Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: over the last two decades , the application of ion traps has expanded from mass spectrometry  @xcite and frequency standards  @xcite towards engineering of quantum systems which can be used for quantum computation  @xcite and quantum simulation  @xcite . it is commonly accepted that large - scale trapped ion quantum information processors require micrometer - scale ion traps  @xcite . such traps usually suffer from excessive electric field noise close to metallic surfaces at room temperature , but at cryogenic temperatures this noise is strongly reduced  @xcite . thus , it seems natural to move towards cryogenic experimental setups which have the additional advantage that the ambient pressure is usually a few orders of magnitude lower than at room temperature . this enables trapping of longer ion strings due to fewer collisions with background gas . furthermore , no bake - out procedure of the vacuum vessel is required , allowing for rapid trap cycle times . + the operation of paul traps requires high radio - frequency ( rf ) voltages , which are usually generated with the aid of the voltage gain present in rf resonators . for this purpose , helical resonators are typically used in the frequency regime up to 50mhz , whereas for experiments requiring higher drive frequencies coaxial resonators have been used as well  @xcite . in cryogenic experiments , the resonator needs to fulfill different criteria than in room temperature experiments where the resonator can be placed outside the vacuum vessel . in particular , the connections in a cryostat need to have low thermal conductivity to limit the thermal load . following the wiedemann - franz law , this results in a low electrical conductivity between room - temperature and the cryogenic parts of the experiment . thus , the resonators have to be operated at the cold - stage . moreover , space constraints are stricter in cryogenic systems which makes helical resonators undesirable as they are generally bulky . to minimize the volume of the resonator , an rlc - series - resonator can be used  @xcite . + in section  [ sec : general considerations ] , we focus on the choice of the trap drive frequency , the required voltage gain , and voltage monitoring . section  [ sec : coil design ] covers coil design for three types of coils , and in the following section  [ sec : matching ] , we discuss impedance matching of the resonator and present an efficient way to match cryogenic resonators . section  [ sec : rf shield ] focuses on the design of rf shielding , and finally , we present the results in section  [ sec : results ] . in trapped ion experiments , rf - voltages of several hundreds of volts are commonly applied to the trap , which has a simple capacitor as its electrical circuit equivalent . thus , we need to design a resonator that maximizes the rf - voltage at this capacitor for a given input power . in this section , we discuss general considerations in resonator design which are not limited to a specific resonator type .      at first , we consider the losses in an rlc - resonator and its scaling with frequency . from the solution of the equation of motion of a trapped ion in a paul trap ( mathieu equation ) , one obtains the trap voltages with the stability parameter @xmath0  @xcite , which scales as @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the amplitude of the rf - voltage at the trap and @xmath3 is the trap drive ( angular ) frequency . hence , for constant @xmath0 the loss power scales as @xmath4 a low trap drive frequency will reduce the losses . on the other hand , high secular motion frequencies of the ion in the trap are desirable for operation . higher secular frequencies require a higher @xmath3 , and thus the desired secular frequencies set a lower limit for @xmath3 . in this study , we aim for a @xmath0 around 0.25 , an axial secular frequency of 1mhz , and both radial frequencies to be 3.7mhz . this will require a trap drive frequency of @xmath5 42.6mhz . simulations of our trap show that we need a drive voltage of about @xmath6 to reach the desired trap frequencies . in order to limit the thermal load onto the cryostat from dissipated power in the resonator , this voltage should be reached with less than 100mw of rf  input power . this power corresponds to a consumption of about 1/7l of liquid helium per hour when operating a wet cryostat at 4.2k  @xcite . ( 0,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 5.2,1.75 ) ; ( 5,1.75 ) to [ r=@xmath7 ( 6.5,1.75 ) ; ( 6.3,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.9,1.75 ) ; ( 6.9,1.75 ) to [ l=@xmath8 ( 8,1.75 ) ; ( 8,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , i=@xmath9 ( 9,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 9,1.15 ) ; ( 9,1.2 ) to [ c=@xmath10 ( 9,0.8 ) ; ( 9,0.85 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 9,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,1.75 ) ; ( 9,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * -o ] ( 11,0.25 ) ; ( 11,0.35 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 11,1.75 ) ; ( 11,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 9,1.75 ) ;    at ( 2.5,1 ) * matching * ;    fig . [ fig : general matching ] shows an rlc - series - resonator driven through a matching network . in the following , we will assume perfect impedance matching with a loss - less matching network . thus , we can set the input power equal to the loss power in the resonator @xmath13 , where @xmath14 with @xmath15 being the input voltage supplied to the circuit and @xmath16 the wave impedance of the connecting cable , commonly @xmath17 . we can further write @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the current in the resonator , @xmath20 its effective loss resistance , @xmath3 its frequency , @xmath21 the voltage at the capacitor , and @xmath22 the capacitor representing the trap . thus , we obtain @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the voltage gain of the circuit , defined as @xmath25 . + the quality factor @xmath26 of a resonator is defined as the resonance frequency @xmath27 divided by the bandwidth @xmath28 @xmath29 in trapped ion experiments , we are usually not interested in a small bandwidth around @xmath3 but rather in a large voltage gain at the trap drive frequency . it should be noted that the voltage gain and bandwidth are qualitatively but not necessary quantitatively the same for different types of resonators . the quantity that is of direct interest for our application is the voltage gain , which can be derived from  ( [ eq : matching 1 ] ) as @xmath30 with the quality factor of an ideal rlc resonator @xmath31 . this indicates that both , the capacitive load , and the effective resistance of the resonator should be minimized . ( 0,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 3.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , i=@xmath9 ( 4.5,1.75 ) ; ( 4.4,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 5.4,1.75 ) ; ( 5.3,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.9,1.75 ) ; ( 5.9,1.75 ) to [ l , l_=@xmath8 ( 7,1.75 ) ; ( 7,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,1.1 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 7.5,0.9 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,1.75 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath32 , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath33 ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 8.4,1.75 ) ; ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * -o ] ( 11.5,0.25 ) to [ open , v=@xmath34 ( 11.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 9.5,1.75 ) ; ( 8.6,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 11.5,1.75 ) ; ( 11.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,0.9 ) ; ( 9.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,1.1 ) ; ( 7.4,3 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.4,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,2.5 ) ; ( 7,2.5 ) to [ l , l_=@xmath35 ( 5.9,2.5 ) ; ( 5.9,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,3 ) ; ( 7.4,3 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 7.4,3.5 ) ; ( 7.4,3.5 ) to [ open , v=@xmath36 ( 5.4,3.5 ) ; ( 5.4,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 5.4,3 ) ; ( 7.7 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 7.7,1.75 ) ;    at ( 2.25,1 ) * matching * ;    voltage pick - ups are not required for the operation of the trap , but are useful to measure the voltage on the trap and are required to actively stabilize the rf voltage on the trap . in this section , we discuss inductive and capacitive pick - up , as shown in fig . [ fig : general pickup ] . + a capacitive pick - up consists of a voltage divider parallel to the trap , where @xmath37 , which leads to the pick - up voltage @xmath38 @xmath39 has to be small compared to the trap capacitance @xmath22 , or the capacitive load of the rlc - resonator will increase significantly , reducing @xmath24 as shown in  ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . typical values for @xmath40 are several hundred times the value of @xmath39 . + in an ideal rlc - series - resonator , the voltage on the coil is the same as the voltage at the capacitor but with a phase shift . we can monitor the voltage at the coil as a signal proportional to the voltage at the trap since we are only interested in the amplitude of the trap voltage . here , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are coupled , and the pick - up voltage can be estimated with the derivations from ref . + in order to maintain low losses , the pick - up should not add significant losses in the resonator . if one uses a coaxial cable with a wave impedance @xmath16 to monitor the pick - up signal , a resistor @xmath16 is used as a termination to avoid reflections . the losses are then @xmath43 which need to be small compared to the losses in the resonator @xmath44 . + in general , we recommend using an inductive pick - up , because it does not increase the capacitive load , which would reduce the voltage gain . however for experiments , which frequently test different traps , a capacitive pick - up may be preferable since the more accurate ratio between pick - up and applied voltage facilitates estimating trapping parameters . surface traps for cryogenic environments typically use a high - quality dielectric carrier material and thus the losses in the resonator are usually dominated by the coil . in this study , we demonstrate the design and production of compact and low - loss coils that should allow us to drive our resonator under the conditions stated in section  [ sec : gen considerations - choose trap drive ] . coils produced with machines are desirable because the production process is reproducible . furthermore , we prefer toroid coils as they guide the magnetic field in their center , making them less sensitive to their environment . in our application , ferromagnetic core materials are undesirable , because they would induce spatial inhomogeneities of the magnetic field near the trap . we estimate the load capacitance of our resonator to be 10pf , which at a given resonance frequency of 42.6mhz yields a required inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . kamby and coworkers  @xcite demonstrated the integration of toroidal rf - inductors into printed circuit boards ( pcb ) . these coils can be fully produced by machines and in this study we will refer to these inductors as pcb coils . @xcite provides specific formulas for the inductance @xmath41 , the resistance of one segment @xmath46 , and the resistance of one via @xmath47 of pcb coils . in order to minimize the losses of the coil we want to minimize the resistance of one winding while maintaining a constant cross - section to keep the inductance constant the resistance of one winding is defined by @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the outer and the inner radius of the pcb coil , @xmath51 is the thickness of the pcb , and @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the average length - dependent resistances of a segment and a via . @xmath52 and @xmath53 depend on the exact geometry , but usually vias have similar cross - sections as the segments making their length - dependent resistances approximately equal . that means , in order to minimize  ( [ eq : pcb coils minimize resistance ] ) and to keep the cross section of the coil constant , @xmath54 and @xmath51 should be similar in size . + we chose rogers 4350b as the substrate material , because it has a small loss tangent , a similar thermal expansion coefficient as copper , and is ultra - high vacuum compatible . the thickest available rogers 4350b had 3.1 mm thickness , which is unfortunately too thin to minimize the resistance for a given cross - section . +        we produced this type of coil in - house and during multiple iterations , we varied the size and the number of vias . the lowest losses for our production process could be achieved with the design depicted in fig . [ fig : pcb coil ] . the pcb coil has an outer diameter of 35 mm and an inner diameter 20.4 mm with a substrate thickness of 3.1 mm . its 64 windings result in an inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . we added one winding which is galvanically isolated from the rest of the coil . this winding acts as an inductive pick - up and should thus be as reproducible as the entire coil .      for the second type of coils , wire coils , we wound a single wire around a rigid structure leading to a similar geometry as the pcb coils . such a coil is less reproducible than a pcb coil since the wire length will vary for each coil . hence , its inductance and its resistance will vary as well . a coil with the same geometry as for the pcb coils above , made out of silver - plated copper on a rogers 4350b substrate , is shown in fig . [ fig : wire coil ] . +        in wire coils , the cross - section of the core of a wire coil is bigger than that of a pcb coil , because the wire bends are less sharp . hence , we expect the inductance of a wire coil to be higher than the one of a pcb coil with the same nominal geometry . the 0.4 mm thick silver - plated copper wire , which we used for the wire coil , had a cross - section similar to the average cross - section of a pcb coil . therefore , we expect similar losses in both types of coils with the same geometries . these considerations allow us to characterize the production processes of the pcb coils by comparing the two types of coils . higher losses in the pcb coils are an indication that the production of the pcb coils can be improved . + since we do not need traces on the substrate , it is possible use any machinable material with a low loss tangent . we also produced wire coils with a teflon core since it has a lower loss tangent and a lower dielectric constant than rogers 4350b . thus , the losses will be less affected by the core material and the self - resonance frequency of the coil will be higher . another option to minimize the losses in the coil can be to use a superconducting wire to reduce the ohmic losses of the resonator . the quality factor of the presented coils are limited by the ohmic resistance of the conductor . thus , a coil based on a superconductor is expected to result in lower losses in the resonator . furthermore , it could be necessary to operate the experiment at temperatures above 15k to reduce the liquid helium consumption in wet cryostats . at these temperatures , a superconductor with a high critical temperature such as a high temperature superconductor ( hts ) is required . however , a coil made from a readily available hts material needs to be a two - dimensional ( 2d ) structure due to manufacturing constraints , and we choose to use a spiral coil as shown in fig .  [ fig : hts coil ] . +        since such coils require only 2d structuring , they can be manufactured in a very accurate and reproducible way . for the demonstrated spiral coil , a high - temperature superconductor ( hts ) was produced by _ _ ceraco ceramic coating__. our coils were made out of an yttrium barium copper oxide ( ybco ) film of 330 nm thickness on a sapphire wafer . to facilitate soldered connections , a 200 nm film of gold was placed on top of the superconductor . the critical temperature of this ybco film is above 87k , and its critical current density is higher than @xmath55a/@xmath56 at 77k . we can derive the peak current in the coil from section  [ sec : general considerations ] to be 0.64a . hence , traces with a width of more than 100@xmath45 m are required to stay below the critical current density . + for our square spiral coils , we chose a trace width of 300@xmath45 m , a trace gap of 150@xmath45 m , and 10 windings . we designed 9 different coils varying the outer diameter between 14 and 20 mm . equation 4.1 of reference  @xcite gives an estimate for the inductance , which results in target inductances between 1.2@xmath45h and 1.6@xmath45h for our coils . this design should allow for coils with very high quality factors already at temperatures accessible with liquid nitrogen instead of liquid helium . + it should be noted here that superconductors are perfect diamagnets , which are spatial inhomogeneities for magnetic fields . one can align the 2d plane of the spiral coil with the spatially homogeneous magnetic field of the experiment to minimize this effect , but one should always keep this in mind . the resonator is connected to the source through a cable with a given wave resistance @xmath16 , typically 50@xmath3 . the complex voltage reflection coefficient @xmath57 at the transition from the cable to the resonator  @xcite is then @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the complex reflected voltage , @xmath60 is the complex incoming voltage , and @xmath61 is the complex impedance of the resonator . the reflected power coefficient @xmath62 is then just @xmath63 . since rlc - series resonators have a very low impedance on resonance , @xmath64 , the transition from a 50@xmath3-cable to the resonator on resonance will reflect almost all the inserted power . in order to minimize the reflection , a properly designed impedance matching network is required . the most commonly used matching network is the @xmath41-network as it is the simplest , consisting only of two circuit elements . +    ( 0,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 1.15,5.75 ) ; ( 1.05,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath65 ( 1.45,5.75 ) ; ( 1.35,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.1,5.75 ) ; ( 3,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4,5.75 ) ; ( 3.9,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.05,5.75 ) ; ( 4.9,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l , l=@xmath8 ( 6,5.75 ) ; ( 5.8,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,4.85 ) ; ( 6.5,4.95 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 6.5,4.55 ) ; ( 6.5,4.65 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,3.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,3.75 ) ; ( 0,3.85 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,5.75 ) ; ( 2.25,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.25,5.05 ) ; ( 2.25,5.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath66 , color = black ] ( 2.25,4.15 ) ; ( 2.25,4.35 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,3.75 ) ; ( 6.7 , 3.8 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 6.7,5.75 ) ; ( -1.5,6 ) node [ ] ;    ( 0,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 0.85,2.25 ) ; ( 0.7,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l=@xmath66 ] ( 1.8,2.25 ) ; ( 1.6,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.1,2.25 ) ; ( 3,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4,2.25 ) ; ( 3.9,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.05,2.25 ) ; ( 4.9,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l , l=@xmath8 ( 6,2.25 ) ; ( 5.8,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,1.35 ) ; ( 6.5,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 6.5,1.05 ) ; ( 6.5,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,2.25 ) ; ( 2.25,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.25,1.35 ) ; ( 2.25,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath68 , color = black ] ( 2.25,1.05 ) ; ( 2.25,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,0.25 ) ; ( 6.7 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 6.7,2.25 ) ; ( -1.5,2.5 ) node [ ] ;    fig . [ fig : matching networks ] shows the two possible @xmath41-networks where the reactance parallel to the resonator transforms the real part of the impedance to be @xmath16 . the resulting imaginary term is small compared to @xmath16 ( for low loss resonators ) and can be compensated with the series reactance . +     and matching coil @xmath69 for the matching networks of fig . [ fig : matching networks ] over a varying quality factor of the coil . the matching is calculated for a 50@xmath3-cable , an inductor of 1.4@xmath45h , and a capacitor of 10pf . ] the resonator s quality factor from  ( [ eq : quality factor - bandwidth ] ) can be written as @xmath70 for an rlc - series resonator . [ fig : matching network simulation ] shows the required values for the matching capacitor @xmath71 and inductance @xmath69 as a function of the quality factor of the coil with inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . for quality factors around 1000 , the required inductance @xmath69 is in the range of 10nh . thin traces on a pcb have approximately a length - dependent inductance of 1nh / mm . therefore , small deviations in the trace length will lead to inefficient matching . the strong dependence of the matching on the reactance parallel to the resonator makes the matching network from fig . [ fig : matching networks]b ) more favorable , because capacitances of several hundred pf can be adjusted with much more precision than inductances of about 10nh . one can incorporate the inductance @xmath69 into the trace on the pcb from the coaxial connector to the matching capacitance , by setting this distance between 1 and 2 cm . hence , we expect a power reflection of 1% or less even without adding an additional inductor . +    ( -0.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 3.6,2.25 ) ; ( 3.5,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4.5,2.25 ) ; ( 4.4,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.45,2.25 ) ; ( 5.4,2.25 ) to [ l , l=@xmath8 ( 6.6,2.25 ) ; ( 6.