Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: the formation mechanism of compact objects , neutron stars ( nss ) and black holes ( bhs ) , is an unsolved problem in high - energy astrophysics . a model for the formation of such objects requires to perform physically - motivated simulations of the core - collapse supernova , which is computationally challenging ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . another possible way to investigate the formation of nss and bhs is to study the birth and evolution of x - ray binaries ( xrbs ) hosting a bh or a ns accreting from a stellar companion . the orbital parameters , peculiar velocities and galactic position of these binaries directly follow from their evolutionary history , and are affected in particular by the conditions at the moment of compact object formation ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) .    the measurement of pulsar proper motions ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) , combined with the study of ns - xrbs ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , has exposed evidence that some nss receive a low velocity , whereas others a high velocity at formation ( so called _ natal kicks _ , nks ) . the prevailing idea is that nss are formed either in a standard core - collapse supernova ( sn ) , or in a less energetic type of sn expected for star with small cores . the latter can take place either as an electron - capture sn or as an iron core - collapse sn with a small iron - core mass ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . for the case of bhs , observations are rather scarce and patchy , thus it is not yet possible to discriminate between different models of bh formation ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . in this paper , one of our goals is to investigate whether the observed galactic distribution of xrbs hosting a bh ( bh - xrbs ) can reveal something about how bhs are formed . the main underlying idea is that any offset of a bh - xrb from the galactic plane ( assumed as birth place ) is a signature of some peculiar velocity of the system with respect to the circular galactic motion . the magnitude of such velocity gives clues on the sn mechanism , in particular on the magnitude of the nk at birth ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the idea of using the galactic position and/or line of sight velocities of a population of xrbs to investigate the formation of compact objects was employed previously for the ns case ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . + we covered the topic of bh formation in two previous works . in  @xcite , we followed the galactic trajectories of a simulated population of bh - xrbs , and investigated which nk distribution gives rise to the observed @xmath0-distribution of bh - xrbs ( where @xmath0 is the height above the galactic plane ) . the aim was to discriminate between _ high _ and _ reduced _ nks for bhs . high nks are larger than the nk expected in a standard formation scenario for bhs , in which the bh forms via fallback of material on to the proto - ns and the nk is caused by asymmetries in the sn ejecta . in the standard scenario , the nk would conserve the linear - momentum and roughly scale as the nk received by the ns multiplied by the ratio between the mass of the bh and the mass of the ns . we call these kicks as _ reduced _ or _ momentum - conserving _ nks . if the ns receives a nk of the order of @xmath1 km / s , a @xmath2 bh would get a nk of @xmath3 km / s . we define _ high _ nks as @xmath4 km / s . in  @xcite , we found that high nks , comparable to ns nks , were required . in  @xcite , we combined the information from the kinematics and binary evolution of a subset of bh - xrbs to find evidence both for low and high nks . in this paper , we aim at complementing and extending those previous studies . following up on the work by @xcite and @xcite , @xcite found that the root - mean - square ( rms ) value of the height above the galactic plane of bh - xrbs is similar to that of ns - xrbs , suggesting that bhs could also receive a _ high _ kick at formation , or even one as high as nss . in this work , we develop this idea further . we build synthetic populations of bh- and ns - xrbs and we model their binary evolution and their kinematics in the galaxy , to investigate whether different assumptions on compact object formation ( such as a different distribution for the nk and/or a different amount of mass ejected in the sn ) have an imprint on the observed galactic distribution of bh- and ns - xrbs , and we quantify these effects . furthermore , we will dedicate part of this work to discuss a method we previously employed to calculate the minimum peculiar velocity at birth of individual bh - xrbs ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the difference of the galactic potential value between the observed position @xmath5 and its projection on to the galactic plane was used to analytically derive a lower limit for the peculiar velocity at birth . this method has been recently challenged by @xcite . we investigate how robust our estimate is , i.e. how close this estimate is to the true value of the minimal peculiar velocity at birth , how this estimate scales with the distance from the galactic centre , and how it varies for different choices of the galactic potential . + the paper is structured as follows . in section [ sec : estimate ] we study our estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth of individual bh - xrbs . in section [ sec : bps ] we build synthetic populations of bh- and ns - xrbs for different assumptions on the compact object formation . in section [ sec : results ] we look at the galactic distributions of these synthetic binaries while investigating how they differ , and inferring which nk distribution fits best the observed galactic position of ns- and bh - xrbs . in section [ sec : discussion ] we discuss our findings and in section [ sec : conclusion ] we draw our conclusions . 0.33     0.33     0.33 xrbs are thought to originate from binary progenitors born in the galactic plane , the birth - place of most massive stars ( @xcite ) . when the compact object forms , the binary typically acquires a peculiar velocity . the mass ejection in the sn imparts a recoil velocity to the binary ; the nk adds up vectorially to this velocity , giving the total peculiar velocity of the binary , @xmath6 . such a systemic velocity adds up vectorially to the local galactic rotation and probably has no preferential orientation . the full 3d velocity is measured only for a handful of bh - xrbs ( see @xcite ) . for these , the integration of the orbit backwards in time can in principle provide an estimate for @xmath6 at birth . however , uncertainty in the distance and differences in the galactic potential can prevent a unique determination of the initial position ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . when the full 3d peculiar velocity is not known , one can estimate @xmath6 at birth using a simple model . for an object located at galactic height @xmath0 : the distance from the galactic centre , and @xmath0 : the height above the galactic plane . ] , we expect a trajectory purely perpendicular to the plane to be the one which minimises the initial @xmath6 . in our previous works @xcite and  @xcite , we estimated the minimum peculiar velocity at birth of a bh - xrb employing energy conservation along such trajectory , and assuming that the maximum height @xmath0 from the plane is the observed one . we get : @xmath7 } ,       \label{eq : estimate}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is a model for the galactic potential , @xmath9 is the measured distance of the binary from the galactic centre projected on to the galactic plane , and @xmath0 is the current height above the plane . recently @xcite argued that the difference in the gravitational potential between the observed location and its projection on to the galactic plane is not an accurate estimate of the required minimum peculiar velocity at birth . he suggests that there are always possible trajectories different from a purely perpendicular one which require a lower @xmath10 at birth than the one estimated through equation [ eq : estimate ] to reach the same offset from the galactic plane . we check the validity of our estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth , @xmath11 , for high-@xmath0 sources , performing a monte carlo simulation using the python package for galactic dynamics ( @xcite ) . we simulate @xmath12 points , whose initial conditions are set as follows : 1 ) the initial position is at @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is uniformly distributed between @xmath15 and @xmath16 kpc ; 2 ) the initial peculiar velocity @xmath17 is uniform between @xmath15 and @xmath18 km / s ; 3 ) the orientation of this velocity is uniformly distributed over a sphere . we note that since we are only interested in the minimum value of @xmath17 , the shape of the assumed velocity distribution is not important . we add the circular motion in the galactic disc to the 3d peculiar velocity @xmath6 . we integrate the orbits in the galaxy for @xmath19 gyr , using a 4th - order runge - kutta integrator , and we check for conservation of energy over the trajectory making sure that the relative error on the energy is less than @xmath20 at the final step . we record the positions @xmath21 @xmath18 times over the orbit sampling from constant time steps , along with the initial peculiar velocity @xmath17 . from the simulated points , we select only those ones located at @xmath22 at the sampled times , to represent high-@xmath0 sources . we perform the simulation for three different choices of the galactic potential : model 2 of , @xcite , and the potential from @xcite , which are all multi - component potentials consisting of disc , bulge , and halo . the @xcite potential is made up of two miyamoto - nagai potentials for disc and bulge , and one pseudo - isothermal potential for the halo . the @xcite potential is made up of a power - law density profile with an exponential cut - off for the bulge , a miyamoto - nagai potential for the disc , and a navarro - frenk - white profile for the halo . the potential is composed of two miyamoto - nagai potentials and a wilkinson - evans potential for the halo . we show the rotation curve of each of the three potentials in figure [ fig : rotcurve ] . is the potential used by @xcite ; @xcite is the one we adopted in @xcite ; the is a realistic model for the milky way potential favoured by @xcite . we present the results of this simulation in figure [ fig : density ] . the red line is our estimate for the peculiar velocity taking @xmath23 kpc in equation [ eq : estimate ] and it follows the lower edge of the simulated points . figure [ fig : density ] shows that our analytical estimate ( eq . [ eq : estimate ] ) successfully describes the value and trend of the minimal peculiar velocity as a function of the galactocentric distance .    in order to better quantify the goodness of our estimator @xmath11 , we compute the ratio @xmath24 using @xmath25 kpc - wide bins in @xmath26 , for those points which reach a height above the galactic plane along their orbit in the range @xmath27 kpc . the velocity @xmath17 is the actual initial peculiar velocity which we showed in figure [ fig : density ] . we plot @xmath28 in figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] , for the three different potentials . @xmath11 is an excellent estimator for @xmath29 kpc , since at these radii @xmath28 is equal or greater than @xmath25 . it is less robust in the inner part of the bulge for the @xcite and potentials , but not in the potential , that is fit to the most recent dynamical constraints on the milky way and has a more realistic bulge model ( jo bovy , private communication ) . in the bulge region , our estimate is steeper than the real minimal peculiar velocity for the first two potentials , i.e. , it varies strongly for small variation in @xmath26 . this can be seen in figure [ fig : andrei ] , where for every position @xmath21 we show as a density map the real minimal peculiar velocity at birth necessary to reach that position . we integrated @xmath30 orbits for @xmath19 gyr and using as potential the one in . the contour lines show our analytical estimate @xmath11 ; the discrepancy between the two velocities is evident in the inner region of the galaxy . figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] also show an increase of the average value of @xmath28 with larger distances @xmath26 . this is an artefact caused by our choice of the @xmath17 initial distribution ( uniform between @xmath31 km / s ) , as the numerator in the ratio @xmath28 can take all the values between @xmath32 and @xmath18 km / s .    from our extensive analysis , we find that the estimate @xmath33 accurately represents the real minimal value for the peculiar velocity at distances from the galactic centre @xmath34 kpc , and can be safely applied to estimate the peculiar velocity at birth of xrbs born in the galactic plane .     of simulated points which reach that position @xmath21 . the contour lines show our analytical estimate @xmath11 at that position . the estimate differs strongly from the real value in the bulge region ( each solid line differs by @xmath35 km / s from the closest - neighbouring one ) . the potential used is from . ] the estimate @xmath11 is a function of the potential used , in particular in the bulge , as can be seen in figure [ fig : difference ] , where we show @xmath11 for the @xcite , and @xcite potentials , and assuming @xmath23 kpc in eq . [ eq : estimate ] . additionally , from figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] , we note that the fraction of systems with @xmath36 in the region @xmath37 $ ] kpc also strongly depends on the potential . the minimum values @xmath38 are : @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 for @xcite , , @xcite potential respectively , where these lower limits are defined such that @xmath42 of the points in the same bin have a value larger than the lower limit . figure [ fig : density ] also shows that the galactic bulge ( @xmath43 kpc ) is much less populated ( an order of magnitude fewer systems than in regions at larger distance from the galactic center ) . there are two reasons for this : i ) the bulge volume is small ; ii ) it is unlikely for a binary born in the galactic disc to overcome the strong potential well in its motion towards the galactic bulge . the inaccuracy of our analytical estimate in the bulge region affects only the source h1705 - 250 , which is the only bh - xrb located close enough to the galactic centre ( see table [ tab : systems ] ) , at @xmath44 kpc ( @xcite ) . without a measurement of its 3d peculiar velocity , it is impossible to discriminate between a birth in the disc or a birth in the bulge ( hence close to its observed position ) . more in general , bulge sources are not suitable for estimating the peculiar velocities at birth , since the current view on bulge formation is that it was