Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: an empirical tenet in the study of accreting compact objects is that their maximum radiative luminosity is about eddington luminosity , that is the limit where the inward - directed gravitational force is balanced by the outward - directed radiation force . for spherical accretion of fully ionized hydrogen , the eddington limit can be written as @xcite @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the thomson scattering cross section , @xmath7 is the proton mass , and @xmath8 is the black hole ( bh ) mass . the x - ray luminosity is generally used as a good proxy for the bolometric luminosity for accreting neutron stars and stellar mass bhs . the eddington argument proved very valuable in the early stages of x - ray astrophysics , to show that most galactic x - ray binaries are neutron stars @xcite . later on , dynamical mass measurements confirmed the existence of a population of galactic bhs with masses @xmath9@xmath10 ( * ? ? ? * for a review ) : they also satisfy the eddington limit , with peak luminosities @xmath11 erg s@xmath12 . the _ einstein _ satellite revealed for the first time a small number of non - nuclear x - ray sources in nearby galaxies ( particularly , in star - forming galaxies ) with apparent luminosities @xmath13  @xcite . however , it was not immediately clear whether these sources could be a distinct class from galactic stellar mass bh candidates , which were just being discovered around the same years . _ s relatively crude spatial resolution allowed for the possibility of source confusion in compact star - forming regions ; lack of long - term monitoring made it hard to distinguish between persistently luminous sources and transient events , _ e.g. _ , young supernovae ( sne ) missed by optical observers .    in the following decade , as nearby galaxies were repeatedly observed with x - ray satellites such as _ rosat _ and _ asca _ , with superior spectral coverage and resolution , it became clear that some of those non - nuclear sources could not be sne , and had apparent luminosities well above the eddington limit of typical galactic stellar mass bhs . for example , the `` most likely interpretation '' of the brightest non - nuclear source in the spiral galaxy ngc1365 was `` an ultra - powerful x - ray binary , with either a highly super - eddington low - mass black hole or a very massive black hole '' with @xmath14@xmath15 , `` which may pose a challenge for stellar evolution models '' @xcite ; a third scenario , beamed emission , was also proposed for other sources @xcite . thirteen years later , distinguishing between those three alternative scenarios remains the unsolved fundamental question for this class of sources , despite the wealth of new discoveries from _ chandra _ , _ xmm - newton _ , _ suzaku _ and _ swift _ , intensive modeling of their x - ray spectral and timing properties , and integrating studies of their multiband counterparts .    for a while , different names have been in use to identify this class of accreting bhs : extraluminous x - ray binaries @xcite , superluminous x - ray sources @xcite , intermediate - luminosity x - ray objects @xcite . in recent years , the community consensus has settled on ultraluminous x - ray sources ( ulxs ) , adopting the terminology first used by japanese _ asca _ teams @xcite . a handful ulxs are observed to exhibit strong x - ray variability at time scales as short as minutes @xcite , and many others have shown random variation at long time scales from days , weeks to years @xcite , confirming their compact nature . they are 10100 times more luminous than galactic black hole binaries ( bhbs ) , whose peak luminosity is about @xmath16  . as the eddington limit is proportional to the bh mass , this suggests that ulxs may contain bhs at least 10100 times more massive than galactic ones which are typically of 10  @xmath1 , and thus represents a new class of bhs with masses in the range of @xmath3@xmath4  @xmath1 , intermediate between stellar mass and supermassive bhs . however , some models suggest that the eddington limit could be violated by a factor up to @xmath1710 for stellar mass bhs @xcite , and the x - ray luminosity may be overestimated due to anisotropic emission caused by geometric beaming expected at high accretion rate @xcite . in these circumstances , intermediate mass black holes ( imbhs ) are not required to interpret ulxs . a combination of super - eddington and mildly beamed emission from stellar mass bhs could account for ulxs with an apparent luminosity up to @xmath17@xmath18  @xcite .    some objects other than bhbs may appear like ulxs if their timing or multiwavelength properties are unavailable . young sne , especially of type iin , could be as luminous as @xmath19  in the x - ray band @xcite . their x - ray spectrum is usually thermal and soft , and will not show chaotic variability . young x - ray pulsars could theoretically be more luminous than @xmath16  but the number of such sources appears to be very small @xcite . in general , these objects can be distinguished from accreting sources with variability @xcite , but it is possible that a sn leaves behind a compact remnant which becomes x - ray luminous when a fallback disk forms @xcite and mixed properties may be seen . in a survey of ulxs in nearby galaxies with archival _ xmm - newton _ data , it was found that the x - ray spectra of a few sources can be decomposed into a power - law component plus a thermal plasma , and in one of them x - ray variability was detected , suggesting that they may be recent sne with an accreting compact core @xcite . background active galactic nuclei ( agn ) that happen to lie behind a nearby galaxy could be misidentified as ulxs in the galaxy . their cosmological location could be revealed if redshift is measured from optical lines ( _ e.g. _ , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the fraction of background objects is usually high in massive , elliptical galaxies ( _ e.g. _ , * ? ? ? * ) . many ulxs are found to be spatially associated with nebulae , young star clusters , or globular clusters ; these are most likely located in the galaxy rather than foreground or background objects . even if they are identified as bhbs , their nature is still not unique in terms of the companion star ( low mass or high mass ) , the mode of the mass transfer ( roche - lobe overflow or wind - fed ) , or the mass of the accretor ( stellar mass or intermediate mass ) . for example , @xcite found that ulxs in young , star forming galaxies are much more variable than in old , elliptical galaxies ( associated with globular clusters ) . no matter what their nature is , ulxs are of great interest in astrophysics . if they are imbhs , their formation mechanism could be rather different from typical stellar mass bhs ; extreme environment , more massive and/or less abundant progenitors are likely required @xcite . imbhs could have played an important role in the formation of supermassive bhs in the early universe and be important targets to search for gravitational wave emission @xcite . instead , if they are stellar mass bhs , it is interesting to investigate why they are so distinct from their galactic cousins . they may be good candidates for the study of the accretion physics at near or super eddington accretion rates @xcite , and they may shed light on binary stellar evolution channels not seen in our galaxy . ulxs are usually defined as non - nuclear , point - like objects which at least once have been observed at an apparent isotropic x - ray luminosity higher than that of stellar mass galactic bhs : typically , @xmath20  erg  s@xmath12 in the 0.310  kev band . some authors ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? * ) prefer to use @xmath21 ergs s@xmath12 , that is the eddington limit of the heaviest stellar bh ( @xmath22 ) expected at normal metallicity @xcite , to exclude a large number of `` faint '' ulxs that should be similar to normal galactic bhbs . such an empirical definition may have ambiguities and also include young x - ray pulsars , sne , and sn remnants as mentioned above . the consensus in the ulx community is to restrict the definition of ulxs to accreting bhs . therefore , we define ulxs as _ non - nuclear accreting bhs with peak luminosities inferred assuming isotropic emission above the eddington limit of normal stellar mass bhs_. this definition is confined to compact objects that are most likely accreting from a companion star in a binary system , but more exotic possibilities , for example isolated imbhs accreting via the bondi process from the surrounding medium are not excluded a priori . observationaly , variability information is required to define a ulx . recently , many ulxs are found to have a mechanical power output as high as in radiation @xcite . in one of them , the mechanical output is dominant while the radiative output is way below the ulx threshold @xcite . this source is apparently not a ulx , but speculated to be an offset ulx or quiescent ulx ( see section  [ sec : bub ] for details ) . we thus define them as `` ultrapowerful sources ( upss ) '' for completeness , to standard for the same population of sources perhaps in a different state or viewing angle . a _ rosat_/hri catalog of luminous , non - nuclear x - ray sources by @xcite proved to be very important for bringing ulxs to the forefront of research , and for emphasizing the possible observational link with theoretically - predicted intermediate mass bhs , with masses @xmath23 . larger and more systematic x - ray source catalogs based on re - analysis of archival _ rosat_/hri data soon followed : in particular , by @xcite , by @xcite , and by @xcite , which included 106 sources above @xmath16 erg s@xmath12 . the first xmm - newton catalog was done by @xcite . catalog with 154 sources in 82 galaxies was produced by @xcite , and 226 objects were included in the catalog by @xcite , compiled from mixed literature sources . such works allowed the first population studies of these objects as a well recognized group , and in relation to the properties of their host galaxies . they also provided the rationale for longer , targeted observations with _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton_. today , the largest catalog @xcite is based on the 2xmm serendipitous survey , and contains 470 ulxs , of which 367 not listed in previous compilations . updated catalogs based on _ chandra _ observations have been compiled by @xcite and @xcite . there are three basic ways to explain non - nuclear systems with apparent accretion luminosities @xmath24 erg s@xmath12 , using only standard accretion physics already included in @xcite s model . we can either increase the mass of the bh ( thus , increasing its eddington limit ) , or attribute the enhanced brightness to beamed emission , or require a mass accretion rate high enough to allow the source to exceed the eddington limit by a factor of a few . it is also possible that the most luminous ulxs may be explained by a combination of all three factors . assuming solar abundances , the _ apparent _ luminosity . ] of an accreting bh is : @xmath25 @xcite , where @xmath26 is the beaming factor , and @xmath27 is the dimensionless accretion rate at large radii ( typically , the mass transfer rate from the donor star ) , that is normalized to the eddington accretion rate , typical of efficient disk accretion ; hence , a dimensionless accretion rate @xmath28 produces a luminosity @xmath29 . other authors prefer to define @xmath30 , in which case the eddington limit is reached at @xmath31 . ] : @xmath32 . let us examine the main tenets of these alternative or complementary scenarios .    _ strong beaming _ ( @xmath33 )  a decade ago , accreting bhs with strongly beamed emission were already well known in extragalactic astronomy ( bl lac objects and blazars : * ? ? ? * ) , and at least one galactic bh ( ss  433 ) was known to have semi - relativistic jets , massive outflows and likely anisotropic emission . naturally , a possible explanation for the early sample of _ rosat _ ulxs was that they were microblazars , or ss  433-like objects seen face - on @xcite . the relativistic beaming scenario soon ran into several fatal difficulties . it predicts that for every ulxs , there should also be a large number of lower - luminosity beamed sources : @xmath34 sources with apparent @xmath35 erg s@xmath12 for every ulx at @xmath36 erg s@xmath12 ; but there is no evidence of this population @xcite . instead , empirical luminosity functions show only @xmath9@xmath37 sources more luminous than @xmath16 erg s@xmath12 for every ulx at @xmath19 erg s@xmath12 @xcite , consistent with the higher end of the high - mass x - ray binary luminosity function . there is also no multiband evidence of the large number of jet sources beamed in other directions , required by this scenario @xcite . conversely , the presence of photoionized bubbles around several ulxs ( for example holmberg ii x-1 : @xcite ; ngc5408 x-1 : @xcite ) requires quasi - isotropic x - ray emission with luminosities @xmath38 erg s@xmath12 . finally , the majority of ulxs do not have radio counterparts and/or rapid x - ray variability , expected for relativistic beaming . for all those reasons , relativistic beaming is now ruled out as a general scenario . _ mild beaming and/or super - eddington accretion _ ( @xmath39 , @xmath40 )  when the accretion rates exceeds the eddington limit , radiatively - driven outflows are launched from the inner part of the disk , inside the spherization radius where the disk becomes geometrically thick @xcite . it was suggested @xcite that the wind may produce a funnel wall that scatters and collimates the emission along the axis perpendicular to the disk plane . the apparent high luminosity of ulxs is then a combination of this mild collimation ( with @xmath41 , @xcite ) and mild super - eddington emission ( @xmath42 ) . in this scenario , accretion rates @xmath31@xmath43 are enough to explain most or all ulxs up to luminosities @xmath44 erg s@xmath12 with bh masses @xmath45 . recent numerical radiation - magneto - hydrodynamical simulations @xcite supported and advanced earlier analytical results ( slim disk models ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and the radiation - hydrodynamical simulations of , among others , @xcite . an important result of the simulations is that even a moderately super - critical mass supply @xmath46 can produce a total luminosity @xmath47 ( in rough agreement with the standard analytical scaling used earlier ) , and an apparent luminosity @xmath48 for face - on observers , due to mild collimation in the magnetized outflow @xcite . an alternative explanation for ulxs relies on super - critical accretion but does not require collimation of the emerging radiation . it was suggested that radiation pressure - dominated accretion disks have strong density inhomogeneities due to the development of photon - bubble instabilities @xcite . radiation would escape from such disk regions at rates @xmath49 times above the classical eddington limit for stellar mass bhs . _ quasi - isotropic eddington luminosity _ ( @xmath50 , @xmath51 )  although some models and simulations offer us compelling reasons to ignore the eddington limit as a constraint for the ulx interpretation , some authors remain wary of this scenario . they point out that the eddington limit works well for galactic bhs and neutron stars . more significantly , the isotropic bolometric luminosity of the whole population of @xmath52 quasars at redshift @xmath53 in the sloan digitized sky survey is strongly eddington - limited at all bh masses , with only a very small fraction of sources between 1 and 3 @xmath54 @xcite . perhaps like the bumblebee , the eddington limit should not fly , but does . thus , it is argued that the null hypothesis for ulxs should be that their luminosities are @xmath55 , despite the difference on the gas reservoir between agn and binary systems , and their radiative anisotropy is only a factor of @xmath56 ( a standard accretion disk has a beaming factor @xmath57 in the absence of any other collimation ) . these conditions are possible to explain most ulxs up to a few @xmath58  with accreting bhs of masses @xmath59 , which is the theoretical upper limit for a direct collapse of a single stellar core in the current universe ( see section  [ sec : bhmass ] ) . sources more luminous than that may require imbhs . for example , hlx-1 in eso243 - 49 , the most luminous ulx found to date , has a peak bolometric luminosity @xmath60 erg s@xmath12 @xcite . if it is eddington limited , a black hole mass of at least @xmath61 is inferred . even if super - eddington emission is allowed , an imbh is required . _ quasi - isotropic sub - eddington luminosity _ ( @xmath62 , @xmath63 )  finally , it is possible that ulxs are accreting at sub - eddington accretion rates with nearly isotropic emission or disk beaming , which requires the compact objects to be imbhs ( @xmath64 ) . then we expect to see similar state transition and x - ray spectral properties from both ulxs and galactic bhbs , scaled only by the mass . the emission scenarios outlined above require three different ranges of bh masses , with different formation mechanisms .    _ ordinary stellar mass bhs _ ( @xmath65 )  the first advantage of explaining ulxs with ordinary stellar mass black holes ( smbhs ) is that we already have direct evidence of their existence in the local universe . there are more than 20 bhs identified in x - ray binaries with dynamically measured masses @xmath9@xmath10 ( for reviews see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . in the milky way , the most massive smbhs are those in grs  1915@xmath66105 ( @xmath67 ; * ? ? ? * ) and in cygnus x-1 ( @xmath68 ; * ? ? ? a similarly massive bh is found in m33 x-7 ( @xmath69  @xmath1 ; * ? ? ? an accreting binary system in the nearby starburst galaxy ic 10 @xcite contains a bh with a mass of @xmath70@xmath71 ( the mass uncertainty is mainly due to the unconstrained companion mass and inclination angle of the binary plane ) . the second advantage is that they are the easiest bhs to form : standard stellar models predict smbhs as the endpoint of individual massive star evolution , for a wide range of stellar masses and metallicities . thus , the strictest constraints to smbh models for ulxs come not from the bh formation process , but from the extreme super - eddington accretion , beaming and outflows required by these models .    _ massive stellar bhs _ ( @xmath72 )  the mass of a compact remnant depends both on the initial mass of the stellar progenitor , and on how much mass is lost through stellar winds during the stellar lifetime @xcite . radiatively - driven winds from massive stars are strongly dependent on their metallicity @xcite . therefore , metallicity plays an important role in stellar evolution and determines the maximal mass of a bh that can be formed via core collapse . @xcite argued that the collapse of a single star can form a bh up to @xmath73 at solar metallicity , @xmath74 at 0.3 times solar metallicity , and @xmath75 at 0.01 times solar metallicity ; consistent results ( upper bh mass limit @xmath76 at low metallicities ) that are obtained by @xcite and @xcite . these results can well explain the inferred bh masses in galactic x - ray binaries ( average metallicity close to the solar value ) and in the ic 10 source ( metallicity @xmath77 solar ) . in summary , current stellar evolution models predict a bh remnant distribution peaked around @xmath78 , with a tail extending up to @xmath59 . as the formation of stellar bhs more massive than @xmath79 may require rarer , more extreme conditions , we will refer to them as `` massive stellar black holes ( msbhs ) '' . there is another interesting physical difference between smbh and msbh formation , in addition to different progenitor mass and metallicity : smbhs are probably formed through a sn explosion and subsequent rapid fallback ; msbhs are probably formed from direct core collapse without an explosion @xcite . this is because for the more massive objects , the gravitational energy released during core collapse is not enough to unbind and expel the stellar envelope . at low metallicities , the threshold for direct collapse is an initial stellar mass @xmath80 @xcite ; at solar metallicity , even the most massive stars may lose enough mass in winds and explode as sne . _ intermediate mass bhs _ ( @xmath81@xmath4  @xmath1 )  to produce an imbh of @xmath82@xmath83 , the core collapse of an isolated star in the current epoch is not a viable process . this is not because of the lack of very massive stars ( in fact , several stars with initial masses @xmath84@xmath85 may exist in the lmc ; * ? ? ? * ) , but because helium cores more massive than @xmath86 ( corresponding to initial stellar masses @xmath87 at zero metallicities ) undergo an electron / positron pair - instability explosion that leads to the complete disruption of the star , without bh formation @xcite . however , a bh may form again if the helium core is more massive than @xmath88 , corresponding to initial stellar masses @xmath89 at zero metallicity @xcite .    it has been suggested that metal - free population iii stars formed in the very early universe could reach masses of a few hundred @xmath90 @xcite , above the pair - instability limit , and thus may have collapsed into imbhs @xcite . in young and dense star clusters , dynamical friction could lead to massive stars sinking towards the center and undergoing runaway collisions and mergers on timescales @xmath91 yr . numerical simulations suggest that such a process may result in the formation of a huge star , which may subsequently collapse into an imbh @xcite . dynamical evidence for imbhs with masses @xmath92 has been proposed for a few globular clusters , _ e.g. _ , g1 in m31 @xcite , although the issue is still controversial @xcite . @xcite suggested that in massive and/or compact globular clusters , a central seed smbh may grow by up to a factor of 100 via accretion of gas lost by the first generation of cluster stars in their red - giant phase . imbhs may also wander in the halo of major galaxies , after tidal stripping of merging satellite dwarfs that contained nuclear bhs @xcite ; this is currently the most plausible explanations for the most extreme ulx found to date , hlx-1 in eso243@xmath9349 . to summarize , three types of non - nuclear bhs could be powering ulxs ( table  [ tab : bh ] ) . cclc type & mass & progenitor & @xmath94 + smbh & @xmath1710 @xmath1 & normal star & @xmath56 + msbh & @xmath95100 @xmath1 & low - z star & @xmath96 + & & pop iii & + imbh & @xmath3@xmath4 @xmath1 & cluster core & @xmath97 + & & stripped nucleus & + assuming that ulxs are binary systems with a bh receiving matter directly from an individual donor star , we can try to fit them into the traditional classification of galactic x - ray sources , as either high - mass or low - mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs and lmxbs , respectively ) . hmxbs have a massive ob donor star with a characteristic age @xmath98 yrs ; lmxbs have a low - mass donor ( often in the subgiant or giant phase ) with ages @xmath99 yrs ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? hmxbs are mostly found in spiral and irr galaxies , with current or recent star formation , while lmxbs populate old spheroidals and globular clusters . ulxs are found both in ellipticals and in spiral / irregular galaxies ; however , the most luminous ones are found predominantly in star - forming galaxies . specifically , more than two thirds of ulxs found in ellipticals are in the lowest luminosity range , with @xmath100 erg s@xmath12 @xcite , and can easily be explained as the upper end of the lmxb distribution , with bh masses @xmath101 . it was even suggested @xcite that all ulx candidates in ellipticals with apparent @xmath102 erg s@xmath12 could be dismissed as background or foreground sources . today , it