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,1.35 ) ; ( 7,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 7,1.05 ) ; ( 7,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( -0.5,0.25 ) ; ( -0.5,0.25 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( -0.5,2.25 ) ; ( 1.75,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 1.75 , 1.35 ) ; ( 1.75,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath68 , color = black ] ( 1.75,1.05 ) ; ( 1.75,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 1.75 , 0.25 ) ; ( 2.75,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.75 , 1.65 ) ; ( 2.75,1.85 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l=@xmath72 , color = black ] ( 2.75,0.65 ) ; ( 2.75,0.85 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.75 , 0.25 ) ; ( 7.2 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 7.2,2.25 ) ;    rf transformers or baluns on the rf input side are commonly used to avoid ground loops between the rf source and the experiment . when using the circuit from fig . [ fig : matching networks]b ) in combination with a transformer , the dc potential of the trap electrodes is not defined . we mitigate this by adding an rf - choke parallel to the matching capacitor , where @xmath73 , as depicted in fig . [ fig : matching network choice ] . +    -cable , an inductor of 1.4@xmath45h , and a capacitor of 10pf , thus a resonance frequency of 42.6mhz . the red lines show the values for a fixed capacitance @xmath71 chosen for an ideal matching of @xmath74 . in a ) , one can see the required matching capacitor as a function of the quality factor of the coil @xmath75 . b ) shows the change in resonance frequency of an ideal match . in c ) , the voltage gain is plotted over @xmath75 . d ) shows the reflection coefficient of the matching network . ]    in a cryostat , it is impractical to adjust the matching capacitance @xmath71 during or after a cool down . hence , we have to find an efficient way of choosing the best value for @xmath71 with a minimum number of temperature cycles . for this , we simulated our matching circuit for varying and also for a constant value of @xmath71 . [ fig : matching reflection ] shows results of simulations where the fixed capacitor value was chosen for a match at @xmath74 . fig . [ fig : matching reflection]a ) depicts an increase of the optimum @xmath71 with increasing @xmath75 . [ fig : matching reflection]b ) illustrates the dependence of the matched resonance frequency on @xmath75 . in fig . [ fig : matching reflection]c ) , the simulations confirm the dependence of the voltage gain on @xmath75 , following from  ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . if the physical value for @xmath75 is smaller than the expected value , used to chose the fixed matching capacitor , the voltage gain is about the same than for an ideal match . but if the actual quality factor @xmath75 is higher than the expected value , the voltage gain will be lower than with an ideal match . hence underestimating the quality factor of the coil should be avoided since it would result in a significantly lower voltage gain . [ fig : matching reflection]d ) shows the reflection coefficient as a function of @xmath75 . the effect of @xmath69 is small and thus it was omitted for these simulations . we can see that even without @xmath69 , but with an ideally matched @xmath71 , a low reflection coefficient can be achieved . if one chooses a constant value for @xmath71 at a match for @xmath74 , the reflected power will stay below 5% even if @xmath75 varies between 800 and 2000 . + the parameters for exact impedance matching can be estimated with one additional cooling cycle . for the first cycle , one has to guess the value for @xmath75 and adjust @xmath71 according to simulations following the approach of fig . [ fig : matching reflection]a ) . when the resonator is cold , the reflection coefficient is measured and compared with the simulations in fig . [ fig : matching reflection]d ) . the measured reflection coefficient can then only correspond to two values for @xmath75 . if the reflection coefficient passed a minimum during cool - down , one should choose the higher value , if not , the lower value of @xmath75 . with this new value for @xmath75 , one can calculate the correct matching capacitor value @xmath71 . our experience shows that this method will yield a power reflection coefficient of less than 2% for the second cool down . rf resonators emit electromagnetic radiation , which needs to be shielded to minimize unwanted rf interference in other parts of the experiment . the rf shield needs to be grounded , and thereby generates a capacitance between the resonator and ground . this capacitance has to be minimized as suggested in  ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . in order to keep the resonator compact , we have to find a trade - off between the size of the shield and the capacitance added by it . +    ( 1,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 2.1,2.5 ) ; ( 2,2.5 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 3,2.5 ) ; ( 2.9,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.55,2.5 ) ; ( 3.4,2.5 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath8 ( 4.5,2.5 ) ; ( 4.3,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,1.735 ) ; ( 6.2,1.825 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath10 ( 6.2,1.425 ) ; ( 6.2,1.525 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,1 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,1 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,0.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 1,0.75 ) ; ( 5.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 4.8,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,1.725 ) ; ( 4.8,1.825 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath76 ( 4.8,1.425 ) ; ( 4.8,1.525 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,1 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 5.5,1 ) ; ( 5.1,3 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.6,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.362,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,4.538 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.762,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,3.462 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.6,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.127,2.973 ) ; ( -1.5,7 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( -0.9,7 ) ; ( -1,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , r=@xmath77 ( 0,7 ) ; ( -0.1,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 0.35,7 ) ; ( 0.25,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath78 ( 1.25,7 ) ; ( 1.15,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 1.75,7 ) ; ( 1.5,7 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 1.5,6.35 ) ; ( 1.5,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c , l_=@xmath79 ( 1.5,6.05 ) ; ( 1.5,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 1.5,5.5 ) ; ( 1.75,5.5 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( -1.5,5.5 ) ;    ( 2.24,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,6.25 ) ; ( 2.51,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.5,6.25 ) ; ( 2.74,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.75,6.25 ) ;    ( 3.25,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.6,7 ) ; ( 3.5,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , r=@xmath77 ( 4.5,7 ) ; ( 4.4,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.85,7 ) ; ( 4.75,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath78 ( 5.75,7 ) ; ( 5.65,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,6.35 ) ; ( 6,7 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 6,6.35 ) ; ( 6,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c , l_=@xmath79 ( 6,6.05 ) ; ( 6,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 6,5.5 ) ; ( 8,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c=@xmath10 ( 8,6.05 ) ; ( 8,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,5.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.25,5.5 ) ; ( -1.5,7.75 ) to[out=-90,in=-180 ] ( -1.4,8 ) to[out=0,in=-90 ] ( 0.125,8.25 ) to[out=-90,in=-180 ] ( 1.65,8 ) to[out=-0,in=-90 ] ( 1.75,7.75 ) ; ( 0.125,8.75 ) circle(0pt)node[anchor = north]half a winding ; ( -1.5,5.25 ) to[out=-90,in=180 ] ( -1.25,5 ) to[out=0,in=180 ] ( 1.5,5.25 ) to[out=0,in=+90 ] ( 2.375,4.7 ) to[out=+90,in=+180 ] ( 3.25,5.25 ) to[out=0,in=180 ] ( 6,5 ) to[out=0,in=-90 ] ( 6.25,5.25 ) ; ( 2.375,4.05 ) circle(0pt)node[anchor = south]x 2n ;    first , we need to find a model for the shield capacitance @xmath80 . [ fig : shield cap model ] depicts a model where we divide the coil in 2@xmath81 half windings . each has an ohmic resistance of @xmath82 , an inductance @xmath83 , and a capacitance to the shield @xmath84 . we can estimate @xmath84 with the standard formula for a parallel - plate capacitor if we assume that the grounded shield is parallel to the coil . from the calculations of the impedance of the entire circuit , we can extract the effective capacitance @xmath80 that occurs due to the presence of the shield . +        the results of these simulations for our pcb coils with an outer radius of 17.5 mm and an inner radius of 10.2 mm are shown in fig . [ fig : shield cap simulation ] . it can be seen that a distance of about 2 mm is sufficient to keep the additional capacitive load below 1pf . adapted simulations for the wire coils yield results similar to the ones for the pcb coils . hence , we can use the same shield for both types of coils . + we expect that the capacitance caused by the shield for the spiral coils is even smaller , because its surface is smaller . additionally , if we place the spiral coil in the center of the same shield , the distance to the shield will be 1.55 mm bigger than for the other coils . hence , the capacitance to ground will decrease further . moreover , the shield has an influence on the magnetic field lines of the spiral coil in this configuration and thereby also on the inductance and the losses of the coil . + at room temperature , the penetration depth due to skin effect in copper at frequencies around 40mhz is about 10@xmath45 m . thus , any mechanically stable shield , of a couple of 1/10 mm thickness , should yield a suitable attenuation . [ fig : resonator with shield ] shows a resonator encased in a silver - plated copper shield . the dimensions of this resonator are 57 mm x 40 mm x 10.2 mm . on the left side of the resonator , one can see a pcb with the matching network at the top and the smt - connector for the inductive pick - up at the bottom . on the right side is the pcb coil , and the two pcbs are connected together by soldered joints . in our measurement setup , we used a capacitive pick - up to measure the voltage at the trap . with the known ratio of this capacitive voltage divider , we could directly measure the voltage at the trap and calibrate the inductive pick - up of the coil . +    lcccc * name * & * t * & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 + pcb coil & 295k & 42.4mhz & 19.4 & 60 + pcb coil & @xmath8880k & 42.8mhz & 27.1 & 115 + pcb coil & @xmath8810k & 42.9mhz & 41.5 & 208 + wire coil & 295k & 36.8mhz & 25.2 & 89 + wire coil & @xmath8880k & 37.2mhz & 36.5 & 184 + wire coil & @xmath8810k & 37.9mhz & 58.9 & 624 + hts coil & @xmath8988k & 44.3mhz & 92.1 & 1172 +    table  [ tab : measurement results ] shows our measurement results . the pcb coils had an inductance very close to the desired value . unfortunately , we could not achieve the expected quality factor . we