not formed in situ . the bulge population is thought to come from the disc through dynamical instabilities ( @xcite ) , with most of its mass coming from major and minor merger events with satellite galaxies ( @xcite ) . + we compute the minimum peculiar velocity at birth for the seven short - period bh - xrbs studied by @xcite , using the three galactic potentials ( see table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . we add to this sample two other short - period bh - xrbs which we did not consider in @xcite ( xte j1650 - 500 and xte j1859 + 226 ) , due to the lack of a strong constraint on the bh mass ( @xcite ) . for h 1705 - 250 , we put in parenthesis the velocity @xmath11 multiplied by the factor @xmath28 found above . c c c c + source & bovy & pac . & irrgang & repetto et al . + & & & & 2015 + xte j1118 + 480 & 62 & 70 & 68 & 72 + gro j0422 + 32 & 20 & 25 & 22 & 25 + grs 1009 - 45 & 34 & 40 & 37 & 41 + 1a 0620 - 00 & 8 & 10 & 8 & 10 + gs 2000 + 251 & 12 & 15 & 12 & 15 + nova mus 91 & 44 & 51 & 46 & 52 + h 1705 - 250 & 259 ( 262 ) & 363 ( 158 ) & 350 ( 186 ) & 402 + xte j1650 - 500 & 17 & 21 & 16 & - + xte j1859 + 226 & 61 & 68 & 68 & - +    we have found an error in the halo component of the @xcite potential that we used for the computation of @xmath11 in  @xcite . this mostly affects the bulge source h 1705 - 250 , whereas the other six sources are not greatly affected ( compare third and last column in table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . accounting for the thickness of the galactic disc instead of assuming a birth place at @xmath45 does not significantly affect the minimal peculiar velocity ( see @xcite ) . @xcite used the source h 1705 - 250 to conclude that the difference in the galactic potential between the observed position and the projection of this position on to the galactic plane is not a conservative estimate of the minimal initial velocity of the binary . they show an example of a trajectory for h 1705 - 250 which starts from the galactic plane and ends at the observed position for an initial velocity of @xmath46 km / s , lower than the value provided by eq . [ eq : estimate ] ( see table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . we agree with his conclusion , but only as far as sources close ( or in ) the bulge are concerned . on the contrary , for sources located at @xmath47 kpc , our analytical estimate perfectly matches the real minimal velocity . in @xcite we used the high minimal velocity at birth for xte j1118 + 480 and h 1705 - 250 to claim that at least two out of the seven bh - xrbs we considered were consistent with a high ( or relatively high ) nk . this holds true with our current revision of the minimal velocities at birth , and we find another bh - xrb that is potentially consistent with a relatively high nk : xte j1859 + 226 . the velocities we have been dealing so far with are _ minimal _ velocities , and do not necessarily correspond to _ expected _ ( _ realistic _ ) velocities . in what follows , we study the latter .     for the peculiar velocity at birth as a function of the distance from the galactic centre @xmath26 ( projected on to the galactic plane ) for the three different galactic potentials used in this work : @xcite ( dashed line ) , @xcite ( dotted line ) , ( solid line ) . we assumed @xmath23 kpc . ] in this part of the work , instead of dealing with the minimal peculiar velocities , we deal with the expected peculiar velocities . we perform a binary population synthesis study of bh- and ns - xrbs , starting just before the bh / ns formation , varying the conditions at the formation of the compact object . the goal is to investigate the impact that different bh and ns formation assumptions have on the galactic distribution of xrbs containing a ns or a bh . we assume that the binaries are formed in the galactic thin disc , where most of the massive stars reside ( @xcite ) . in this study , we do not account for the possibility that a few systems could have been formed in the halo ( i.e. in star clusters that have now been dissolved ) , and neither of the possibility that a few systems could have been ejected from globular clusters ( gcs ) via n - body interactions . gcs seem to be very efficient in producing ns low - mass x - ray binaries ( ns - lmxbs ) , as @xmath48 of all ns - lmxbs are found in globular clusters , which contain only @xmath49 of all the stars in the galaxy ( @xcite ) . such an investigation is , however , outside the scope of this paper . we take different models for the formation of the compact object . the nk is drawn either from a maxwellian distribution peaked at @xmath50 km / s ( with @xmath51 km / s ) representing a low - nk , or from a maxwellian distribution peaked at @xmath52 km / s ( with @xmath53 km / s ) representing a high - nk . we assume a certain amount of mass ejection in the sn , @xmath54 . bhs are thought to form either via prompt collapse of the progenitor star or via partial fallback of the sn ejecta onto the proto - ns ( see @xcite ) . in our models , the progenitors of bhs either do not eject any mass at collapse , or they eject @xmath55 . stars with a zams - mass larger than @xmath56 are thought to leave a bh behind ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . for a progenitor of mass @xmath57 , the helium core mass ( which collapses into a bh ) is between @xmath58 ( @xcite ) , which motivates our ( conservative ) choice for @xmath54 . for the previous models , we assume a bh mass of @xmath59 ( which is the typical mass for bhs in our galaxy ; @xcite ) . we also picture a higher - mass helium star ( @xmath60 ) which directly collapses into a bh with no mass ejection . for nss , the ejected mass is calculated as : @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the helium core mass ( @xmath63~m_\odot$ ] , see @xcite ) , and @xmath64 . for the bh case the models are :    * model 1 : high nk , @xmath65 , @xmath66 ; * model 2 : low nk , @xmath65 , @xmath66 ; * model 3 : high nk , @xmath65 , @xmath67 ; * model 4 : low nk , @xmath60 , @xmath66 .    for the ns case the models are :    * model 5 : high nk , @xmath54 uniform between @xmath68~m_\odot$ ] ; * model 6 : low nk , @xmath54 uniform between @xmath68 ~m_\odot$ ] .    for all the models , we simulate @xmath69 binaries composed of the helium star ( which core - collapses ) and a companion star of @xmath70 . the pre - sn orbital separation is uniformly drawn in the range @xmath71 with zero initial eccentricity , where @xmath72 is the minimal orbital separation such that either one of the two components fills its roche lobe . we calculate the effect of the compact object formation on the orbital properties and on the kinematics of the binary ( for more details on the method , see @xcite ) . in particular , the effect of the mass ejection together with the nk impart a peculiar velocity to the binary : @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the total mass of the binary after the sn , @xmath75 is the magnitude of the nk , @xmath76 its component along the orbital speed of the bh progenitor , and @xmath77 is the _ mass - loss kick _ : @xmath78 the recoil the binary gets because of the instantaneous mass ejection @xmath54 ( @xmath79 is the initial mass of the binary ; @xmath80 is the mass of the companion ; @xmath81 is the initial orbital separation ) . we follow the evolution of the binaries under the coupling between tides and magnetic braking using the method developed in @xcite , and select those systems that start mass transfer ( mt ) , i.e. become x - ray sources , while