Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: in this review i will concentrate on the values of the cosmological parameters . the other key questions in cosmology today concern the nature of the dark matter and dark energy , the origin and nature of the primordial inhomogeneities , and the formation and evolution of galaxies . i have been telling my theoretical cosmology students for several years that these latter topics are their main subjects for research , since determining the values of the cosmological parameters is now mainly in the hands of the observers .    in discussing cosmological parameters , it will be useful to distinguish between two sets of assumptions : ( a ) general relativity plus the assumption that the universe is homogeneous and isotropic on large scales ( friedmann - robertson - walker framework ) , or ( b ) the frw framework plus the  family of models . in addition to the frw framework , the  models assume that the present matter density @xmath3 plus the cosmological constant ( or its equivalent in `` dark energy '' ) in units of critical density @xmath13 sum to unity ( @xmath14 ) to produce the flat universe predicted by simple cosmic inflation models . these  models assume that the primordial fluctuations were adiabatic ( all components fluctuate together ) and gaussian , and had a zeldovich spectrum ( @xmath15 , with @xmath16 ) , and that the dark matter is mostly of the cold variety . although the results from the long - duration boomerang @xcite and the maxima-1 @xcite cmb observations and analyses @xcite were were not yet available at the dark matter 2000 conference , i have made use of them in preparing this review . the table below summarizes the current observational information about the cosmological parameters , with estimated @xmath17 errors . the quantities in brackets have been deduced using at least some of the  assumptions . the rest of this paper discusses these issues in more detail . but it should already be apparent that there is impressive agreement between the values of the parameters determined by various methods . the strongest lower limits for @xmath2 come from studies of the stellar populations of globular clusters ( gcs ) . in the mid-1990s the best estimates of the ages of the oldest gcs from main sequence turnoff magnitudes were @xmath18 gyr @xcite . a frequently quoted lower limit on the age of gcs was @xmath19 gyr @xcite , which was then an even more conservative lower limit on @xmath20 , where @xmath21 gyr is the time from the big bang until gc formation . the main uncertainty in the gc age estimates came from the uncertain distance to the gcs : a 0.25 magnitude error in the distance modulus translates to a 22% error in the derived cluster age @xcite .    in spring of 1997 , analyses of data from the hipparcos astrometric satellite indicated that the distances to gcs assumed in obtaining the ages just discussed were systematically underestimated @xcite . it follows that their stars at the main sequence turnoff are brighter and therefore younger . stellar evolution calculation improvements also lowered the gc age estimates . in light of the new hipparcos data , chaboyer et al . @xcite have done a revised monte carlo analysis of the effects of varying various uncertain parameters , and obtained @xmath22 gyr ( @xmath17 ) , with a 95% c.l . lower limit of 9.5 gyr . the latest detailed analysis @xcite gives @xmath23 gyr from main sequence fitting using parallaxes of local subdwarfs , the method used in @xcite . these authors get somewhat smaller gc distances when all the available data is used , with a resulting @xmath24 gyr ( 95% c.l . ) . however , if main sequence fitting is the more reliable method , the younger age may be more appropriate . stellar age estimates are of course based on stellar evolution calculations , which have also improved significantly . but the solar neutrino problem reminds us that we are not really sure that we understand how even our nearest star operates ; and the sun plays an important role in calibrating stellar evolution , since it is the only star whose age we know independently ( from radioactive dating of early solar system material ) . an important check on stellar ages can come from observations of white dwarfs in globular and open clusters @xcite . what if the gc age estimates are wrong for some unknown reason ? the only other non - cosmological estimates of the age of the universe come from nuclear cosmochronometry  radioactive decay and chemical evolution of the galaxy  and white dwarf cooling . cosmochronometry age estimates are sensitive to a number of uncertain issues such as the formation history of the disk and its stars , and possible actinide destruction in stars @xcite . however , an independent cosmochronometry age estimate of @xmath25 gyr has been obtained based on data from two low - metallicity stars , using the measured radioactive depletion of thorium ( whose half - life is 14.2 gyr ) compared to stable heavy r - process elements @xcite . this method could become very important if it were possible to obtain accurate measurements of r - process element abundances for a number of very low metallicity stars giving consistent age estimates , and especially if the large errors could be reduced . independent age estimates come from the cooling of white dwarfs in the neighborhood of the sun . the key observation is that there is a lower limit to the luminosity , and therefore also the temperature , of nearby white dwarfs ; although dimmer ones could have been seen , none have been found ( cf . however @xcite ) . the only plausible explanation is that the white dwarfs have not had sufficient time to cool to lower temperatures , which initially led to an estimate of @xmath26 gyr for the age of the galactic disk @xcite . since there was evidence , based on the pre - hipparcos gc distances , that the stellar disk of our galaxy is about 2 gyr younger than the oldest gcs ( e.g. , @xcite ) , this in turn gave an estimate of the age of the universe of @xmath27 gyr . other analyses @xcite conclude that sensitivity to disk star formation history , and to effects on the white dwarf cooling rates due to c / o separation at crystallization and possible presence of trace elements such as @xmath28ne , allow a rather wide range of ages for the disk of about @xmath29 gyr . one determination of the white dwarf luminosity function , using white dwarfs in proper motion binaries , leads to a somewhat lower minimum luminosity and therefore a somewhat higher estimate of the age of the disk of @xmath30 gyr @xcite . more recent observations @xcite and analyses @xcite lead to an estimated age of the galactic disk of @xmath31 gyr . we conclude that @xmath7 gyr , with @xmath32 gyr a likely lower limit . note that @xmath33 gyr implies that @xmath34 for matter density @xmath35 , and that @xmath36 even for @xmath37 as small as 0.3 in flat cosmologies ( i.e. , with @xmath38 ) . the hubble parameter @xmath40 km s@xmath1 mpc@xmath1 remains uncertain , although no longer by the traditional factor of two . the range of @xmath41 determinations has been shrinking with time @xcite . de  vaucouleurs long contended that @xmath42 . sandage has long contended that @xmath43 , although a recent reanalysis of the type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) data coauthored by sandage and tammann @xcite concludes that the latest data are consistent with @xmath44 . the hubble parameter has been measured in two basic ways : ( 1 ) measuring the distance to some nearby galaxies , typically by measuring the periods and luminosities of cepheid variables in them ; and then using these `` calibrator galaxies '' to set the zero point in any of the several methods of measuring the relative distances to galaxies . ( 2 ) using fundamental physics to measure the distance to some distant object(s ) directly , thereby avoiding at least some of the uncertainties of the cosmic distance ladder @xcite . the difficulty with method ( 1 ) was that there was only a handful of calibrator galaxies close enough for cepheids to be resolved in them . however , the hst key project on the extragalactic distance scale has significantly increased the set of calibrator galaxies . the difficulty with method ( 2 ) is that in every case studied so far , some aspect of the observed system or the underlying physics remains somewhat uncertain . it is nevertheless remarkable that the results of several different methods of type ( 2 ) are rather similar , and indeed not very far from those of