is generally accepted that there are a few genuine ulxs in ellipticals at luminosities @xmath103@xmath104 erg s@xmath12 , but none has been found above @xmath19 erg s@xmath12 . in spirals , by comparison , one third of ulxs have luminosities @xmath105@xmath106 erg s@xmath12 , and about 10% have luminosities @xmath107 erg s@xmath12 @xcite . both early - type ( hubble types 0 to 4 ) and late - type ( hubble types 5 to 9 ) spirals may contain ulxs , with similar probability , within the current statistical error of the samples ; @xcite find slightly more ulxs in early - type spirals , while @xcite find slightly more in late types , due to the different spatial resolutions of the instruments . furthermore , the fact that a luminous ulx is found in a spiral galaxy does not imply that it has an ob donor star . many ulxs in spirals are not located in regions ( within a few 100s of pc ) with evidence of current or very recent star formation @xcite . using the optical color distribution in a sample of face - on host galaxies , @xcite found that the brightest ulxs turn on @xmath0@xmath108 myr after the end of star formation . characteristic ages @xmath109 myr for the surrounding stellar population were also found for example in the case of ngc1313 x-1 and x-2 @xcite , ic 342 x-1 @xcite , ngc4559 x-1 @xcite , and ngc 1073 ixo 5 @xcite . @xcite normalized the radial distance of all ulx candidates in their sample to the deprojected @xmath110 diameter of their host galaxies . they found that the ulx surface density profile is strongly peaked towards the center . the profile can be fitted with a sersic function , with a best - fit index consistent with a de vaucouleurs profile ( @xmath111 ) , and an exponential scale - radius @xmath112 . this finding suggests that the ulx population is intrinsically related to the stellar population of their host galaxies . less centrally concentrated distributions would be expected if most ulxs were primordial halo relics such as population iii remnants , or nuclear bhs of accreted satellite galaxies . a _ chandra _ sample of ulxs in 58 face - on star - forming galaxies within 15 mpc , studied in details by @xcite , does not show statistically significant associations between ulxs and young , massive ( @xmath113 ) star clusters , within @xmath114 regions . the same conclusion was found by @xcite for ulxs in the antennae galaxies . this is inconsistent with formation scenarios based on runaway core collapse and mergers of o stars inside a compact , young stellar cluster , leading to the possible formation of an imbh of a few hundred solar masses via direct collapse of the resulting superstar @xcite . in fact , most ulx host galaxies do not even have stellar clusters sufficiently massive and compact to satisfy the requirements for runaway core collapse . in theory , imbhs could be formed inside clusters that have since dispersed . however , the evaporation timescale of such clusters would be too long to explain the observed association of many ulxs with young ( @xmath115 myr ) stellar populations .      here , we further quantify the association between ulx populations and host galaxy properties . @xcite studied 107 ulxs in a complete sample of 127 nearby galaxies ( @xmath116 mpc ) , selected to be above the completeness limit of both the uppsala galaxy catalog and the _ infrared astronomical satellite _ ( _ iras _ ) survey . the total star formation rate ( sfr ) of the galaxies in the sample is @xmath117 yr@xmath12 based on the _ iras _ data , consistent with other measurements of star formation based on the h@xmath118 and [ o@xmath119ii ] indicators @xcite . this , in turn , corresponds to an sfr density @xmath120 yr@xmath12 mpc@xmath121 in the local universe . finding @xmath122 ulxs in that volume , after correcting for incompleteness and background interlopers , implies that we expect , on average , @xmath123 ulxs for a sfr of @xmath124 yr@xmath12 , and 1 ulx in a volume of @xmath125 mpc@xmath121 . this is consistent with the hmxb luminosity function in local star - forming galaxies : @xcite find @xmath34 sources with @xmath126 erg s@xmath12 ( corresponding to @xmath127 erg s@xmath12 in the ulx definition used in @xcite ) in a sample of galaxies with a total sfr @xmath128 yr@xmath12 . the average specific frequency in star - forming galaxies , in the local universe , is 1 ulx per @xmath129 , for galaxies with dynamical mass of @xmath130 @xcite . this rate decreases for increasing galaxy mass , scaling as @xmath131 @xcite . in elliptical galaxies , the specific rate is 1 ulx per @xmath132 @xcite . thus , it appears that low - mass spirals and irregulars are more efficient at producing ulxs , per unit mass . this is true at least down to galaxy masses @xmath133 . there may be two reasons why low - mass galaxies contain more ulxs per unit mass @xcite . one is that their sfr per unit mass is higher , so they are more efficient at producing ulxs . the other is that they have lower metal abundances , which may favor the formation of heavier stellar bhs from the collapse of massive o stars @xcite . however , it is suggested by @xcite that the metallicity does not affect the ulx production strongly after comparing two pairs of colliding galaxies . finally , it is often noted that many luminous ulxs reside in colliding or strongly interacting galaxies : the antennae @xcite , the cartwheel @xcite , the mice @xcite , ngc4485/90 @xcite , ngc7714/15 @xcite , ngc3256 @xcite , and a few more arp galaxies . this may simply be due to the fact that colliding galaxies have the largest sfr , and the number of ulxs scales with the recent sfr . the cumulative luminosity function ( lf ) of a population of accreting sources ( also known as @xmath134@xmath135 curve ) is expected to have a break or cut - off at the eddington luminosity of the most massive objects in the population . therefore , in the absence of direct mass measurements , the lf can be used as a rough indicator of the maximum mass . in fact , things are not so simple . the lf of x - ray binaries in our galaxy and in other nearby galaxies does not show any features at @xmath136 erg s@xmath12 , eddington limit of the neutron star population . moreover , the location of the upper cutoff may be a function both of mass ( via the eddington limit ) and of the age of the population , since the most luminous sources tend to have a shorter lifetime @xcite . thus , careful modeling is required to interpret a lf .    matches the observed distribution better than an unbroken power - law , although the issue remains controversial ( _ cf . at the low - energy end , it also matches the slope and normalization of the hmxb distribution below @xmath16  @xcite . [ fig : lf ] ]    with this caveat , we can use the ulx lf to test the scenario that ulxs in star - forming galaxies are mostly the high - luminosity tail of hmxbs ( plus some additional lmxbs ) , and ulxs in ellipticals are the high - luminosity tail of lmxbs . chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ surveys of discrete x - ray sources in nearby galaxies have produced consistent results in agreement with this interpretation @xcite . in summary , they have all found that the cumulative lf of young x - ray populations in star - forming galaxies is a simple power - law with a slope @xmath137@xmath138 , while the cumulative lf of old x - ray populations in ellipticals and spiral bulges has a slope of @xmath139 . thus , short - lived hmxb - like sources dominate the high - luminosity end of the distribution . the normalization of the hmxb lf is proportional to the sfr ; the normalization of the lmxb lf is proportional to the stellar mass @xcite . what remains controversial is the behavior of the lf for the young ulx population above an x - ray luminosity @xmath38 erg s@xmath12 . from their _ chandra _ survey , @xcite find that a pure power - law @xmath140 provides a very poor fit to the data above that threshold ( figure  [ fig : lf ] ) . a cut - off power - law model with @xmath141 provides an acceptable fit , with @xmath142 ( as required by the low - luminosity end of the lf ) and @xmath143 erg s@xmath12 . a very similar result was also found by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . the cut - off power - law model does not preclude the possibility of finding ulxs above @xmath144 erg s@xmath12 , but they would be increasingly rarer . it predicts @xcite 1 ulx with @xmath145 erg s@xmath12 within a radius of @xmath146@xmath147 mpc , and 1 ulx with @xmath148 erg s@xmath12 within a radius of @xmath149@xmath150 mpc . if the luminosity of a few ulxs recently discovered by @xcite is confirmed to be @xmath44 erg s@xmath12 , their existence would not be consistent with the cut - off model of @xcite , and may suggest a physically different population of accretors @xcite . and , of course , so does hlx-1 in eso243@xmath9349 with its peak outburst luminosity @xmath60 erg s@xmath12 @xcite . in contrast with those findings , the _ xmm - newton _ survey of @xcite does not see any turnover or cut - off in the cumulative lf above @xmath19 erg s@xmath12 , but their data can not rule out the presence of a similar break . at this stage , the discrepant result may be caused by a different binning technique , or by small - number statistics . both the @xcite and @xcite complete subsamples have only 5 sources with @xmath151 erg s@xmath12 out of a total of @xmath152 ulxs . a few other ulxs above that threshold are known , but can not simply be added to the lf because they do not form part of a complete sample . thanks to the large effective area of _ xmm - newton _ , combined with _ chandra _ observations , the spectral and timing properties of ulxs in the @xmath153@xmath37 kev band have been widely investigated and modeled over the last decade , even though the physical interpretation is still controversial . most of the x - ray studies have focused on bright ulxs ( @xmath154  ) in nearby galaxies ( @xmath155  mpc ) that allows spectral and timing analysis at high signal to noise ratios . in the next two sections , we review x - ray spectral and timing properties of bright ulxs and discuss their physical interpretation in comparisons with well - defined emission properties of galactic bhbs . phenomenologically , the energy spectra of ulxs in the @xmath153@xmath37 kev band can be divided into two groups : those that are consistent with a simple power - law , and those that are more complex @xcite . the latter mainly refers to a mild broad curvature ( convex shape ) over the whole band , a break or steepening above @xmath103 kev , or a soft excess below @xmath103 kev . a typical ulx spectral shape of the latter is sketched in figure  [ fig : spec ] . many ulx spectra are well fitted by a single , absorbed power - law model . the photon index has a broad distribution , peaked at @xmath1562.0 @xcite but with a few much harder ( down to @xmath157 ) as well as much softer sources ( up to @xmath158 ) . the distribution does not appear to be bimodal ; there is no evidence of a gap between a `` hard state '' and a `` soft state '' . @xcite found that the power - law photon index tends to be harder at increasing luminosity ; a selection of ulxs with high luminosity ( @xmath159 erg s@xmath12 ) and hard power - law spectrum ( @xmath160 ) is also presented in @xcite . some of the hard sources with multiple observations show strong flux variability ( sometimes by an order of magnitude ) but constant photon index @xcite . similar behavior has been seen from galactic bhbs in the hard state @xcite . the x - ray luminosity in the hard state is usually @xmath161 times eddington @xcite , but during hard - to - soft state transitions the hard state can reach a luminosity up to 30% of eddington @xcite . thus , if hard power - law ulxs belong to the same canonical hard state defined in galactic bhs , their bh masses must be @xmath162 @xcite . a key signature of the hard state is the presence of compact , continuous radio jets . so far , the only possible detection of such jets is from ic 342 x-1 , with _ vla _ observations @xcite . using the fundamental plane of accreting bhs , @xcite estimate a compact object mass @xmath163@xmath164 . further observations are needed to spectrally constrain the nature of the radio core in this system . m82 x-1 is another good candidate for hard state ulxs . this source displays low frequency quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) @xcite above a band - limited broad noise component , and its x - ray spectrum is a featureless power - law with a photon index @xmath165 @xcite . we note that m82 x-1 may be one of the very few ulxs that change their spectral state during outbursts , switching from a hard to a thermal state ( see section [ sec : curve ] ) . the hard spectrum may come from an advection - dominated accretion flow @xcite , a luminous hot accretion flow @xcite , a classical hot corona above the accretion disk @xcite , or from a combination of synchrotron and inverse - compton emission at the base of the jet @xcite . the first mechanism is limited to low accretion rates , but the latters can in principle operate also near the eddington luminosity and be relevant to ulxs @xcite . thus , an alternative interpretation favored by some authors is that hard power - law ulxs are not in the canonical low / hard state ; in other words , that the ulx hard state is not confined to luminosities @xmath166 eddington , and does not switch to a softer , disk - dominated thermal state as the accretion rate increases @xcite . we could call it a persistent high / hard state ( unknown in galactic bhbs ) , which can extend all the way to the eddington luminosity and smoothly morph into the very high state or other super - eddington accretion states .    