the donor is on the main sequence . we choose the radial distribution of the binaries to follow the surface density of stars in the thin disc : @xmath82 , with @xmath83 kpc ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , and with a maximum distance from the galactic centre of @xmath84 kpc . concerning the height above the plane , we model it as an exponential with scale height @xmath85 equal to the scale height of the thin disc ( @xmath86 kpc ; @xcite ) . this is a conservative choice for the scale height , being the scale height of massive stars in the disc typically smaller ( @xmath87 pc ; see table 4 in @xcite ) . we assume that the stars follow the galactic rotation , with no additional component . various mechanisms can heat up the stars in the disc , increasing their dispersion velocity , such as encounters with spiral density waves , giant molecular clouds , and various other forms of stochastic heating ( @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) . , using a large sample of late - type dwarfs in the milky way disc , measured a dispersion in the three velocity - components of @xmath88 km / s , @xmath89 km / s , @xmath90 km / s at @xmath91 gyr ( see also ) . we neglect this influence , as we expect that for low - mass stars hosted in ( massive ) binaries these velocity would be significantly lower . we integrate the orbit of the binaries for @xmath19 gyr using the potential from @xcite , which is a realistic model for the milky way potential . we record the position along the orbit every @xmath19 myr after @xmath25 gyr .        using the catalogue of , we classify the systems into three main groups :    1 . short - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs ( 9 systems ) ; 2 . short - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs + short - period bh candidates ( 15 systems ) ; 3 . short- and long - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs ( 12 systems ) ,    which we list in table [ tab : systems ] , along with their galactic position @xmath5 derived from their sky - position and distance . dynamically - confirmed bhs are those for which a dynamical measurement of the bh mass is available ( see e.g. @xcite ) .    * 3|l| name & r & @xmath92 + & & +   + xte j1118 + 480 & @xmath93 @xmath94 & @xmath95 @xmath96 + gro j0422 + 32 & @xmath97 @xmath98 & @xmath99 @xmath100 + grs 1009 - 45 & @xmath101 @xmath102 & @xmath103 @xmath104 + 1a 0620 - 00 & @xmath105 @xmath106 & @xmath107 @xmath108 + gs 2000 + 251 & @xmath109 @xmath110 & @xmath111 @xmath112 + nova mus 91 & @xmath113 @xmath96 & @xmath114 @xmath104 + h 1705 - 250 & @xmath115 @xmath116 & @xmath117 @xmath118 + xte j1650 - 500 & @xmath119 @xmath120 & @xmath121 @xmath122 + xte j1859 + 226 & @xmath123 @xmath124 & @xmath125 @xmath126 +   + xte j1550 - 564 & @xmath127 @xmath128 & @xmath129 @xmath130 + grs 1915 + 105 & @xmath131 @xmath132 & @xmath133 @xmath134 + gs 2023 + 338 ( v404 cyg ) & @xmath135 @xmath136 & @xmath137 @xmath138 +   + maxi j1836 - 194 & @xmath139 @xmath140 & @xmath141 @xmath142 + maxi j1659 - 152 & @xmath143 @xmath144 & @xmath145 @xmath146 + xte j1752 - 223 & @xmath147 @xmath148 & @xmath149 @xmath150 + swift j1753.5 - 0127 & @xmath151 @xmath126 & @xmath152 @xmath153 + 4u 1755 - 338 & @xmath154 @xmath155 & @xmath156 @xmath102 + grs 1716 - 249 & @xmath157 @xmath158 & @xmath159 @xmath130 +    the observed bh - xrbs are both long ( @xmath160 day ) and short orbital period ( @xmath161 day ) , thereby originating from different evolutionary paths . hence , in order to compare the observed systems with the simulated binaries , we need to produce two separate synthetic population of binaries , one population with short - period and one population with long - period , to which we compare the observed binaries according to their type . for the short - period binaries , we follow the binary evolution of simulated binaries using the method we explained in section [ sec : bps ] . for the long period ones , which are driven by the nuclear evolution of the donor , we model them assuming the post supernova orbital separation to be such that @xmath162 , where @xmath163 is the circularised orbital separation and @xmath164 is the eccentricity in the post - sn configuration . this assumption is based on the fact that long - period binaries evolve to longer and longer period during the mt phase , hence : @xmath165 , where @xmath166 is the orbital separation at the onset of mt , and @xmath167 is the observed orbital separation . the assumptions on the compact object formation are the same as for the short - period binaries , as well as the masses of the binary components . since our simulated binaries have a companion mass of @xmath70 , we exclude from the observed sample those binaries with a companion mass : @xmath168 ( gro j1655 - 40 , 4u 1543 - 475 , and sax j1819.3 - 2525 ) . we account for a possible observational bias on the dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs . in order to get a dynamical measurement of the bh mass , hence fully confirming the nature of the source , high signal - to - noise optical spectra are required ; this might be prevented in regions of high extinctions , i.e. in and close to the galactic plane . we then remove from our simulated populations those binaries which are located at @xmath169 kpc . we note that the lowest @xmath0 in the sample of short - period dynamically confirmed bh binaries is for 1a 0620 - 00 ( @xmath170 kpc ; see table [ tab : systems ] ) . for the long - period binaries , we exclude from the study the sources grs 1915 + 105 ( donor spectral type : k1/5 iii ) and v404 cyg ( donor spectral type : k0 iv ) , which are located at @xmath171 kpc and @xmath172 kpc respectively ( see table [ tab : systems ] ) . these two systems do have a dynamical measurement of the bh mass ( see @xcite ) . in figure [ fig : spectype ] we plot the absolute value of the height @xmath0 versus the spectral type and luminosity class of the @xmath173 to which we add the three bh - xrbs with an intermediate - mass companion . ] dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs ( the spectral types are from ) . at small @xmath0 , stars have an earlier spectral type and/or are giants or sub - giants . whereas ms / dwarf stars tend to be seen at larger distances above the plane .     and the spectral type and luminosity class of the 15 dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs . when the spectral type of the donor star in the system is not univocally identified , we indicate the range of possible types . ] the only long - period binary in our sample , after removing those sources close to the galactic plane , is xte j1550 - 564 , which has a current orbital separation of @xmath174 , consistent with our assumption on @xmath163 . the galactic population of ns - xrbs consists of more than @xmath175 objects ( see @xcite and references therein ) . for our study , we select the @xmath176 ones with a short - orbital period ( @xmath177 day ; see table 2 in @xcite ) . the identification of a ns - xrb typically occurs via the detection of x - ray bursts which ignite on the surface of the ns . therefore , unlike for bhs , there are potentially no biases against the identification of such systems . the scale height of bh- and ns - xrbs is a proxy of the effect of different compact object formation mechanisms on to the galactic distribution of the binaries . we quantity the scale height of the binaries as the rms of their height @xmath0 as a function of @xmath26 for all points . to plot the results , we bin the systems into @xmath25 kpc - wide bins in