ( depicted in the middle diagram of fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] ) , mediated by the coupling of @xmath42 to the longitudinal @xmath4 , which originates from the top yukawa @xmath276 where @xmath277 was defined in eq .  . the total width of the @xmath233 is of @xmath278-@xmath244 mev , which on the one hand is much smaller than the lhc experimental resolution , and on the other hand satisfies @xmath279 across all parameter space considered here , guaranteeing that the bound state annihilation occurs before the individual constituents can decay . production at the @xmath31 tev lhc , multiplied by the branching ratio into one family of sm leptons , as a function of @xmath280 . three different choices of the twin confinement scale @xmath7 are considered . the dashed blue lines include also the contribution of @xmath281 , which is expected only for @xmath282 ; see text for details . in orange , the current constraints from the atlas dilepton resonance search ( solid ) , as well as the projections to the end of run 2 ( dashed ) and to the high - luminosity lhc ( dotted ) . _ right panel : _ similar to the left panel , but for @xmath283 . the @xmath284 annihilation signal is expected only if @xmath230 . in the gray - shaded region , this condition requires @xmath285 gev , which leads to a tuning worse than @xmath286 in the higgs mass for a cutoff of @xmath287 tev . , title="fig:",width=302 ]   production at the @xmath31 tev lhc , multiplied by the branching ratio into one family of sm leptons , as a function of @xmath280 . three different choices of the twin confinement scale @xmath7 are considered . the dashed blue lines include also the contribution of @xmath281 , which is expected only for @xmath282 ; see text for details . in orange , the current constraints from the atlas dilepton resonance search ( solid ) , as well as the projections to the end of run 2 ( dashed ) and to the high - luminosity lhc ( dotted ) . _ right panel : _ similar to the left panel , but for @xmath283 . the @xmath284 annihilation signal is expected only if @xmath230 . in the gray - shaded region , this condition requires @xmath285 gev , which leads to a tuning worse than @xmath286 in the higgs mass for a cutoff of @xmath287 tev . , title="fig:",width=302 ]    the pseudoscalar @xmath232 is produced in photon fusion , with cross section @xmath288 where @xmath289 is the width for @xmath290 , and @xmath291 is the @xmath292 luminosity @xcite . numerically , the production of @xmath232 is roughly two orders of magnitude smaller than that of @xmath233 : for the benchmark @xmath206 gev , @xmath293 varies from @xmath294 to @xmath295 fb for @xmath296 $ ] gev . in addition , the @xmath232 width is dominated by decays into twin hadrons . in the perturbative approximation , these can be parameterized by the @xmath297 process , which has a branching ratio of @xmath298-@xmath299 across the parameter space . this suppresses the branching ratios into sm final states , among which @xmath292 and @xmath300 would be most promising experimentally , to the few percent level . thus detection of the @xmath232 appears challenging even with high luminosity . the total width of @xmath232 is a factor @xmath301-@xmath302 larger than @xmath303 due to the unsuppressed decay into twin hadrons . we conclude this subsection with a comment on the validity of the coulomb approximation for the bound states , which applies if @xmath304 where @xmath305 is the bohr radius , defined below eq .  . in the entire parameter space shown in fig .  [ fig : upsilondileptons ] we have @xmath306 , confirming the applicability of the coulomb treatment . for even larger @xmath7 the effects of confinement become important , and the approximation will not be valid . next , we turn to the possible observation of bound states containing @xmath84 , in particular the spin-1 @xmath227 state , labeled by @xmath307 , and the electrically charged @xmath228 vector , @xmath308 . if @xmath84 decays into on - shell @xmath223 , its lifetime is in the range @xmath309 . since ( barring @xmath310 factors ) @xmath311-@xmath244 mev , this implies that the constituent @xmath84 s likely decay before the bound states they form can annihilate . conversely , for @xmath230 we find @xmath312 mev , which guarantees signals from @xmath307 and @xmath284 . in the remainder of this subsection we discuss the corresponding phenomenology . the @xmath284 is produced in the charged dy channel , and decays primarily into sm fermion pairs . subleading decays are into @xmath313 and into @xmath314 , where @xmath315 is a neutral electroweak gauge boson . the @xmath316 widths arise from the interaction in eq . , after @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing . the mixing also implies that