method ( 1 ) . this gives reason to hope for convergence . one piece of good news is that the several methods of measuring the relative distances to galaxies now mostly seem to be consistent with each other . these methods use either `` standard candles '' or empirical relations between two measurable properties of a galaxy , one distance - independent and the other distance - dependent . the favorite standard candle is sne ia , and observers are now in good agreement . taking account of an empirical relationship between the sne ia light curve shape and maximum luminosity leads to @xmath45 @xcite , @xmath46 @xcite , or @xmath47 @xcite , and the slightly lower value mentioned above from the latest analysis coauthored by sandage and tammann agrees within the errors . the hst key project result using sne ia is @xmath48 , where the first error quoted is statistical and the second is systematic @xcite , and their cepheid metallicity - dependent luminosity - period relationship @xcite has been used ( this lowers @xmath41 by 4% ) . some of the other relative distance methods are based on old stellar populations : the tip of the red giant branch ( trgb ) , the planetary nebula luminosity function ( pnlf ) , the globular cluster luminosity function ( gclf ) , and the surface brightness fluctuation method ( sbf ) . the hst key project result using these old star standard candles is @xcite @xmath49 , including the cepheid metallicity correction . the old favorite empirical relation used as a relative distance indicator is the tully - fisher relation between the rotation velocity and luminosity of spiral galaxies . the `` final '' value of the hubble constant from the hst key project taking all of these into account , including the metallicity dependence of the cepheid period - luminosity relation , is @xcite @xmath50 , where the first error is statistical and the second is systematic . the largest source of systematic uncertainty is the distance to the lmc , which is here assumed to have a distance modulus of 18.45 . this is a significantly higher @xmath41 than their previous @xcite @xmath51 , or @xmath52 including the cepheid metallicity dependence , using a lmc distance modulus of 18.5 . the fundamental physics approaches involve either type ia or type ii supernovae , the sunyaev - zeldovich ( s - z ) effect , or gravitational lensing of quasars . all are promising , but in each case the relevant physics remains somewhat uncertain .    the @xmath53ni radioactivity method for determining @xmath39 using type ia sne avoids the uncertainties of the distance ladder by calculating the absolute luminosity of type ia supernovae from first principles using plausible but as yet unproved physical models for @xmath53ni production . the first result obtained was that @xmath54 @xcite ; however , another study @xcite ( cf . @xcite ) found that uncertainties in extinction ( i.e. , light absorption ) toward each supernova increases the range of allowed @xmath41 . demanding that the @xmath53ni radioactivity method agree with an expanding photosphere approach leads to @xmath55 @xcite . the expanding photosphere method compares the expansion rate of the sn envelope measured by redshift with its size increase inferred from its temperature and magnitude . this approach was first applied to type ii sne ; the 1992 result @xmath56 @xcite was subsequently revised upward by the same authors to @xmath57 @xcite . however , there are various complications with the physics of the expanding envelope @xcite . the s - z effect is the compton scattering of microwave background photons from the hot electrons in a foreground galaxy cluster . this can be used to measure @xmath39 since properties of the cluster gas measured via the s - z effect and from x - ray observations have different dependences on @xmath39 . the result from the first cluster for which sufficiently detailed data was available , a665 ( at @xmath58 ) , was @xmath59 @xcite ; combining this with data on a2218 ( @xmath60 ) raised this somewhat to @xmath61 @xcite . the history and more recent data have been reviewed by birkinshaw @xcite , who concludes that the available data give a hubble parameter @xmath62 with a scatter of about 0.2 . but since the available measurements are not independent , it does not follow that @xmath56 ; for example , there is a selection effect that biases low the @xmath41 determined this way . several quasars have been observed to have multiple images separated by @xmath63 a few arc seconds ; this phenomenon is interpreted as arising from gravitational lensing of the source quasar by a galaxy along the line of sight ( first suggested by @xcite ; reviewed in @xcite ) . in the first such system discovered , qso 0957 + 561 ( @xmath64 ) , the time delay @xmath65 between arrival at the earth of variations in the quasar s luminosity in the two images has been measured to be , e.g. , @xmath66 days @xcite , although other authors found a value of @xmath67 days @xcite . the shorter @xmath65 has now been confirmed @xcite . since @xmath68 , this observation allows an estimate of the hubble parameter . the latest results for @xmath41 from 0957 + 561 , using all available data , are @xmath69 ( 95% c.l . ) @xcite , and @xmath70 @xcite , where the error does not include systematic errors in the assumed form of the lensing mass distribution . the first quadruple - image quasar system discovered was pg1115 + 080 . using a recent series of observations ( schechter et al . 1997 ) , the time delay between images b and c has been determined to be about @xmath71 days . a simple model for the lensing galaxy and the nearby galaxies then leads to @xmath72 ( schechter et al . 1997 ) , although higher values for @xmath41 are obtained by more sophisticated analyses : @xmath73 @xcite , @xmath74 @xcite . the results depend on how the lensing galaxy and those in the compact group of which it is a part are modelled . another quadruple - lens system , b1606 + 656 , leads to @xmath75 , where the first error is the 95% c.l . statistical error , and the second is the estimated systematic uncertainty @xcite . time delays have also recently been determined for the einstein ring system b0218 + 357 , giving @xmath76 ( 95% c.l . ) @xcite . mainly because of the systematic uncertainties in modelling the mass distribution in the lensing systems , the uncertainty in the @xmath41 determination by gravitational lens time delays remains rather large . but it is reassuring that this completely independent method gives results consistent with the other determinations .      to summarize , relative distance methods favor a value @xmath77 . meanwhile the fundamental physics methods typically lead to @xmath78 . among fundamental physics approaches , there has been important recent progress in measuring @xmath41 via the sunyev - zeldovich effect and time delays between different images of gravitationally lensed quasars , although the uncertainties remain larger than via relative distance methods . for the rest of this review , we will adopt a value of @xmath79 . this corresponds to @xmath80 gyr for @xmath35  probably too low compared to the ages of the oldest globular clusters . but for @xmath81 and @xmath82 , or alternatively for @xmath83 and @xmath84 , @xmath85 gyr , in agreement with the globular cluster estimate of @xmath2 . this is one of the weakest of the several arguments for low @xmath3 , a non - zero cosmological constant , or both . the recent atmospheric neutrino data from super - kamiokande @xcite provide strong evidence of neutrino oscillations and therefore of non - zero neutrino mass . these data imply a lower limit on the hot dark matter ( i.e. , light neutrino ) contribution to the cosmological density @xmath86 . @xmath5 is actually that low , and therefore cosmologically uninteresting , if @xmath87 , as is suggested by the hierarchical pattern of the quark and charged lepton masses . but if the @xmath88 and @xmath89 are nearly degenerate in mass , as suggested by their strong mixing , then @xmath5 could be substantially larger . although the cold + hot dark matter ( chdm ) cosmological model with @xmath90 , @xmath35 , and @xmath91 predicts power spectra of cosmic density and cmb anisotropies that are in excellent agreement with the data @xcite , as we have just seen the large value measured for the hubble parameter makes such @xmath35 models dubious . it remains to be seen whether including a significant amount of hot dark matter in low-@xmath3 models improves their agreement with data . primack & gross @xcite found that