the @xmath26-direction . we show the results in figure [ fig : zrms ] for the six models . the monotonic rise of @xmath178 is expected , since the galactic potential becomes weaker further away from the galactic centre , and the binary moves further up for the same initial velocity it is interesting to note that if bhs and nss receive the same nk , they would still show a different scale height , with nss reaching larger distances from the galactic plane ( compare black solid line with grey solid line , and black dashed line with grey dashed line ) . this is due to the fact that for the same linear momentum , a binary with a larger mass receives a lower @xmath17 ( as is shown in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . if the progenitor of the bh ejects mass at core - collapse as in model 3 ( see black dashed - dotted line in figure [ fig : zrms ] ) , it will move further out from the plane than when no mass is ejected , since the mass ejection adds an extra contribution to @xmath17 . furthermore , @xmath17 does not depend on the mass of the bh when no mass is ejected at bh formation ( black dashed and black dotted lines in figure [ fig : zrms ] ) , since it scales as @xmath179 , for low - mass companion stars ( see equation [ eq : pec ] ) .    in figure [ fig : vsys ] we also show as arrows the lower limits on the peculiar velocity at birth of the 9 bh - xrbs we studied in section [ sec : effect ] . it is clear that a high - nk distribution ( darker - grey solid line ) more easily accounts for the higher - velocity systems , as @xmath180 systems lie in or beyond the high - velocity tail of the distribution corresponding to the low - nk model . @xcite found a similar @xmath178 between ns- and bh - xrbs and deduced that bhs should receive nks too , unless differences in the binary evolution and observational biases were strong . we confirm that accounting for binary evolution does not strongly change the galactic distributions of bh- and ns - xrbs . however , the scale height does strongly depend on the position in the disc . we compute the @xmath178 of the observed bh - xrbs , both of the whole sample and of the dynamically - confirmed systems only . we find a rms of @xmath181 kpc and @xmath182 kpc respectively . for the short - period ns systems , we calculate a @xmath178 of @xmath183 kpc , when excluding the source xte j2123 - 058 since its velocity is consistent with being a halo source , as @xcite noted . the error on these @xmath178-values accounts for the uncertainty on the distance to the sources . in figure [ fig : space ] we show the galactic distribution of ns and bh systems ( the lines account for the uncertainty in the distance to the source ) . the result that ns systems should have a larger scale height than bh systems is consistent with what the observed populations show .     above the galactic plane of simulated bh- and ns - xrbs for the different models used . ] ( after the formation of the compact object ) of bh - xrbs in model 1 ( black solid line ) and model 2 ( black dashed line ) , and of ns - xrbs in model 5 ( grey solid line ) and model 6 ( grey dashed line ) . the dotted and dotted - dashed dark - grey lines are variations of model 1 ( see section [ sec : discussion ] for details ) . the arrows represent the lower limits on the peculiar velocity at birth for the 9 short - period bh - xrbs using the potential from @xcite . ] is the distance from the galactic center projected on to the plane , and @xmath0 is the height above the plane . one ns - xrb falls off the figure : xte j2123 - 058 . for each source , the line accounts for the uncertainty on the distance . we also show the results from the population study in terms of @xmath178 as a function of @xmath26 : model 1 ( grey lines ) , model 2 ( grey - dashed lines ) , model 3 ( grey - dotted lines ) . ]      in the models we used in section [ sec : bps ] , the orbit of the binary progenitors of bh- and ns - xrbs was chosen to be uniformly distributed in the range @xmath184~r_\odot$ ] . it could be that this choice biases our results towards certain values for @xmath17 . to test this , we check how the distribution of the initial orbital separation of the binaries ( i.e. prior to the formation of the compact object ) varies with the magnitude of the nk and of @xmath17 . from figure [ fig : presn ] , it is clear that the majority of the initial orbital separations are constrained to lie within a small range ( @xmath185 ) both for ns and bh systems , and both for high and low nks . furthermore , there is no clear trend of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath186 . we hence conclude that it is unlikely that the peculiar velocities @xmath17 would be very much influenced if the pre - sn orbits had a distribution different from the uniform one we use in our study , or if they were drawn from a smaller range .     and the orbital separation @xmath186 of bh- and ns - xrbs prior to the formation of the compact object . each panel corresponds to different assumptions on the nk . the fraction of systems in each 2-dimensional bin is shown ; darker colours correspond to a larger fraction of systems.,title="fig : " ]   and the orbital separation @xmath186 of bh- and ns - xrbs prior to the formation of the compact object . each panel corresponds to different assumptions on the nk . the fraction of systems in each 2-dimensional bin is shown ; darker colours correspond to a larger fraction of systems.,title="fig : " ]      we now turn to the comparison of the different models with the observed bh - xrbs . in order to compare the simulations with the observed systems , we note that every subgroup of bh binaries of table [ tab : systems ] gives rise to a certain 2d distribution in @xmath26 and @xmath0 . one way of proceeding would be to compare the 2d simulated distribution with the 2d observed one . we compare the data with the simulated populations dividing the galaxy into @xmath25 kpc - wide bins along the @xmath26-direction . this allows to account for the fact that the galactic potential is a strong function of the position in the disk , as we showed in section [ sec : effect ] . for every @xmath26-bin , we compute the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of the height @xmath0 above the galactic plane based on the population synthesis results within model 1 and model 2 ( see as an example black and grey lines in figure [ fig : intersection ] , for the bin : @xmath187 $ ] kpc ) . then we calculate where in the cumulative distribution the observed systems lie ( see as an example the intersection between the blue vertical lines and the cdfs in figure [ fig : intersection ] ) . in such a way , we obtain a list of percentiles . if the model is correct , we expect these percentiles to be drawn from the uniform distribution . we note that we have removed from our comparison those sources located in the bulge of the galaxy ( i.e. h 1705 - 250 and maxi j1659 - 152 ) , which could have had a different origin rather than having formed in the plane ( see section [ sec : effect ] ) . we plot the cumulative distribution of these percentiles in figures [ fig : obs1 ] ( short - period confirmed bh - xrbs ) , [ fig : obs2 ] ( short - period confirmed + candidates ) , and [ fig : obs4 ] ( whole sample ) . in the figures , the solid lines correspond to model 1 and the dashed lines correspond to model 2 . we also consider a model which consists of a superposition of model 1 and model 2 in equal parts ( see thin solid in figure [ fig : obs1 ] , in the case of the short - period confirmed bh - xrbs ) . the model which fits best is the one which comes closer to the diagonal line ( that represents the cumulative of a uniform distribution ) . in all three cases , a high nk distribution is the most preferable one . we perform a kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test to measure how close is the distribution of percentiles to the diagonal line of figures [ fig : obs1 ] , [ fig : obs2 ] , [ fig : obs4 ] . we summarise the @xmath188-values and their corresponding probabilities in table [ tab : dvalues ] for every subgroups of bh - xrbs . for each of the sub - groups the high - nk model fits the data best , although in the group with confirmed bhs only , the low - nk is also consistent with the data . for the confirmed+candidate short - period systems as well as for the whole sample , the low - nk model is inconsistent . interestingly , the model in which the bhs receive both low and high nks , fits the data best for the confirmed systems .    