at the opposite end of the broad photon - index distribution , several ulxs with @xmath167 could be classified in the steep power - law state of galactic bhbs , typically found at near - eddington luminosities @xcite . the fact that there are no clear gaps , but instead a continuous distribution in photon index and an overlapping luminosity distribution between hard and soft ulxs may be an indication that the two regimes are smoothly connected .    in conclusion , with longer x - ray observations and increasing photon statistics , we have reached a stage where we can identify and model a number of subtle spectral features on top of the simple power - law for many ulxs . in the rest of this section , we discuss a variety of spectral models that account for such features , and their physical implications . -free ) or a warm , thick comptonization model can adequately fit the hard curvature ; in the plot , a @xmath168-free model with @xmath169  kev and @xmath170 has an almost identical spectral shape to a comptt model with @xmath171  kev and @xmath172 , which is shifted vertically for clarity . for comparison , two diskbb models are plotted with @xmath173 and 2.5  kev , respectively . they are more curved and can not fit the energy spectrum over the 0.3 - 10 kev band . [ fig : spec ] ]      in many ulxs , excessive residuals at low energies ( @xmath174  kev ) would be seen if one makes a power - law fit at high energies ; an additional disk component could adequately fit the excesses and the inferred disk inner temperature is around 0.10.4  kev . this cool , soft excess was first identified by @xcite in ngc 5408 x-1 ; @xcite showed the emission was point like and applied a disk plus power - law model . similar phenomena were then found in ngc 1313 x-1 and x-2 @xcite , and later on in many other ulxs @xcite . such a fit is analogous to the empirical model for galactic bhbs except that the disk is cooler and more luminous in ulxs than in smbhs at their high state @xcite . for a standard accretion disk @xcite extending to the last stable orbit around a bh , the inner disk temperature @xmath175 is a function of bh mass @xmath8 and total luminosity @xmath176 : @xmath177 where @xmath118 depends on the bh spin ( @xmath178 for a schwarzschild bh , @xmath179 for an extreme kerr bh ) , @xmath180 is a corrective factor that takes into account the no - torque condition at the innermost orbit , and @xmath181 is the spectral hardening factor @xcite . given the same spinning and correction factors , the bh mass is scaled with the disk inner temperature and luminosity as a function of @xmath182 thus , the low - temperature , high - luminosity characters of the assumed disk suggest that the emission arises from accretion onto imbhs . for comparison , the typical disk inner temperature is about 1  kev at a luminosity of @xmath183  for smbhs about 10  @xmath1 . the characteristic temperature for ulxs is usually around 0.10.4  kev and the luminosity is some @xmath16@xmath19  , suggestive of a bh mass of @xmath184 @xmath4  @xmath1 . however , the interpretation of soft excesses as emission from cool accretion disk has confronted challenges . @xcite argued that soft excesses could also be soft deficits depending on the energy band where the power - law is fitted . @xcite found similar soft excesses in both ulxs and less luminous x - ray sources , implying that they are not a unique signature of imbhs in a statistical sense . it is suggested that supercritical accretion may produce massive outflows , which are optically thick with soft , thermal emission at similar temperature , being another possible origin for the detected soft excesses @xcite . other authors @xcite have suggested that the soft excess does come from the disk surface , but much further away than the innermost stable orbit , where the disk may be obscured or replaced by an outflow or a scattering corona ( section  [ sec : curve ] ) . in that case , the characteristic radius of the thermally - emitting disk region can not be used to infer the bh mass .    repeated observations of an individual ulx may help test the cool disk model @xcite . if the disk touches the innermost stable orbit around the bh , one expects to see the disk luminosity vary to the 4th power of the inner temperature , @xmath185 , as well known in the thermal state of galactic bhbs @xcite . if , instead , the observed inner disk radius is the boundary between an outer standard disk and an inner corona or outflow , we expect that such transition will move further and further out at higher accretion rates when super - eddington . in the simplest outflow scenario , @xmath186 @xcite . this implies @xcite @xmath187 constant for a viscously heated outer disk and @xmath188 for a strongly x - ray - irradiated outer disk ( as is more likely the case in ulxs ) . most other plausible relations between @xmath189 and @xmath27 predict negative correlations between the disk luminosity and temperature , with slopes between @xmath190 and @xmath191 @xcite . a negative correlation between the luminosity and temperature is clearly detected for at least ngc 1313 x-2 and ic 342 x-1 @xcite . from a sample of 8 ulxs , @xcite found that the luminosity of the soft excesses scales with the temperature as @xmath192 , roughly consistent with the model prediction that the soft emission arises from a photosphere due to strong outflows from a supercritical disk and its temperature is determined by the spherization radius @xcite . on the contrary , a positive correlation is seen from ngc5204 x-1 ; however , it has a shallower slope @xmath193 @xcite . @xcite suggested , based on a disk atmosphere model , that the hardening correction factor becomes larger at increasing luminosity , and explains the apparent shallower slope in galactic bhs such as xte  j1550@xmath93564 and h1743@xmath93322 . applying such a varying hardening correction , one can recover the @xmath194 relation for ngc5204 x-1 , which would favor the imbh scenario . however , this result is not robust yet : @xcite found that the positive correlation disappears or even becomes negative if one chooses a different lower energy bound for the spectral fitting . also , the disk contributes only @xmath195 of the 0.310 kev luminosity , inconsistent with the thermal dominant state .    instead , if ulxs were imbhs , we would expect to see many of them in the canonical thermal state dominated by the soft disk component . in summary , using the disk parameters inferred from x - ray spectra to determine the bh mass is based on assumptions that have proved either incorrect or problematic for most sources . it was noted by @xcite and @xcite that high energy curvature / steepening is a common feature in high - quality ulx spectra . generally , the break / steepening could be fitted by a comptonization model with relatively low energy electrons and high optical depth @xcite . a few ulx spectra are mildly convex , formally consistent with a standard disk model . we thus discuss the physical implications of these models .      with _ asca _ observations , a hot multicolor accretion disk model was found to fit the spectra of a number of ulxs ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? for those with relatively low temperatures ( @xmath196  kev ) , they could be explained by accretion onto smbhs or msbhs @xcite . the high temperature and luminosity may be explained by large bh spin @xcite , but this does not work for extreme cases where relatively small bh mass is required , which in turn is inconsistent with the observed high luminosity . for _ xmm - newton _ spectra , a single hot disk with absorption is usually unable to fit the data ; an additional component is required and dominates in the low energy band @xcite , and the disk component is not the dominant part @xcite . the presence of a soft component in addition to the hot disk is unusual in bhbs and does not have a simple physical interpretation . in general , the hot disk model is problematic . the standard disk emission is best known in the thermal state in bhbs , in which the x - ray spectrum is dominated by emission from a standard accretion disk ; plus , the x - ray variability is low , with no or weak qpos @xcite . so far , the thermal state may have been identified only in one case , m82 x-1 , constrained using both spectral and timing information . with simultaneous _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations of m82 , @xcite found surprisingly that the previously known qpos in the source disappeared . the light curve was no longer highly variable and the power spectrum was consistent with that of white noise . the energy spectrum also changed dramatically from a straight power - law to a disk - like spectrum . fitting with a standard accretion disk model , the inferred luminosity and temperature from three repeated observations are consistent with a 4th power relation . all results are well consistent with that expected for the thermal state . the monitoring data from _ rxte _ indicate that these _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations were made during the source outbursts , suggesting that m82 x-1 usually stays in the hard state and could transition to the thermal state during outbursts . fitting with a relativistic disk model , the bh is estimated to be a fast spinning imbh of 200800  @xmath1 . there are a few more sources @xcite which have shown spectral variability possibly consistent with a @xmath194 relation if fitted with a hot standard disk model . another group of five nearby ulxs consistent with the thermal state spectrum , based on x - ray spectral modeling , was discussed by @xcite . these sources all lie at the lower end of the ulx luminosity regime , and could be explained by kerr msbhs in the thermal state . they do not stand for the majority of ulxs , in particular those with a typical luminosity around @xmath19  . also , lack of fast timing information hampers a firm identification . therefore , it is generally accepted that the canonical thermal state is rare in ulxs @xcite . the slim disk can radiate near or moderately above the eddington limit estimated from spherical accretion @xcite . this super - eddington disk is thus a good candidate for ulx emission @xcite . when advective energy transport dominates over radiative cooling in an accretion