had designed the wire coils to have losses similar to the pcb coils , but the pcb coils showed much higher losses than the wire coils . we think this is due to an imperfect production process that we could not improve further with our in - house techniques . + additionally to the pcb coils in copper , we produced them in silver as well . the inductances were similar , but the losses in the silver coils were even higher . this was unexpected as silver is a better conductor than copper . but the silver coils needed to be reworked after fabrication to remove shorts between the segments . during this process , the silver coating might have been scratched , resulting in higher losses . we expect that silver plating after structuring should reduce the losses compared to a copper coil , but we were unable to do so with our in - house fabrication process . + the voltage gain of about 60 of the wire coil would require 160mw rf input power to get to the desired 170@xmath90 at the trap . if we adjust the voltage to keep the stability parameter @xmath91 , only 100mw rf input power are required at the modified resonance frequency . + we expect that one can improve the quality factor of the wire coil by using a thicker wire . we also tested a resonator with a lead - plated wire , which did not show an increased voltage gain . we either could not reach the critical temperature of lead in our test setup , or the lead was not pure enough to become superconducting . + the spiral coil showed the highest voltage gain , although the shield influences the magnetic field generated by the coil . we observed a change of the resonance frequency of a couple of percent when cooling down from liquid nitrogen temperatures to liquid helium temperatures , which we attribute to the shield surrounding the coil . with a voltage gain of 92 , one would need about 70mw of rf input power to get 170@xmath90 . with a stability parameter @xmath92 at the higher resonance frequency , it would be 82mw . we have demonstrated three designs of rf resonators for trapped ion experiments with paul traps . the pcb coils have favorable mechanical properties but still need an improved production process , such as e.g. thermal annealing . the wire coils fulfill our criteria and can be further improved by using a thicker or superconducting wire . the hts spiral coil showed the highest voltage gain , which was already accessible at temperatures reached with liquid nitrogen cooling . + efficient matching is usually difficult in a cryogenic environment because normally one can not tune the matching parameters when the cryostat is cold . we have shown a recipe to efficiently match rlc - resonators without precise knowledge of their quality factors . during this empirical study we regularly achieved matching with a power reflection of less than 2% on the second cool - down . additionally , we designed and implemented a shield for resonators to minimize rf pick - up in other parts of the experiment . we thank gerhard hendl from the institute of quantum optics and quantum information of the austrian academy of science for the production of pcbs , and pcb coils for this study . furthermore , we want to thank florian ong for feedback on the manuscript . this research was funded by the office of the director of national intelligence ( odni ) , intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) , through the army research office grant w911nf-10 - 1 - 0284 . all statements of fact , opinion or conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be construed as representing the official views or policies of iarpa , the odni , or the u.s . government . w. paul , rev . * 62 * ( 1990 ) 531 - 540 m. chwalla , j. benhelm , k. kim , g. kirchmair , t. monz , m. riebe , p. schindler , a.s . villar , w. haensel , c. f. roos , r. blatt , m. abgrall , g. santarelli , g. d. rovera , ph . laurent , phys . * 102 * ( 2009 ) 023002 h. s. margolis , g. huang , g. p. barwood , s. n. lea , h. a. klein , w. r. c. rowley , p. gill , r. s. windeler , phys . rev . a * 67 * ( 2003 ) 032501 j.i . cirac , p. zoller , phys . * 74 * ( 1995 ) 4091 - 4094 d. kielpinski , c. monroe , d.j . wineland , nature * 417 * ( 2002 ) 709 - 711 t. monz , p. schindler , j.t . barreiro , m. chwalla , d. nigg , w.a . coish , m. harlander , w. hnsel , m. hennrich , r. blatt phys . * 106 * ( 2011 ) 130506 d. porras , j.i . cirac , phys . * 92 * ( 2004 ) 207901 p. jurcevic , b.p . lanyon , p. hauke , c. hempel , p. zoller , r. blatt , c.f . roos , nature * 511 * ( 2014 ) 202 - 205 q.a . turchette , b.e . king , d. leibfried , d.m . meekhof , c.j . myatt , m.a . rowe , c.a . sackett , c.s . wood , w. itano , c. monroe , d. j. wineland , physical review a * 61 * ( 2000 ) 063418 j. labaziewicz , y. ge , p. antohi , d. leibrandt , k. r. brown , i. l. chuang , physical review letters * 100 * ( 2008 ) 013001 w.w . macalpine , r.o . schildknecht , proc . ire * 47 * ( 1959 ) 2099 - 2105 j.d . siverns , l.r . simkins , s.weidt , w.k . hensinger , appl . b * 107 * ( 2012 ) 921 - 934 s.r . jefferts , c. monroe , e.w . bell , d.j . wineland , phys . rev . a * 51 * ( 1995 ) 3112 - 3116 m. e. poitzsch , j. c. bergquist , w. m. itano , d. j. wineland , rev . sci . instrum . * 67 * ( 1996 ) 129 - 134 d. gandolfi , m. niedermayr , m. kumph , m. brownnutt , r. blatt , rev . * 83 * ( 2012 ) 084705 d. j. wineland , c. monroe , w. m. itano , d. leibfried , b. e. king , d. m. meekhof , journal of research of the national institute of standards and technology * 103 * ( 1998 ) 259 - 328 j. w. ekin , _ experimental techniques for low - temperature measurements _ ( oxford university press , 2006 ) 504 - 505 p. kamby , a. knott , m.a.e . andersen , iecon 2012 - 38th annual conference on ieee industrial electronics society ( 2012 ) 680 - 684 s. s. mohan , _ the design , modeling and optimization of on - chip inductor and transformer circuits _ thesis , department of electrical engineering , stanford university , 1999 ) d.m . pozar , _ microwave engineering _ ( john wiley & sons , 2011 )
Abstract:

Answer: trapping ions in paul traps requires high radio - frequency voltages , which are generated using resonators . when operating traps in a cryogenic environment , an in - vacuum resonator showing low loss is crucial to limit the thermal load to the cryostat . in this study , we present a guide for the design and production of compact , shielded cryogenic resonators . we produced and characterized three different types of resonators and furthermore demonstrate efficient impedance matching of these resonators at cryogenic temperatures .


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: in the last few years , the universality of the stellar initial mass function ( imf ) has been questioned by the results of theoretical studies , which consistently predict that the first stars ( hereafter pop iii stars ) had characteristic masses of 100 - 600 @xmath3 ( omukai & nishi 1998 ; abel , bryan & norman 2002 ; bromm , coppi & larson 2002 ; omukai & palla 2003 ) , about 100 times more massive than those observed today ( larson 2003 ) .    indeed , the physical conditions in primordial star - forming regions appear to systematically favor the formation of very massive stars . in particular , ( i ) the fragmentation scale of metal - free clouds is typically @xmath4 ( abel , bryan & norman 2002 ; bromm , coppi & larson 2002 ) ( ii ) because of the absence of dust grains the radiative feedback from the forming star is not strong enough to halt further gas accretion ( omukai & palla 2003 ) . ( iii ) since the accretion rate is as large as @xmath5-@xmath6 , the star grows up to @xmath7 within its lifetime ( stahler , palla & salpeter 1986 ; omukai & nishi 1998 ; ripamonti et al . 2002 ) .    in spite of the significant progresses made by numerical simulations and semi - analytic models , many aspects of primordial star formation remain to be fully understood , the more important of which are the radiative feedback effects which operate during protostellar accretion and which are likely to ultimately set the final stellar mass . by modeling the structure of the accretion flow and the evolution of the protostar , tan & mckee ( 2004 ) have recently shown that radiative feedback becomes dynamically significant at protostellar masses @xmath8 , and are likely to constrain the mass of first stars in the range @xmath9 . on the other hand , observations of present - day stellar populations show that stars form according to a salpeter imf with a characteristic mass of 1 @xmath3 , below which the imf flattens . thus , unless the current picture of primordial star formation is lacking in some fundamental physical process , a transition in the modes of star formation must have occurred during cosmic evolution . the physical processes responsible for this transition , as well as its cosmological consequences , are currently the subject of systematic investigation . in particular , following the early study by yoshii & sabano ( 1980 ) , it has been shown that a key element driving this transition is the metallicity of the star - forming gas ( omukai 2000 ; bromm et al . 2001 ; schneider et al . 2002 , 2003 ) . the fragmentation properties of the collapsing clouds change as the mean metallicity of the gas increases above a critical threshold , @xmath10 ( schneider et al . 2002 , 2003 ) . the fragmentation of clouds with @xmath11 proceeds only down to relatively massive ( @xmath12 ) cores , whereas in clouds with @xmath13 lower mass fragments can be formed . within the critical metallicity range , low - mass cores can form if a sufficient amount of metals are depleted onto solid dust grains , which provide an efficient cooling channel in the high density regime ( schneider et al . 2003 ; omukai et al . 2005 ) .    on cosmic scales , the transition between an epoch dominated by the formation of massive pop iii stars to an epoch dominated by the formation of ordinary pop ii / i stars is controlled by the strength of the so - called _ chemical feedback _ : the explosions of the first massive supernovae starts to metal - enrich the gas out of which subsequent stellar generations form . in particular , in regions of the universe where the metallicity exceeds @xmath14 , low - mass stars can form . chemical feedback self - propagates through the metal enrichment process and therefore depends on many poorly constrained parameters , such as the star formation efficiency at high redshifts , the number of supernovae per stellar mass formed , the efficiency of metal ejection and mixing . in particular , the shape of the primordial imf governs the number of pop iii stars with masses in the pair - instability supernova range ( pisn , heger & woosley 2002 ) 140 @xmath3 - 260 @xmath3 ( which contribute to the metal enrichment ) relative to that of pop iii stars which end up as massive black holes ( which instead do not contribute to the metal enrichment as all the heavy elements are captured by the black hole ) .    