the possible improvement of the low-@xmath3 flat ( ) cosmological models with the addition of light neutrinos appears to be rather limited , and the maximum amount of hot dark matter decreases with decreasing @xmath3 @xcite . for @xmath92 , @xcite find that @xmath93 ; @xcite finds more restrictive upper limits with the constraint that the primordial power spectrum index @xmath94 , but this may not be well motivated . the strongest evidence for a positive @xmath95 comes from high - redshift sne ia , and independently from a combination of observations indicating that @xmath96 together with cmb data indicating that the universe is nearly flat . we will discuss these observations in the next section . here we will start by looking at other constraints on @xmath95 . the cosmological effects of a cosmological constant are not difficult to understand @xcite . in the early universe , the density of energy and matter is far more important than the @xmath95 term on the r.h.s . of the friedmann equation . but the average matter density decreases as the universe expands , and at a rather low redshift ( @xmath97 for @xmath98 , @xmath99 ) the @xmath95 term finally becomes dominant . around this redshift , the @xmath95 term almost balances the attraction of the matter , and the scale factor @xmath100 increases very slowly , although it ultimately starts increasing exponentially as the universe starts inflating under the influence of the increasingly dominant @xmath95 term . the existence of a period during which expansion slows while the clock runs explains why @xmath2 can be greater than for @xmath101 , but this also shows that there is an increased likelihood of finding galaxies in the redshift interval when the expansion slowed , and a correspondingly increased opportunity for lensing by these galaxies of quasars ( which mostly lie at higher redshift @xmath102 ) . the observed frequency of such optical lensed quasars is about what would be expected in a standard @xmath103 , @xmath101 cosmology , so this data sets fairly stringent upper limits : @xmath104 at 90% c.l . @xcite , with more recent data giving even tighter constraints : @xmath105 at 95% confidence if @xmath106 @xcite . this limit could perhaps be weakened if there were ( a ) significant extinction by dust in the e / s0 galaxies responsible for the lensing or ( b ) rapid evolution of these galaxies , but there is much evidence that these galaxies have little dust and have evolved only passively for @xmath107 @xcite . an alternative analysis @xcite of some of the same optical lensing data gives a value @xmath108 . my group @xcite ( cf . @xcite ) showed that edge - on disk galaxies can lens quasars very effectively , and discussed a case in which optical extinction is significant . but the radio observations discussed by @xcite , which give a @xmath109 limit @xmath110 , are not affected by extinction , so those are the ones quoted in the table above . recently a reanalysis @xcite of lensing using new models of the evolution of elliptical galaxies gave @xmath111 , but kochanek et al . @xcite ( see especially fig . 4 ) show that the available evidence disfavors such models . a model - dependent constraint appeared to come from simulations of @xmath95cdm @xcite and opencdm @xcite cobe - normalized models with @xmath112 , @xmath98 , and either @xmath99 or , for the open case , @xmath82 . these models have too much power on small scales to be consistent with observations , unless there is strong scale - dependent antibiasing of galaxies with respect to dark matter . however , recent high - resolution simulations @xcite find that merging and destruction of galaxies in dense environments lead to exactly the sort of scale - dependent antibiasing needed for agreement with observations for the  model . similar results have been found using simulations plus semi - analytic methods @xcite ( but cf . @xcite ) . another constraint on @xmath95 from simulations is a claim @xcite that the number of long arcs in clusters is in accord with observations for an open cdm model with @xmath98 but an order of magnitude too low in a  model with the same @xmath3 . this apparently occurs because clusters with dense cores form too late in such models . this is potentially a powerful constraint , and needs to be checked and understood . it is now known that including cluster galaxies does not alter these results @xcite . the present author , like many theorists , has long regarded the einstein - de sitter ( @xmath35 , @xmath101 ) cosmology as the most attractive one . for one thing , of the three possible constant values for @xmath113  0 , 1 , and @xmath114  the only one that can describe our universe is @xmath35 . also , cosmic inflation is the only known solution for several otherwise intractable problems , and all simple inflationary models predict that the universe is flat , i.e. that @xmath115 . since there is no known physical reason for a non - zero cosmological constant , it was often said that inflation favors @xmath103 . of course , theoretical prejudice is not a reliable guide . in recent years , many cosmologists have favored @xmath116 , both because of the @xmath117 constraints and because cluster and other relatively small - scale measurements have given low values for @xmath3 . ( for a summary of arguments favoring low @xmath118 and @xmath101 , see @xcite ; @xcite is a review that notes that larger scale measurements favor higher @xmath3 . ) but the most exciting new evidence has come from cosmological - scale measurements . * type ia supernovae . * at present , the most promising techniques for measuring @xmath3 and @xmath6 on cosmological scales use the small - angle anisotropies in the cmb radiation and high - redshift type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) . we will discuss the latter first . sne ia are the brightest supernovae , and the spread in their intrinsic brightness appears to be relatively small . the supernova cosmology project @xcite demonstrated the feasibility of finding significant numbers of such supernovae . the first seven high redshift sne ia that they analyzed gave for a flat universe @xmath119 , or equivalently @xmath120 ( @xmath121 at the 95% confidence level ) @xcite . but adding one @xmath122 sn ia for which they had good hst data lowered the implied @xmath3 to @xmath123 in the flat case @xcite . analysis of their larger dataset of 42 high - redshift sne ia gives for the flat case @xmath124 where the first errors are statistical and the second are identified systematics @xcite . the high - z supernova team has also searched successfully for high - redshift supernovae to measure @xmath3 @xcite , and their 1998 dataset of @xmath125 high - redshift sne ia including three for which they had hst data ( two at @xmath126 and one at 0.97 ) imply @xmath127 in the flat case with their mlcs fitting method . the main concerns about the interpretation of this data are evolution of the sne ia @xcite and dimming by dust . a recent specific supernova evolution concern is that the rest frame rise - times of distant supernovae may be longer than nearby ones @xcite . but a direct comparison between nearby supernova and the scp distant sample shows that they are rather consistent with each other @xcite . ordinary dust causes reddening , but hypothetical `` grey '' dust would cause much less reddening and could in principle provide an alternative explanation for the fact that high - redshift supernovae are observed to be dimmer than expected in a critical - density cosmology . grey interstellar dust would induce more dispersion than is observed , so the hypothetical grey dust would have to be intergalactic . it is hard to see why the largest dust grains , which would be greyer , should preferentially be ejected by galaxies @xcite . such dust , if it exists , would also absorb starlight and reradiate it at long wavelengths , where there are other constraints that could , with additional observations , rule out this scenario @xcite . such grey dust would also produce some reddening which could be detectable via comparison of infrared vs. optical colors of supernovae ; such a measurement for one high - redshift sn ia disfavors significant grey dust extinction @xcite , and more observations could strengthen this conclusion . yet another way of addressing this question is to collect data on supernovae with redshift @xmath128 , where the dust scenario predicts considerably more dimming than the @xmath95 cosmology . the one @xmath128 supernova currently available , scp s `` albinoni '' ( sn1998eq ) at @xmath129 , favors the @xmath95 cosmology . more such data are needed for a statistically significant result , and both the scp and the high - z group are attempting to get a few more very high redshift supernovae .    * cmb anisotropies . * the location of the first acoustic ( or doppler , or sakharov ) peak at angular wavenumber @xmath130 indicated by the data available at the time of this meeting was evidence in favor of a flat universe @xmath131 ( e.g. @xcite ) . new data from the boomerang long - duration balloon flight around antarctica @xcite and the maxima-1 balloon flight @xcite confirm this , with @xmath132 at 95% c.l . @xcite . the preliminary boomerang results @xcite are lower around @xmath133 than the predictions in this second peak region in -type models ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and this could @xcite indicate higher @xmath4 than expected from big bang nucleosynthesis together with the recent deuterium measurements ( discussed below ) . however , the maxima-1 data for @xmath134 are more consistent with expectations of standard models and the standard bbn @xmath4 @xcite ( but cf . @xcite ) . the boomerang and maxima-2 data are still being analyzed , and other experiments will have relevant data as well . further data should be available in 2001 from the nasa microwave anisotropy probe satellite . * large - scale measurements . * the comparison of the iras redshift surveys with potent and related analyses typically give values for the parameter @xmath135 ( where @xmath136 is the biasing parameter for iras galaxies ) , corresponding to @xmath137 ( for an assumed @xmath138 ) . it is not clear whether it will be possible to reduce the spread in these values significantly in the near future  probably both additional data and a better understanding of systematic and statistical effects will be required . a particularly simple way to deduce a lower limit on @xmath3 from the potent peculiar velocity data was proposed by @xcite , based on the fact that high - velocity outflows from voids are not expected in low-@xmath113 models . data on just one nearby void indicates that @xmath139 at the 97% c.l . stronger constraints are available if we assume that the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the primordial fluctuations was gaussian . evolution from a gaussian initial pdf to the non - gaussian mass distribution observed today requires considerable gravitational nonlinearity , i.e. large @xmath3 . the pdf deduced by potent from observed velocities ( i.e. , the pdf of the mass , if the potent reconstruction is reliable ) is far from gaussian today , with a long positive - fluctuation tail . it agrees with a gaussian initial pdf if and only if @xmath140 ; @xmath141 is rejected at the @xmath109 level , and @xmath142 is ruled out at @xmath143 @xcite . it would be interesting to repeat this analysis with newer data . analyzing peculiar velocity data without potent again leads to a strong lower limit @xmath144 ( 99% c.l . ) , and together with the sn ia constraints leads to the conclusion that @xmath145 @xcite .    * measurements on scales of a few mpc . * a study by the canadian network for observational cosmology ( cnoc ) of 16 clusters at @xmath146 , mostly chosen from the einstein medium sensitivity survey @xcite , was designed to allow a self - contained measurement of @xmath3 from a field @xmath147 which in turn was deduced from their measured cluster @xmath147 . the result was @xmath148 @xcite . these data were mainly compared to standard cdm models , and they appear to exclude @xmath35 in such models .    * estimates on galaxy halo scales . * work by zaritsky et al . @xcite has confirmed that spiral galaxies have massive halos . they collected data on satellites of isolated spiral galaxies , and concluded that the fact that the relative velocities do not fall off out to a separation of at least 200 kpc shows that massive halos are the norm . the typical rotation velocity of @xmath149 km s@xmath1 implies a mass within 200 kpc of @xmath150 . a careful analysis taking into account selection effects and satellite orbit uncertainties concluded that the indicated value of @xmath3 exceeds 0.13 at 90% confidence @xcite , with preferred values exceeding 0.3 . newer data suggesting that relative velocities do not fall off out to a separation of @xmath151 kpc @xcite presumably would raise these @xmath3 estimates . weak lensing data confirms the existence of massive galactic halos @xcite . * cluster baryons vs. big bang nucleosynthesis . * white et al . @xcite emphasized that x - ray observations of the abundance of baryons in clusters can be used to determine @xmath3 if clusters are a fair sample of both baryons and dark matter , as they are expected to be based on simulations @xcite . the fair sample hypothesis implies that @xmath152 we can use this to determine @xmath3 using the baryon abundance @xmath153 ( 95% c.l . ) from the measurement of the deuterium abundance in high - redshift lyman limit systems , of which a third has recently been analyzed @xcite and more are in the pipeline d. tytler , these proceedings . using x - ray data from an x - ray flux limited sample of clusters to estimate the baryon fraction @xmath154 @xcite gives @xmath155 using @xmath79 . estimating the baryon fraction using sunyaev - zeldovich measurements of a sample of 18 clusters gives @xmath156 @xcite , and implies @xmath157 . * cluster evolution . * the dependence of the number of clusters on redshift can be a useful constraint on theories @xcite . but the cluster data at various redshifts are difficult to compare properly since they are rather inhomogeneous . using just x - ray temperature data , @xcite concludes that @xmath158 , with @xmath35 strongly disfavored .    * power spectrum . * in the context of the  class of models , two additional constraints are available . the spectrum shape parameter @xmath159 , implying @xmath9 . a new measurement @xmath160 comes from the amplitude of the power spectrum of fluctuations at redshift @xmath161 , measured from the lyman @xmath162 forest @xcite . this result is strongly inconsistent with high-@xmath3 models because they would predict that the fluctuations grow much more to @xmath163 , and thus would be lower at @xmath164 than they are observed to be . we thus end up with a picture of the distribution of the density of energy density in a flat universe represented by figure 1 @xcite . one of the most striking things about the present era in cosmology is the remarkable agreement between the values of the cosmological densities and the other cosmological parameters obtained by different methods  except possibly for the quasar lensing data which favors a higher @xmath3 and lower @xmath6 , and the arc lensing data which favors lower values of both parameters . if the results from the new cmb measurements end up agreeing with those from the other methods discussed above , the cosmological parameters will have been determined to perhaps 10% , and cosmologists can focus their attention on the other subjects that i mentioned at the beginning : origin of the initial fluctuations , the nature of the dark matter and dark energy , and the formation of galaxies and large - scale structure . cosmologists can also speculate on the reasons why the cosmological parameters have the values that they do , but this appears to be the sort of question whose answer may require a deeper understanding of fundamental physics  perhaps from a superstring theory of everything . this work was supported in part by nsf and nasa grants and a faculty grant at ucsc . i am grateful to leo stodolsky for hospitality at the max planck institute for physics in munich , and to the alexander von humboldt foundation for a humboldt award . primack , n.e . abrams , ` introduction to the conference ' , in : _ cosmic questions conference , smithsonian museum of natural history , washington , dc , april 1999 _ ( ny academy of sciences , new york 2000 , in press )
Abstract:

Answer: the cosmological parameters that i will emphasize are the hubble parameter @xmath0 km s@xmath1 mpc@xmath1 , the age of the universe @xmath2 , the average matter density @xmath3 , the baryonic matter density @xmath4 , the neutrino density @xmath5 , and the cosmological constant @xmath6 . the evidence currently favors @xmath7 gyr , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 .


Instruction: Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper.

Input:
Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .

Paper: the quasar pmn  j01340931 calls attention to itself in many ways . it is very bright at radio frequencies ( 1  jy at 2  ghz ) ; its optical counterpart is extraordinarily red ( @xmath0 ) ; and it has a unique radio morphology consisting of six compact components within a circle of diameter @xmath1 . it is therefore unsurprising , in retrospect , that it was discovered to be an interesting object by two independent groups . winn et al . ( 2002a ; hereafter , w02 ) found it during a survey for radio - loud gravitational lenses . they showed that at least five of the six radio components have identical continuum radio spectra , and discovered a curved arc of radio emission joining two of the components . these properties are hallmarks of strong gravitational lensing . gregg et al . ( 2002 ; hereafter , g02 ) found it in a cross - compilation of radio , optical , and near - infrared catalogs that was designed to identify the reddest quasars on the sky . they measured its redshift ( @xmath2 ) and found at least three components in a near - infrared image . the multiplicity of the near - infrared counterpart , and the extremely large inferred luminosity ( @xmath3 , even under the conservative assumption of no extinction ) were evidence of gravitational lensing . however , neither group could explain the unique morphology with a plausible lens model , because strong lensing by a single galaxy usually results in only two or four images . another difficulty was that two of the components were found to have a lower surface brightness than the other components in high - resolution radio images , in apparent contradiction of the conservation of surface brightness by gravitational lensing . also unknown was the reason for the extremely red color of . the two most obvious possibilities  reddening due to dust in the host galaxy , or due to dust in the lens galaxy  could not be distinguished . @xcite detected strong  h and k absorption lines at @xmath4 ( presumably the lens redshift ) , but they were not able to determine the reason for the redness of the quasar spectrum .    in a companion paper , keeton & winn ( 2003 ; hereafter , kw03 ) present the first quantitative models that explain all the previously known properties of . in those models , five of the radio components are multiple images of a single quasar , and the sixth component represents a different source , which is presumably a second component of the same background radio source . the positions of the two lens galaxies are constrained remarkably well by the observed image configuration . furthermore , the two low - surface - brightness components are located close to the expected position of one of the lens galaxies , suggesting that scatter broadening by ionized material in that lens galaxy could account for their large angular sizes . in addition to explaining the previous data , the kw03 models make a number of predictions about more subtle properties of  that would be detectable in radio and optical observations with high sensitivity and high angular resolution . in this paper we present multi - frequency observations of  with the very long baseline array ( vlba ) and the hubble space telescope ( hst ) that confirm some of these predictions , and refute none of them .    before describing the new observations , in   [ sec : overview ] we provide an overview of the previously - known radio morphology of , and the nomenclature used to describe it . we also review the main features of the kw03 models . the radio data (   [ sec : radio ] ) confirm that the sixth and faintest radio component has a significantly different spectral index than the other five components (   [ sec : cmptf ] ) . the two components that were observed to have larger angular sizes are indeed being scatter broadened (   [ sec : scatter ] ) . there is tantalizing ( but tentative ) evidence for one of the additional images of the second background source that are predicted by the kw03 models (   [ sec : counterimage ] ) . the extended radio emission (   [ sec : arc ] ) and component shapes (   [ sec : shapes ] ) can be explained by the models . after subtracting point sources from the optical images (   [ sec : optical ] ) , we identify two faint but significant peaks of residual flux as direct detections of the lens galaxies (   [ sec : lensgals ] ) . the optical counterparts of the radio components have different colors , and their optical flux ratios differ from their radio flux ratios , implying that the extreme red color of  is at least partly due to reddening by dust in the lens galaxy (   [ sec : colors ] ) . finally , in   [ sec : summary ] , we summarize the evidence that  is the first known instance of a quintuply - imaged quasar . figure  [ fig : overview ] is a diagram of the observed configuration of the radio components . the dots represent the six compact radio components a  f , which are named in decreasing order of radio flux density . the size of each dot is proportional to the logarithm of its flux density ratio relative to component d. the angular sizes of c and e are much larger than the other components at 1.7  ghz and 5.0  ghz , which is why we have used gray dots to represent those components instead of black dots . there is a curved arc extending between a and b at 1.7  ghz , represented schematically by a solid line . components a  e all have the same spectral index , as measured from 5  ghz to 43  ghz ( @xmath5 , where @xmath6 ) , but the spectral index of f was unknown .    according to the kw03 models , the background radio source has two components ( s@xmath7 and s@xmath8 ) and there are two lens galaxies ( gal - n and gal - s ) . the five observed radio components a  e are five images of s@xmath7 , and f is the brightest of three images of s@xmath8 . the positions and masses of the lens galaxies are fairly well constrained by the data , but their ellipticities and position angles are not . for reference , the critical curves and caustics of a representative lens model are shown in fig . [ fig : lensmodel ] . the reader is referred to kw03 for a full theoretical analysis . this system was observed with the vlba at 1.7  ghz and 5.0  ghz by w02 . below , we present the results from new vlba observations at three different frequencies . we also present images based on both the old and the new data , to provide a uniform multi - frequency study . a list of the basic parameters of all the vlba observations is given in table  [ tbl : journal ] . the new observations were conducted in standard vlba continuum frequency bands at 2.3  ghz , 8.4  ghz , and 15  ghz . the array consisted of the usual ten antennas , except that the pie town antenna did not participate in the 15  ghz observation . for the 2.3  ghz observation , we did not employ phase referencing because the source was sufficiently bright for self - calibration . at the higher frequencies , we switched between  and the nearby , bright , compact source j01410928 in order to calibrate the relative antenna gains . the cycle times were 4 minutes and 2 minutes at 8.4  ghz and 15  ghz , respectively . short observations of the bright radio sources j2253 + 1608 and j0555 + 3948 were included to serve as fringe - finders and to correct large delay errors . the observing bandwidth of 32  mhz per polarization was divided into 4 sub - bands of width 8  mhz . both senses of polarization were recorded with 1-bit sampling . the data were correlated in socorro , new mexico , producing 16 channels of width 0.5  mhz from each sub - band , with an integration time of one second . calibration was performed with aips using standard procedures summarized as follows . obviously corrupted data , and data taken at elevations less than @xmath9 , were discarded . visibility amplitudes were calibrated using on - line measurements of antenna gains , system temperatures , and voltage offsets in the samplers . large delay errors were removed by fringe - fitting the data from a 1.5-minute observation of j2253 + 1608 and applying the delay corrections to all the data . at 2.3  ghz , we corrected residual rates , delays , and phases by fringe - fitting the data from  directly ; at the higher frequencies we fringe - fitted data from j01410928 and interpolated the solutions . after calibration , the data were averaged in time and frequency in order to reduce the data volume , but we ensured that the final sampling was still fine enough to produce @xmath101% smearing over the desired field of view . lccrccrc    2000  apr  28 & 4.99 & 1 & @xmath11 & 0.50 & @xmath12 & @xmath13 & 0.30 + 2000  oct  31 & 1.67 & 4 & @xmath14 & 1.00 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & 0.20 + 2001  oct  17 & 2.27 & 7 & @xmath14 & 1.00 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 & 0.23 + 2001  dec  08 & 8.42 & 7 & @xmath19 & 0.25 & @xmath20 & @xmath21 & 0.13 + 2002  feb  02 & 15.36 & 7 & abc :  @xmath11 & 0.15 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & 0.36 + & & & df :  @xmath24 & 0.15 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & 0.32 + & & & e :  @xmath24 & 0.15 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & 0.37 +      imaging was performed with aips . for each frequency , we first applied a gaussian tapering function to the visibility data , to emphasize the low - resolution ( short - baseline ) information , and used the clean algorithm to create a preliminary model of the detected radio structures . this model was used to self - calibrate the antenna phases . a new map was created with no tapering function , and the process of cleaning and self - calibration was repeated until no further improvement was noted . we then used the latest clean model to self - calibrate the relative amplitudes of the antennas with a solution interval of 30  minutes . the amplitude corrections were typically smaller than 10% . we used a moderately uniform weighting ( robust  @xmath25 , in aips ) for the final images . we also applied the self - calibration and imaging procedures described above to the previously published 1.7  ghz and 5.0  ghz data , for the sake of uniformity . this resulted in an improvement in dynamic range over the previously published images , due to the increased care in removing corrupted data , the use of amplitude self - calibration , and the different choice of visibility weighting .    