disk , the radial temperature profile changes from @xmath197 for a standard disk to @xmath198 for a slim disk @xcite . an extended multicolor disk model called the @xmath168-free model was introduced , with the radial dependence @xmath168 on temperature ( @xmath199 ) being an additional free parameter @xcite , and used to explain ulx emission @xcite . @xcite investigated the energy spectra of four ulxs , ngc 5204 x-1 , ngc 4559 x-7/x-10 , and ngc 1313 x-2 , and found that they can be well fitted by the @xmath168-free model . interestingly , the best - fit @xmath168 value was found to be around 0.5 , consistent with that for a slim disk . in the luminosity vs.  disk temperature diagram , the four ulxs and galactic bhbs appear to be in line with the same @xmath194 relation , suggesting that ulxs may be bhs of similar or slightly higher masses ( smbhs or msbhs ) but in the slim disk state . another successful test of the @xmath168-free or slim disk model was for m33 x-8 , which is marginally classified as a ulx but a good candidate for deep investigation owing to its relatively small distance ( _ e.g. , _ * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . @xcite first identified that an extra power - law component is required in addition to the @xmath168-free disk to fit the source spectrum . the best - fit @xmath168 value ( @xmath200 ) suggests notable advection in the disk , close to the slim disk nature rather than a standard one . these indicate that the slim disk state may be a natural extension of the canonical thermal state at supercritical accretion . this is consistent with the radiation - magnetohydrodynamic simulations that the hard , thermal and slim states could be produced under a single model with different accretion rates @xcite . however , the @xmath168-free model encounters difficulties in both observation and theory . in some sources , the disk inner temperature was found too high to be physically reasonable when fitted with the @xmath168-free model @xcite . if photon trapping is taken into account , the radial temperature profile is expected to be significantly flatter than @xmath201 within the trapping radius @xcite , in contrast to the spectrum predicted without considering photon trapping @xcite . also , numerical simulations suggest that dense , warm outflows are always associated with supercritical accretion @xcite , which would comptonize and obscure the emission from the underlying disk , see details in the following subsection .      in galactic bhbs , high energy spectral curvature is also detected , but usually occurs at tens to hundreds of kev . it is interpreted as comptonization in a thin corona with temperatures typical of @xmath3  kev . however , the spectral curvature in ulxs suggests an electron temperature of a few kev and a scattering optical depth significantly higher than unity , indicative of a warm and thick corona . due to the presence of such a thick corona , the emission from the disk would be distorted and the previous interpretation , a simple summation of a cool disk and a warm corona @xcite , needs be modified consequently . @xcite revisited best quality _ xmm - newton _ data and concluded that two common features simultaneously exist in the energy spectrum of ulxs : soft excesses below 2 kev and high energy curvature above 2 kev . this is not frequently seen in the spectra of galactic bhbs when they are thought to accrete at sub - eddington level . thus , they suggested that ulxs represent a new state distinct from the four well - known states ( quiescent , hard , thermal , and steep power - law ) in galactic bhbs @xcite , and call it ultraluminous state . please refer to @xcite for a more detailed review of this state . the galactic bhb that comes closest to this state is xte  j1550@xmath93564 at the peak of its 1998 september outburst . a coupled disk - corona model @xcite was proposed to explain such state , in which the disk and corona are not independent but share the total gravitational energy release . the un - scattered outer disk is responsible for the soft excesses , while the comptonized inner disk produces the hard , curved tail . the bh mass , estimated from the unmasked temperature and radius of the underlying disk , lies in the regime of smbhs or msbhs . numerical simulations of supercritical accretion indicates that radiation pressure would power strong outflows above the disk in the inner region @xcite . the wind is optically thick and warm ( a few kev ) , and would strongly comptonize the disk emission . at high accretion rate , the disk becomes thick and would collimate the radiation along the symmetric axis causing geometric , mild beaming with an apparent isotropic luminosity over the eddington limit by a factor up to @xmath1710 . this picture is consistent with the proposed ultraluminous state . observationally , from the spectral evolution of m33 x-8 , @xcite suggested that the outflow is launched at near - eddington luminosity , and the radius at which it is launched moves further out with increasing luminosity . if the comptonizing region is the fast outflow , rather than a static corona , it is possible that bulk motion @xcite can be as or more important than thermal comptonization , depending on the characteristics of the outflow @xcite . observationally , ulx spectra that can be formally fitted with thermal comptonization models can be equally well fitted with bulk motion models ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? the only difference is in the interpretation of the characteristic energy of the upscattering electrons . as noted by @xcite , simple physical considerations , comparisons with other astrophysical classes of outflows , and numerical simulations all suggest that super - eddington ulx outflows have a characteristic speed @xmath202 escape velocity from the launching radius , corresponding to a bulk kinetic energy @xmath203 kev for the outflowing electrons . this is similar to the characteristic energy of the spectral breaks . most ulxs and bhbs have considerable radiation output above 2  kev , while supersoft sources ( ssss ) have most of their energy released below 2  kev . canonical ssss are speculated to be powered by steady nuclear burning on the surface of white dwarfs @xcite . a number of supersoft ulxs have been discovered , whose spectrum is dominated by a cool blackbody component of tens to a hundred ev , being a distinct class from the majority of ulxs . these include m101 ulx-1 @xcite , antennae x-13 @xcite , m81 uls1 @xcite , ngc 4631 x1 @xcite , and ngc 247 ulx @xcite . at long timescales , most of these sources have shown dramatic variability with a luminosity change by a factor up to @xmath184 but with consistently low temperatures . a weak power - law tail is significantly detected in at least one source @xcite , but none of the supersoft ulxs has become a power - law dominated ulx or vice versa . fast timing noise was detected in two of them , m101 ulx-1 @xcite and ngc 247 ulx @xcite , down to a timescale around 100  s , indicating that they are not agn . the nature of these peculiar sources is very uncertain . they are unlikely powered by white dwarfs , because they are too luminous ( a few times @xmath16  ) and some of them are too hot ( @xmath204  ev ) . they are also unlikely to be due to cool disks around imbhs , because such disks can not have a huge variability with a constant temperature . one possible scenario is that their emission is produced by massive outflows from supercritical accreting sources viewed at a high inclination angle @xcite . a unification model ( supercritical accretion with thick outflows , see figure  [ fig : model ] ) may be able to explain both normal , broad - band ulxs and less luminous , supersoft ulxs with different viewing angles . so far , we have briefly reviewed a variety of scenarios that can account for the observed ulx spectra ( see also figure  [ fig : spec ] ) . in figure [ fig : model ] , we sketch the physical ingredients behind the most common combination of such models , which may be successfully used to explain the multiband spectrum of most ulxs .    ]      the study of long term spectral variability of ulxs mainly relies on pointed observations with _ chandra _ or _ xmm - newton _ , or quasi - regular snapshots with the x - ray telescope on board _ swift_. in addition , _ rxte _ has been used to monitor the brightest ( in terms of observed flux ) ulx in m82 . the most interesting science with these observations , in addition to the search for orbital periods , is perhaps to find state transitions known in galactic bhbs . canonical transitions between the low / hard and high / soft states were reported in ic 342 x-1 and x-2 with _ asca _ observations @xcite and also in holmberg ix x-1 with multiple missions @xcite . however , almost no such canonical state transitions have been reported in the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ era . in contrast , transitions between soft and hard states were found but not in a way similar to galactic sources @xcite . a major difference between ulxs and galactic bhbs is that most ulxs are persistent sources and have been bright since their discovery decades ago , while the latter are usually transients especially accreting from a low mass companion with roche lobe overflow . _ swift _ monitoring @xcite of bright ulxs have revealed flaring activity with a luminosity change by a factor of @xmath155 on time scales of days to months . in particular , @xcite found holmberg ix x-1 remains in the hard state as its flux varies , and @xcite found the x - ray spectral state is not correlated with the luminosity in holmberg ii x-1 . also , as mentioned previously in section  [ sec : curve ] , @xcite found m82 x-1 may have changed from the hard state to thermal state during outbursts . there is one exceptional case . eso243@xmath9349 hlx-1 shows a low / hard to high / soft jump reminiscent of the canonical state transition @xcite . it also displays outbursts in a `` fast rise exponential decay '' pattern , very similar to those seen in galactic bhbs @xcite . however , the authors argued that the observed variability is unlikely triggered by disk instability due to inconsistent timescale . the power spectrum of galactic bhbs can be decomposed into broad components ( power - law red noise , band - limited noise , flat - top or zero - centered broad lorentzian , etc . ) and narrow components ( qpos ) . although we still know little about the physical origin of these temporal features , their phenomenology has proved useful in defining and identifying accretion states @xcite and possibly in determining bh masses via model independent calibrations ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? an important model - independent finding of @xcite , based on the study of sample of 16 bright ulxs , is that those sources can be divided into two groups defined by their short - term x - ray variability , even though they have similar energy spectra and luminosities . one group ( including among others ngc 5204 x-1 ) shows weak or absent variability on timescales at least as large as 100s . the other group ( including among others ngc 5408 x-1 ) has similar variability levels and power spectra as luminous galactic bhbs and agn in the observed frequency bandpass ( @xmath205@xmath206 hz ) . it is still unclear what suppresses short - term variability in one class but not the other . in galactic bhbs , high variability is often associated to non - thermal emission with steady jets ; low variability to thermal emission with no jets @xcite .    in the following , we select four ulxs in which interesting structures have been found in their power spectra , shown in figure  [ fig : psd ] .    _ m82 x-1 , also known as m82 x41.4 + 60 _  @xcite first discovered low frequency qpos around 54  mhz from the m82 galaxy with both _ xmm - newton _ and _ rxte _ observations . by fitting the _ xmm - newton _ images to its point spread function with known source positions from _ chandra _ , @xcite identified that m82 x-1 is the source that produced the qpos , and interestingly , it was not the brightest x - ray source in m82 at the time of qpo discovery . a following _ xmm - newton _ observation revealed that the qpos have changed the central frequency from 54  mhz to 114  mhz , above a flat - top component with a low frequency break at 34  mhz @xcite . @xcite also found that the qpos changed frequency from 107  mhz to 120  mhz during the second observation , and a plausible harmonic ratio of 1:2:3 for qpo frequencies with _ these qpos , however , were undetected with three _ xmm - newton _ observations of similar depth , suggestive of a spectral state transition @xcite .    _ ngc 5408 x-1 _  with a short _ xmm - newton _ observation , @xcite found the source is highly variable , and its power spectrum has a break at 2.5  mhz . @xcite reported the identification of narrow qpos around 20  mhz from the source , and confirmed the presence of the frequency break . the qpos are narrow and may show a pair with a 4:3 frequency ratio . a longer _ xmm - newton _ observation later detected the qpos at about 10  mhz and the energy spectral parameters of the source also changed @xcite . the qpo frequency was found to scale with the disk flux and also the spectral index of the power - law component . these correlations are analogous to that seen in galactic bhbs , suggesting that this ulx is in an emission state similar to sub - eddington sources . the qpo properties ( narrow , strong , with a flat - top continuum ) and the temporal - spectral evolution patterns suggest that the qpos are of type c and the compact object in ngc 5408 x-1 is an imbh . however , as the qpo frequency is not proportional to the break frequency of the continuum as expected , the identification as of type c was questioned and so was the imbh scenario @xcite ; they proposed that the source is super - eddington and the turbulence in the comptonization region gives rise to the observed variability . other authors have also rejected the imbh argument @xcite , pointing out that neither lower qpo frequencies nor larger , cooler disks can be used as indicators of higher bh masses in ulxs ; both findings may simply suggest that the visible inner radius of the disk has receded much further than the innermost stable orbit , and has been covered or replaced by a thick comptonizing region or outflow in the inner region . besides , @xcite also found that the source shows a linear correlation between the rms amplitude and flux , similar to that seen in bright bhbs and agn .    _ m82 x42.3 + 59 _  this is a transient ulx in m82 @xcite . it could not be detected by _ chandra _ in its low state , but sometimes , was even brighter than m82 x-1 , being the most luminous source in m82 @xcite . with _ chandra _ observations , and also confirmed by a simultaneous _ xmm - newton _ observation once , @xcite discovered low frequency qpos around 3 - 4  mhz in its power spectrum . these qpos are wide and strong , appear above white noise , and can only be detected when the source is brighter than @xmath19  . this is consistent with a type a or b classification , but is inconsistent with the properties of type c qpos .    _ ngc 6946 x-1 _  this source has the highest short - term variability found in a ulx , with a fractional rms amplitude of 60% integrated in the frequency range of 1 - 100  mhz @xcite . its power spectrum shows a flat - top continuum that breaks at about 3  mhz with possible quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) near 8.5  mhz .    ] the characteristic frequency alone usually is not a direct indicator of the bh mass , as these noise features can vary dramatically in a single source . however , correlations between the frequency and spectral parameters have been found , and the correlation patterns are thought to scale with the bh mass . the most common qpos seen in bhbs are of type c ( _ cf . the frequency of type c qpos are found to vary over a wide range . for example , the lowest detected frequencies in grs 1915 + 105 are around 1  mhz @xcite , even lower than the frequencies of all qpos detected in ulxs . a positive correlation between the qpo frequency and disk flux has been found for type c qpos in xte  j1550@xmath93564 , gro  j1655@xmath9340 and h  1743@xmath93322 @xcite . the qpo frequency also scales with the photon index of the power - law component in the energy spectrum ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? @xcite suggested that the qpo frequency scales inversely with the bh mass at a fixed power - law photon index , and thus one can infer the mass given spectral index @xcite . on the contrary , type a and b qpos show in a relatively narrow frequency range . the broad continuum seems to be a more reliable determinant of bh mass , as it is detected in both bhbs and agn and the scaling has been tested over a wide frequency and mass range . smbhs and agn appear to populate a `` variability plane '' defined by the bh mass , accretion rate , and @xmath207 , which is the frequency of the lower high - frequency lorentzian component in the power spectrum @xcite . limited by sensitivity , @xmath207 can not be detected in ulxs . based on a correlation between @xmath207 and the frequency of type c qpos , @xcite extended the variability plane to type c qpos that are visible in ulxs . the bh mass can be inferred from the x - ray luminosity ( here we adopt the radiatively efficient accretion case ) and type c qpo frequency as @xmath208 where the inequality is due to the unknown bolometric correction ( @xmath209 ) . although the `` variability plane '' is tested for a wide range of bh masses , the correlation between @xmath207 and @xmath210 has not been tested in ulxs and even the identification as of type c is questioned at least for ngc 5408 x-1 @xcite . attempts to scale bh mass with the variability amplitude ( rms ) have made great success in agn @xcite . however , it is found that ulxs are significantly less variable than agn , and a simple extrapolation could not be obtained @xcite . based on the correlations mentioned above , the bh masses inferred from the characteristic frequencies are all about @xmath184@xmath4  @xmath1 , indicating that ulxs contain imbhs . however , application of these mass scaling methods requires strong caveats . there are at least three problems . first , we are not sure whether the timing features detected in ulxs are the same type found to scale with bh masses in galactic bhbs ; for example , we are not sure whether the qpos in ngc 5408 x-1 are of type c @xcite . for other types of timing features ( _ e.g. _ , type a and b qpos ) , it is still not known whether their frequency is proportional to the bh mass @xcite . second , frequency - luminosity - mass relations have been calibrated and tested for galactic bhbs and agn in sub - eddington accretion , that is when the inner edge of the disk is constant or moves towards the innermost stable orbit as the accretion rate increases ( thus , increasing qpo frequencies ) . there is no empirical evidence that the scaling goes the same way in ulxs , which may be super - eddington systems where the visible inner edge of the disk recedes from the innermost stable orbit for increasing accretion rates ( thus , reducing qpo frequencies ) . the third problem is that we do not have enough signal - to - noise ratio to detect high - frequency qpos , which severely limits possibility of direct comparisons with galactic bhbs . in this section the `` optical counterpart '' refers to the point - like optical source that is spatially associated with the ulx ; sources with resolved structure , such as optical and radio nebulae , will be discussed in the next section . the optical emission from the counterpart could arise from the donor star or outer accretion disk , or both . it provides interesting information regarding the binary evolution history , nature of the donor star , disk geometry , and mode of mass transfer , and would also help constrain the bh mass . several groups have modeled x - ray irradiation in order to distinguish between the contributions of the outer disk and the donor star , and constrain the intrinsic stellar properties . @xcite applied their irradiation model to the photometric data for seven ulxs ; they suggested that donor stars are consistent with spectral type b or later , and the bh masses are in the range of @xmath0@xmath211 . @xcite computed evolution tracks of ulx counterparts on the color - magnitude diagram , assuming a massive companion orbiting an smbh or a msbh ; they applied their models to ngc1313 x-2 , suggesting a bh mass @xmath212@xmath211 . in addition to reproducing the observed colors and luminosity ( after accounting for irradiation and disk contribution ) , a donor star in a ulx must be able to supply a mass accretion rate @xmath213 yr@xmath12 , which requires roche lobe overflow , and to do it over a sufficiently long period of time to explain the observed number of ulxs per galaxy . binary population synthesis models have been developed and used to address this problem @xcite . modeling the binary evolution requires calculations of the mass transfer rate , the corresponding change in orbital separation , and the subsequent fate of the transferred mass . this in turn depends critically on whether we impose a strict eddington limit on the mass transfer rate that can be accepted by the bh ( with the rest being expelled in a wind ) , or instead we assume that the bh can accrete at higher rates . thus , for the same kind of donor star , the outcome in terms of x - ray luminosity and lifetime is very different depending on whether the primary is an eddington - limited stellar bh , a non - eddington - limited stellar bh , or an imbh . @xcite considered three characteristic families of binary evolution tracks , with different bh mass distributions : @xmath214@xmath10 , @xmath214@xmath215 , and a single - mass population of @xmath216 bhs . they built probability diagrams in different slices of parameter space ( optical color - magnitude diagram ; orbital period versus potential x - ray luminosity ; x - ray luminosity versus age ) , representing the total time spent by all the systems in those regions of parameter space . their main conclusion is that the most probable ulx system parameters correspond to high - mass donors ( @xmath217 ) , with orbital period between 1 and 10 days and characteristic age @xmath218 yr . in terms of bh mass , they found that both the @xmath216 bh population , and that with non - eddington - limited bhs up @xmath219 were consistent with the optical and x - ray observations and with the observed number of ulxs per galaxy ; the @xmath220@xmath211 bh mass range has not been tested yet . thanks to the sub - arcsecond resolution of _ chandra _ and _ hst _ , the optical counterparts of more than a dozen ulxs have been identified . these are done mainly by aligning _ chandra _ and _ hst _ images using objects with emission on both , to reduce the _ chandra _ x - ray position error from 0.6  to about 0.20.4 . @xcite collected all available data in the _ hst _ archive to investigate the optical properties of 13 ulxs , which can be summarized as follows . a.   the x - ray to optical flux ratios and optical colors are consistent with that of lmxbs , but unlike hmxbs or agn . this indicates that the optical emission from ulxs is mainly due to reprocessing of x - rays on the outer accretion disk . as a consequence , one can not infer the spectral type of the companion star using optical colors directly . b.   the broad band optical spectrum can be generally fitted with a power - law model ( @xmath221 ) . the distribution of the spectral index @xmath118 peaks between 1 and 2 , which is also consistent with disk irradiation models . c.   the counterpart has unique optical properties within its neighborhood . nearby sources usually show a blackbody spectrum instead of a power - law spectrum . d.   the optical emitting region is estimated to be large , of the order of @xmath222  cm , indicative of long binary periods ( @xmath109  days ) for smbh or msbh primaries , or shorter periods for imbhs . e.   sources with multiple observations usually show strong , random variability on both magnitudes and colors . there are a few outliers showing peculiar properties . the optical spectra of ngc 2403 x-1 and m83 ixo 82 have a slope consistent with that of the standard disk emission , @xmath223 . m101 ulx-1 and m81 uls1 are more similar to hmxbs than lmxbs in terms of x - ray to optical flux ratios . ic 342 x-1 may show a blackbody - like spectrum instead of a power - law . more details can be found in @xcite . there have been a lot of observational efforts to determine the nature of the companion stars in nearby ulxs . so far , ngc 7793 p13 is the only ulx in which emission from the companion star is directly seen beyond reasonable doubt @xcite ; detection of narrow emission lines identifies the companion star as a late - b type supergiant with a mass @xmath79 . orbital periods may have been detected in a few sources . assuming roche - lobe overflow , the companion density can be simply determined from the binary period , @xmath224  g  cm@xmath121 @xcite . m82 x-1 is the strongest case of a positive detection ; a monitoring program with _ rxte _ revealed a steady period of about 62  day @xcite , corresponding to a companion density of @xmath226  g  cm@xmath121 . @xcite discovered a 115  day x - ray period from ngc 5408 x-1 with _ swift _ monitoring , and inferred a similar companion density of @xmath227  g  cm@xmath121 ; however , the interpretation of that modulation as a binary period has been disputed @xcite . these claimed long periods imply an evolved donor star . possible detections include a 6.1 day period from ngc 1313 x-2 with _ hst _ observations @xcite ; however , low significance of the period was claimed by other groups @xcite . m82 x-1 is located near or within a super star - cluster mcg-11 with an age of 7 - 12 myr @xcite . ngc 1073 ixo 5 appears near a ring of star formation of 816 myr old @xcite . ngc 1313 x-2 is found near a star cluster with an age of 20  myr @xcite . ic 342 x-1 lies in a field with relatively old stellar objects , mostly older than 10  myr @xcite . the stellar field around ngc 1313 x-1 is at least 30  myr old @xcite . holmberg ix x-1 is suggested to be part of a loose cluster with an age @xmath115  myr @xcite . all those findings suggest that ulxs are in relatively old stellar environments with ages of at least 10  myr . an exceptional case is provided by a transient ulx recently discovered in m83 @xcite . it is located in an interarm region with a stellar population older than @xmath228 yr . _ hst _ observations when the system was probably in quiescence constrain the donor star to be @xmath229 . instead , _ observations during the recent outburst revealed a bright , blue counterpart with absolute @xmath230 magnitude @xmath231 , due to the irradiated outer disk and/or irradiated donor star . identification of the optical counterparts to ulxs is the first step for a potential dynamical mass measurement . @xcite found that the broad he ii @xmath232 line from ngc 1313 x-2 changed its velocity by about 380  km  s@xmath12 between two observations . if this is due to binary motion of the disk , an upper limit on the bh mass of 50  @xmath1 can be placed . there have been a few attempts to obtain the mass function of a few ulxs using emission - line velocity curves . however , the lines were found to vary randomly instead of showing an ellipsoidal modulation ; thus , they did not provide dynamical constraints on the bh masses @xcite . the orbital period is a key parameter for dynamical mass measurement . with current facilities , it may be more feasible to search for orbital periods in x - rays and then confirm them in optical for extragalactic sources , like the cases of m33 x-7 and ic 10 x-1 . we naturally expect ulxs to ionize the surrounding interstellar medium ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) for the basic principles of x - ray ionization . the main difference between uv ionized h@xmath119ii regions and x - ray ionized nebulae is the lack , in the latter , of a sharp boundary ( strmgren sphere ) between the ionized and neutral plasma @xcite . instead , there is an extended warm region where weakly ionized atoms coexist with collisionally excited neutral species . as a result , an x - ray ionized nebula is characterized by high - ionization emission lines such as he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 and [ o@xmath119iv ] at 25.89 @xmath234 m in the inner regions , and low - ionization forbidden lines such as [ o@xmath119i ] @xmath2336300 in the outer regions . in particular , he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 acts as a photon counter of the ionizing flux between 54 ev and @xmath235 ev @xcite . by comparing the true source flux inferred from the he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 line with the apparent flux measured at energies @xmath236 ev with _ chandra _ or _ xmm - newton _ , we can test whether the x - ray emission is isotropic or beamed . the n159f nebula , powered by the smbh lmc x-1 , is the best - known example of a large - scale ( @xmath0 pc ) x - ray ionized nebula in galactic systems @xcite . @xcite opened a new field with their systematic search for similar nebulae around ulxs . they found a spectacular case around the ulx in m81 group dwarf galaxy holmberg ii . the holmberg ii x-1 ionized nebula ( now known as `` foot nebula '' ) has a he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 luminosity @xmath237@xmath238 erg s@xmath12 @xcite , 30 times higher than the lmc x-1 nebula , which implies an average in the nebula , estimated as @xmath239 yr @xcite . ] ionizing x - ray flux @xmath240@xmath241 erg s@xmath12 . this result has been confirmed by further optical / infrared spectroscopic studies @xcite . on the other hand , the apparent x - ray luminosity of holmberg ii x-1 has been seen to vary over the years between @xmath17 a few @xmath16 erg s@xmath12 and @xmath242 erg s@xmath12 @xcite . the consistency between the two independent measurements gives the strongest evidence to date that beaming is negligible ( @xmath243 ) for this ulx ; this favors models with relatively large bh masses ( section [ sec : bh ] ) . similar arguments have also been applied to the photoionization - dominated nebula around ngc 5408 x-1 . from the flux in high - ionization lines such as he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 and [ ne@xmath119v ] @xmath2333426 , @xcite inferred a lower limit on the isotropic x - ray luminosity @xmath244 erg s@xmath12 , only a factor of 3 lower than the directly measured x - ray luminosity . as in holmberg ii x-1 , this suggests that beaming factor is @xmath245 . more examples of x - ray ionized nebulae in ulxs are reported by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite , although in those cases the interpretation is more model dependent , because the observed line spectra are a mix of photo - ionized and shock - ionized plasma emission . +     +    it is often hard to distinguish between x - ray photoionization and shock excitation , for ulx nebulae  just as it is generally difficult to separate the contribution of a starburst nucleus and/or a low - luminosity agn in a liner . diagnostic diagrams with several line ratios are computed with shock and photoionization codes such as mappings iii @xcite and cloudy @xcite . shock - ionized plasma is characterized by high ratios of low - excitation lines such as [ o@xmath119i ] @xmath246 [ s@xmath119ii ] @xmath247,@xmath248 and [ n@xmath119ii ] @xmath249,@xmath250 over h@xmath118 . for shock velocities @xmath251@xmath252 km s@xmath12 , the high - ionization , forbidden transitions [ o@xmath119iii ] @xmath253,@xmath254 are strong ( [ o@xmath119iii ] @xmath233 5007/h@xmath255 for @xmath256 km s@xmath12 ) , while he@xmath119ii @xmath2334686 indicates @xmath257 km s@xmath12 @xcite . the luminosity in the h@xmath258 line is only a function of the total shock power @xmath259 and shock velocity @xcite ; for typical speeds @xmath260@xmath261 km s@xmath12 , @xmath262@xmath263 .    supershells were first found around ngc 6946 mf 16 @xcite and holmberg ix x-1 @xcite , and were initially speculated to be powered by unusually energetic sn remnants . the x - ray emission could not be from the nebulae , because of its variability @xcite . following the pioneering work of @xcite , several more huge shock - ionized nebulae have been identified around ulxs ( `` ulx bubbles '' , see figure  [ fig : bubble ] for examples ) , with characteristic diameter @xmath264@xmath265 pc , expansion velocity @xmath260@xmath266 km s@xmath12 , characteristic age @xmath267@xmath206 myr , mechanical power @xmath268@xmath19 erg s@xmath12 ( independently determined from the bubble expansion speed and from the h@xmath258 luminosity ; @xcite ) and energy content @xmath269 erg @xcite . the two best - studied examples are the bubbles around ngc 1313 x-2 and holmberg ix x-1 @xcite . ulx bubbles resemble ordinary sn remnants , but are an order of magnitude larger and 10 to 100 times more luminous . they can not come from ( hypothetical ) single hypernova explosions : first , because the surrounding stellar populations are already too old ( typically @xmath270 yr ) and without o stars ; secondly , because it is unlikely that a lower - mass binary companion that survived the hypothetical hypernova explosion could evolve to fill its roche lobe and feed the ulx already within @xmath271 myr @xcite . invoking 10 to 100 ordinary sn explosions over the last 1 myr would require a massive star cluster with @xmath272 a few @xmath273 ( _ e.g. _ , from starburst99 ; @xcite ) . however , none of those ulxs is associated with a massive star cluster : at most , they are inside ordinary ob associations with age @xmath0@xmath108 myr and total stellar mass @xmath92 . the only plausible conclusion is that ulx bubbles are inflated by a continuous jet or outflow from the ulx , with a power comparable to the radiative output @xcite . jet - inflated bubbles around accreting bhs are found in our galaxy , too . the best - known example is the w50 nebula around ss433 @xcite : a spherical shell with two lateral extensions , the ears , that are inflated by interaction of the jets with the interstellar medium . the characteristic diameter along the major axis is @xmath152 pc . both the jet power and the radiative luminosity are @xmath13 erg s@xmath12 . indeed , it is suggested that ss433 would appear as a beamed , super - eddington ulx if it was seen face - on @xcite . another local example is the 5-pc bubble inflated by the smbh cygnus x-1 @xcite : the shock velocity determined from optical emission line ratios is @xmath260@xmath274 km s@xmath12 ; the required jet power @xmath275 erg s@xmath12 is @xmath276@xmath206 times the x - ray luminosity . the ulx bubbles discovered so far have a quasi - spherical appearance , with no direct signature of relativistic , collimated jets ( as in the galactic source ss433 ) . the first extra - galactic super - bubble with collimated jets was recently found in the outskirts of the spiral galaxy ngc7793 @xcite . this source ( figure  [ fig : bubble ] ) , known as s26 , has : x - ray and optical hot spots where the jet and counter - jet interact with the interstellar medium ; an optical nebula with a size of @xmath277 pc , expanding at @xmath278 km s@xmath12 ; an associated x - ray and radio nebula with bright radio lobes . the long - term - average jet power @xmath17 a few @xmath19 erg s@xmath12 @xcite , over a characteristic age @xmath279 yrs . the x - ray luminosity of the central bh is only @xmath280 erg s@xmath12 . this might be because the bh emission is highly obscured and we only see a scattered component ; or because it is beamed away from us ; or because the bh is a transient , currently in a radiative - faint state , but may appear as a ulx at other times . whatever the reason for the