using a semi - analytic approach , scannapieco , schneider & ferrara ( 2003 ) have modeled the probability that a collapsing halo has been impacted by metal - enriched outflows from neighboring halos . exploring different chemical feedback strengths , they concluded that the transition between the pop iii and pop ii / i dominated star formation epochs is essentially controlled by the spatial distribution of metals . because metal enrichment is generally inefficient ( the filling factor of metals is always found to be @xmath15 ) , the transition epoch is extended in time , with coeval pop iii and pop ii / i star formation episodes , and pop iii stars still contributing to the global star formation rate at redshifts @xmath16 . these findings have very important implications for the detection of pop iii stars through their strong ly@xmath17 emission ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ) as well as the corresponding pair - instability supernova rate ( scannapieco et al . 2005 ) .    in this work , we investigate the cosmic transition between pop iii and pop ii / i stars following a complementary approach . we use the code pinocchio developed by monaco , theuns & taffoni ( 2002 ) and taffoni , monaco & theuns ( 2002 ) to produce random catalogues of dark matter halos at different redshifts . we then propagate metal enrichment along the hierarchy of mergers of star - forming galaxies to predict the number and mass distribution of metal - free objects , which can host pop iii stars , at each redshift . we then couple these findings to the star formation history ( of pop iii and pop ii / i stars ) and to the history of cosmic reionization and quantify their interplay through radiative feedback effects which can contribute to the extinction of pop iii stars . a similar approach has been recently undertaken by furlanetto & loeb ( 2005 ) with the aim of assessing the plausibility of the double reionization scenario suggested by cen ( 2003 ) as a way to meet both the constraints on the gas neutral fraction implied by observations of gunn - peterson troughs in the spectra of distant quasars ( fan et al . 2002 , 2003 ) and on the gas ionized fraction derived by the high optical depth to thomson scattering measured by the wmap satellite ( spergel et al . 2003 ; kogut et al . 2003 ) .    here we instead focus on the extinction epoch of pop iii stars which we believe to be regulated by feedback both of radiative and chemical types . we investigate the implications that complementary observations on galaxy number counts at redshifts @xmath1 ( bouwens et al . 2005 ) and on the history of cosmic reionization ( kogut et al . 2003 ) set on the transition epoch between pop iii and pop ii / i stars and on the nature of pop iii stars as sources of uv photons contributing to cosmic reionization . in particular , the detection of galaxies at the highest redshifts is challenging because of the redshifting of uv light into the infrared and the well - known limitations of current ir instruments . in spite of these difficulties , the search for high redshift galaxies , based on the dropout technique , has provided the first tentative detection of galaxies at redshifts beyond @xmath18 ( bouwens et al . 2004 ) , stimulating a re - analysis of the small amount of deep ir data . bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) looked at the prevalence of galaxies at @xmath19 by applying the dropout technique to the wide variety of deep fields that have been imaged with the near infrared camera and multi - object spectrometer ( nicmos ) on board of the hubble space telescope . using an appropriate selection criterion for high-@xmath20 sources , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) concluded that the number of @xmath21 sources must be three or fewer . when combined with the high optical depth to thomson scattering inferred from the _ wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe _ ( wmap ) satellite ( kogut et al 2003 ) , these data already provide a demanding benchmark for theoretical models . the paper is organized as follows . in section  2 we describe the different feedback effects that control the transition from a pop  iii to a pop  ii dominated star formation epoch . we illustrate the adopted chemical feedback model , predicting the number and mass function of halos which can host pop iii stars at different redshifts . in section  3 , we couple these predictions to a star formation and reionization model . in section  4 we summarize the observations of galaxy counts at redshifts @xmath22 and discuss how these can be used to set important constraints on the model . finally , in section  5 we present the main results and in section  6 we discuss their implications .    throughout the paper , we adopt a @xmath23cdm cosmological model with parameters @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 , which lie within the experimental errorbars of wmap experiment ( spergel et al . we also use the ab magnitude system , where @xmath30 is the spectral energy density within a given passband in units of erg s@xmath31 @xmath32 hz@xmath31 ] . at least three types of feedback effects can be relevant to the extinction of the first massive stars : ( i ) radiative feedback caused by h@xmath34 photo - dissociating radiation emitted by the first stellar sources , which can inhibit gas cooling and star formation inside small halos ( ii ) chemical feedback due to the release of metals and dust in the first pop iii supernova explosions , which pollute the gas out of which subsequent generations of pop ii stars form ( iii ) radiative feedback due to photo - heating filtering caused by cosmic reionization , the increased temperature of the cosmic gas suppresses the formation of galaxies below the jeans mass . a thorough discussion of each of these processes is beyond the scope of this paper and can be found in the recent extensive review by ciardi & ferrara ( 2005 ) .    as a first step , we build up the hierarchy of mergers of dark halos hosting the star formation sites . we use pinocchio code ( monaco , theuns & taffoni 2002 ; taffoni , monaco & theuns 2002 ) to generate random catalogues of dark matter halos in a hierarchical universe . our reference run has @xmath35 particles within a volume of comoving side 6 mpc  @xmath36 so that the smallest resolved dark matter halos have total mass @xmath37 ( in the merger trees only halos with at least 10 particles are considered ) . 1 summarizes the details of our reference pinocchio run and shows the redshift evolution of the largest and smallest mass present in the simulation box and of the minimum halo mass that is allowed to form stars . the latter corresponds , at each redshift , to halos with virial temperatures @xmath38k , m_min = 10 ^ 8 ( ) ^-3/2 [ eq : min ] so that stars do not form in halos which rely only on h@xmath34 cooling ( radiative feedback ) . the chosen resolution ensures that we can follow the formation of stars in the lowest mass halos at the highest redshift . due to radiative feedback , the first star - forming halos have a total mass @xmath39 and start to form at @xmath40 . this resolution is appropriate to follow the transition from a pop  iii to a pop  ii  star formation mode around redshift @xmath1 , which is the main scope of this analysis .    in fig . 2 we compare the resulting mass function of existing halos at redshifts 30 , 20 , 10 and 5 in the simulation box , to the analytic predictions of press & schechter ( 1974 ) and sheth & tormen ( 1999 ) . the errorbars are poisson errors on the counts in each mass - bin . the agreement is very good down to redshift @xmath16 showing that the chosen resolution ensures completeness in the simulation volume in the redshift range relevant to our analysis .      at each redshift , existing halos which are allowed to form stars ( @xmath41  k ) are classified as hosting pop ii ( pop iii ) stars depending on whether the halo itself or any of its progenitors have ( have not ) already experienced an episode of star formation , leading to the formation of sn progenitors which then metal - enrich the gas . note that even a single 200 @xmath3 pisn can enrich the gas within a halo with mass @xmath42 to a metallicity level well above the critical value as ,    z = 0.02 z _ ( ) ^3/2    where , following heger & woosley ( 2002 ) , we have assumed that the mass of metals released in a pisn explosion is 45% of the initial progenitor mass . this way of taking into account chemical feedback is very conservative as ( i ) we are assuming that all metals synthesized during a star formation episode remain confined ( or are re - accreted ) within the host halo and/or ( ii ) even if a fraction of metals is ejected out of the host halo , the metals that are kept within the potential well are sufficient to pollute the gas within the host system or within any unpolluted halo that the system will later merge with , to a metallicity level larger than @xmath14 . on the other hand , we are neglecting metal pollution from neighboring galaxies through enriched - winds ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ; sigward , ferrara & scannapieco 2005 ) . 3 shows the fraction of halos which can host pop iii stars ( hereafter pop iii halos ) at different redshifts as a function of their mass . the three different curves correspond to different assumptions on the shape of the primordial imf . in particular , we randomly classify pop  iii halos as sn - forming or bh - forming depending on whether they host stars with masses in the pisn range or outside this range . sn - forming halos are metal - enriched and pollute their descendants . bh - forming halos are not enriched in metals and therefore do not propagate chemical feedback along their subsequent hierarchy of mergers . the fraction of sn - forming halos , @xmath43 , is therefore a free parameter that controls the strength of chemical feedback . the three curves shown in each panel of fig . 3 correspond ( from bottom to top ) to @xmath44 . each curve represents an average over 50 realizations of the random classification procedure and the errors are poisson errors on the counts in each mass bin . when @xmath45 , all pop iii halos are sn - forming and chemical feedback is strong . the total fraction of pop iii halos decreases with time , being @xmath46 at @xmath47 and @xmath48 at @xmath49 ; at all redshifts , pop iii stars are confined to form in the smallest halo mass bins ( close to the minimum mass to form stars shown as the vertical dotted line in each panel ) . for @xmath50 ( 50% of pop iii halos host sn ) , the number of pop iii halos at each redshift is larger than the previous case ( @xmath51 at @xmath47 and @xmath52 at @xmath53 ) but pop iii halos are still confined to the smallest mass bins ( @xmath54 ) . finally , when @xmath55 the strength of chemical feedback is significantly reduced ( as only 10% of pop iii halos at each redshift host sn ) and therefore the fraction of pop iii halos is dominant at all redshifts , being @xmath56 at @xmath47 and @xmath57 at @xmath49 , not negligible even in halos with the largest mass present in the simulation box at each redshift . hereafter we only consider @xmath55 and @xmath58 as representative of weak and strong chemical feedback models .    despite the strength of chemical feedback , pop iii halos continue to form stars even at redshifts as small as @xmath16 , in agreement with the results of scannapieco et al . thus , independently of whether it preferentially propagates through galaxy mergers or through metal - enriched winds , chemical feedback always leads to a smooth transition between a pop iii and a pop ii dominated star formation epoch . note that the above results depend only on the parameter @xmath43 and on the hierarchy of galaxy mergers , and are totally independent of the star formation efficiency or of the value of critical metallicity for the transition in fragmentation scales of collapsing pre - stellar clouds .    [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]      so far , we have taken into account radiative feedback only through the choice of the minimum halo mass that can host stars . namely , we have assumed that mini - halos with virial temperatures less than @xmath59k do not significantly contribute to the cosmic star formation history . however , radiative feedback does affect larger halos , particularly when the universe is approaching the epoch of cosmic reionization . indeed , the increase in temperature of cosmic gas during reionization will suppress the formation of small galaxies with mass below the jeans mass . to quantify this effect , we follow the method proposed by gnedin ( 2000 ) and adopt the filtering mass as the characteristic scale below which the gas fraction in star forming objects , hence the fraction of stellar mass , is reduced with respect to the universal value . in particular , before reionization , the average baryon fraction ( the ratio of the mass in baryons over the total halo mass ) has the universal value @xmath60 while after reionization it can be approximated by the fitting formula ( gnedin 2000 ) ,    f_b = , [ eq : fil ]    where the characteristic mass , @xmath61 , is the total mass of objects which , on average , retain 50% of their universal baryon mass , @xmath62 . this characteristic mass is very well approximated by the linear - theory filtering mass , @xmath63 , with m_f^2/3 = _ 0^a da^m_j^2/3(t , a^)[1-()^1/2 ] ,    where the jeans mass is given by    m_j(t ) = 2.56 10 ^ 5 ( _ m h^2)^-1/2(t/)^3/2 ( 1+z)^-3/2 ,    with @xmath64 and @xmath65 the temperature and molecular weight of the cosmic gas . here we assume the temperature of ionized regions to be @xmath66  k and we modulate the increase in temperature of the cosmic gas due to reionization with the volume filling factor of ionized regions at the corresponding redshift @xmath67 ( see section  [ sec : reio ] ) . thus , the characteristic mass depends on the thermal history of the gas and it accounts for the finite time required for pressure to influence the gas distribution . the redshift evolution of the filtering mass is shown in fig .  1 for a model where reionization occurs at redshift @xmath68 ( short - dashed line ) and @xmath69 ( long - dashed line ) . the filtering mass steeply increases with time and , as expected , its value in the redshift range @xmath70 depends strongly on the reionization history . at redshift @xmath1 , the filtering mass is @xmath71 for the late reionization case , and it is a factor ten larger for the early reionization case .    as can be inferred from fig .  1 and  3 , following reionization , photoionization feedback can significantly suppress the formation of pop iii stars since halos with masses @xmath72 have evaporated at least 50% of their mass . following barkana & loeb ( 2001 ) , we compute the redshift evolution of the filling factor of hii regions as , q_hii(z ) = _ z^ dz^ ^f(z^,z ) , [ eq : reio ]    where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the present - day number densities of hydrogen and baryons ( @xmath75 is the hydrogen mass fraction ) , and @xmath76 is the production rate of ionizing photons that we can express as ,    = f_esc n _ _ ,    where @xmath77 is the escape fraction , the fraction of ionizing photons that is able to escape the host galaxy , @xmath78 is the time - averaged number of ionizing photons emitted per unit stellar mass formed , and @xmath79 is the comoving star formation density , _ = f_f_b _ m_min^ dm m ( m , z ) where @xmath80 is the star formation efficiency , @xmath81 is the baryon fraction given by eq . ( [ eq : fil ] ) , @xmath42 is the minimum halo mass to form stars ( see eq . [ eq : min ] ) and @xmath82 is the number density of halos ( pop ii and pop iii ) at redshift @xmath20 . the parameter @xmath77 also affects the relative strength of the stellar continuum and the ly@xmath17 line and nebular luminosity of each galaxy . the latter contributions are particularly important for massive pop  iii stars . finally , the function @xmath83 takes into account the effect of recombinations . assuming a time - independent volume - averaged clumping factor @xmath84 , common to all hii regions , we can write ,    f(z^,z ) = - c [ f(z^)-f(z ) ] ,    and    f(z)= ,    where @xmath85 is the hydrogen recombination rate .    for a given reionization history , it is straightforward to compute the optical depth to electron scattering as ,    _ e(z)=_0^z dz^c _ t n_e(z^ ) ,    where @xmath86 is the thomson cross section and @xmath87 is the number density of free electrons at redshift @xmath20 . in this paper we only consider the evolution of the filling factor of hii regions ( @xmath88 ) . however , for the purpose of computing the optical depth to electron scattering , we assume that @xmath89 and we neglect the contribution of electrons coming from heiii regions ( see also haiman & holder 2003 ) . under these assumptions we can write @xmath90 where @xmath67 is given by eq.(6 ) . bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) looked at the prevalence of galaxies at @xmath19 by applying the dropout technique to the wide variety of deep f110w- and f160w - band ( hereafter @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively ) fields that have been imaged with the near infrared camera and multi - object spectrometer ( nicmos ) . the principal data set is constituted by two 1.3 arcmin@xmath93 deep nicmos parallels taken with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) hubble ultra deep field ( udf ; each has about @xmath94 orbits data ) . complementary shallower fields possessing similar @xmath95 imaging have been analyzed as well . the 5@xmath96 limiting magnitude for the udfs is @xmath97 in @xmath91 and @xmath98 in @xmath92 ( @xmath99 aperture ) . since these limiting magnitudes are reached only in the deepest regions of the two nicmos udfs , we adopt the conservative limiting magnitude @xmath100 ( bouwens , private communication ) .    the primary selection criterion for high-@xmath20 sources is @xmath101 . using this criterion , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) found eleven sources . eight of these are ruled out as credible @xmath21 sources , either as a result of detection ( @xmath102 ) blue - ward of @xmath91 or because of their colors red - ward of the break ( @xmath103 ) . the nature of the three remaining sources could not be assessed from the data , but this number appears consistent with the expected contamination from low - redshift interlopers . hence , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) concluded that the actual number of @xmath21 sources in the nicmos parallel fields must be three or fewer .    adopting the same selection criterion as in bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) , we compute the number of @xmath104 galaxies detectable in the nicmos udfs predicted by our models . assuming that the three candidates selected by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) are indeed @xmath105 galaxies , we can set interesting constraints on the models . in particular , for a given chemical feedback strength @xmath43 , we compute the number density of pop iii and pop ii halos at each redshift . we then assume a universal value for the star formation efficiency @xmath106 and escape fraction @xmath77 of ionizing photons and we characterize each stellar population ( pop iii and pop ii / i stars ) by assuming a specific template emission spectrum .    in the following , we consider two models , a and b , whose details are given in table  1 . we assume two representative chemical feedback strengths ( @xmath43 = 0.1 for model a and @xmath43 = 1 for model b ) . in both cases , the emission properties of pop  ii stars have been computed using a simple stellar population model taken from the galaxev library ( bruzual & charlot 2003 ) . pop  ii stars have an initial metallicity of @xmath107 and are assumed to form according to a salpeter imf ( with masses in the range 0.1 @xmath3 - 100 @xmath3 ) . pop  iii stars are assumed to be very massive ( with masses larger than 100 @xmath108 ) and their emission properties are computed using the stellar spectra of schaerer ( 2002 ) , including the nebular continuum emission found to be very important for stars with strong ionizing fluxes ( bromm , kudritzki & loeb 2001 ; schaerer 2002 ) , we are not forced to make any assumption about the shape of the imf of pop  iii stars as long as these are assumed to be very massive . ] .    for each model , we then compute the number of sources per unit solid angle with observed flux in the range @xmath109 and @xmath110 as    @xmath111    where @xmath112 is the comoving volume element per unit solid angle and redshift , @xmath113 is the comoving number of objects at redshift @xmath20 with observed flux in the range @xmath114 $ ] , given by    @xmath115    here @xmath116 is the halo formation rate , and the factor @xmath117 converts the number density per unit mass in unit flux interval . the average flux @xmath109 from a halo of mass @xmath118 at redshift @xmath20 that has formed at @xmath119 is ,    @xmath120    where @xmath121 is the template luminosity per unit solar mass for a population of age @xmath122 ( the time elapsed between the redshift @xmath123 and @xmath20 ) , @xmath124 is the luminosity distance , @xmath125 is the instrumental bandwidth , @xmath126 and @xmath127 are the restframe frequencies corresponding to the observed ones . finally , @xmath128 is the intergalactic medium ( igm ) effective optical depth at @xmath129 between redshift @xmath130 and @xmath20 ( see sect . 2.2 of salvaterra & ferrara 2003 ) we compute the expected number of @xmath1 galaxies detectable in the nicmos udfs using eqs . [ eq : counts1]-[eq : counts3 ] and applying the same selection criterion of bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) ( @xmath101 , integrated up to the magnitude limit of the survey , @xmath100 ) . assuming that only the three most luminous sources should be above the detection threshold , we derive the maximum allowed value for the star formation efficiency , @xmath80 , corresponding to a given escape fraction of ionizing photons . the results obtained for models a and b are shown in fig .  4 in terms of comoving star formation density in pop  iii and pop  ii stars as a function of redshift . model c will be discussed in section [ sec : reio ] .    in each panel , vertically ( horizontally ) shaded regions represent the range of star formation histories for pop  iii ( pop  ii ) stars allowed by the nicmos - udfs counts when a value @xmath131 in assumed ( see table  1 for the corresponding values of @xmath80 ) . for both models and all the explored values of @xmath77 , the three most luminous objects in nicmos udfs are always represented by galaxies hosting pop  iii stars , as their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular emission ( schaerer 2002 ) is dominant . as a consequence , @xmath80 is restricted to relatively small values , which increase with increasing @xmath77 . model b , being characterized by the strongest chemical feedback , and therefore by the smallest fraction of halos hosting pop  iii stars at redshift @xmath132 ( see also fig . 