in all cases except 15  ghz , we created one wide - field image , centered between components b and d in right ascension , and between d and e in declination . at 15  ghz we used the multiple - field clean algorithm to deconvolve three fields simultaneously : one field centered on components a , b , and c ; one field centered on component e ; and one field centered on components d and f.    figure  [ fig : grayscale - maps ] shows wide - field grayscale images for all frequencies except 15  ghz . these images provide an overview of the detected radio structures . to ease the visual interpretation of these images , they were created after applying a gaussian tapering function to the visibility data , and were restored with a circular gaussian beam . for the 1.7  ghz and 2.3  ghz images , the tapering function declined to 30% at a visibility radius of @xmath26 , and the restoring beam had a diameter of 20  milli - arc  seconds ( mas ) . for the 5.0  ghz and 8.4  ghz images , the corresponding values were @xmath27 and 7  mas . we also present narrow - field contour maps of the fields surrounding components a , b , and c ( figure  [ fig : abc ] ) , components d and f ( figure  [ fig : df ] ) , and component e ( figure  [ fig : e ] ) . the 15  ghz contour maps are presented separately for each component ( figure  [ fig : uband ] ) . all the contour maps were created without any tapering function and therefore employ the full resolution of the observations . these contour maps allow for a closer examination of individual component sizes and shapes . the most important parameters describing these full - resolution images are given in table  [ tbl : journal ] : the image dimensions , the major and minor axes ( full - width - half - maximum ) and orientation of the restoring beam , and the root - mean - squared ( r.m.s . ) noise level . we draw attention to some features of these images and contour maps that will be discussed in detail , and placed in the context of the kw03 models , in subsequent sections :    1 . component f is detected at all frequencies except 15  ghz . it is especially prominent at 1.7  ghz but fades relative to d as the frequency increases (   [ sec : cmptf ] ) . components c and e are heavily resolved at 1.7  ghz , are faint and resolved at 2.3  ghz and 5  ghz , and are compact and bright at the highest frequencies . by contrast , components b and d are compact at all frequencies (   [ sec : scatter ] ) . 3 .   in the 1.7  ghz map , there is extended radio emission near the expected location of c , but its centroid appears to be shifted @xmath2830 mas south (   [ sec : counterimage ] ) . the radio arc between a and b was detected at the two lowest frequencies . in addition , at 1.7  ghz , there is a significant extension of component a towards the expected location of c (   [ sec : arc ] ) . 5 .   at 15  ghz ( fig . [ fig : uband ] ) , component b appears to be a fainter and parity - reversed copy of component a. component c is elongated along a line pointing to a (   [ sec : arc ] ) . we measured the total flux density of each radio component by fitting an elliptical gaussian function to the appropriate region of each vlba image using the aips procedure jmfit , which takes into account the ellipticity of the restoring beam . the results are given in table  [ tbl : fluxes ] . the flux densities of components a , b , d , and f are plotted in figure  [ fig : cmptf ] as a function of frequency . also plotted is the total flux density of all components , from the measurements compiled by w02 . the upper limit on the flux of f at 15  ghz represents the @xmath29 level in that region of the image . results for components c and e are not plotted because , for these components , a substantial amount of flux is `` resolved out '' at low frequencies due to the interferometer s lack of short baselines .    the continuum spectra of components a , b , and d are nearly identical , while the spectrum for component f is significantly steeper . to make the difference in spectral slope obvious to the eye , we have divided the flux densities of d by 9 , to match the 1.7  ghz flux density of f , and plotted the results with open squares . using the measurements at which the components are fairly compact and the fitting results are therefore most accurate , we find spectral slopes of @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 ( where @xmath33 ) . these values agree with the value @xmath34 measured by w02 using lower - resolution data . for component f , using measurements at all frequencies for which it was detected , @xmath35 .    in the kw03 scenario , a  e are multiple images of the same quasar , and should have nearly identical spectral indices , but f need not have ( and probably would not have ) the same spectral index . it was already established by w02 that a  e have the same spectral index . by establishing that f has a different spectral index than the other components , our analysis has confirmed this key expectation of the kw03 models . cccccc a & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 + b & @xmath41 & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 + c & & & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 + d & @xmath49 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 + e & & & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 + f & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 ( @xmath29 )      one objection to the kw03 models , or any scenario in which components a  e are gravitationally lensed images of a single source component , is that components c and e were observed to have a much lower surface brightness at 1.7  ghz and 5.0  ghz than the other components . the problem is that gravitational lensing can not alter surface brightness . however , it is possible for a non - gravitational effect , namely scatter broadening due to electron - density fluctuations in the lens galaxy or our own galaxy , to cause differences in the surface brightness of lensed images . if different images pass through different electron columns they will be broadened by different amounts . scatter broadening can be recognized because the angular size of an affected source increases strongly with observing wavelength . for a source that is intrinsically a point source , the angular size due to scatter broadening is typically proportional to @xmath62 where @xmath63 ( for a review , see * ? ? ? * ) . a particularly well - studied case is sgr  a@xmath64 ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . among gravitational lenses , the best - studied case of differential scatter broadening is pks  1830211 @xcite . in that case , the broader image passes through the spiral arm of the lens galaxy where a higher electron column density might be expected @xcite . our vlba maps strongly suggest that components a , c , and e are being scatter broadened . all three of these components are fairly compact at 15  ghz , but are heavily resolved at 5  ghz and very heavily resolved at 1.7  ghz . this is despite the _ decreasing _ angular resolution of the observations as one proceeds to lower frequencies . to test the @xmath65-dependence , we fitted elliptical gaussians to all the components detected in each image ( as in   [ sec : cmptf ] ) . the fitting procedure takes into account the intrinsic ellipticity of the beam and finds the deconvolved major and minor axes ( @xmath66 and @xmath67 ) . we note that it would be preferable to fit models to the visibility data rather than the image data , because the noise properties of the visibility data are better understood , but in this case visibility - fitting was unfeasible because of the large data volume . we also note that not all the components are well described by ellipses , especially at 15  ghz , but the results from elliptical fits should be accurate enough to determine the approximate logarithmic scaling . figure  [ fig : scatter ] shows the dependence of @xmath66 on @xmath68 for components a , c , and e. as a measure of the angular resolution , we have plotted black dots indicating the length of the minor axis of the restoring beam , which is approximately proportional to @xmath68 . for comparison , we have also plotted the results for component d , which does not exhibit scatter broadening ; its size is comparable to or smaller than the beam minor axis in all cases except 1.7  ghz . ( component b does not appear to be scatter - broadened either , but the results are not plotted in order to reduce clutter . )    components a , c , and e are well - approximated by the @xmath65 law ( dashed line ) , although the true dependence is not as steep , especially when the 15  ghz ( 2  cm ) point is included . given that scatter broadening seems inevitable as an explanation for the wavelength - dependent morphology of these components , we believe that the departure from the @xmath65 law shows that the observed angular size is partially intrinsic at the shortest wavelengths . the dotted line shows the expectation of a scatter - broadened source with intrinsic size 2  mas . the source shapes in the 8.4  ghz and 15  ghz images appear to be mainly intrinsic . the flux densities , major and minor axis sizes , and position angles of the components , taken from the 15  ghz image in order to minimize scatter broadening , are given in table  [ tbl : shapes ] . the observed angular sizes can be used to estimate the scattering measure ( sm ) along the lines of sight to the broadened components . the sm is defined as the line - of - sight integral of @xmath69 , where @xmath69 is the normalization of the power spectrum of electron - density fluctuations . assuming a kolmogorov spectrum , the sm can be related to the observed broadening of an extragalactic source via the relation ( see fey , spangler , & cordes 1991 , eq .  4 ; or cordes & lazio 2003 , eq . a17 ) : @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the frequency at the lens redshift , and sm has the units m@xmath72  kpc . this predicts that angular size should vary as @xmath73 , a little steeper than observed . nevertheless , the best fit to the data plotted in fig .  [ fig : scatter ] gives sm  @xmath28  1525  m@xmath72  kpc . this value is too large to be attributed to ionized material in our galaxy . the galactic latitude of  is @xmath74 , and the sm along such high - latitude lines of sight in the galaxy is typically less than @xmath75  m@xmath72  kpc ( cordes & lazio 2003 , fig . by contrast , the sm for low - latitude lines of sight in our galaxy can exceed @xmath76  m@xmath72  kpc , and has an average value of order unity within @xmath77 . this suggests that a spiral lens galaxy viewed nearly edge - on could produce the observed broadening , although it seems unlikely that the disk would be aligned just right to intersect all three components a , c , and e. it could also be that the lens galaxy has a larger electron content than our galaxy . we caution , however , that comparisons with our galaxy may be misleading because the observed major axes of @xmath2830  mas at 18  cm correspond to a physical size of @xmath28150@xmath78  pc at the lens redshift , which is much larger than the length scales probed by scattering effects in our galaxy . ( for exactly that reason , observations of scatter broadening in gravitational lens systems such as  may prove useful for characterizing electron - density fluctuations on scales inaccessible in our galaxy . ) cccccc    a & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + b & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 + c & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 + d & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 + e & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103      component f , in the kw03 models , is actually the brightest of three images of the second source component s@xmath8 . the other two images of s@xmath8 ( the `` counter - images '' of f ) are expected to be located just south of components c and e. for convenience , we refer to the hypothetical counter - images near c and e as components @xmath104  and @xmath105 , respectively . the kw03 models suggest that the flux ordering , from brightest to faintest , is f@xmath104@xmath105 . it is also possible that there are two additional counter - images located between a and b , for a total of five , but the models that produce these two additional counter - images occupy a tiny volume in the phase space of model parameters explored by kw03 . there is suggestive evidence for one of these counter - images in the 1.7  ghz map . in fig . [ fig : abc ] , black dots mark the positions of a , b , and c ( as measured at higher frequencies ) , and the predicted position of @xmath104 . there is a puff of extended radio emission located @xmath2830  mas due south of the expected position of component c. the location of the peak emission is not consistent with c , but it is within 6  mas of the predicted position of @xmath104 . its total flux density is @xmath2810  mjy , or @xmath2890% of the total flux density of f , which is also the expectation of the kw03 models . it is therefore possible that c is almost completely resolved out at 1.7  ghz , and the extended emission that is observed is instead the scatter - broadened counter - image @xmath104 . the reason we consider the evidence `` suggestive '' rather than definitive is that @xmath104  was not detected at any other frequency . in particular , the 8.4  ghz data are inconsistent with @xmath106 , unless @xmath104  is being scatter - broadened even at that higher frequency . therefore , we withhold final judgment on whether the detected flux is actually @xmath104until it can be detected at a higher frequency . the challenge will be to achieve the required signal - to - noise ratio in spite of the steep spectrum of s@xmath8 ( see   [ sec : cmptf ] ) . assuming that we did not detect additional radio components , we can set upper limits on the fluxes on @xmath104  and @xmath105 . we express these limits as ratios relative to component f , because lens models directly prescribe the magnification ratios of the counter - images relative to component f. we derive the limits from the 8.4  ghz map , because that is the highest - frequency image in which f is detected . by requiring the flux density of a point source be below @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the noise level of the 8.4  ghz image , we find @xmath109 and @xmath110 .    as discussed in detail by kw03 , the limit on @xmath105  is not constraining , but the limit on @xmath104  formally rules out all but a few models . however , as mentioned previously , the true limit on @xmath104  may be weaker due to scatter broadening . for example , assuming that the observed sizes of c and e at 8.4  ghz are due entirely to scatter broadening , we might allow @xmath104  and @xmath105  to have the same ratio of total to peak flux density . modified in this way , the upper limits become @xmath111 and @xmath112 , which are consistent with all the kw03 models . the truth lies somewhere between these extremes , because the observed sizes of c and e at 8.4  ghz are probably at least partially intrinsic ( see   [ sec : scatter ] ) . the radio arc joining components a and b was known previously , and is a natural consequence of the kw03 models . in addition , the kw03 models predict there should be a bridge of radio emission between components a and c. the detailed surface brightness profile of the bridge depends on the source size and shape , but it is otherwise a robust prediction . there are two indications in the radio maps that this is correct . the first indication is found in the lowest - frequency ( 1.7  ghz ) image , in which there are faint traces of extended flux between components a and c. this can be seen in the upper left panel of fig . [ fig : grayscale - maps ] , as a faint prong extending eastward from component a , but is more easily seen in the upper left panel of fig . [ fig : abc ] . the lowest 3 contours ( @xmath29 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 ) bulge eastward from a to c.    the second indication is the orientation of component c in the higher - frequency ( 5  ghz , 8.4  ghz and 15  ghz ) images . the deconvolved position angle of c is oriented nearly along the direction to component a. for example , at 15  ghz , where we expect the observed orientation to be intrinsic , component c is elongated with position angle @xmath115 , whereas the direction from c to a has position angle @xmath116 ( see the lower left panel of figure  [ fig : abc ] ) .      since we have argued that the observed sizes of the radio components at 15  ghz are mainly intrinsic , the morphologies of the components should provide clues about the properties of the background source and the correct lens model . in fig . [ fig : uband ] , component a appears to be a two - sided core - jet source . there is a longer and more prominent jet directed southwest of the core , towards b , and there is a shorter jet directed northeast . component b also appears to be a core - jet source , but only one jet is observed , and is directed northeast , towards a. apparently , a and b are opposite - parity images of a two - sided core - jet source , but only one jet is apparent in b due to the relative compression of that image by the lens mapping . the morphologies of the other components are simpler . component c is highly elongated towards a , as already noted . component d is mainly compact but does have a faint extension to the southwest , suggesting that d and a have the same parity . component e is resolved but is too faint for a detailed examination . component f was not detected . the kw03 models predict that a and b have opposite parities , and that a and d have the same parity , which is consistent with the observed morphologies . in addition , the position angles given in table  [ tbl : shapes ] for components a  e can be produced by 23% of the models discussed by kw03 . however , we caution against over - interpreting the shape parameters . as described in   [ sec : scatter ] , they were derived by the simple procedure of fitting a single elliptical gaussian function to each component . the quoted errors are the statistical errors in the fitting process , and are therefore under - estimated for those components that are not well described by ellipses ( especially a and b ) . the most secure parameters are the position angles , and the least secure parameters are the minor axis lengths ( which in some cases are considerably smaller than the restoring beam ) . on 2001  july  18 we obtained optical images of  in the f555w ( hereafter , @xmath117 ) and f814w ( @xmath118 ) filters on the wfpc2 camera of the hst . we obtained two 21.7-minute exposures at each of two dither positions , for a total exposure time of 86.8  minutes per filter . the target was centered in the pc chip , which has a pixel scale of @xmath119  pixel@xmath120 . the exposures were combined and cosmic rays rejected using standard iraf procedures . the images are shown in the upper two panels of figure  [ fig : hst ] . components a and b were detected in both filters . component d was detected in @xmath118-band but is nearly absent in @xmath117-band . these same data were previously analyzed by @xcite , who also measured the optical flux ratios and detected residual flux after subtracting point sources at the positions of the radio components . our results confirm this previous work . however , as described below , our more detailed methods have allowed us to proceed further in the interpretation of the results . we built photometric models of the hst images using custom software for convolving a parametric model with a simulated psf and varying the model parameters to achieve the best fit to the images . the simulated psf was generated with the tiny tim program by @xcite . for the @xmath117-band image , the model consisted of 5 point sources , representing the radio components a  e . at @xmath118-band we found that components a and b are not well represented by point sources , possibly due to a contribution from the quasar host galaxy . we obtained much smaller residuals by allowing for small gaussian components at the locations of both a and b , in addition to point sources . even with this modification , there were still significant residuals . in figure [ fig : hst ] we show the residuals as grayscale images overlaid with white contours . the positions of the subtracted components are marked with white circles . the ring of negative residuals surrounding component a is spurious and due to imperfect psf subtraction , but there are two peaks of positive emission in the residual images .    1 .   