in these results , we have excluded all the systems in the plane ( both observed and simulated ) . an accurate modelling of the obscured systems would require a model for the galactic extinction in and out of the plane combined with a model for the optical / nir magnitudes of bh - xrbs in their quiescent state . as a first step , we simplistically model the observational effects near the galactic plane including a certain fraction of those simulated points which end up in the galactic disc ( at @xmath189 kpc ) : either @xmath190 , or @xmath191 , or @xmath192 . we compare the galactic distribution of these simulated binaries with the distribution of the whole sample of binaries , including this time the obscured sources grs 1915 + 105 and v404 cyg as well . the results are presented in figure [ fig : obs5 ] and table [ tab : dvalues ] . also when including the obscured systems , the high - kick model is the most successful in reproducing the observed binaries .    [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]      the distance @xmath193 to a bh - xrb is typically estimated by measuring the apparent magnitude of the companion star in a certain colour band , and computing its absolute magnitude . once an estimate of the reddening towards the source is known and the spectral type of the donor star is clearly identified , the distance can be calculated . in the best case scenario , one would have the apparent magnitude of the source in different bands , and then would compute the scatter between the derived distances as estimate of the distance uncertainty . we expect such uncertainties to follow a gaussian distribution . however , in case a range of spectral types is equally probable , we expect the errors on the distance to be distributed more uniformly . to investigate the influence of the uncertainty in the distance , and since for most of the literature there is no easy way of determining the type of error distribution , we randomly generate 100 values for the distance to each bh - xrb , either distributed as a gaussian ( with @xmath194 equal to the distance uncertainty @xmath195 ) or as a uniform distribution in the range @xmath196 . such errors can cause a binary to move from one @xmath26-bin to the adjacent one , affecting the percentile values . however , we find that there is no systematic shift that would make low nks fit best the observed data , @xmath195 being smaller than the discrepancy between the two distributions .     for model 1 ( black lines ) and model 2 ( grey lines ) , in the bin @xmath187 $ ] kpc . solid lines correspond to the whole sample of simulated binaries ; dashed lines correspond to the remaining part of the sample after the exclusion of systems close to the galactic plane , i.e. @xmath169 kpc . the blue vertical lines represent the observed @xmath92 of 3 bh - xrbs ( from left to right : 1a 0620 - 00 ; grs 1009 - 45 ; xte j1118 + 480 ) . ]    ) . the model which fits best the observed data is the one closer to the diagonal line . ] ( black lines ) , @xmath191 ( darker grey lines ) , or @xmath192 ( lighter grey lines ) . the model which fits best the observed data is the one closer to the diagonal line . ] we compare the observed @xmath0 distribution of ns systems with the distribution of the two simulated population of ns - xrbs in the context of model 5 and model 6 . we perform the comparison in the same way we did for bh - systems in section [ s : rules_for_cumul ] . from figure [ fig : obsns ] we see that none of the distributions ( solid and dashed lines ) fits the data . our goal is not to calibrate the ns nk distribution from the ns - xrb population , nor from a population model of radio pulsars ( cf . ) . nevertheless , we can note that the observed population of ns - xrbs seems to be consistent with nks larger than @xmath197 km / s . this is in line with the catalogue of pulsar proper motions by @xcite , who inferred a mean pulsar birth velocity of @xmath198 km / s . however , the derivation of pulsar velocities from the measured proper motions has to be taken with caution , because of the possible uncertainties in the proper motion measurements as well as in the distance measurements . more in general , underestimating proper motion measurement errors can lead to an overestimate of pulsar velocities , as noted by . the distance to a pulsar is typically estimated through parallax . showed that a more proper bayesian approach to calculate the distance probability function from a single parallax measurement has to be used . such method has not been applied yet to the whole population of pulsars . we show the results of the ks - test for ns systems in table [ tab : dvalues ] : both models have large @xmath188-values .    for an illustrative purpose , we also compare the observed population of ns - xrbs to a simulated one in which the nk is drawn from a maxwellian distribution with @xmath199 km / s ( @xcite ) . the results of the ks test favours this distribution : @xmath200 ; see dotted line in figure [ fig : obsns ] . we note that we did not include the long - period ns - xrbs to our study as in the sample of ns - xrbs from @xcite that we are using , there is only one long - period system with a low - mass companion , cygnus x-2 . 1 .   in our models of section [ sec : bps ] , we have assumed an ejected mass at bh formation of @xmath15 or @xmath55 . taking @xmath201 would not greatly affect the scale height of the binaries in the case of a high nk distribution , since the typical peculiar velocities are comparable to the case when @xmath55 are ejected ( see dotted line in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . this is due to the fact that a high ejected - mass is compatible only with the lower - velocity tail of the nk distribution in order for the binary to stay bound . in the case of a low nk distribution , the higher ejected - mass has a greater effect on the average peculiar velocity ( see dashed - dotted line in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . the ns systems velocities are still larger . in order for bh systems to have the same peculiar velocity as ns systems , we would need that @xmath202 , which follows from the expression for @xmath17 ( equation [ eq : pec ] ) , imposing that @xmath203 and assuming that @xmath204 . this would constraint @xmath54 to be much larger than what is allowed for the binary to stay bound . 2 .   