3 ) , has larger allowed star formation efficiencies than model a.    fig . 4 shows that in model a chemical feedback is very inefficient ( @xmath133 ) and pop  iii stars dominate the cosmic star formation history down to redshift @xmath134 . conversely , model b shows that when chemical feedback is maximally efficient , the star formation density in pop  iii stars is sub - dominant at all but the highest redshifts , but pop  iii stars still make a significant contribution to the cosmic star formation history down to redshift 5 .    because of the moderate star formation efficiencies implied by the observed nicmos udfs counts , radiative feedback is negligible for the most massive galaxies . to evaluate its impact on the predicted star formation densities shown in fig .  4 , we have assumed a clumping factor @xmath135 . for @xmath136 , the corresponding reionization redshifts vary in the range @xmath137 for model a , and in the range @xmath138 for model b.    in model a , radiative feedback effect on the overall pop  iii star formation density manifests itself as a progressive decrement of the upper limit ( which corresponds to the largest @xmath77 and @xmath80 ) of the shaded region for @xmath139 . in model b , where the star formation efficiencies implied by the observed counts are larger and , at each redshift , pop  iii stars are confined to form only in the smallest halos , radiative feedback is more significant ; around redshift 10 , the lines corresponding to the maximum and minimum pop  iii star formation efficiencies cross each other ( the highest the star formation efficiency and escape fraction , the strongest the radiative feedback ) . overall , the observed galaxy counts at redshift @xmath1 favor a cosmic star formation history where the transition from pop  iii to pop  ii stars is governed by strong chemical feedback , with all pop  iii halos efficiently propagating metal enrichment to their descendants along the hierarchy of galaxy mergers . in fact , in less efficient chemical feedback scenarios ( @xmath140 ) , the predicted cosmic star formation density is dominated by pop iii stars down to redshift @xmath53 . stronger constraints on models a and b come from their corresponding reionization histories . figs .  5 and  6 show isocontours of redshifts of reionization as a function of the clumping factor and the escape fraction ( the star formation efficiency is set by the observed counts at @xmath1 ) . we define the redshift of reionization , @xmath141 , as the redshift when the filling factor of ionized regions , given by eq . ( [ eq : reio ] ) is @xmath142 . the shaded regions indicate the parameter space which leads to an optical depth to electron scattering within the range @xmath143 observed by the wmap satellite ( spergel et al . 2003 ; kogut et al . 2003 ) , with the dashed line corresponding to the central value . as it can be inferred from the figures , both models lead to reionization histories which are in poor agreement with observations . indeed , large escape fractions and moderate clumping factors are required to reproduce the observed range of optical depths . independent observations of the escape fraction give , with few exceptions , values in the range @xmath144 ( ciardi & ferrara 2005 and references therein ) whereas numerical simulations ( gnedin & ostriker 1997 ; iliev , scannapieco & shapiro 2005 ) and semi - analytic models ( madau , haardt & rees 1999 ) predict clumping factors in the range @xmath145 . 5 shows that in model a , even assuming an homogeneous igm ( @xmath146 ) , the escape fraction has to be @xmath147 to be marginally consistent with the observations . in model b , the agreement improves but still requires extreme assumptions on either the escape fraction or the clumping factor : when @xmath144 , the predicted optical depth lies within -1@xmath96 error from the observed value only if @xmath148 . our analysis suggests that it is very hard to reconcile the observed number counts at redshift @xmath1 with the reionization history inferred by wmap observations if pop  iii stars are assumed to be all very massive , with masses @xmath149 . this result is somehow counter - intuitive because metal - free very massive stars have always believed to play an important role in an early epoch of cosmic reionization ( cen 2003 ; haiman & holder 2003 ; sokasian et al . 2004 , 2004 ; venkatesan , tumlinson & shull 2003 ; wyithe & loeb 2003 ; but see also ciardi , ferrara & white 2003 , and ricotti & ostriker 2004 for alternative interpretations ) . still , due to their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular luminosity , pop  iii stars with masses @xmath150 always dominate the predicted galaxy number counts at @xmath1 , even assuming the strongest chemical feedback model . the paucity of candidate objects observed in nicmos udfs implies that star formation in halos with @xmath151  k must have occurred very inefficiently . even if all three objects identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) are truly @xmath1 sources , the contribution of pop  iii stars to cosmic reionization is strongly constrained . the constraints are particularly severe when chemical feedback is less efficient ( model a ) , because pop  iii stars can form at redshift @xmath1 in relatively large , and therefore luminous , galaxies . even if chemical feedback is assumed to be maximally efficient and pop  iii stars are confined to form in the smallest halos , their contribution to cosmic reionization is in agreement with observations only for moderate ( @xmath152 ) clumping factors . unless an additional type of feedback comes into play , the transition between pop  iii to pop  ii halos , regulated by chemical and radiative feedback , is very smooth . thus , to relax the severe upper limits placed on the star formation efficiencies by nicmos udfs counts , the emission properties of pop  iii stars have to be modified .    in particular , if pop  iii stars are assumed to form according to a salpeter imf with masses in the range @xmath153 , their ly@xmath17 and nebular emission is strongly suppressed . in this limit , ( see model c in table  1 ) , all pop  iii halos contribute to chemical feedback , @xmath154 , because each burst of star formation leads to the formation of sn progenitors and nicmos udfs counts at @xmath1 are dominated by pop  ii galaxies . as a consequence , the upper limit on the star formation efficiency set by the observed counts is @xmath155 , much higher than those found for models a and b and independent of the escape fraction . the predicted evolution of the star formation density in pop ii and pop iii stars is shown in the lowest panel of fig . similar to model b , pop ii star dominate the star formation history at all but the highest redshifts . indeed , in our approach the transition between pop iii and pop ii dominated star formation epochs is controlled only by the strength of chemical feedback ( @xmath156 ) and it is independent of the assumed star formation efficiencies ( see section [ sec : chem ] ) . however , contrary to model b , the star formation density depends on the escape fraction only indirectly , through the strength of radiative feedback . for this reason , the shaded regions representing the range of allowed star formation densities are not degenerate only after reionization which , for @xmath157 and @xmath158 occurs at redshift @xmath159 ( for pop ii stars , which are preferentially hosted in large halos , this effect is negligible ) . the implications for the history of reionization are summarized in fig . 7 , which shows that model c is in much better agreement with observations than model a and b. the optical depth observed by wmap can be reproduced with @xmath144 even if the clumping factor is as high as @xmath160 . thus , when the observed @xmath1 counts are used to set an upper limit to the allowed star formation efficiency , pop  iii stars forming with a conventional imf are more efficient sources of cosmic reionization than very massive stars . note that this conclusion is independent on issues related to chemical and radiative feedback . indeed , both models b and c assume maximally efficient chemical feedback and radiative feedback plays a minor role for model c because the predicted @xmath1 counts are dominated by massive pop  ii galaxies , which are largely unaffected by photoevaporation . fig.7 shows that the best - fit value of optical depth implied by wmap observations , @xmath161 , can only be reproduced by model c with @xmath144 if @xmath162 . if larger values of @xmath84 are to be favored or the observed optical depth will be corrected up - ward in future wmap data releases , a revision of model c is to be considered .    however , unless the nicmos udfs counts have under - estimated by a large factor the number of @xmath1 sources , our results suggest that the only plausible revision of model c is to modify the primordial imf by increasing the characteristic mass but allowing pop  iii stars to form only in the conventional mass range , @xmath163 . in fig . 8 we show the predicted optical depth as a function of the pop  iii characteristic stellar mass , @xmath164 . we assume that the characteristic stellar mass enters in the definition of the stellar imf as suggested by larson ( 1998 ) ,    ( 1 + ) ^-1.35 , which , for @xmath165 leads to the standard salpeter imf .    for a given @xmath164 , we compute @xmath166 considering the proper emission rate of ionizing photons ( taken from table  1 of ciardi & ferrara 2005 ) , assuming @xmath167 , three different clumping factors @xmath168 and 30 , and that either all 3 or none of the candidates identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) in nicmos udfs represent @xmath1 galaxies ( upper and lower limits to each shaded region ) . 8 shows that the predicted optical depth depends more on the clumping factor than on the assumed value of @xmath164 . if @xmath135 , the predicted @xmath166 is in agreement with the observed values even assuming @xmath165 , consistent with the results shown in fig . 7 . if @xmath169 , wmap and nicmos udfs data can be reconciled only if all three candidates are confirmed to be @xmath1 galaxies and if the characteristic pop  iii stellar mass is @xmath170 . finally , if the observed @xmath166 will be corrected up - ward in future analyses of wmap data , none of the models considered , independently of the assumed @xmath164 , will be able to reconcile the observed reionization history with the counts at @xmath171 , unless @xmath172 . the tentative detections of @xmath1 galaxies in nicmos udfs by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) provides tight constraints on the relative contributions of pop  iii and pop  ii stars to the galaxy luminosity function . when coupled to the reionization history of the universe implied by the wmap satellite , this collection of data sets represents already a very demanding benchmark for galaxy evolution models . stimulated by these data , we have followed the assembling history of high - redshift galaxies hosting the first stars in a hierarchical model for structure formation . adopting simple prescriptions for chemical and radiative feedbacks along with available data , we have constrained the evolution of the imf of the first stars . in particular we find that :    1 .   