current radiative dimness , it is important to note that ngc7793 s26 has had collimated jets with a long - term average power at least of order of the eddington power ( and probably much greater ) of a stellar bh ( smbh or msbh ) . in other words , it is a jet - dominated system at super - eddington mass accretion rates . there is no physical principle that prevents mechanical power to exceed the eddington luminosity . however , the fact that it is collimated in a large - scale jet may be surprising . the canonical view @xcite of bh accretion states  based mostly on the behavior of galactic transients  is that collimated , steady jets are found at @xmath281 , when accretion is radiatively inefficient ( low / hard state ) . whether and how steady , collimated jets can be launched during super - eddington accretion phases remains an unsolved theoretical problem . a possible solution comes from the radiation - magnetohydrodynamic simulations of @xcite , who find that a jet can be accelerated up to mildly relativistic speed by radiation pressure , and collimated by the lorentz force of a magnetic tower made of wound - up toroidal magnetic field lines . the magnetic structure is itself kept collimated by the geometrically thick accretion flow that dominates in the innermost region when @xmath282 . an ultrapowerful ( rather than ultraluminous ) system such as ngc7793 s26 is the local - universe analog of a recently discovered class of quasars , dominated by mechanical power @xcite . in those quasars , the jet power is up to 25 times higher than the bolometric radiative luminosity ; in some of those systems , the jet power is near or above the eddington power . mechanically - dominated , radiatively inefficient quasars in the early universe may grow much faster than eddington - limited sources , and would provide strong mechanical rather than radiative feedback onto the surrounding gas . thus , understanding the inflow / outflow / radiation processes in ulxs has wider astrophysical relevance . moreover , radiative and mechanical feedback from hmxbs and ulxs themselves may have been an additional , important source of heating and reionization of the intergalactic medium at high redshifts @xcite .      some ulx bubbles ( from both the photoionized and shock - ionized variety ) are associated to extended radio emission . the best - studied examples are holmberg ii x-1 @xcite and ngc5408 x-1 @xcite . both radio nebulae are dominated by optically thin synchrotron emission , somewhat similar but much larger ( @xmath283 pc and @xmath284 pc , respectively ) and more luminous than typical radio sn remnants . they are also an order of magnitude more luminous than the radio nebula around ss433 @xcite , which well matches the relative values of radiative and mechanical core power in those sources . the total power carried by synchrotron - emitting electrons has been estimated to be between @xmath17 a few @xmath285 erg s@xmath12 and @xmath286 erg s@xmath12 , depending on the very uncertain lower - energy cut - off of the distribution . in any case , both nebulae are much more energetic than w50 around ss433 ( @xmath17 a few @xmath287 erg s@xmath12 : @xcite ) or than the extended lobes of typical galactic microquasars such as grs1758@xmath93258 ( @xmath288 erg s@xmath12 ; @xcite ) . ngc7793 s26 also has a large radio nebula @xcite , interpreted as a combination of flat - spectrum free - free emission ( mostly in the central region ) and steep - spectrum synchrotron emission from the radio hot spots and lobes . the energy stored in relativistic electrons is @xmath17 a few @xmath289 erg s@xmath12 . the energy content in relativistic electrons for typical ulx nebulae is only @xmath290@xmath291 of the core power  in particular , of the mechanical power when it can be reliably estimated from bubble size or optical line fluxes  integrated over the characteristic age of the bubble . the main reason is that most of the input energy is transferred to non - relativistic electrons , protons and nuclei @xcite . the fraction of energy in non - radiating particles to that in relativistic electrons in a system such as ngc7793 s26 is similar to the values found by @xcite for a sample of agn , seyfert and giant elliptical galaxies . for the same jet power , agn , ulxs and galactic microquasars may be radio louder or radio quieter depending on the amount of plasma entrained by the jets . we speculate that an interesting test may come from comparisons of the radio loudness and lobe energy in low / hard state microquasars , probably dominated by magnetically accelerated jets @xcite , and in ulxs , possibly dominated by radiation - pressure accelerated jets / outflows @xcite , with more entrainment . there is no doubt that our understanding of the phenomenology of ulxs has greatly advanced in the past decade thanks to _ chandra _ , _ xmm - newton _ , and many other space- and ground - based facilities . however , the key physical issue is still unresolved : that is , whether they are powered by imbhs or normal stellar bhs . a few sources have emerged as strong imbh candidates : in particular , eso243@xmath9349 hlx-1 and m82 x-1 . on the other hand , for the majority of ulxs , there is no strong theoretical need nor compelling observational evidence for imbhs . in the absence of direct mass - function measurements from phase - resolved optical spectroscopy , we still have to rely on x - ray spectral and timing modeling and other indirect clues . reviewing the results that we have collected here , we suggest the following conservative statement :    _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ulxs are a diverse population ; msbhs with moderate super - eddington accretion seem to be the easiest solution to account for most sources up to luminosities @xmath17 a few @xmath19 erg s@xmath12 ; strong beaming ( @xmath292 ) can be ruled out for the majority of ulxs ; imbhs are preferred in a few exceptional cases . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _    some of the following kinds of observations may provide further breakthroughs :    a.   measurements of the fast timing behavior down to a time scale of sub - seconds may probe the inner part of the inflow : ideally , we would search for possible high frequency features ( breaks and qpos ) that are found in galactic bhs at frequencies @xmath82 hz . this would require a new generation of x - ray telescopes with large effective area . b.   determining the relative contribution of thermal emission and comptonization component is a key test for competing accretion models . for that , multilayer - coated x - ray telescopes with good sensitivity up to a few tens of kev are needed . c.   detection of , or a more solid upper limit to broad iron k lines may constrain the properties of the inner disk . d.   high - resolution x - ray spectroscopy with gratings or microcalorimeters may constrain the metal abundance and ionization state of the inflow , the mass and energy of the outflow , and probe the absorption from the surrounding interstellar medium . e.   the ulx sample within @xmath293 mpc is almost complete , and it does not contain enough sources to permit statistical studies of the luminosity distribution above @xmath294 a few @xmath58 erg s@xmath12 . a homogeneous all - sky survey , complete for ulxs up to @xmath212 mpc would allow us to determine whether or not the luminosity distribution extends unbroken up to at least @xmath18 erg s@xmath12 . such survey will hopefully be successfully conducted by _ erosita _ ; f.   repeated snapshot monitoring of nearby ulxs over the next few years will extend their long - term lightcurves enough to prove that their duty cycles and transient behavior are different from those of galactic bhs . this can be easily done with smaller x - ray missions ; g.   phase - resolved spectroscopy would lead to the measurement of radial velocity curves and mass functions . attempts to do so with 8-m class telescopes have so far been inconclusive but have suggested that it will be easily done with future 30-m class telescopes ; h.   integral - field spectroscopic studies of star forming galaxies , as well as low - frequency radio studies , may reveal fainter , older ulx bubbles or lobes , still expanding into the interstellar medium but no longer energized by a central source . this would constrain the duration of the ulx active phase ; i.   searching for compact radio jets down to a sensitivity of @xmath295jy will constrain the bh mass , in relation to other classes of accreting bhs in the fundamental plane . this may be done in the near future with the _ evla _ and with _ ska _ pathfinders , and in the more distant future with the ska itself .    in conclusion , we gather from this list that there is more than one way to skin a cat . many fundamental aspects of ulx physics will be understood with instruments already planned or under construction . thus , we anticipate a fruitful decade of ulx studies beyond the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ era . we thank andy fabian , sean farrell , luigi foschini , fabien gris , phil kaaret , kip kuntz , manfred pakull , tim roberts , mat servillat , tod strohmayer , doug swartz , dany vanbeveren , and luca zampieri for helpful discussions and comments . hf acknowledges funding support from the national natural science foundation of china under grant no . 10903004 and 10978001 , the 973 program of china under grant 2009cb824800 , the foundation for the author of national excellent doctoral dissertation of china under grant 200935 , the tsinghua university initiative scientific research program , and the program for new century excellent talents in university . rs acknowledges support from a curtin university senior research fellowship , and hospitality at the mullard space science laboratory , tsinghua university and the university of sydney during part of this work . , f. , pakull , m.  w. , soria , r. , & motch , c. 2009 , in american institute of physics conference series , vol . 1126 , american institute of physics conference series , ed . j.  rodriguez & p.  ferrando , 201203                                                                                , m.  w. , & gris , f. 2008 , in american institute of physics conference series , vol . 1010 , a population explosion : the nature & evolution of x - ray binaries in diverse environments , ed . r.  m.  bandyopadhyay , s.  wachter , d.  gelino , & c.  r.  gelino , 303307                            , a.  h. , galache , j. , kalogara , v. , linden , t. , kilgard , r. , zezas , a. , wolter , a. , & trinchieri , g. 2010 , in bulletin of the american astronomical society , vol . 36 , american astronomical society meeting abstracts # 215
Abstract:

Answer: ultraluminous x - ray sources ( ulxs ) are accreting black holes that may contain the missing population of intermediate mass black holes or reflect super - eddington accretion physics . ten years of _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations of ulxs , integrated by multiband studies of their counterparts , have produced a wealth of observational data and phenomenological classifications . we review the properties of their host galaxies , list popular spectral models and implications for standard and supercritical accretion physics , demonstrate how x - ray timing of these objects places constraints on their masses . we also review multiwavelength studies of ulxs , including the optical emission of the binary system and nebulosity around them . we summarize that three classes of black holes could power ulxs : normal stellar mass black holes ( @xmath0  @xmath1 ) , massive stellar black holes ( @xmath2  @xmath1 ) , and intermediate mass black holes ( @xmath3@xmath4  @xmath1 ) . we collect evidence for the presence of these three types of compact objects , including caveat of each interpretation , and briefly review their formation processes . ultraluminous x - ray sources , ultrapowerful sources , intermediate mass black holes , super - eddington accretion , slim disk .