in the modelling of the progenitors of bh- and ns - xrbs , we have assumed a flat distribution of the initial orbital separation in the range @xmath184~r_\odot$ ] ( section [ sec : bps ] ) . with this choice , we are including all possible pre - sn orbital separations . in @xcite we verified that larger separations do not contribute to the final separation of the binary ( see their figure 13 ) . this is due to the fact that the strength of the coupling between tides and magnetic braking , which is responsible for the shrinking of a binary to short orbital periods , decreases strongly with larger orbital separations . for long - period bh - xrbs , this choice is also acceptable , as none of the observed binaries in our sample have an orbital separation larger than @xmath205 . there could be of course cases in which the orbit in the post - sn phase is highly eccentric and very wide , but these cases would contribute only to a minority of the systems . more importantly , we have found that the nk distribution does not in fact depend on the pre - sn orbital period ( see figure [ fig : presn ] , where there is no trend of the orbital separation depending on the nk ) . we can also compare the circularised orbital period distribution after the sn in our models , @xmath206 , with the one in @xcite , who did detailed evolutionary calculations of ns - lmxbs . in our models , @xmath206 ranges from @xmath207 days to @xmath208 days , which is compatible with the range shown by @xcite in their figure 1 . we have assumed that the companion of bhs and nss are stars with an initial mass of @xmath70 . @xcite argued that the majority of lmxbs have likely originated from binaries with an intermediate mass companion ( @xmath209 ) . we have checked how our results would be affected when taking a companion of initial mass : @xmath210 . the peculiar velocity right after the bh formation ( see figure [ fig : vsys ] ) would decrease due to the larger binary mass : by a factor of @xmath211 on average . this implies that the nk would need to be even larger in order for the simulated systems to match the observed ones . 4 .   the two maxwellian distributions used in section [ sec : bps ] do not correspond to the real physical distributions , but rather are representative of two complementary distributions , one generating large kicks , the other generating low kicks . the choice of two distributions peaked at two different velocities serves the purpose of analysing how close in magnitude are the velocities received by bhs with respect to the velocities received by nss . the nk distribution of nss can be estimated via proper motion studies of pulsars . the pulsar birth speed distribution has been estimated as a maxwellian distribution with @xmath212 km / s by @xcite ; however , one should bear in mind the caveats discussed in section [ sec : obsns ] . for bhs , the number of sources with measured 3d space velocity ( @xmath19 ; see @xcite ) is not sufficient to allow for a calibration of their nk distribution . when comparing the observed bh - xrbs with the synthetic bh - xrbs which result from our population synthesis , we found that the population in which bhs receive high nks best fit the observed data . this conclusion gains strength when including in the comparison between observations and simulated population the sources located in the bulge of the galaxy ( i.e. h 1705 - 250 and maxi j1659 - 152 ) . in this case , the ks - values for the short - period confirmed bh - xrb sample are : @xmath213 , @xmath214 , and for the short - period confirmed + candidates bh - xrb sample are : @xmath215 , @xmath216 . we did not include the long - period ns - xrbs in our study . we can still investigate how much long- and short - period ns - xrbs differ when it comes to the peculiar velocity after the sn , and hence how they differ in terms of the scale height above the galactic plane . we build a population of binaries which evolve into long - period ns - xrbs along the lines of the computational method used for long - period bh - xrbs ( see section [ sec : bps ] ) . we find that the long - period systems have slightly lower peculiar velocities , which results in a slightly lower scale height ( by a factor of @xmath217 , for every radial distance ) . this is due to the fact that the binary , having lower binding energy , can only survive lower kicks . as it was mentioned in the introduction , there is evidence for some nss receiving low kicks at birth : nss residing in double - ns systems ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) and nss hosted in a subset of high - mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ; @xcite ) . it was suggested that electron - capture sne are too fast for large asymmetries to develop , resulting in a modest kick , of a few @xmath176 km / s at maximum . such kicks are of the order of the low natal kick model we took in our binary population synthesis of section [ sec : bps ] through which we found ( section [ sec : obsns ] ) that high - kick models best fit the galactic distribution of ns - lmxbs : i.e. we did not find any evidence for nss born in an electron - capture sn . this might be due to a different evolutionary path for the progenitors of ns - lmxbs . several studies have investigated the type of sn event ( either a standard collapse of the iron core or an electron capture sn ) as a function of the evolutionary state of the helium star progenitor of the ns as well as the characteristics of the binary orbit . @xcite performed detailed evolutionary sequences of binaries hosting an ns and a helium star . they found that helium stars with an initial mass of @xmath218 could be stripped of a significant fraction of their mass through case bb mass transfer towards an ns companion when the helium star expands as a giant . the low - mass core would then form an ns via electron - capture sn , provided the initial orbital period is sufficiently wide . shorter orbital period would instead result in a white dwarf ( wd ) . we can extrapolate this finding to the short - period systems formed by an ns and a low - mass companion studied in our work . however , we must bear in mind that the stripping effect is less understood for a giant helium star experiencing mass transfer to a low - mass main - sequence star , as indeed mentioned by @xcite . thus we conclude that , heretofore , there is no strong theoretical support for a preference for electron - capture sn in the progenitors of ns - lmxbs . we also wish to note that the study by @xcite highlighted the impossibility of forming short - period ( less than one day ) ns - lmxbs without large natal kicks at birth ( where for large they chose a maxwellian distribution with an average kick of 300 km / s ) .      