two types of feedbacks need to be considered : ( ia ) radiative feedback , which suppresses star formation in h@xmath34-cooling halos and the formation of low - mass galaxies because of photoionization heating following reionization , and ( ib ) chemical feedback due to the progressive enrichment of ( pop  ii ) star forming gas by the metals released by the first ( pop  iii ) stellar explosions . 2 .   if chemical feedback is weak ( @xmath133 ) pop  iii stars can form in relatively large halos and dominate the evolution of the cosmic star formation density down to redshift @xmath16 . more realistic scenarios are found assuming @xmath154 , where pop  iii stars are confined to form only in the smallest halos at each redshift . 3 .   the combined effect of radiative and chemical feedbacks fails to suppress the formation of massive pop  iii stars at @xmath139 . if pop  iii stars are assumed to form with a top - heavy imf , that is with masses @xmath173 , pop  iii galaxy are always found to dominate the predicted @xmath1 nicmos udfs counts . because of their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular luminosities , very tight upper limits on the star formation efficiency in @xmath174  k halos are placed by the paucity of observed counts . the corresponding reionization histories fail to reproduce the observed wmap optical depths unless uncomfortably large values for the escape fraction of ionizing photons and/or too small values for the igm clumping factor are assumed . reionization constraints from wmap and observed @xmath1 counts in nicmos udfs can be reconciled if pop  iii stars form according to a larson imf with stellar masses in the conventional range @xmath175 and a characteristic mass @xmath176 if the clumping factor is @xmath177 , or @xmath178 if the clumping factor is as large as 30 . in the latter case , at least 1 candidate identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) has to be a galaxy at @xmath1 . our analysis is based on the assumption that chemical feedback propagates along the hierarchy of galaxy mergers from progenitors to descendants rather than through metal - enriched galaxy outflows ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ) . by adopting this simplified scheme , we are implicitly assuming that ( i ) even if a fraction of metals is ejected out of the host halo , the metals that are kept within the potential well are sufficient to pollute the gas within the host system or within any unpolluted halo that the system will later merge with , to a metallicity level larger than @xmath14 and that ( ii ) metal pollution from neighboring galaxies is negligible . in spite of these simplifying assumptions , the resulting pop  iii and pop  ii star formation histories are consistent with the predictions of scannapieco et al . in particular , even assuming a maximally efficient chemical feedback , the transition is always predicted to be very smooth , with pop  iii stars which continue to form in the smallest halos at each redshift down to @xmath16 . interestingly enough , our conclusion is independent of the primordial imf and/or star formation efficiency . we show that models where all pop  iii halos are able to metal pollute their descendants ( @xmath154 ) are favored by observations . the smoothness of the cosmic imf transition is therefore strictly linked to the inhomogeneous character of the metal enrichment process , independently of how it is implemented in the models .    even if we have adopted a very approximate description of the thermal evolution of the cosmic gas , we find that radiative feedback following reionization can play an important role in the extinction of pop  iii stars . in particular , if reionization occurs at redshifts @xmath179 ( @xmath1 ) the baryon fraction in @xmath180 halos is reduced to 70% ( 99% ) of its universal value ( @xmath60 ) at redshift 10 and to 10% ( 30% ) of this value at redshift 5 . thus , the baryon content in the smallest halos where pop  iii stars can form at low redshift is severely limited by radiative feedback . this is strongly related to the epoch of cosmic reionization which , in turn , depends on the degree of inhomogeneities which characterize the cosmic gas . we have parametrized this quantity through a constant clumping factor @xmath84 and we have explored different values of @xmath84 ranging from 1 to 50 . however , it is likely that the degree of clumpiness of the cosmic gas varies with time , rising from @xmath181 at high redshift to a few tens at @xmath1 as structures go increasingly non - linear . recently , iliev et al . ( 2005 ) have studied the effect of igm clumping at redshifts @xmath182 , providing a fit to the evolution of the clumping factor ( see their fig .  7 ) where @xmath183 at redshift 30 and raises to @xmath184 at redshift 10 . adopting this evolution for the clumping factor and @xmath185 we find that models a and b are unable to reproduce the optical depths inferred from wmap data whereas in model c we find that reionization is complete at redshift 13.5 and that the resulting optical depth is @xmath186 in very good agreement with the observed value . thus , our analysis suggests that pop  iii stars forming with masses in the same dynamical range as pop  ii / i stars , but possibly with higher characteristic stellar mass , appear to be favored by observations . several scenarios that enable the formation of low - mass stars in metal - free environments have been proposed , among which the bi - modal imf ( nakamura & umemura 1999 , 2002 ) , enhanced hd - cooling in relic hii regions ( uehara & inutsuka 2000 ; nakamura & umemura 2002 ) , the influence of a strong uv radiation field due to the vicinity of a very massive star ( omukai & yoshii 2003 ) , fragmentation in shock - compressed shells induced by the first very massive sn explosions ( mackey , bromm & hernquist 2003 ; salvaterra , ferrara & schneider 2004 ) . however , all these processes either require very special conditions , generally related to the existence of a previous generation of very massive stars , or have failed to be realized in realistic numerical simulations . in spite of this , observations seem to indicate that either radiative feedback effects during the accretion phase on protostellar cores and/or a combination of the above mentioned processes can lead to the formation of pop  iii stars with masses @xmath187 . according to the results of our analysis , the latter contribution to the pop  iii stellar imf must be dominant at least at redshifts @xmath1 . if this scenario is correct , relics of the low - mass pop  iii star formation mode should be still present in our galaxy , eventually contributing to the lowermost end of the metallicity distribution function ( salvadori , schneider & ferrara in prep ) . we acknowledge the use of pinocchio v 1.0 package written by pierluigi monaco , tom theuns & giuliano taffoni ( http://www.daut.univ.trieste.it/pinocchio ) . this work has been partially supported by the research and training network `` the physics of the intergalactic medium '' set up by the european community under the contract hprn - ct-2000 - 00126 . 99 abel t. , bryan g. l. , norman m. l. 2002 , science , 295 , 93 barkana , r. & loeb , a. 2001 , phr , 349 , 125 bouwens r. j. et al . 2004 , , apj , 616 , l79 bouwens r. j. , illingworth g. d. , thomson r. i. , & franx m , 2005 , apj , 624 , l5 bromm , v. , ferrara a. , coppi p. s. , larson r. b. 2001 , mnras , 328 , 969 bromm , v. , kudritzki , r. p. & loeb , a. 2001 , apj , 552 , 464 bromm , v. , coppi p. s. , larson r. b. 2002 , apj , 564 , 23 bruzual , g. & charlot , s. 2003 , 344 , 1000 ciardi , b. & ferrara , a. 2005 , space science reviews , 116 , 625 ciardi , b. , ferrara , a. , white , s. d. m. 2003 , mnras , 344 , l7 cen , r. 2003 , apj , 591 , 12 furlanetto , s. & loeb , a. 2005 , apj in press , ( astro - ph/0409736 ) gnedin , n. , ostriker , j. 1997 , apj , 474 , 581 gnedin , n. 2000 , apj , 542 , 535 haiman , z. & holder , g. p. 2003 , apj , 595 , 1 heger , a. & woosley , s. 2002 , apj , 567 , 532 iliev , i. , scannapieco , e. , shapiro , p. 2005 , apj , 624 , 491 kogut , a. et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 161 larson , r. b. 1998 , mnras , 301 , 569 mackey , j. , bromm , v. , hernquist , l. 2003 , apj , 586 , 1 madau , p. , haardt , f. , rees , m.  j. 1999 , apj , 514 , 648 monaco , p. , theuns , t. & taffoni , g. 2002 , mnras , 331 , 587 nakamura , f. , umemura , m. 1999 , apj , 515 , 239 nakamura , f. , umemura , m. 2002 , apj , 569 , 549 omukai , k. & nishi , r. 1998 , apj , 508 , 141 omukai , k. 2000 , apj , 534 , 809 omukai , k. & palla , f. 2003 , apj , 589 , 677 omukai , k. & yoshii , y. 2003 , apj , 599 , 746 omukai , k. , tsuribe , t. , schneider , r. , ferrara , a. 2005 , apj , 626 , 627 ricotti , m. & ostriker , j. p. , 2004 , mnras , 350 , 539 ripamonti , e. , haardt , f. , ferrara , a. , & colpi , m. , 2002 , mnras , 334 , 401 salvaterra , r. , ferrara a. , schneider r. 2004 , new astronomy , 10 , 11 salvaterra , r. & ferrara a. 2003 , mnras , 339 , 973 scannapieco , e. , schneider , r. & ferrara , a. 2003 , apj , 589 , 1 scannapieco , e. , madau , p. , woosley , s. , heger , a. , ferrara , a. 2005 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0507182 ) schaerer , d. 2002 , a&a , 382 , 28 schneider r. , ferrara a. , natarajan p. , omukai k. 2002 , apj , 571 , 30 schneider r. , ferrara a. , salvaterra r. , omukai k. , bromm v. 2003 , nature , 422 , 869 sigward , f. , ferrara , a. & scannapieco , e. 2005 , mnras , 358 , 755 sokasian , a. , yoshida , n. , abel , t. , hernquist , l. , springel , v. 2004 , mnras 350 , 47 spergel , d. l. et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 175 stahler , s. w. , palla , f. , & salpeter , e. e. 1986 , apj , 302 , 590 tan , j. c. & mckee , c. f. 2004 , apj , 603 , 383 taffoni , g. , monaco , p. & theuns , t. 2002 , mnras , 333 , 623 uehara , h. & inutsuka , s. 2000 , apj , 531 , l91 venkatesan , a. , tumlinson , j. , shull , j.  m. 2003 , apj , 584 , 621 wyithe , j. s. b. & loeb , a. 2003 , apj , 588 , l69 yoshii , y. , sabano , y. 1980 , pasj , 32 , 229
Abstract:

Answer: motivated by theoretical predictions that first stars were predominantly very massive , we investigate the physics of the transition from an early epoch dominated by massive pop  iii stars to a later epoch dominated by familiar low - mass pop  ii / i stars by means of a numerically - generated catalogue of dark matter halos coupled with a self - consistent treatment of chemical and radiative feedback . depending on the strength of the chemical feedback , pop  iii stars can contribute a substantial fraction ( several percent ) of the cosmic star formation activity even at moderate redshifts , @xmath0 . we find that the three @xmath1 sources tentatively detected in nicmos udfs should be powered by pop  iii stars , if these are massive ; however , this scenario fails to reproduce the derived wmap electron scattering optical depth . instead , both the udfs and wmap constraints can be fulfilled if stars at any time form with a more standard , slightly top - heavy , larson imf in the range @xmath2 . = = = = = = = =    # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = " 33e = = = = = = = =    # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = =    [ firstpage ]    galaxies : formation - cosmology : theory - cosmology : observations - intergalactic medium