the `` northern peak , '' @xmath121 south and @xmath122 east of e , and 2 . the `` southern peak , '' @xmath123 south and @xmath124 east of c.    we believe these two peaks represent genuine emission rather than artifacts of the subtraction . this pattern of residuals did not appear when we applied the same fitting and subtraction procedure to an isolated field star on the pc chip . in addition , although the peaks are more prominent in @xmath118-band , they are detected in both filters , despite the completely different psf . @xcite already noted the presence of low - surface - brightness flux underlying the point sources . however , the pattern in their residual image is less obvious , possibly due to an inferior psf subtraction . they used only integral pixel shifts , did not simultaneously fit for the fluxes of the point sources , and did not allow for any extension of a and b.    interestingly , g02 also found two residual peaks of emission by deconvolving a ground - based @xmath125-band image . the locations of each @xmath125-band peak is within @xmath126 of the corresponding peak in our images , which is fairly good agreement , considering that the spurious residuals around a may be corrupting our measurements of the peak locations . although g02 were unsure whether the @xmath125-band peaks represented genuine emission , or artifacts of the deconvolution , we argue that the observation of similar peaks at both @xmath118-band and @xmath117-band lends confidence to all three detections . the detection of two diffuse light sources is a further confirmation of the two - galaxy kw03 lens models . as discussed further by kw03 , the predicted positions of the galaxies are both within @xmath127 of the observed locations at @xmath118-band and @xmath117-band . the approximate range of lens galaxy positions predicted by kw03 is indicated by the two small gray ellipses in figure  [ fig : hst ] . it is not clear how seriously to take the observed morphologies of the northern and southern peaks , because they are faint , and because of possible contamination by spurious residuals from the psf subtraction . nevertheless , given the morphology of the southern peak observed in both filters , we conjecture that the southern lens galaxy is elongated east - west , and overlaps component d at its easternmost extent . this would explain the very red color of d ( see   [ sec : colors ] ) . we measured the optical fluxes of components a  e using the psf - fitting procedure described above . the optical flux ratios for a  e , relative to component b , are given in table  [ tbl : ratios ] for both the @xmath118 and @xmath117 filters . for some components we could derive only upper limits . for reference , we also list the radio values measured by w02 . cccc    a & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + b & @xmath131 & @xmath131 & @xmath131 + c & @xmath132 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + d & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 + e & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & @xmath139    to convert the fluxes to standard photometric magnitudes , we adopted zero points of 21.69 for f814w and 22.56 for f555w , based on the work of @xcite and corrected for infinite aperture . no correction was attempted for the charge - transfer - efficiency ( cte ) problem of wfpc2 . the total magnitudes of all the components in our model was @xmath140 and @xmath141 , in good agreement with the ground - based photometry of w02 ( @xmath142 , @xmath143 ) . all the components that were detected are very red . even component b , the bluest of the detected components , has @xmath144 . this is redder , for example , than any of the 157 quasars in the radio - selected ( and optically unbiased ) sample of parkes sources that was investigated by @xcite ( see fig .  4 of that work ) . the optical flux ratios disagree strongly with the radio flux ratios , even though gravitational lensing is achromatic . this is a common observation among gravitational lenses , usually attributed to dust extinction by the lens galaxy ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) or optical microlensing @xcite , although in this case the differential extinction is larger than usual . by comparing the radio flux ratios and the optical flux ratios , we can estimate the difference between the @xmath118-band extinction @xmath145 incurred by b ( the bluest component ) , and the @xmath118-band extinction incurred by the other components : @xmath146 where @xmath147 refers to the @xmath118-band flux of component b , and so forth . the results for the components , in order from bluest to reddest , are : @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 . ( the position of c in the ordering is uncertain because the result is a relatively weak upper limit . ) the most plausible explanation for the different optical colors of all the lensed components is differential reddening due to dust in the lens galaxies . the main alternative explanation , microlensing , is implausible because it is unlikely that microlensing would affect more than one image to the required degree at the same time . @xcite , for example , estimate there is only a 30% chance for even one image of a multiple - image quasar to vary by more than 0.5  mag over 10  years . in addition , the dust hypothesis explains why the fainter components are also redder ; this would be a coincidence under the microlensing hypothesis . therefore , at least part of the reason for the extreme red color of  is dust extinction in the lens galaxies . this need not be the entire reason . because we can determine only the differential extinction , rather than the total extinction , we can not rule out the existence of dust in the host galaxy that reddens the background source , or an intrinsically red background source . the evidence presented in this paper strongly supports the models developed in detail by @xcite : the unique radio morphology of  represents five images ( a  e ) of a single radio - loud quasar . there is also a sixth radio component ( f ) representing a different part of the background radio source . radio observations with the vlba at five widely spaced frequencies demonstrate that f has a steeper spectral index than components a  e , ruling out six - image models and supporting the notion that f represents a different part of the background radio source . one of the predicted counter - images of f may have been detected at 1.7  ghz , but this needs to be confirmed with more sensitive observations at higher frequencies . if there remains any doubt about the kw03 scenario , detection of both of the counter - images would be definitive . the multi - frequency maps also demonstrate that the lower surface brightness of components a , c , and e at long wavelengths is due to differential scatter broadening . this defends the theory that they are multiple images of a single quasar from the objection that surface brightness must be conserved by gravitational lensing . components b , d , and f do not appear to be significantly scatter broadened .    at short wavelengths , where scatter broadening is minimized , the resolved shapes of the radio components can be broadly explained by a subset of the kw03 models . in particular , component c is aligned in the direction of component a , as predicted generically by those models . the radio arc between components a and b , which was previously detected at 1.7  ghz and which we also detected at 2.3  ghz , emerges naturally from the models . at the longest wavelength there is a trace of extended emission between a and c , again fulfilling the expectation of the lens models that these components should be connected by an arc . the positions of the two lens galaxies proposed by kw03 are in rough agreement with two residual peaks in optical images with the hst , and also with two residual peaks identified by g02 in a deconvolved @xmath125-band image . the northern galaxy appears to be responsible for the reddening and scatter broadening observed in components a , c , and e. the southern galaxy appears to be responsible for the reddening of component d. component b , which is the most distant in projection from either galaxy , is not scatter broadened and is the bluest component , as expected . it should be possible to improve the characterization of the lens galaxies with space - based images , or ground - based images with a very high signal - to - noise ratio ( allowing a reliable deconvolution ) . given the presence of dust and ionized material in the lens galaxies and the possibly elongated morphology observed for the southern lens galaxy , it seems likely that both galaxies are spiral galaxies . we thank ramesh narayan and david rusin for useful discussions . we are indebted to steven beckwith for providing director s discretionary time on the hst for this project , and we thank emilio falco , chris impey , brian mcleod , and hans - walter rix , for helping to obtain the hst data as members of the castles collaboration . is supported by an nsf astronomy & astrophysics postdoctoral fellowship , under grant ast-0104347 . c.s.k.is supported by nasa atp grant nag5 - 9265 and hst grant go-9133 .
Abstract:

Answer: we present results from high - resolution radio and optical observations of pmn  j01340931 , a gravitational lens with a unique radio morphology and an extremely red optical counterpart . our data support the theory of keeton & winn ( 2003 ) : five of the six observed radio components are multiple images of a single quasar , produced by a pair of lens galaxies . multi - frequency vlba maps show that the sixth and faintest component has a different radio spectrum than the others , confirming that it represents a second component of the background source rather than a sixth image . the lens models predict that there should be additional faint images of this second source component , and we find evidence for one of the predicted images . the previously - observed large angular sizes of two of the five bright components are not intrinsic ( which would have excluded the possibility that they are lensed images ) , but are instead due to scatter broadening . both the extended radio emission observed at low frequencies , and the intrinsic image shapes observed at high frequencies , can be explained by the lens models . the pair of lens galaxies is marginally detected in hst images . the differential extinction of the quasar images suggests that the extreme red color of the quasar is at least partly due to dust in the lens galaxies .