in assessing the quality of the fit of our simulations , we used the classical application of the ks - test . in order to test its validity and determine the _ power _ of the test in distinguishing the two hypothesis we draw samples of various sizes from the simulated populations , and we calculate the @xmath188-value distribution of each of these samples , according to the rules described in section  [ s : rules_for_cumul ] . we find that the probabilities follow the classical ks test ( as expected ) to an accuracy ( @xmath219 ) that is comparable to the poisson noise in our simulations ( @xmath220 ) . more interesting is the measurement of how often we obtain @xmath188-values smaller then the ones we measured for our observed samples when _ testing the wrong hypothesis _ - i.e. when using a sample drawn from the high ( low ) nk synthetic population and testing the low ( high ) nk hypothesis ( also known as false negative rate ) . for the bh case , we find @xmath188-values smaller than the ones in table [ tab : dvalues ] in less than @xmath221 of the cases , for the high nk hypothesis , and in more than @xmath222 for the low nk hypothesis . a particularly interesting fact is that @xmath223 for short - period confirmed + candidate bh - xrbs . if we accept the @xmath224 confidence level and use the standard 4-to-1 weighting ( i.e. @xmath225 ) , the test we developed has enough power to distinguish between the high- and low - nk hypothesis in this case , and that the high - nk hypothesis is clearly preferable . this is a _ non_-expected result given the small number of object , and it can potentially dissolve if some of the bh candidates turn out to be ns - xrbs . to calculate what is the optimal number of observed systems to decrease such rate @xmath226 , we draw samples of various sizes from the population synthesis results of model 1 and we test the low - nk hypothesis , and vice - versa . to decrease this rate to the level that in @xmath42 of cases we obtain @xmath227 , we find that it is necessary to increase the size of the observed sample to @xmath3 systems , both in the bh and ns case . in this work we performed a binary population synthesis study of bh- and ns - xrbs , tracing their binary evolution from the moment of compact object formation until the observed phase of mass transfer , and integrated their orbits in the galaxy . the main goal was to investigate whether different assumptions on compact object formation manifest themselves in the galactic distribution of the binaries . we found that these assumptions do affect the scale height of the binaries , which we quantified through their @xmath178 . in particular , we found that if bhs and nss receive the same nk at birth , nss would still have a larger scale height above the galactic plane , due to the fact that their systemic velocities acquired when the compact object is formed are typically larger , their total binary mass being smaller . the larger scale height of ns - xrbs with respect to bh - xrbs is clearly seen also in the observed populations . we also found a clear trend for both populations of increasing scale height for larger galactocentric radii , which should manifest itself , but which is not clearly observed in the current populations ( see figure [ fig : space ] ) . the main outcome of this study is that when analysing the @xmath0-distribution of the observed bh systems as a function of @xmath26 , the simulated population in which at least some bhs receive a ( relatively ) high nk ( @xmath228 km / s ) fits the data best . this is in agreement with previous findings by @xcite , who compared the observed and simulated populations of bh - xrbs only in the @xmath0-direction , whereas we compare the 2d distributions , accounting for how the binaries are distributed along the @xmath26-direction as well . furthermore , we increased the sample of sources adding @xmath229 bh candidates , updated their distances according to the recently published bh catalogue of , and followed the binary evolution of the binaries in a detailed way ( accounting in particular for magnetic braking and tides ) .    in this work we also checked numerically the validity of a simple one - dimensional analytical estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth of bh - xrbs which we used in our previous works @xcite and @xcite . we found that this estimate is less reliable for some gravitational potentials for sources in the bulge of the galaxy , i.e at @xmath230 kpc . this was also shown by @xcite , who studied the kinematics of h 1705 - 250 , a bh - xrb close to the galactic bulge . however , the estimate is robust for systems at galactocentric radii larger than @xmath25 kpc . @xcite followed the binary evolution of seven short - period bh - xrbs and estimated their minimal peculiar velocity at birth , to conclude that two out of the seven sources were consistent with a high ( or relatively high ) nk at birth . this conclusion remains valid even in view of the current analysis . @xcite found that the rms - value of the distance to the galactic plane for bh - xrbs was similar to that of ns - xrbs . this was suggestive for bhs receiving a kick - velocity at formation . we revised the distances and updated the sample of bh - xrbs using the catalogue from and we found that ns systems have a larger scale height than bh systems , a trait which is also present in the simulated populations .    finally , we found that the comparison of the data to our simulations is limited by the small number of observed bh - xrbs , and thus that more systems should be found to determine in more detail the nk that bhs receive . in this respect , the possible future discovery of new bh transients with gaia ( @xcite ) , and through dedicated surveys such as the galactic bulge survey ( @xcite ) , are promising . sr is thankful to jo bovy for answering her questions concerning galpy and for useful comments on the manuscript . sr wishes to warmly thank her office mates ( pim van oirschot , martha irene saladino , laura rossetto , thomas wevers ) at radboud university for their great moral support during the hectic times of finishing up her thesis . sr wishes to acknowledge melvyn b. davies with whom she started her research on black hole natal kicks . this research has made use of nasas astrophysics data system . o. , 2015 , in points s. , kunder a. , eds , fifty years of wide field studies in the southern hemisphere : resolved stellar populations of the galactic bulge and magellanic clouds vol . 491 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , formation models of the galactic bulge . p.  169 h.  m. , 1996 , in wijers r.  a.  m.  j. , davies m.  b. , tout c.  a. , eds , nato advanced science institutes ( asi ) series c vol .  477 of nato advanced science institutes ( asi ) series c , an observational approach to binary population synthesis . p.  385 g. , 2007 , in st .- louis n. , moffat a.  f.  j. , eds , massive stars in interactive binaries vol . 367 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , what can we learn about black - hole formation from black - hole x - ray binaries ? . p.  533 j.  a. , preto m. , 2002 , in athanassoula e. , bosma a. , mujica r. , eds , disks of galaxies : kinematics , dynamics and peturbations vol . 275 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , scattering of stars by transient spiral waves .
Abstract:

Answer: the aim of this work is to study the imprints that different models for black hole ( bh ) and neutron star ( ns ) formation have on the galactic distribution of x - ray binaries ( xrbs ) which contain these objects . we find that the root mean square of the height above the galactic plane of bh- and ns - xrbs is a powerful proxy to discriminate among different formation scenarios , and that binary evolution following the bh / ns formation does not significantly affect the galactic distributions of the binaries . we find that a population model in which at least some bhs receive a ( relatively ) high natal kick fits the observed bh - xrbs best . for the ns case , we find that a high nk distribution , consistent with the one derived from the measurement of pulsar proper motion , is the most preferable . we also analyse the simple method we previously used to estimate the minimal peculiar velocity of an individual bh - xrb at birth . we find that this method may be less reliable in the bulge of the galaxy for certain models of the galactic potential , but that our estimate is excellent for most of the bh - xrbs . [ firstpage ]    x - rays : binaries  supernovae : general  galaxy : dynamics  binaries : general  black hole physics stars : neutron