the mass of @xmath284 is expected to be slightly smaller than that of @xmath233 , since @xmath318 . the most promising signal is @xmath319 , whose cross section at the @xmath31 tev lhc is shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] , together with the constraint from the current atlas @xmath320 resonance search @xcite and its projections to the end of run 2 and to the hl - lhc . for the sake of simplicity , in this figure the @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing was neglected , leading to the simplifications @xmath321 and @xmath322 . on the other hand , if the decay @xmath323 is fast , the electroweak production of a @xmath324 pair is followed by the formation of a @xmath325 bound state instead . provided its angular momentum is not too large , this bound state could annihilate on a time scale shorter than the @xmath42 lifetime . electric charge conservation forces the annihilation channel to be @xmath326 , thus giving rise to the @xmath4+met signature . the @xmath307 phenomenology is qualitatively similar to that of the @xmath233 . one important quantitative difference is that the mass of @xmath307 is @xmath327 smaller , which increases from @xmath328 at @xmath329 gev to @xmath330 at @xmath331 gev for @xmath332  tev . for comparison , the experimental resolution at dilepton invariant mass of @xmath39 tev is @xmath333 in the @xmath334 channel and @xmath335 in the @xmath336 channel @xcite , suggesting that the two - peak structure formed by the @xmath233 and @xmath307 would likely be resolved in the dielectron channel , while a single broader peak would be observed in dimuons . for simplicity , here we ignore the @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing that generates the small mass splitting between the resonances , and simply show in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] ( dashed blue ) the sum of the @xmath233 and @xmath307 dilepton signals as a function of @xmath337 . the @xmath307 contributes about half compared to the @xmath233 , due to a smaller branching ratio into dileptons . a comparison of the two panels of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] shows that for @xmath230 , the reach in the @xmath338 and @xmath339 final states is similar . we conclude with a comment on the pseudoscalar states @xmath340 and @xmath341 , whose production cross sections at the lhc are tiny . in fact , since @xmath84 has zero electric charge , @xmath340 is not produced in photon fusion , while the production of @xmath342 in @xmath343 fusion is very suppressed by the small @xmath4 pdf . so far we have neglected the effects of the @xmath27 off - diagonal vector @xmath26 on the physics of the bound states composed of exotic fermions . however , since the coupling @xmath75 is expected to be naturally rather large , a relatively light @xmath26 can have significant effects on the bound state phenomenology , which will be discussed here .    through the coupling in eq .  , the @xmath344-channel exchange of the exotic vector mediates the decay of @xmath233 into @xmath345 , which is depicted in the last diagram in fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] . the width is @xmath346 where the interference with the @xmath231-channel @xmath234 exchange was neglected . thus for sufficiently light @xmath26 the @xmath233 acquires a large branching fraction into @xmath345 , which in particular dilutes the dilepton rate . at the same time , the exotic vector also mediates @xmath233 production in @xmath345 annihilation , with cross section given by a formula similar to eq .  . the total effect on the dilepton signal is shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] , where @xmath347 gev was assumed . gev the condition in eq . is not satisfied , hence the bound states can not be described within the coulomb approximation . in this case we replace eq .   with the ansatz @xmath348 , which is motivated by the physical picture of a string with linear potential , and holds to reasonable accuracy for the lowest - lying sm bottomonia . for example , from the measured value of the electronic width of the @xmath257 @xcite one extracts @xmath349 , where the number in parentheses was obtained using our ansatz with @xmath350 mev . ] @xmath351 signal from the @xmath233 , for twin confinement scale @xmath347 gev . the dashed and dotted blue curves show the cross section in presence of a light exotic vector . the orange curves show the current and projected experimental constraints , similarly to fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons].,title="fig:",width=302 ]    @xmath351 signal from the @xmath233 , for twin confinement scale @xmath347 gev . the dashed and dotted blue curves show the cross section in presence of a light exotic vector . the orange curves show the current and projected experimental constraints , similarly to fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons].,title="fig:",width=302 ]    for this larger confinement scale , which is at the upper edge of the plausible range in the fraternal th @xcite , the increased @xmath233 production cross section implies that masses @xmath352 gev are ruled out already at the time of writing , and the hl - lhc will be able to probe up to @xmath353 tev . however , as shown by fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] , an exotic vector with mass @xmath354 and coupling @xmath355-@xmath356 can suppress the dilepton rate significantly . this is accompanied by a large increase of the @xmath357 signal , shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] together with the current @xcite and projected experimental constraint .- tagging efficiency and kinematic acceptance : @xmath358 and @xmath359 for @xmath360 tev , @xmath361 for @xmath362 tev , valid in the range @xmath363 $ ] tev . we thank a.  coccaro for useful clarifications about ref .  @xcite . ] interestingly , even for a very light and strongly coupled @xmath26 the @xmath233 resonance in the @xmath345 final state would remain hidden after the hl - lhc . notice also that , since @xmath26 only couples to the left - handed @xmath17 , the exotic vector exchange does not mediate the decay of the pseudoscalar @xmath232 into bottom quarks . a relatively light @xmath26 also provides , through its decays , an additional mechanism for production of exotic fermion bound states . in particular , the process @xmath364 , where the @xmath143 production is via qcd ( see eq .  ) , is followed by formation of a twin qcd string between the @xmath42 and @xmath365 . based on a simple counting of degrees of freedom , we can estimate that the resulting bound state will be a @xmath233 with probability @xmath366 , or a @xmath232 with probability @xmath367 . then the dominant final state is expected to be @xmath368 , stemming from @xmath369 . notice that the total width of the exotic vector is @xmath370 ( where we have assumed that @xmath37 is too large for @xmath26 to decay into the exotic quarks @xmath16 ) , which for @xmath371 implies a broad resonance . although phenomenologically interesting , a light @xmath26 is however potentially problematic for two reasons . first , it should be accompanied by a light kk gluon , which is subject to strong experimental constraints . second , the @xmath2 breaking @xmath38 leads to a @xmath44-loop quadratically divergent correction to the higgs mass that is negligible for large @xmath372 , but can become important if the exotic vector is light , thus increasing the fine - tuning . these aspects are discussed in the next two subsections .      in the minimal version of the two - site model , from the kinetic term of the link field @xmath373 , link field by @xmath373 , to distinguish it from the @xmath23 one that we labeled @xmath161 . ] @xmath374 $ ] , one finds that the mass of kk gluon @xmath122 is related to the mass of @xmath26 by @xmath375 , where @xmath376 . because @xmath377 , this would give @xmath122 a mass similar to , but slightly higher than @xmath378 . however , this relation can be violated by higher dimensional operators . for example , @xmath379 with a spurion @xmath380 inserted on the @xmath136 site makes @xmath381 twice as big as @xmath382 ( if one ignores @xmath383 ) . in summary , @xmath384 is expected to be of the same order as @xmath378 , although with some freedom . since the kk gluon , being a sm color octet , has a very large production cross section at hadron colliders ( see fig . [ fig : rrxsec ] ) , it is then important to take it into account in the discussion of a light @xmath27 exotic vector . the partonic cross section for @xmath385 , which mediates kk gluon pair production , can be found for example in ref . @xcite , and has a structure similar to eq .  . the couplings of @xmath122 to fermions read approximately @xmath386 whereas the coupling to the @xmath387 is strongly suppressed by @xmath388 . therefore the kk gluon decays into @xmath28 and @xmath345 with approximate branching ratios @xmath389 and @xmath390 , respectively . since the total width is @xmath391 , the kk gluon , like the @xmath26 , is expected to be a broad resonance . the leading constraint on @xmath122 pair production comes from the @xmath392 final state , where the @xmath393 fb upper limit on the four tops cross section @xcite translates into @xmath394 tev . fb limit is for the case of a @xmath392 contact interaction , which we believe to be the best available approximation , because @xmath122 is a broad resonance . ] however , the kk gluon can also be singly produced in @xmath345 annihilation , with cross section @xmath395 the large coupling @xmath75 can compensate the suppressed @xmath345 pdf , leading to competitive constraints from searches for @xmath28 resonances . from the cms analysis in ref . @xcite we obtain @xmath396 tev for @xmath397 , see fig .  [ fig : kkgluontt ] . annihilation , multiplied by the branching ratio into @xmath28 , for two representative values of @xmath398 . the mstw08lo pdfs were used , evaluated at @xmath399 . in red , the cms bound from the first @xmath31 tev data.,width=302 ]    the couplings of @xmath122 to the third - generation sm fermions , eq . , could also lead to constraints from flavor observables . we focus on the down - quark sector , which gives the strongest bounds . integrating out @xmath122 and applying fierz transformations , we obtain the effective lagrangian @xmath400 we observe that since the coupling of @xmath122 to the @xmath387 is very suppressed , only ll operators are generated with relevant size , whereas experimentally , the strongest bounds are on the coefficients of lr operators . applying to the down - type quarks the rotation that diagonalizes the mass matrix and selecting the @xmath401 operator that contributes to kaon mixing , we find ( see for example ref . @xcite ) @xmath402 where @xmath403 are elements of the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa matrix , and we assumed the coefficient of the operator to be real . defining the coefficient of @xmath404 as @xmath405 , the experimental bound reads @xcite @xmath406 . this can be translated into @xmath407 tev , which is weaker than the lhc constraints for a typical coupling @xmath408-@xmath356 . notice , however , that if the operator in eq .   were generated with an unsuppressed phase , the bound on the imaginary ( @xmath409-violating ) part would read @xmath410 @xcite , leading to @xmath411 tev . thus , to envisage a kk gluon lighter than @xmath412 tev we need to postulate that its couplings respect @xmath409 invariance @xcite . since the @xmath2 symmetry is crucial in protecting the higgs potential from large radiative corrections , a @xmath2-breaking spectrum for the exotic fermions necessarily has implications on naturalness . the contribution to the potential from the top sector of eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) ,  ( [ eq : mass ] ) is finite for @xmath413 @xcite , but if this relation is violated then the logarithmic divergences do not cancel exactly , leading to an additional contribution @xmath414}{\left(\tilde{m}_a^2 - y_t^2 f^2\right ) \left(\tilde{m}_b^2 -   y_t^2 f^2\right ) } + o(h^4),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath415 is the cutoff . unless the splitting between @xmath37 and @xmath33 is very large , this extra term is of moderate size and does not require significantly more tuning . notice also that in the region of parameters studied here , @xmath416 , the sign of the extra mass term is negative and thus does not help to achieve @xmath417 , which is needed for a realistic model . an additional , small source of @xmath2 breaking is therefore still required . in passing we note that in the opposite regime @xmath418 , the @xmath2 breaking from the exotic fermion masses may be sufficient for realistic ewsb . closer inspection reveals that the @xmath2-breaking @xmath38 also gives rise to a @xmath44-loop quadratic divergence in the higgs mass . this can be understood by noticing that due to the couplings in eq . , the wavefunction of @xmath419 is renormalized by a loop of @xmath26 and @xmath420 , @xmath421 , whereas the wavefunction of @xmath422 is renormalized by a loop of @xmath26 and @xmath423 , with renormalization constant @xmath424 . for @xmath38 we have @xmath425 , leading to a @xmath44-loop quadratic contribution to the physical higgs mass , @xmath426 for light @xmath26 , this correction is important and an increased fine - tuning is required to obtain @xmath427 gev : for example , taking @xmath428 tev , @xmath429 , @xmath430 and a cutoff @xmath431 tev , we find a tuning of @xmath432 ( we take @xmath433 at scale @xmath415 ) . , since in this limit the result is most transparent . in our actual parameter space we have @xmath434 , but eq .   still provides a reasonably accurate estimate of the fine - tuning . ] this shows that large effects of the exotic vector on the physics of the exotic fermion bound states , such as those illustrated by fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] in [ subs z2break:3 ] , would be associated with a stronger fine - tuning . it is important to stress , however , that the bound state signals discussed in [ subs z2break:1 ] and [ subs z2break:2 ] do not need to carry a naturalness price tag , because the @xmath26 may simply be heavy , strongly suppressing the correction in eq .  . an independent @xmath44-loop tuning arises if the twin confinement scale @xmath7 differs from the @xmath2-symmetric value @xmath435 gev @xcite . this requires a splitting of the standard and twin qcd couplings at high scale , @xmath436 . the associated @xmath44-loop contribution to the higgs mass can be roughly estimated as @xcite @xmath437 for reference , if twin qcd is not gauged ( @xmath438 ) this estimate gives @xmath439 tuning , where we used @xmath440 at high scale . in this paper we studied the collider phenomenology of the exotic states which appear in the non - supersymmetric uv completions of the th model . these exotic states carry charges under both the sm and twin gauge groups , so they constitute a window to the twin sector . they may also provide the first experimental hint of the th , given that the low energy effective theory is quite elusive and may even escape future lhc detection for some range of underlying parameters . the exotic quarks @xmath16 that carry the sm color and twin electroweak charges were the subject of a previous study  @xcite . here we extended the analysis to several other states , including the exotic fermions @xmath17 , which are charged under the sm electroweak and twin color groups , as well as the exotic vectors @xmath22 and @xmath26 , which transform in the bifundamental of @xmath18 and @xmath21 , respectively . as in ref . @xcite , due to naturalness considerations the low energy theory was assumed to be approximately described by the fraternal th model . the collider phenomenology of the exotic fermions @xmath17 crucially depends on their masses . if the vector - like masses of the @xmath16 , @xmath37 , and of the @xmath17 , @xmath33 , are linked by the @xmath2 symmetry , then theoretical and experimental constraints on the exotic quarks require @xmath441 tev . in this case the exotic fermions have very suppressed electroweak pair production , but they can still be produced with significant rate in the decays of @xmath26 . we found that the ensuing signals are qualitatively similar to those of the exotic quarks , consisting primarily in @xmath28+met . a potential handle to pin down the @xmath17 is to require an additional @xmath5 boson , which is rarely produced in the decays of the @xmath16 . however , since the direct experimental constraints on the masses of the @xmath17 are rather weak , because they only carry sm electroweak charges , it is interesting to consider the case where @xmath442 tev . this soft @xmath2 breaking does not generate 1-loop quadratic divergences for the higgs mass , and hence does not introduce significant fine - tuning . the second part of the paper is therefore devoted to the study of this scenario . we found that in this case , at least one of the exotic fermions has a very suppressed decay width . as a consequence , its pair production through the drell - yan process is followed by the formation of twin qcd bound states , which then annihilate primarily into sm particles . the associated resonance signals , typical of hidden valley models @xcite , provide a novel aspect in the phenomenology of the th . we also discussed the significant effects that a relatively light @xmath27 exotic vector can have on the bound state phenomenology . notice that while in this paper we focused on the decays of the bound states into sm particles , which are dominant , mixed sm / twin decays may provide rare but striking signatures if some of the twin particles are long - lived . for example , the charged bound state @xmath284 can decay into @xmath443 . if the hadronization of the twin gluons produces the lightest twin glueball , the latter can travel a macroscopic distance and decay through mixing with the higgs , leading to the @xmath444+@xmath445 displaced vertex ) signature . we also sketched the phenomenology of the @xmath23 exotic vectors . some of them have the right quantum numbers to mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and can therefore be singly produced in hadron collisions . we found that their contribution to the @xmath35 parameter of ewpt likely puts them out of the lhc reach , but they could discovered at a future @xmath15 tev collider . to avoid the large @xmath47 parameter constraint that would further push up their masses , the @xmath23 group may be extended to an @xmath24 , which contains the custodial symmetry to protect the @xmath47 parameter . in this case there will be more exotic states , both in the vector and the fermion sectors . however , as shown in app . [ so8exo ] , their phenomenologies are not qualitatively different and hence are well covered in this study .    * acknowledgments * we thank y.  bai , a.  coccaro , r.  harnik , g.  marques tavares , t.  tait and j.  zupan for useful discussions . this work was performed in part at the aspen center for physics , which is supported by national science foundation grant phy-1066293 . hc and es were supported in part by the us department of energy grant de - sc-000999 . yt was supported in part by the national science foundation under grant phy-1315155 , and by the maryland center for fundamental physics . we describe here a two - site model where the gauge symmetry is @xmath159 on the first ( ` strong ' ) site , and @xmath160 ^ 2 \subset su(4)'\times u(1)_x'$ ] on the second ( ` elementary ' ) site . the gauge symmetries are broken to the diagonal subgroup by the vev @xmath162 of a link field @xmath161 that transforms as @xmath446 , where @xmath447 and @xmath448 . the covariant derivative for @xmath161 is then @xmath449 the strong gauge fields are defined as @xmath450 where the @xmath451 matrix @xmath22 was defined in table  [ tab : charges ] together with the quantum numbers of its components , and @xmath452 . setting @xmath453 and @xmath454 , eq . can be rewritten as @xmath455 where @xmath456 . it is immediate to see that the sm and twin hypercharges are identified with @xmath457 and @xmath458 ( for fields neutral under @xmath27 ) , matching the normalization of ref . the elementary gauge bosons read instead @xmath459 the kinetic term of @xmath161 is @xmath460/4 $ ] , which setting @xmath161 to its vev yields @xmath461 + ( a \to b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the @xmath22 acquire a mass @xmath462 , while the mixing between strong and elementary states is diagonalized by , for example for the charged ` @xmath19 ' states : @xmath463 which leaves the @xmath464 massless , while @xmath465 . similar rotations diagonalize the mixing of the neutral ` @xmath19 ' and all the ` @xmath20 ' fields . we also need to take into account the symmetry breaking due to the vev of @xmath92 , which lives in the strong site and also has @xmath466 . its covariant derivative is @xmath467 , with @xmath468 defined in eq .  . in the vacuum of eq .  , the kinetic term @xmath469 gives @xmath470 + \tfrac{1}{2 } s_h^2 [ ( \tilde{w}_a^3 - \tilde{b}_a)^2 + 2 \tilde{w}_a^+ \tilde{w}_a^- ] \nonumber \\ + & \ , s_h c_h [ ( \tilde{w}_b^3 - \tilde{b}_b)\mathcal{w}_{1r}^0 + \tilde{w}^+_b \mathcal{w}_2 ^ 0 + \mathrm{h.c . } ] \nonumber \\ + & \ , s_h c_h [ ( \tilde{w}_a^3 - \tilde{b}_a)\mathcal{w}_{1r}^0 + \tilde{w}^-_a \mathcal{w}_1^+ + \mathrm{h.c.}]\ , \big\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath177 . notice that the imaginary counterpart of @xmath471 does not mix with any other field . the masses of the @xmath22 resulting from @xmath472 were given in eq . , neglecting small corrections due to ewsb ( i.e. proportional to @xmath473 ) . at @xmath474 , the @xmath4 and @xmath5 masses have the standard expressions @xmath475 and @xmath476 , provided we identify the sm parameters as @xmath477 the contribution to the @xmath35 parameter is computed from @xcite @xmath478 where @xmath479 is the self - energy between the states @xmath480 and @xmath481 , defined through the following effective lagrangian in momentum space ( the @xmath482 is omitted for brevity ) @xmath483 notice that it is natural to assume that the light sm fermions live on the elementary site . therefore the strong ( tilded ) fields do not couple to light fermions , and once they are integrated out , only oblique corrections are generated @xcite . to integrate them out we proceed diagrammatically , noticing that at @xmath474 only exchange of the states @xmath484 and @xmath471 is relevant . the result was given in eq .  . the @xmath47 parameter can be computed from the corrections to the @xmath485 masses at @xmath486 , @xmath487 and @xmath488 . for @xmath170 we find @xmath489 leading to @xmath490 where in the last equality we took the leading order in @xmath491 , and employed the fact that for @xmath170 , @xmath492 . quantitatively , requiring @xmath493 gives @xmath494 tev . in this appendix we comment about the additional states that are present in th models where the global symmetry is extended from @xmath23 to @xmath24 . in the gauge sector , the adjoint representation of @xmath24 decomposes under the @xmath495 subgroup as @xmath496 . the @xmath497 contains @xmath498 ( @xmath499 ) , where the @xmath500 are the gauge bosons of @xmath501 , identified with the @xmath502 of eq .  , while the @xmath503 are new vectors that gauge @xmath504 . the phenomenology of the latter has been studied in the context of custodial composite higgs models , see for example ref . the decomposition of the @xmath505 is entirely analogous , with @xmath506 . the @xmath507 contains the exotic vectors , that include both the @xmath22 and additional states . however , there will still be only one linear combination of the exotic vectors that mixes with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and can therefore be singly produced at hadron colliders . its phenomenology will be qualitatively similar to the one we outlined for the @xmath22 .    in the fermion sector , the number of fields in @xmath508 needs to be doubled to form a fundamental representation of @xmath24 . in our formalism , this can be done by extending the fields carrying twin color as follows @xmath509 where the fields in each set of parentheses transform in the same way under the @xmath510 gauge group , but have different hypercharges or twin hypercharges . all fields except @xmath511 , @xmath512 acquire vector - like masses with their vector - like partners , as in eq . ( [ eq : mass ] ) . the sm and twin electric charges of these fields are @xmath513 with the sm and twin charges swapped for @xmath514 and @xmath515 . the phenomenology of the @xmath516 doublet is familiar from custodial composite higgs models , see for example ref . @xcite and references therein . for the extra copy of the exotic quarks , the upper component of @xmath517 has twin electric charge @xmath518 and behaves similarly to @xmath61 , whereas the lower component has zero twin electric charge and can mix with the sm top , in analogy with @xmath60 . therefore the phenomenology of the additional exotic quarks is not expected to differ qualitatively from the one presented in ref . likewise , the upper component of @xmath519 has sm electric charge @xmath518 and behaves similarly to @xmath42 , whereas the lower component has zero sm electric charge and can mix with the twin top , in analogy with @xmath84 . thus the phenomenology of the exotic fermions is qualitatively well captured by restricting the attention to the @xmath17 , as we did in this paper . g.  burdman , z.  chacko , r.  harnik , l.  de lima and c.  b.  verhaaren , `` colorless top partners , a 125 gev higgs , and the limits on naturalness , '' phys .  rev . d * 91 * 055007 ( 2015 ) , arxiv:1411.3310 [ hep - ph ] . r.  barbieri , d.  greco , r.  rattazzi and a.  wulzer , `` the composite twin higgs scenario , '' jhep * 1508 * 161 ( 2015 ) , arxiv:1501.07803 [ hep - ph ] . m.  bando , t.  kugo , s.  uehara , k.  yamawaki and t.  yanagida , `` is rho meson a dynamical gauge boson of hidden local symmetry ? , '' phys . * 54 * 1215 ( 1985 ) . n.  arkani - hamed , a.  g.  cohen and h.  georgi , `` ( de)constructing dimensions , '' phys .  rev . * 86 * 4757 ( 2001 ) , arxiv : hep - th/0104005 . collaboration , `` search for resonances below @xmath523 tev from the mass distribution of @xmath146-jet pairs in proton - proton collisions at @xmath524 tev with the atlas detector , '' atlas - conf-2016 - 031 , june 2016 . collaboration , `` search for new phenomena in @xmath28 final states with additional heavy - flavour jets in @xmath521 collisions at @xmath524 tev with the atlas detector , '' atlas - conf-2016 - 104 , september 2016 . collaboration , `` search for @xmath28 resonances in boosted semileptonic final states in @xmath521 collisions at @xmath525 , '' cms - pas - b2g-15 - 002 , march 2016 .
Abstract:

Answer: the twin higgs model is the preeminent example of a theory of neutral naturalness , where the new particles that alleviate the little hierarchy problem are standard model ( sm ) singlets . the most promising collider search strategy , based on rare higgs decays , is nevertheless not effective in significant regions of the parameter space of the low energy theory . this underlines the importance of phenomenological studies on ultraviolet completions of the twin higgs model , which must lie at a scale lower than @xmath0-@xmath1 tev . we pursue this course in the context of non - supersymmetric completions , focusing on exotic fermions that carry sm electroweak and twin color charges , as well as on exotic vectors that transform as the bi - fundamental of the electroweak or color groups . both @xmath2-preserving and @xmath2-breaking mass spectra are considered for the exotic fermions . in the former case they must be heavier than @xmath3 tev , but can still be sizably produced in the decays of the color bi - fundamental vector . in the @xmath2-breaking scenario , the exotic fermions can have masses in the few hundred gev range without significantly increasing the fine - tuning . once pair - produced through the electroweak interactions , they naturally form bound states held together by the twin color force , which subsequently annihilate back to sm particles . the associated resonance signals are discussed in detail . we also outline the phenomenology of the electroweak bi - fundamental vectors , some of which mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 and can therefore be singly produced in hadron collisions .